Dwellings of Eldervale: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for dwellings of elder vale which is a game that uh was actually highly anticipate all my highly anticipated games of 2020 um that i did last year uh and breaking games i haven't played a whole lot of their games they did one called rise of tribes which was also another kind of work replacement uh in the set in the the neanderthal period we play that one we do uh it's it's good but it's like almost kind of forgettable yeah it feels similar to this because it was kind of like yeah you labels and hexagons and okay it's a similar vibe in terms of like the actual placement um boy do i not like this game yeah i it just did not work for me um which is interesting considering that it has a lot of i would say probably neat mechanics um like i like the way that the work replacement is innovative um the fact that to end the game you actually have to get your workers out and then slowly lose them uh so yeah yeah slows you down catch-up mechanic all that good [ __ ] yeah yeah that i i wasn't sure how to feel about that right yeah it's definitely slowed me down early game i was just like oh let's throw out something why you got a free card that lets you just [ __ ] get one for free i know um and because this game is almost like everything that can get you like ahead is all luck all points are luck except for uh the actual dwellings part um and the
game centers around these elements and there's only ever going to be five out per game and so you like i don't know if the strategy is to go for all one color i mean you can't because there's only three of each color yeah but that kind of seems to be the goal hey go after the ones that you that your faction is right and then maybe one more i think the only reason i ended up winning was because i had dwellings and more locations okay because i mean like i just i was able to disperse and i netted a [ __ ] ton of points from that and the prophecy cards yeah those prophecies for cars that was that that was pretty sweet gotcha yep that's once i was looking through those and i'm like well i'm not gonna win through elements and i'm not gonna win through dropping my last one yeah uh i was like oh i'm just gonna constantly keep milling gonna keep going to the mage tower and keep milling until i find prophecy cards to be able to get end game victory points yeah um i don't like that i don't like winning like that i don't like sitting here and drawing cards and hope i get lucky yeah maybe like oh wow look three points i mean you're spamming yeah yeah and which i hate right it's it's not a fun way to play it's it was only in my favor just luck of the draw um but you still pushed it like that was a strategy that you could find yeah that's a boring strategy because that's the thing though is he had he had to really [ __ ] look for it because i did not i did not encounter
one yeah i didn't really go too heavy on it either but like not one at all yeah the magic cards were definitely very powerful yeah and they're completely unbalanced it's just like oh look at my free starting hand oh free free dwelling free person oh with free resources free quests it's just like okay well my my hand at the beginning was garbage it was like a fireball oh the only monster i out i can't [ __ ] use it against uh it doesn't matter anyway because battle in this game is like they basically took this game and took a [ __ ] hot [ __ ] in it with their battle mechanism that is the dumbest rules for battle hey roll the most dice and if you get a six you win we didn't really want to put in any effort into battle why that would just take too much time we want to make these subpar minis that that make a the same noise over and over oh and they die easily because wow they didn't roll a six but you did so you killed him oh yeah i don't like this game at all that's fair uh so what do you guys think well i mean i can agree with you with the like not really jivin it's definitely i don't know it definitely there was a strange there's definitely a stress to it it was also two hours long oh god yeah i didn't feel like everything i feel like we had the same thing with clash of uh of the uh clash of uh uh the tribal thing what was it you just
said rise of truth rise of tribes thank you i feel like they overstayed their welcome yeah i feel like that was kind of a similar complaint to that one but yeah oh yeah two hours i mean i was certainly like engrossed but i felt like i was stressing you know about you know getting all these points and i thought it was interesting the element system and just like how much it can just cascade on itself like if you like go all out on this one element and you go and you build your settlements on those elements you collect those doors for those elements and it's just like so you're five each one of these is now five points right i mean that's a lot yeah i mean that's it was interesting but it's like definitely adds to the stress mechanic yeah i mean you i mean because you basically place it's so weird because you place to get these stupid treasure tokens that you can either buff your tableau cards and i usually like games with tableaus uh because it's like oh here's what i built right now here's here's my abilities but it was like well i don't get to use them until after i regroup my people yeah so then essentially when you call them back then that's when you get the resources for the next round yeah and then it's like if someone goes somewhere before you then it's like okay i guess i'll [ __ ] myself oh you placed your dragon okay well i'll try and fight it okay i'll play a fireball fireball you know i have these so i'mma roll all six of my dice wow i rolled one six oh you got two sixes i guess you beat me you rolled two dice wow look at that you actually somehow you still won i hate roll to resolve when it comes to
battle it's a big reason why i hate a game called us uh summon masters yeah scythe uh summon masters uh some of their wars some of their wars is that the one that we played years ago okay years ago it's called summon uh summoner wars and it was the same thing you battle everyone rolls a die mm-hmm you hit them you hit or you miss yeah yeah it's like it's it's like we might as well just play rock paper scissors right yeah i think we've learned to this point that we just don't like dice in our battles yeah i like dice for like action selection i like dice for events um but battling it's just it at this point for a game that's coming on 2020 it's the laziest route to take because i mean while battling isn't huge in terms of points like you really only go up on the glory track or if you kill one of these monsters you just get one element from them you it's basically a big hindrance on the player because you can only place your units adjacent so the only reason i was upset when you attacked me there was not because you attacked me was because my whole plan i was trying at this point i was really trying to [ __ ] end the game uh was i was trying to build both there right and then the only way i can get to the mill to build was by go snake in that route gotcha and i was like okay well so you attacked me and you won uh even though i you know had adjacent people and all that you just rolled higher then it's like okay he's gone and i get a sword
at least you get something yeah for it cat what do you think yeah i mean i just uh i it is hard for me to put into words why i don't like this game because it is so separate from why you guys don't like this game there's a lot of stuff that i agree with that you just said like the the role to resolve i don't like that you've never really liked that um my first complaint is that um and it's gonna be kind of specific and it's gonna be kind of stupid that's okay because this is mine this is my complaint your opinion my complaint um the symbols are just small enough that if you are nearsighted or if you are sitting on the you know the head like if you're further away like i can't see [ __ ] yeah i and i'm not gonna lean over and while you guys are all doing your stuff and i'm not gonna take you know five years to try to read every card like i felt like i didn't go for those because i felt like i was going to be a bother so that's that's a turn off for me because well that's just mainly because of placement that i happen to place yeah but it's not a fault of the game but how i don't know i just kind of see like how else where else is it gonna go yeah this game is awkward but also that was just with the cards i also mean it for the for these as well so i mean because like this i can see just fine i can see everything here just fine but like i am i am just even with my contacts in like i can see um them a little more clearly now that i put them in but um some things just kind of like blend they start to kind of blend together um so
that's just a nitpick for me personally also because it's so colorful i feel like you play a two-hour game and you you mentioned the stress i wasn't stressed i mean i didn't give a [ __ ] who won um i was just trying to end it uh because once there was a moment when you got a free worker i immediately checked out yeah because i'm like oh okay so that's how the magic cards are gonna be they're just gonna be extremely random and well lucky you free worker that's good uh you already have a leg up and be able to build a dwelling and not be a hindrance um and then you got another one which was oh free settlement or free dwelling yeah it was just like it just cheapened it to like one gem is what it was oh it looks like so if it wasn't for free or if you had the nature yeah if you had like one element in nature it was free yeah but if there was no nature involved just one gym so like a three cost was down to one with one gem and you get you happened to get a gym because of your uh if i moved up on the truck the fire track um but yeah you play a two hour game and i feel like you put in the stress and you put in the time for really nothing like i didn't get anything out of this game like even where even the the prophecy where i was able to like i was i think i was behind oh i i think i took the lead at some point but then you guys were keeping up like even to snake a prophecy like win isn't rewarding to me like because i had already checked out so if i had like gotten like if i it had been a total victory i would have been like anyway game's over you know so it's like it's luckily my complaints
aren't coming from oh i lost that's why i have a problem i won and i still have all these problems uh and in terms of what cam mentioned about these uh adventure cards did you i never i didn't really get these for their ability right i got them for their part i was getting it for the points yeah that's such a waste of all these cards i mean as we were like going through these like i don't want this i i just want the end game point and i was like yeah you you waste these cards like blades of ice it's free if you have an orb to go up on the glory track you know and there's one yeah they have very unique abilities yeah and they're all like like one of my complaints is that there's no way to like mill them yeah that i have to just well there is if you'd go through the same deck like if you're going for a second card in that same deck you discard the top one okay and then you get to try and buy so like but you have to discard the the top one so you can't you can't say if like if you won if you bought this one as your first car then flip it and you're like oh i want that you can't date this you have to put it at the bottom and then go to the next one okay it's a really dumb way of milling but you're right yeah i didn't i mean that was a complaint because i had a prophecy card that was like i think it was like two or it was three points for each card in my tableau that cost four more resources i got rid of it because i only had one and none none of them came out yeah maybe if they i mean if they devalue the adventure cards a little bit yeah maybe you'd want them more for their abilities yeah i mean definitely like the adventure card like how it was difficult to go through those was a complaint of mine the monsters could be a little cooler
yeah i mean like they're they're they're like board presences isn't as intimidating as i thought it should be right yeah i mean i guess the noise yeah i mean that's unique it is unique and it's nice it was an effort but at some point they all kind of sounded the same yeah and then t-rex and the magic cards being overpowered i'd say those were my three top complaints yeah that's really all it is and that's kind of a big crux well i had another complaint yeah that's fine i like to complain um i did not like um the specific set of rules like this game was a little confusing to me and i know if it's going to be confusing to one person it's going to be a little confusing to others there was there were multiple times you had to tell devon and i um yeah you no you have to these are not free spots you can place so i know that we're not the only ones who suffer from that i feel like maybe they maybe there's something they can do to make that a little more clear i thought it was clear see to a certain person maybe it's just uh how we took it maybe because we didn't yeah i mean because it even has a player reference where it's like retrieve all your units from elder veil one at a time each may be used to perform a different card action in your tableau or replace directly into your right ear it like clearly spells it out but yeah like you guys were kept going oh i'm gonna go here and summon it's like no you can't come in yet i remember reading this and i was like i am not what yeah it's it's just it just did not it was not for me it just wasn't for us i feel like you have to state that when you do reviews like if i was saying this game is [ __ ] which i think it is people just assume oh it's [ __ ] for everyone this game may be fantastic you might like the role the resolve of combat you may like the
uh the random nature of magic cards and that's all fine you might understand a rule if you're reading but the the games that we like are are are based around strategy theme and and games like just tactics especially work replacement um and whenever you have all of these cards oh i will say the theme did get lost in the game oh yeah it was right out the window it was all about points and all this game came down to was place with your dwellings to get max points off of your elements so focus on one one or two and buy these adventure cards to get points as many as you can oh what do they do i don't give a [ __ ] yeah it's just whatever's on top yep can i pay for it let's get it yeah yeah i mean i knew because like at one point you didn't have a whole lot of adventure cards i'm like oh i might actually be able to still win uh then you kept buying more and i'm like [ __ ] okay better start milling through these and just hopefully i get some free points we played another game a while back called takanoko which was the panda one about the bamboo oh yeah we just kept wait we just kept getting through points points and that was a complaint with that game that's how this one felt uh i mean i can't say the production isn't great these game trays are awesome in terms of everything is just here and this and they made it in such a way that it's not oh just for organization in the box it's it's practical for setup okay boom and here's everything yeah no not enough do that yeah and so that's that's a huge plus for them on that but yeah these monsters
were they were just there they were honestly like the big ones i know the lava guy's supposed to look like a blob but the other one looks like a blob and the kraken doesn't look good and oh he has his back well i mean i don't like them i don't like them that way either i mean i think the art on them is is really cool uh on the back i like the art perspective i mean they have they have a bunch of different like they have a bunch of different like uh races so like the servants of the eye these abilities suck to ass compared to you guys like i get to place my dragon and pull one of you in there so i i basically i'm all about combat and then the the wizard was i get to when he when i recall him i can use one of your guys's tablets but i never felt there was a need to because i didn't give a [ __ ] about what these were giving me right it's just their points these are points and then the rattling swarm their dragon is a tunneler when you place your dragon you may use the action of an adjacent realm and so the realm of your dragon is in what's the rattling dragon click yeah i'm gonna look it looks like a muck guide doesn't even look like a rat oh okay yeah it's just like some kind of weird mud dress like a dildo it's kind of hoping for just a giant raptor yeah that would have been cool right um and then like the warriors or the workers each time your worker joins a battle gain a sword so those are like so i i would go out of my way and say that the abilities are not balanced um because cat had one where she could have gotten free glory track abilities and free i mean she had gold and potions that were
anything i suppose we were surprised a little more on how cutthroat it did end up being yeah how much more combat was involved because it's like because we're all recalling at different rates and sometimes you find yourself with a big pile of dudes and the board is [ __ ] full right and you're just like i have got to go to war yeah i mean i was never mad when battle was happening i was mad with the way battle was yeah and then like when you lose it not only the fact that you can't get your recall bonuses because like if you are going to use these you have to have workers to recall exactly if they're dead yeah oh no you can get the lucky raise from the dead magic card that lets you use them anyway nice but yeah you're right and the the recalling like there was times where i'm sitting there and i'm like okay i want to i want to go to the mill and build a dwelling i really hope that cat recalls now oh thank god she is now i can go there and do my action uh there were times i wanted myself to recall just wait and go back to the spot yeah and the other thing was to get your last dwelling out was a way bigger pain than it should have been really i didn't get that far i couldn't do it because i never got my dragon warrior or wizard out oh you were all workers i was all the time i never i didn't felt they sucked yeah i gotcha and i was like i don't want to combat it was so frustrating that is such a huge like be i'll take the randomness of those combat is so bad for me with this game because it's it doesn't matter if like it should be the sum of them that would be even better where
it's like okay i'ma roll more so chances are i will roll higher than all of them like in total but just if i'm rolling four you rolled two sixes in a row yeah and just yeah i win against twofers and i think someone were all three one time and i was like yeah i think one of the monsters like i think you rolled like a like even fighting it's like you roll four dice and it's like damn look at that [ __ ] roll like this would at least be four two so four six eight you win you rolled a five and i rolled four dice yeah and so my dragon and a warrior just die because your your one worker somehow is able to slay both he was you know horrendous battle rules it's it's almost like whoever came up with that rule needs to be fired like it's if it was an intern do not offer him a job he's the manager now i don't know these tokens here the treasure tokens like i mean you kind of started to you did the mainly for end game points but it's like you're supposed to use these to buff i thought i was going to like that i was like oh that'll be neat because yeah didn't end up using it as much i thought well it's because like i kept dying yeah so it was hard like i didn't get to bring them back and go to my door for two hammers in a gym or yeah anything like that i played the plague that just wiped your whole unit yeah down and then now you're like oh i guess i don't get to do anything yeah did you do yeah didn't like yeah it was all points yeah it's all it was so maybe a few boons here and there well a fire i think was the only
one i mainly paid off from i did that once you went heavy fire at the beginning which was weird then you started doing the order well it just kind of like i found myself like i got there and i was like oh i could place a thing and then i end up killing the guy that gave me like two fires well this is working out i honestly don't even like the initial peaceful route like it's funny that i hate battle but that essentially netted you that dwelling for free just because there was a monster there it's like oh we're in a peaceful era i guess the monster has to abide by the treaty but and there was nothing in the rules where it says okay can you go somewhere that someone's at and it just doesn't you just don't fight or do you can you go in the spot with the monster and just not fight no idea number and he was sleepy i guess uh and even then i guess the way they limped out on the limp-dicked battle rules that's why the glory track didn't matter like i mean the only way it matters if you max out each time you move ahead you would get two points yeah yeah so it wasn't worth any points for some reason i thought that it would be worth the eight or something but now i never i mean mainly because we just played a game called tidal blades where there was like a champion track that was worth points but yeah this was only for i mean you gained two four six you can get six as you go up but eventually i mean you go up on the element tracks which get you way more points oh definitely elementary way to go i don't know i just think there's variety in this game because of the different units there's i mean of course a plethora of adventure cards it's all here i just think that they didn't hone the game
down um i'm really finding it difficult to think of positives because the negative really just soured my taste do you guys have anything that you did like i mean like i mean like you said it's very did you want it i was just gonna say i think we pretty much covered it yeah i mean i think definitely on like the tools within the game because it was well constructed i mean i mean like the miniatures are good but the trays it's very nice the art is very nice it's uh yeah it's just within the game mechanics you can't appreciate certain aspects so it is difficult um i mean because the the art on the yeah these are these are really cool yeah they're on the back of yours you have centaurs i don't even know who your years are pirates the pirates yeah and so there's there's eight total or there's so there's 16 total oh my god it does have hooves weird yeah so it's pretty cool um in terms of the art i will say it wasn't that expensive though oh okay it was only four hundred dollars no it was not it was i think 150 yeah so at least for i think for the components you know for the legendary edition for the production yeah i it wasn't i don't think it was overpriced which is lucky that's about what i was assuming it was that anyway i was actually thinking of that earlier um but at the end of the day uh i'd rather play way better worker placement or fantasy games yeah i gotcha so yeah uh i don't know if
you had anything else to add oh god yeah it's just one of those i can't really put my finger on i know i just like i wouldn't be like ooh let's play it again right i know i'm not in that mode i mean i felt like it did ah yeah i can see other people like enjoying it a little more yeah because i thought you were actually really really digging it no i was just into it because i was like oh maybe i could actually win this one can i do this it was funny when we were playing because we played battlecon before we recorded this and i was like man is devon going to win today is it going to be a win devon day yeah and i'm like no i can't let him win both games after a monster beat me in battlecon i'm like i'm just gonna mill through these and just god oh you know that's i mean that was mostly my excitement like maybe i'll win this one today maybe i'm on the right track you you really were i i just i started spreading out and then i got the [ __ ] this great wall those cars always kick my ass you always get the in-game score card i try to my ass every single time that's usually my strategy never i just never go because typically the way i view you right you think i [ __ ] learn the way i view it is like oh if there's a game that has end game goals that's probably where the points are gonna go yeah like you're gonna it's like it just depends on how well you can do to gain a lead that hopefully end game points won't matter um because that's something everyone goes for but the fact that end game points are random like the the [ __ ] exodus oh i happen to have all people like it's not it's like it should be like say its own deck that you get in a
more arduous way right i just think you can only have so many right or like you did you do no sorry i was like do what yeah like edo or these these the adventures being end game points because they are kind of a pain to go through they cost a lot more yeah instead of just random and draw three yeah if they could have i don't know like maybe a point value versus right operating off of the element they do have a point value where you oh yeah no separates like maybe if just the dwellings were the elemental value versus well those were maybe a little different i don't know something like that yeah i mean basically remake the whole game but yeah like it's just this this is not i didn't beat you through any sheer like strategy of my own it was okay i guess i'll just see hope i get free points from this and look at that just because i didn't have this great wall where every dwelling was worth two points if they're next to each other uh i didn't have that until like the final draw and it just so happened that i happened to be building right next to each other and i'm like great look at that 10 points oh wow so fell into your hands cat do you have anything else i do not do you agree with us yes you're like no i love this game scale of one to ten uh devin you might have a higher score than the rest of us ah man i just feel like someone out there would probably like it a lot more than we did but uh probably yeah just like there's a person there i mean i just yeah it's like like if you want people think cards of cards against humanity is the best
game in the world i've never actually played it i hear a lot about it it's it's stupid yeah i'm sure people just put the best combinations online it's anyway i'm off track i guess i will do a six i say like this yeah i'll give it a six yeah i'd say it's definitely above average it's just it's not really to my taste and that's the main thing that's harming it um yeah the battle system if you like the dice systems yeah by all means but yeah i felt like they missed it a little just definitely doesn't tickle my my gizzard all righty cat i'm gonna give it a five wow average game average game huh for someone yeah yeah uh i just i mean just like i will say i just didn't like it yeah just because i didn't like it so i rank games based off my personal preference so i'm giving this a four i think this is below average for this day and age this would have been great five years ago ten years ago you know uh it would have been a masterpiece ten years ago um but for it to be two hours long for you not to care about half the game keep forgetting that it was so long drop it into a four all right because that means a lot to me time right and for it to literally for half the game seems to be this tableau especially that's how you get a lot of your resources and for it to for us come down to i don't really give a [ __ ] what they do
it's just they're going to link to those i want to get that up so you're basically just mid maxing points like you might as well just like roll dice and that's how many points you get and like the battle system is just so like horrendously bad um that yeah i just think it's a below average game um no matter how deluxe it is like it would be a three but the [ __ ] game trades are good uh and at least they're practical so i think that's that's a good smart and like with this to literally be oh look at all these elements look at this giant monster and for you to be able to just basically one shot them and they don't come back yeah like it's not like they limp back to their lair or something and they're always a presence on the board nope they're just all right yeah where were the cards to tame them who knows probably some element yeah like i think i had one yeah i had one was when a a play when a monster rushes into a realm that contains one of your units dominate the monster there you go i didn't have the swords this was very early game where someone rushed in and i was like oh i can do no uh yeah so she could have done it and but i only had one so i mean and at the end of the uh like they're so stupid like they just don't do anything it would have been a little bit more taxing it's like oh man okay if i go to attack seth there's a monster there it'll come in um yeah it's just this game super fell flat to me so that's it everyone that's our thoughts on
dwellings of eldervale let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you