Skip to main content
Loading video...

Battles of the War of 1812 Gameplay & Review | Historical Board Game | Wargame

Transcript 28:25

Hi everybody, I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome. Today we're going to take a look at another one of the Worthington Publishing travel games. This one is Battles of the War of 1812. This contains two scenarios, Lundy's Lane and North Point. In this video, we'll take a look at each of the two scenarios, take a look at some gameplay, and then I'm going to offer up some impressions of my experience with the game so far. So, here's a look at the Battle of North Point, one of the two scenarios in the Battles of the War of 1812. The board we're looking at is a 14in x 7 in mounted thick board here. Folds up into four panels and it goes right back into the box that we looked at in the introduction. Now, what we're looking at here for this battle is the British forces in red and the US forces in blue. And the the battle historically fought in September of 1814 was an advance by British forces to try to take the city of Baltimore. Now, although they did tactically win the field on this day, they lost their major general Ross was was killed in battle and it really took the steam out of the attack on the Battle of Baltimore. Considered to be winning one of the two events that led to the turning of the Battle of Baltimore during the War of 1812 leading to the US victory. Uh British suffered about two casualties to every one US casualty on this day too at this battle.

So, but what are we looking at? Well, we've got the British forces here moving forward and then the US forces here really defending in a line here and we can see there are fences and imp placements here representing the US defensive positions. The British are the aggressor trying to break through the US lines. The US are trying to hold them off. Let's talk a little bit about victory conditions. This is a battle to six points. The first side that gets to six victory points win the battle. Both sides get victory points for eliminating enemy units. You get one victory point for each unit eliminated. So, this really is a battle to try to inflict casualties. However, the British do have one other way that they can get victory points. There are two British victory point locations here way on the far side of the map, signifying that they would be able to advance on Baltimore and would have won the day if they can capture these two spots. They get one victory point each. So, potentially the British can also get victory points for driving the Americans from the field um and controlling these points. To me, it seems like if the British are going to get this far, they're going to have wiped out six units anyway. So, I'm not sure if that's more symbolic than anything else. But as soon as once I get six victory points, the battle is over.

If it ends at turn 16 with neither side getting six victory points, the leading side wins and ties go to the British. And for the most part, as we look at this battle, almost all of the combatants are on the field. The British will get some reinforcements. They get these two units here in turn two and two more units in turn three. Likewise, the US get two reinforcements here on the left in turn five, but most everything starts the battle uh on the board on the map here. Now, I've played through this scenario. It's a bloody slam into the American lines with the British forces uh coming from the left here as they get their reinforcements in. They have quite a formidable force. The US really have to try to hold behind these forces, but they also have to try to inflict enough casualties to win. And I I I had troubles. I thought the British force was pretty strong fighting as uh both sides trying to get through here. I really was able to steamroll the Americans with the British and come out with a British win. Although the Americans did in the end extract some British casualties. So I'm not sure quite what the strategy is for this one, but this is very much a line of British forces advancing British forces trying to break through this American line. So heavy combat. And while we're at this, let's take a look at the rule book to give you an idea of complexity. As with the other games in other game in the series that we looked at, the Battles of the American Revolution, this is uh pretty much an identical rule book. It is 16 pages, but it does include the the startup maps and the instructions for both of the two scenarios. The rules are very straightforward. I I learned them in about 15 minutes or so. Uh and the

game plays very fast. I've played this uh each one of these scenarios now and it's taken 30 minutes to go through them. So this is a fast playing quick to learn very easy I think to learn this game and to play it in one evening if even if that you know probably you could play it a couple of times once you get it down. So with that in mind let's take a look at the second scenario. So here's a look at the battle of Lundy's Lane which historically happened in July of 1814 near Niagara Falls Ontario. This was uh US forces trying to push up into Canada and the battle historically was fought to a stalemate. It was one of the bloodiest battles of the war. Both sides lost an equal amount of casualties, but the forced forced the Americans to withdraw and really ended the advance up into Canada by the Americans at that point in the war. Compared to North Point, this battle is a little bit more free flowing with potentially both sides going in a lot of different directions.

The American forces start at the the southern end of the map here. And the British forces, as we can see, which are almost all on the map at the start of the battle, start in this line. And a lot of these British positions are actually hills uh which give them a pretty good that's clear terrain but give them a good defensive bonus. And this is the churchyard here. We can see there is a victory point location for both the British and the Americans. And you get victory points for controlling victory point locations of your color. So for the Americans, there's this one here in the churchyard at the top of the hill. Then there's one up here in the northwest and one up here in the northeast. So potentially three victory points for the US should they get those. For the British, we have in addition to this churchyard here, there is a victory point location down here which signifies driving the US forces from the battle.

So the British could get two victory points for victory point locations. Otherwise, this is a battle to seven victory points and you get your remaining victory points by eliminating enemy units. Now the US, as you would look at this, you'd say, "Wow, they are outnumbered at the beginning of the battle." And that is true. However, they do have a rather large contingent of reinforcements coming in, but it's not very early in the battle. It's turns uh five, turn six, and turn seven. Turn six, this larger contingent contains. Turn seven, the rest of the troops come in. So, it's a while that the US have to fight with the forces that they have on the map. And then on turn eight, the British get a smattering of reinforcements that we can see on the left hand side. As with the other games in the series, this is a battle to 16 turns. The both sides have artillery and leadership. The uh British forces have seven artillery and five leadership. The US forces have six artillery and eight leadership. So this gives and we'll we'll show how these work as we get into a little bit of gameplay here. And with that being said, I think we're pretty much ready to take a look at this one and give it a start. I'm going to play a turn or two of this one to get a sense again for gameplay. And I'm not quite sure. There are a lot of tactical options here for both sides. So I'm um, you know, we'll explore some, but I'm not sure if there's an optimal strategy or which might be the stronger ones at this point yet. So to get a sense for how gameplay works, let's play a couple of turns from Lundy's lane. Now, um, one thing we'll notice, the the Americans here, they go first and they are

outnumbered. However, u you'll notice that the the British left flank as we view it here on the right flank from the American perspective have um these left numbers and the top number here are all twos. And to to get a quick explanation of the units, the left numbers or the top numbers for cavalry are the combat factors and then the right numbers or the bottom number for cavalry are the movement factors. So these are all twos relatively weak unit and for the Americans we have this 25th infantry 22nd infantry third infantry that's a four these are fives these are relatively strong units so we might be able to have some some some success over here against this side of the British uh line whereas this line here the 89th is their one strong unit they do have some pretty strong fours over here so this side of the British line is a lot more dangerous than this side and Perry here is in the open and these Canadians are in the open. So, we could at the very least, I think, consider pushing the British line back here and perhaps taking some sort of a position here while we wait for reinforcements.

So, with that in mind, let's get started and move some units forward here. Now, we're going to move uh one for open terrain, two for open terrain here. It costs an extra movement point to move adjacent to a unit. So, this would require four and we only have three, but that for the moment that's fine. Let's move our 23rd infantry up one, two, three into the woods. Then our cavalry can go one, two, three into the woods here. And this will deny the Canadians from these woods because you can't move through two enemy zones of control. So, the Canadians would not be able to go here into the space here. Now, let's begin to shuffle over our other forces here. Let's move up into the buildings here, up into this pier farm with our ninth. And then with the 22nd, we'll go 1 2 3 over here. And the 11th, we'll go 1 2 3. I want to be a little bit careful from the British attacking us, but we're starting to get, I think, a little bit better defensive shape. Now, after we've moved, we could attack here. Two against two. We could add some uh firepower here, but I think it's not that great of an attack. I think we can get better attacks going forward. So, we're not going to attack. But before we even declare our attacks, the British could potentially fire artillery against us.

This would be a die roll that would see if they would push this unit back and potentially harm it. But this isn't really threatening, I think, for the British. So, they are going to hold their artillery. They only have, I believe, seven shots here. seven artillery uses in a 16 uh round battle. So, they're not going to uh fire. And as the Americans, we're not going to attack her. I don't necessarily like the odds here, even against these Canadians to two. We could use leadership. Leadership would add two combat factors to our attack, giving us four against two, but it not sure really it achieves much, and I'd like to get a better attack in the future. So, with that in mind, we will uh end the US turn and now we'll go to the British turn and see how they want to react. As the British, I'm thinking we could try a couple of things. We could push down aggressively and try to, for example, mount a good attack against this ninth infantry, which is in a good defensive position because it's embedded in this farm here. So, that would make its defense five. Uh, but nothing really strikes me as being that tempting. And I hesitate to pull ourselves, especially these units up here out of these good defensive positions just to get off one attack cuz I think the American counterattack might be painful. So, we're going to be a little bit uh cautious here with the British. And I'm going to try to save as many of these units on this flank as we can and concede this flank to the Americans. So, with that in mind, I'm going to pull parry back one here. We're going to pull the cavalry back. One, two. We're going to pull our Canadians back. 1 2 3. Now,

there is a victory point up here in the north. We're going to concede that to the US, but I'm not worried about that yet. I think losing these units could be painful, and I'm afraid of the powerful units down here. What I would like to do, however, is to start to get this 89th one, two, three. We're going to slide them over here because I'd like to get them up here trying to hold this line. We'll leave everybody else pretty much here except slide the fourth, the 89th, and these units over here to this hill. And so the British basically just kind of tempting the Americans and saying, "Come get us if you want, but um we're going to give a little bit here and bend but not break perhaps." And so with that in mind, the Americans could fire artillery, but we're not going to do that as the Americans. And there are no attacks. So uh both sides being a little bit cautious here. We'll go to turn two now. Now, because I want to show uh two turns of gameplay, I'm going to uh push the advance here. I do see a a potentially weak spot here for the British because this unit, if we were to attack it, would not be able to retreat.

So, it would take an extra step loss if we can put some damage on it. So, that was a a mistake I realized after I moved the British forces. So, we're going to be a little bit aggressive here cuz I want to show some combat, too. So, we're going to move up 1 2 3 to move next to the British line here. We're going to get our strongest unit going up 1 2 3 to move next to the eighth here. 1 2 3. And that's going to give us a nice 11 to six because this unit is on a hill. 11 to six attack against the eighth. And if they are forced to retreat, we're going to cause an extra step of damage because of the British tactical error here. Then likewise up here in the uh north, we are going to in the east side, the right side of our line here, we're going to think about how we want to move these units up towards the enemy. We're going to go 1/2, one, two, two and a half up here. Just closing this in a little bit here. And then one, two, three, because roads are a half. And then we'll move the cavalry up here. And as the Americans, I'm not going to worry about this victory point location up here. And so that's the end of the American moves at the end of turn two. Now the British have a choice to make. They could use artillery. And in artillery you can do you can use artillery two ways. You can either roll against any unit that is within a range of three hex's of one of your units. And if you get a 1, two, or three, you force that unit back. If you get a a four, five, or a six, if one, two, or three is no effect, a four, five, or six would push that unit back.

and a a four and a six would in addition to pushing it back cause a step loss of damage. There are minuses for terrain, but none of these units are in good defensive terrain. So, this is very much an attack position. But the other thing you can do with artillery is add to the defense factor of the unit. And so, we're going to do that. We are going to take one of the British artillery uses and we're going to put it on this unit right here as the Americans attack because we're not going to fire artillery to defend. The Americans are going to attack. So we have 8 and three is 11. Now the Americans likewise we are going to add we're going to use one of our leadership factors and one of the things you can do with leadership is add two to the attack. So we are going to do that and then over here we're going to burn one of our leadership uses to pull it down here to seven. The British likewise are going to use that artillery, one of their seven artillery uses to add two defensive factors to their unit. And what we're going to do now is compare the two combat factors and then add a die roll to each one. So for the US forces, we have uh two three combat factor units, a five combat factor unit, which adds up to 11. Then we added our leadership gets us to 13 for the Americans on the offense. For the British, which were just attacking this one unit on the corner here, they are a four. Plus two for the artillery defense gives them a six. Plus three because they are on a plus two more because they are on a hill, which gets us to eight. So the final attack here is 13-8. a difference of five. So with that

in mind, we're going to roll one dice for the Americans and add it to the attack. So 13 + 5, a very good attack for the Americans. That gets us to 18 for the Americans. The British are eight plus 2 is 10. So we get to 18- 10 for that attack. That is a resounding American victory here. And the way that the casualties work are if the greater side wins, ties go to the defenders. The losing side has to retreat. So in this case, the British would have to retreat. Additionally though, if you have if you win by four to six uh combat factors, you take a step loss. And if you the opponent takes a step loss and if you uh win by seven or more combat factors, then the opponent takes two step losses.

In this case, we got 18 to 10. So, it's plus eight. That means this British unit here defending the hill has been eliminated. So, we can reach right in here and take the eighth out. And then, as the Americans, we have the opportunity. We may advance. And yes, we are going to get this unit up on the hill. Now, this is going to give the British a chance to counterattack right here on the hill. But I I like that as an attack that gets the Americans one victory point out of the seven that they need to get victory. The British already have one because they are holding this uh hill on the center here on Lundy's Lane. So it is now the score at this moment is 1 to1. And once you get seven victory points, it's over. So the first side that gets there, if it doesn't go 16 turns and with that, the Americans have finished their turn. Now it's time for the British to consider what they want to do. Looking quickly down our line, I think it's going to be very tough to try to get off a good attack with these weak units on this side here.

But we can bring to bear three units on this 22nd infantry, which is in a vulnerable vulnerable position, even though it's strong and on a hill. And if we could weaken this unit, which is the strongest, one of the two strongest American units, that would be a great turn of events for the British. So, I'm going to see if we can mount a stronger attack on this. We've also got this left side of the line here that's rather vulnerable. I think it's time to pull units down here. Now, one consideration, however, is that the American reinforcements are going to come in anywhere along the bottom of the map here. So, we could put ourselves uh susceptible to a strong counterattack once we get to turn six, but we'll worry about that uh later. So, for the moment, let's uh see what we can do to maximize our attack on this unit. First thing I'm going to try to get this weaker unit out. So, we're going to move it out one, two, and just let it sit there. And we can pull this infantry unit here, which is right along the road here. Goes in one along the road, and then two to get next to a unit. That'll be nice because it'll give us a nice strong attack here.

Nine and two is 11 against seven plus four on this unit here. Now, um let's see if we can move forward here. We won't be able to get this attack off this time, I think. But we can start to pin these units here. We'll go forward one here, two here. One, two, three to try to get this unit because we can really threaten the left side of the American flank here. And then this infantry unit, which can move a four. One, two, three. We'll try to leave it here for the moment. I think is probably Actually, let's just go all in for we have a little bit of time. It's only the second turn and reinforcements don't show up until turn six, I believe it is. Yeah, turn six. So, we have some time before we'd have to worry about the American reinforcements crushing our right flank here as the British. Um, let's also move Hamilton up here just to get him a little bit closer to the action. We'll get him down here as a reserve. And I am going to leave our left flank as is. We're just going to have to deal with that as the Americans come up here. This unit, yeah, these are in the open. There's nothing good to defend with here. This could be trouble for us in the future. But let's make the Americans pay down here for their aggressive attack. Okay, so the British have moved and now it's the Americans turn. They can do uh one of one thing.

They could fire artillery to try to drive back one of the units here. And let's think if that makes sense. Right now, the British have an 11. They most certainly will use a leadership to get 13 against seven. We could go to 13 to 9, a plus four. That's a pretty tough attack to beat. So, as the Americans, we're going to use one of our artillery points to try to drive back the British. So, off camera, I'm moving the American potential uh artillery uses down from six down to five. And then we're going to have the Americans fire artillery. And that uses this artillery chart. And let's fire right here on the strongest unit because that will totally break the British attack if we succeed. So, we're going to roll one dieice on a and there the British is in open terrain. So, if it's a one, two, or three, it's no effect. A four, a five, it pushes it back one hex. And a six, it pushes it back a hex with a step loss. A four.

That's excellent for the Americans. Pushes the 89th infantry back away from its attack on our 22nd Infantry. And now the British decide their attacks. And so we have six that we could get against seven in a defensive position. We could add two leadership which would get us to eight against seven. Those are pretty sparse odds. But but what we can do instead, however, we can come here. Four and three is seven against three. And this unit's in the open, so no defense. So we've got seven against three. And let's toss in some leadership points here. So we're going to toss in two leadership. We're going to use a leadership factor to add two to one of these combat units attack factor getting us to 9 to three. So I think we can really put the hurt on this unit here now because the Americans use their artillery to fire and beat back this unit here. That ends that they can't use artillery again. You can only get one use per turn. Thinking smarter, it would have probably been better to fire at this unit here, but that was in a hill which would have given it a minus one die roll modifier to artillery die roll.

So maybe that's not the right way to go anyway. But uh the British are getting this attack off. So we have nine against three, which is we need a good die roll as the Americans. British could wipe this unit out. They get a 9 plus a four is a 13. That's pretty good. The Americans get a three plus a six is a nine. Oh, they kept it alive. So 13 to 9 is plus four. The Americans have to retreat and they take a step loss. They would push this one back here. So they survive and push back here. Now the question is, do we want to advance as the British? And I think the answer is yes, because we can trap this 22nd unit in here and deal with it and make it give it put a a world of hurt on this with a 4 to1 attack in the next turn.

Oop, sorry, a little bit of an earthquake there. Um, and with that, we've ended two turns of this scenario. We've seen how artillery use is used. We've seen uh some leadership uses. You could also use leadership to gain two movement factors. And you can also use leadership to try to rally a unit that's not in adjacent to any enemy uh enemy unit on a four, five or six. You regain a step loss. So potentially we might want to pull this unit back. See if we can get it some space to try to rally it as the Americans in the future. But that shows uh two full turns of Battles of the War of 1812. If you saw the video on the uh Battles of the American Revolution, you'll see the gameplay and rules are are almost identical. They actually are identical. I mean, the scenarios are different, but the rule set is identical. So, if you know how to play one, you know how to play the other. Uh let's take uh let's talk a little bit about some impressions of gameplay. Next, some impressions on gameplay. Some things that I like. If you saw my video on the Battles of the American Revolution, this is very much a lather, rinse, repeat in regards to that. I think these are fantastic introductory war games. If you've got someone you're trying to teach hex encounters wargaming to and is interested in it, it's this is the best I've seen. I mean, these are so good because so many of the hex encounter mechanics that show up in more complicated war games show up here. You got zones of control. You've got odds based combat. Die rolls, combat results table. You're trying to swing the odds in your favor. Terrain plays a factor.

Movement's going to vary by terrain, by enemy zones of control. Um, you've got artillery and leadership uses that you're trying to think of. All of these cool mechanics that show up in more complicated war games are here and you're going to be teaching people how to use them and how to think about them in a very controlled environment where you don't have a ton of overwhelming counters and your objectives are relatively straightforward. So these are perfect introductory games if you're teaching someone how to play a war game. The second thing I would say if you're looking for a kind of a lighter touch beer and pretzels war game where you want to throw down a game with someone that's you know experienced war gamers in a half an hour uh and something not too heavy then I think this is a great choice. This could easily I think be a game you could get in at the end of a war a longer wargaming session say hey we got in a half an hour to play one more game let's throw this in the table and see what happens and have a lot of fun with it. The analogy I used in the earlier video in talking about Battles of the American Revolution was I feel like this is war game checkers. So, it's not wargame tic-tac-toe. There's enough depth here that you're going to be thinking about strategies and tactics and trying to make things work with the terrain, with your stronger units, with your objectives. There's a lot of good thinking here. Um, it's not wargame chess though, right? So, if you are a very deep experienced war gamer and you're looking for a deep historical representation of these battles in the War of 1812, this really isn't what this box is trying to do, right? This is a lighter historical thematic touch. I mean, the units are there and the objectives and that the overall historical movements there, but this is not a historical simulation of this battle. This is a light historical theme

that's going to give you a chance to play some light um hex encounter war games. So, I wouldn't look for war game chess. It's war game checkers. It's got some depth, some good meat to it. Fantastic for introductory gamers and fantastic if you're looking to get in a quick game that's a light game that's a beer and pretzels type thing if you're got two experienced war gamers. I mentioned this in Battles of the American Revolution as well. Luck can play a stronger factor in these games than perhaps in most war games because of the relatively few number of units you've got on the field. If you get a couple of good rolls one way and your opponent doesn't, it can tilt the odds and you get that steamroller going. So, luck is a little bit of a a a heavier in can be a heavier influence in this game than perhaps in larger and more complex games. Again, it's it's a half an hour game, so it's not really a big deal if that happens. You know, this isn't again what it's trying to do is is very different than uh you know, a full historical recreation of these battles.

I imagine there's a couple of other questions out there now that I've looked at two of these games. one would be which one is better. They're the same, right? The rules are the same. The gameplay is the same. The scenarios are very different, right? But the mechanics and all of the gameplay elements are the same. And they both, I think, have scenarios that in my mind strike me as equally good. They're both they're good scenarios. There's some thinking involved and they've done a good job with the mechanics and the force piler to create some interesting engagements in both ones. So, so I would definitely say pick the theme that interests you most and go with that. The next question I think people would ask is, should you get both? I think that's a a harder question to answer. If you are in a situation where you've got a younger player or a player who's learning war games and you want to play with them a number of times, then I think having this set of games, there's a third one that I'll look at later as well. Um, but the American Mexican-American War box, too. But I think then yeah, it would it would having both of these would be great because you can bring to bear more scenarios and more challenges and and get this person up to speed with wargaming with a wider variety than just the two scenarios that are in one box.

So from that line, yeah, sure. Um, if you see yourself in a situation where you've got a lot of beer and pretzels wargaming opportunities where these half an hour 45 minute war games would get a lot of get a lot of use, then I think yeah, you know, but if you're looking for great differences in gameplay or a deep historical simulation of these battles to learn more about the War of 1812 or the battles of the American Revolution, then I would say just get one really because the the historical theme is is it's a very light theme with these, you know, and then the gameplay is very similar. So, you're not going to see differences in gameplay. It's more more scenarios with a different light historical theme. So, from that guard, I think hopefully that gives people enough information as to whether you would want to get both of these. If you're unsure, I would say get one, see how much use it gets, see how much you like it, and then pick up the other one. Although, to be fair, these are war games, so there is always that they go out of stock pretty quickly. So, there's the the FOMO fear of missing out factor in there, too. But hopefully that's some information that can help you make that decision, too.

And with all that being said, there's some thoughts on Battles of the War of 1812 from Warthingington Publishing. If you have not seen the Battles of the American Revolution video, I'll put a link to it up here and you can check that one out. Be happy to entertain your questions and and hear love to hear your comments down below. Thanks.

Progress saved