Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rialto Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:54

hey everybody today i'm talking about rialto which is an older steppenfeld game dating back to 2013. this one accommodates two to five players it takes about 45 to 60 minutes to play um it's a area majority and card drafting game set in venice with the old rialto bridge here um i like the box out here nice minimalist look and the board looks like this so thematically this game doesn't really hold much weight i said it's very very much a game about controlling these regions trying to get points at the end of the game um you've got all these different sections here in venice um all labeled with these numbers um at the beginning of the game so these are dished out randomly and they're going to determine the order in which these islands are resolved in so i've got this one here this kind of pawn here that represents which island's going to start so at number one and mechanically the game is pretty simple and broken down into three pretty simple stages which are illustrated on the board here we're also going to have a player board where we're going to start with a different building each a bit of money and some um pieces that you can put down on the board but you've got the potential to bring a lot more into your um into your supply and i've only set up for one player here but naturally everybody would have their own piece there's also this track up the board here which is very important called the doge track and this is going to be a pivotal piece in terms of breaking ties so depending on the play account we're going to divide up or kind of lay out four or sorry a number of different columns um depending on that player

again so in a two player game you would put three columns in a three player game you put four columns and four player game you put five columns and a five play game you put six columns so it's always one more than the number of players and the idea is we're going to draft one of these columns of cards so you're actually drafting cards uh as a kind of job lot to determine the actions that you're going to do at the end of that round and not only are you going to get that column of cards you're also going to draw two off the top of the deck as well so your opponents have got a pretty good idea of what you can do during the round but not perfect information because as i said you've got two blind drawers there which could be anything so let's talk about what all the different cards do so you've got the um this this symbol here which represents to the doge track and whoever's going to play the most of these cars during the round well you're going to first off everybody's going to move up a number of spaces on this track equal to the amount of cards they've played so let's let's say i played three cards the blue played two cards and the red played one card oh sorry the green paid one card whoever's played the most gets an additional push along as well so this is a game where if you kind of win a certain one of these pools of cars being played then you're going to get an additional little bonus as well so you are incentivized to lead the way on probably a couple of these criteria throughout the coins is pretty simple so the coins are going to get you a coin for each card you played and again whoever's played the most cards is going to get an additional coin the buildings lets you get these get building tiles depending on the number of cards you've played

and whoever's played the most buildings building cards gets to take one level higher so for example if i played let's say i played two building cards and my parents only paid one my parents would get to take a level one building i would get to take a level three building or up to a level three building because not only do i get to get the two that i've played played of but because i played the most i get to take one level higher so again that other slightly incentivized to play at least one more than your opponents and as mentioned before the doze track here is going to break the ties if um if there's a tie for that majority so always being high up on this track is is almost paramount importance now let's talk about what some of the buildings do so the green ones generally let you draw more cards into your hand and hold more cards if you get to write the top layer here the yellow ones are generally used during the actual action phase when you are resolving these cards so this one here lets you pass to wait and see what other players are doing this one here lets you use a card as another card that one here lets you use a card as a wild uh sorry it lets you just have a wild building or a wild card uh that one there lets you convert one card into two and two of another card um the blue ones tend to be resolved at the end of the round where you can upgrade one building to the next level um you can get a point and a new worker into your pool uh you can move the doge track along and ultimately just get more points so that's what all the different buildings do you can only have ever have seven at a time um but you can always replace them if you want to uh you know change your mind throughout so

that's how the building cards are going to work you've got the bridge cards now the bridge cards are interesting because whoever for every card you play you're going to get going to get a point and i think if you don't play any then you're going to score negative points but also whoever's plays the most of those is going to get to place one of these bridge tiles here now these are interesting because they have two different denominations of points on them um and you're going to place them anywhere on the board on these on these kind of highlighted symbols here so see for example i'd like i put this one down like that now these values are important because when it comes to scoring these different regions they're going to be scored based on the on the values of of all the different kind of denominations pointing towards that island so at the moment this one's going to be worth five points whereas this one is going to be worth three points and as you can probably tell the more you build here you can kind of tailor this to your advantage if you are constantly winning that bridge um that bridge draft by pointing the higher value points to the islands that you're controlling the the gondola um actions correlate to getting more workers into your pool so for every card you play you get to take one of these and put it back into your supply ready to be deployed later but additionally whoever wins that um that action is going to get to play one of these gondola tiles and these gondola tiles as you can see have a value of one on both sides so a bit like these ones here with the

bridge tiles if you know an opponent is doing particularly well in an island and you've got no way of catching up then you can always play one of those to make sure that they're not going to get much points or many points at the end of the game so i really do like that and that's a really cool um a cool mechanism there and finally you've got the um the symbol here which represents how many people you're going to deploy in the current region so like the other ones if i played three cards i would get to play three people into the current region and whoever plays the most gets to deploy another one and it's going to be a bit of a battling for position there you've also got a wild card here and that one can represent any single card or any other of the other cards um and you can always choose to not play cards you can choose to keep them back into your hand for the next round but bearing in mind that after you've done your card draft and drawn the additional ones off the top you can ever only ever go back down to you have to discard down to seven cards unless you've got powers that say otherwise so that's going to be the basic game the flow of the game or the main kind of action part part of the game then you go to phase three as i mentioned where you can activate your three um your your level or your blue buildings i should say uh there are other incentive incentives here in order to basically if you control all these southern islands then you're going to get a bonus of five uh five points if you're the first to do that and again with the northern irelands you get the same and that's going to be how the game's going to play out until all the

different islands are going to be resolved so once the level 1's gone you'd move on to the level two or two to number two and then this will be resolved as the game goes on you know more and more of these tiles are going to be placed depending on you know who's doing well where you know and just trying to tailor this to your advantage and then at the end of the game whoever's all the different islands are going to be resolved i'm giving points on majorities um the point equal to the number of gondola uh the number of points on the gondolas and bridges whoever's in second place is going to get half of the half of the points rounded down and whoever's in third is going to get half of those points rounded down so that's going to be how um how rialto is going to play out was a pretty simple game um so let's talk about my actual thoughts on the game so first off i really do like the car drafting now card drafting isn't one of my favorite mechanisms but i particularly do enjoy card drafting games when you take communal lots or job lots and you have to weigh up about what you want here and additionally as i said i do like the fact that your opponents have a pretty good idea on the field you're strong in so you know for example if i if i took this card they know i'm going to at least compete in in the bridges or um or the doze track but they don't know perfect information because i'm always taking cards off the top and can be having cards from my previous round so even though there is you know somewhat random um you know distribution here you've got some autonomy and some mitigation in terms of um holding on to um holding on to cards

from existing rounds you know for example if you if you know you can't really compete for um maybe deploying your your pawns onto that certain spot and you really want to focus on the next phase and deploying there then you can hold back on those so there are some good decisions there in what you're going to keep hold of that little bit of hand management um also you've got some mitigation with the buildings here you know the green ones that you draw more cards and and so on so you've got again a bit more mitigation and you're not somewhat you're not so subject to the to the luck of the draw um there's also of course the idea that you need to basically dabble in all of these fields you can't just neglect one of them because you need to be competing in the doge track in order to break those ties you need to have money because you need money to activate the buildings and you want the buildings because they give you good powers you want the bridges because otherwise you're going to be subject to people just giving you all the rubbish amount of points and you're not going to be getting points by playing them in the first place you want to be deploying your workers but you can't keep deploying your workers unless you pay the gondolas to get workers into your supply so again you can't neglect anything and um kind of knowing when and when you get knowing when to do things and when to pull the trigger on maybe stockpiling on certain actions is important and more importantly knowing when to use these wild cards is so important because um player order is is ultra you know particular in this game where knowing what other players are going to reveal and what they're going to play from rounds around is important because you need to know when to dedicate these wild cards

so i do like that decision space there the game ticks along quite nicely in terms of moving from island to island you know each round around isn't particularly long it's um it certainly isn't one of these long drawn out games and for an area control game it plays pretty quickly you don't get many of them that play in that 45 to 60 minute mark um balance wise kind of ties in to the to the importance of all the different fields here it's not there's there's no real scope for imbalance here i think the only thing is the um you know is the order of the turn turn drafting of the card drafting but you know that's your fault really if you haven't if you've neglected the does track and you're drafting last every time then um that's kind of tough um and and you've kind of laid your bed really the um you know mechanisms i do like the way it's boiled down into three very simple phases obviously the main crux being the being the action phase i will say that the way it's resolved because you kind of play all your doge cards and then resolve but you play all your money cards and then resolve it it's a bit stop and start and um it doesn't flow quite as well as a lot of maybe more recent games do however i understand the way it plays because that's where the gameplay lies is um is almost the the order of these cars being played and knowing when to hold them back and know when to kind of reveal your your hand really but it it kind of it's kind of a a weird scale of things where it doesn't make the game flow wonderfully but it

does add a lot of the interest in the gameplay so yeah the the kind of uptime and the way it ticks along isn't isn't great but it also is almost necessary um the replayability i'm again i'm a bit in two minds about this one because there isn't loads of things you can try i mean you're gonna get a pretty good idea of what the buildings do after one game and yeah maybe you can go for those a different maybe uh focus from game to game in terms of getting the high level buildings but ultimately it's one of those games where you you are getting what you're getting and you're reacting to what the cards are available and your current situation is not a game where you can try lots of different things but at the same time you it's more tactical than anything and um it's gonna keep your engagement that way rather than trying different things from games again the interaction is good i mean i love the i love the fact that you can change the values of the different regions um again by not only helping yourself but by hurting others as well i do like that i think there's some real good interaction in the car draft and some holding back some information here and stuff so yeah i do it does have a good level of interaction and for an area control game it's not a game where you are you know demolishing people and kicking them out of regions you're basically just tailoring the board to suit you more than your opponents rather than smashing anything they've created so i think the interaction is injected quite well with this one

aesthetically i like the way the game looks i will admit it has a classic throwback look even though i like the way the game looks i think functionally it has some issues so first off the islands themselves aren't the easiest to differentiate from one another um not overly important but maybe in terms of the bridge layouts and things it could be a bit clearer um but i i visually i think it looks quite nice my biggest issue is the score track so the score track um as you can see they don't have any numbers on apart from these here and there's you actually put the discs between the spots here and it just it just is a bit off-putting but very small fault there um i think the cars look okay they're all clear on what they do or clear on what they represent so again the the components are a mixed bag you know functionally functionally okay but a bit confusing at points and quality wise uh generally good um i think we'll say that these player boards are very thin they're like almost paper so they're not great but the coins are fine the buildings are fine and the general quality of the cars on board is fine the uh the theme there's no theme here it's just um it's just set in venice you know it's uh based on the different islands and things very much a skin um but it does have all the different region names and things so i think if you're if you're a fan of venice and if you've been there it's quite a nice little thing to you know to remind you of that but it's

a failed game so you know if you're playing failed games you're probably not that interested in theme um scalability it works well at i suppose most player counts there is and for a two-player game actually it works okay because there is a slight modification in the in the box where you almost play you you have the option to play with a dummy player which only focuses on deploying their workers onto different spots so if you want that almost almost um you know ai that you want to compete with to make things a bit more interesting you can choose to do that and the housekeeping is very low for that as well so don't be off per if you like the look of the game and but you mainly play with two players you're still going to get a bit of enjoyment out of this one maybe not quite as good as you know that three four or five player mark but it's still close you know you're not missing out on a whole lot and it's not one of those games where you just it just doesn't work at two um the comparison wise yes there are a lot of area majority in area control games but i think the mix of the car drafting and the and the board itself work well together again i like the way you have to focus on everything and you can't just neglect one thing so yeah i think the two separate distinct mechanisms do tie in together really well which you know stefan felder is great at doing that he's mechanically he's a genius and um you know this certainly is well put together so yeah overall i i do really enjoy this game i can certainly see it's uh you know it's strong points

i like i keep going back to it i like the way you can't neglect anything that the bridges are interesting you need the coins in order to build the buildings and the buildings let you do loads of cool things the order is of the islands is important because you need to know when you're going to play those cars because you can't go back and add where you can but you can't go back and add um major changes onto items that have already been resolved you can only do it with what i think is when you play the gondolas you can add another workout onto either side of that island so you can kind of be a bit sneaky and sneak in at the end but generally it's resolved from point to point to point and you know knowing when to play things and knowing when to commit to things and maybe let things go is important so there's some good decisions there and um additionally they were the buildings there's some good decisions there what you want to focus on you always want to be going up this track here and certainly not slipping too far behind to the point where you're never breaking ties and you're always drafting last so yeah there's some good decisions here and certainly um tactical and strategic options so i do like that um yeah overall a lot of fun it's probably not well certainly not one of my favorite um stefan feld games but it does have a lot of his feel in terms of being mechanically well put together if anything the only thing that puts me off is as i said the the way that all the different actions and the stages are resolved because it's very stop and start rather than just getting out the way quickly it's it's very formulaic but that's part and parcel of the game really so

give this one a you know check those out if you like your yourselves games and you want a more pure area majority game but certainly not they were the best of them but at the same time you know i love stephen feld and even his or my like my least favorite games of his are still really good so that is rialto um yeah i can see why it's not one of his one of his biggest titles but still a strong design and um some fun to be had from this one so i hope you enjoyed the review uh please hit like and subscribe my channel if you have you can also check out my other videos and support me on patreon and back follow me on instagram uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved