Expanding a favorite from 2025 - Forestry Growing Forward Expansion Review
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Johannes
and this is Cinema
and you are watching board gaming ramblings
and today we are taking a look at forestry growing forward.
We are. This is an upcoming spiel release. So it is obviously sent to us by the publisher. Thank you so much for that. If you are going to spiel, we are going to spill. We're going even if you're not going and we are going to hope to see you there. If you see us walking around or sitting or standing or doing whatever, maybe not in the bathroom, but other stuff like that, then you can show us a secret sign that looks like this. If you want to make sure to find us, you can find us h when we are demoing at the Allian booth, Saturday 2 to 7 and Sunday 10 to 2. Come by and say hello and maybe play time span and learn that game from us or just say hello or just not say hello and just show away
and we will we will be be there. We are excited for it. But today, Forestry, which is a great game.
I love Forestry.
And this is an expansion.
Expansion. Best [clears throat] thing about the expansion is that we got to play Forestry again. But we're going to talk to you about the things you get in this expansion and tell you if we think it's a worthy addition to your uh collection. If you don't own forestry, I don't think you should buy it. That's my first line.
Bottom line.
Yes. At least not if you're not also buying forestry because that would be like a bad purchase because you're not going to be able to play. You can make your own game with these components, but I don't think it's going to be such a great one. We're not going to go into detail about what you do in forestry or how that works. So you we we are going to think that you know about forestry before you watch this. We did a review on forestry, so you're going to go and check that out from last year. So first new stuff in this expansion, you're getting wooden upgraded uh pieces for the wood wooden upgraded pieces for the trees on the play on the board, which I think is good. I think especially now that you have more there's going to be more tiles that we're going to talk about soon that's going to be on the map. It is nice to have these. These are chunky. They're easy to grab. They're easy to turn around which you are doing in the game. Not a huge thing, but a nice little upgrade. There's also three new abilities. So, you are getting more variety. I think with the promo from last year, there's like six. So, now there's nine different, which I think is like a huge big deal. Huge big deal.
There's a big variety of abilities that you can choose from. Of course, if you're playing without the abilities, you can just choose now nine different people that you play without them having special abilities or doing anything different.
The other new thing that's just like new stuff is the starting resources card. So, instead of getting the starting resources from the base game, you get two of these cards. You choose one of them, you get what's on them, and then depending on where you are in player order, you might get some extra coins. And then you have the biggest part of the expansion which is the uh what is it called like beetle in
bark beetle.
Bark beetle.
Yes. Infection infestation extraction modes. That's the name of it. Basically there's people infecting not people bark beetle infecting the woods. So talk to me about this module. Sonova.
Mhm. it is uh put out these in the same spacesh as the trees on the in the map.
And if you move on to this space which has this No, you're not. Okay.
But all the other actions you can do on that space is blocked. The only thing you can interact with on that space is this bark beetle infestation. And then you basically use one action point to remove this. This goes into your um what you call playerboard. Yes. So it takes up space in your tree holding area. Yes.
And but you have to have to remove them and and that's a good part.
Yes. Because you can get stuff from it because when you move around with your sawmill director from place to place now there's going to be these three new three new uh locations that are placed behind not behind them in between. That's what I'm trying to say. in between those different modules. Not modules, sawmill locations. So when I move from one HQ to another, I'm going to move past it. And when I do, I'm going to get a resource. You have placed here. They're not usually placed there, but you have place here the resource that you can get. These are three new resources that we're going to talk about soon. The other thing you can do is to deliver. So let's say I moved past this one and I have these three. I can choose to deliver all three of these to this location. And then for each I deliver I will get two stars which is movement here and two points. The other one is resources and three coins. So you can get some extra resources from that. But also these are three new final scoring.
So they're going to have different things that they score each time you play. Not each time you play if you play it like a gillion times, but that is the same in every single game. And then this is a majority. So let's say at the end of the game it looked like this. Then this one would be worth the most points. you can kind of like try to get the thing that you want to score to be worth most. So it's going to be 1062. Then this one is going to be 741. And then this one is going to be 530. So then it's a majority of course in the thing that you're scoring for that location. So it basically gives you another reason from to move from one location to another and maybe you didn't want to move to that particular location because of like the actions on that soulmate or HQ wasn't like I didn't need that right now but these are taking up space in my on my player board. I need to get rid of those to be able to have more trees here. And then I don't want to trigger that other scoring because you're better at that one and me. And then so it adds to the things you need to think about in this game.
Yes. And from before it's nothing to think about in the game. So just a bit more of that is very
about time. Talk to me about these things which are location tiles. Those are new locations and those are added to like the double spaces in each area of the board. Most of the like spaces on the board are single spaces. There's a few double spaces that go there and if you are in that double space, you [clears throat] can interact with those locations and you basically take the resources that like belong to that location from your car. you can have at most two resources on the car at the the same time and you place it there and you get some bonuses. It's very simple.
Yes, really.
That's basically how all of these three work. So again, it just adds a little bit of oh, I have that resource. Should I move to that place so I can deliver that resource to get some extra stuff? Adding again more just more choices in the game which already had zero choices in it from to start with. What I like about these additions to the game though is that besides um removing these bark beetles.
Yes.
Um I was almost saying the Norwegian word.
Um it's it's all like free stuff. So, so you don't need to you don't need to do an action to interact with this and you don't [clears throat] need to use an action besides your original movement to interact with these. So, it doesn't add to like, oh, I need to spend a lot of more more more of my precious precious action points on this. So, you can still interact with the expansion. Nevertheless,
it adds a tiny bit more luck to the game. the game already had some luck because you had a deck of cards that whenever for example one of the forciles is taken you draw another card and that might be like oh it added where it was very easy for me to go and get it that kind of thing was already there so this adds a tiny little bit more of that because whenever somebody gets I think it's 4 10 18 and 28 points you're going to add another of these to the board so these are going to be placed on the scoring track so when every player gets four like not not after everyone but like when I get four and then when and the other player get four.
It's nice balance with more players, too.
You're going to add more of those tiles and going to be added to a random location which doesn't have one from before and doesn't have a harvester. But it might be like, oh, I plan my actions and of course it it's I could go and block the space by moving there. But it's a new thing that is more random because I have planned my actions out perfectly. So if I move there and and and harvest those trees, but now suddenly this one is where I wanted to go and then I need to have another action point and I don't have that and don't want to use my last money for it. So it adds a bit more chaos and a bit more not chaos but like a bit more randomness that can be
um destroy destroyable like destroy your plans in a sort of tight game like this. It wasn't a
big problem I would say.
Yeah. Like because also my strategy last time we played was grabbing this. I was always happy about this. You didn't grab a lot of them. So you were in a position a couple times where it was destroying your plan.
Yes. I I I had two locations that I could visit to do the thing that I wanted. Both of them were bark beetle infested.
Uh so and and like this game is super duper tight so that like oh it's one action point to get rid of that. That's one action point that I don't have. Yes. Like all the time. But I think it's like when you're playing with more players, you you have that interaction on the board already. It's less with two players. Um but but but with two players also, but especially with three and four, it's like this. Are you going to go there and grab the tree before I do it? Because then it needs to be reforested again. And like Yeah. But this is a little more unpredictable.
That is true. And also like if it's still it's more random and not like I'm blocking you, which we don't often have time for, but like I'm doing it before you. And before we go into our kind of final thoughts that we do for expansions, uh I'm just going to say that I'm very happy that we got to play Forestry again because Forestry is still a fantastic game. After we played, I was like, I would like to play it five more times, but we don't have time because we are playing playing all these skill titles right now. But hopefully one day I will sit down and play more forestry. So we are rating expansions basically with two different metrics. The first one is how often would you play with this expansion because some expansions are like this is one I would only play with experienced players or this is one I would never use. So basically it's a four four tiered rankings which is rarely used occasionally use regular use or never play without it.
Yeah.
Where would you put this? I think I I wouldn't say I would never play without it because I think the game is stellar as is. I don't think like this it does something essential to the game that I would miss if we remove it if you get why what I'm meaning. But it's such a simple expansion to add. And also, you could very easily, besides this block.
Yeah. This coming and blocking you and and you have to like deal with it, everything else you could really easily just like
ignore.
Yeah.
And and I kind of ignored like a little bit of this part and I still got some points on it. So, so like you you could have some small benefits with it without going like heavily for the thing that the expansion offers.
Did you answer the question though? Did you say which of those categories you
regularly use it? I would say what would you say? I think like it's it's the thing is that this is one of those expansions which is just like a little extra thing like the module because this I would always include like in the pool of of things to add and this I would always include because it just I think I really like this as well
like the starting resource card just adds a little bit of a different starting position so you have like a little bit okay because I start with this it's pretty decent for me to be able to do this thing that I wouldn't be able to do if I started with the basic starting resources. So I think those are always included and this is as like this is such a small addition.
I think if it wasn't for these blocking so like okay if I'm playing it with somebody have never played a game
I would play without it other than that I would always play with it
because there's no reason not to
like because it just adds a little bit of layer on there. Doesn't change the gameplay too much but just adds to the game for me. Yeah.
Next up is when should someone buy this expansion? The first category there is don't buy it, which is skip, which is for bad expansions. Then you have only for super fans. Then you have buy when you finally buy buy when you find out you really like the game. And then buy it when you buy the base game.
I don't think this is a game that like expansion that you
It's not a game. Yeah, that's true.
It's not a game. Uh, it's not an expansion that, as I said, fixes anything in the base game. So, I don't think it's necessary to buy with this with the base game as from the get-go. No,
but I think this is if you really like the game like aren't that for the most part for I wouldn't say skip it.
No,
I wouldn't say it's only for super fans. I would say it's like in the
the second category. Yes, there's only four of them, so you have to choose one. I forgot which categories there were.
I would put this in the only for super fans.
Oh,
which like is in the category of players who played this more than like 10 to 15 times.
Oh yeah.
Because the base game already has quite the Let's say you play the advanced game, which I think you always should if you played it more than once or if you enjoy heavier games, which I think you should if you play this game. If you don't have the promo, you have five of these already in the base game.
That's true.
So that means you can play the game 10 times and you have tried each of them twice.
Yeah. You can play it 15 times and I play each of them three times. So, I think it's a really good expansion, but I don't think it's one that you do need.
I think it is.
And I know most people don't play their games 10 to 15 times. For me, I use an expansion as an excuse to be able to play the game again. So, if you do that as well, then it's a good thing. And like this is easily to implement, but I don't think it's one that you need, which isn't saying anything bad about the expansion. Just saying that there is a lot to explore and enjoy in the base game before you need to get more stuff for it.
Yeah, because the base game is like you have a lot of variability as it is. I think like that those new new chunky wooden pieces are nice, but like
I wouldn't and it also I don't know what the cost of the expansion is. Probably should have checked. Like if it's a very cheap one, I would just buy it because it adds this and add this stuff. Other than that, it would I would personally think it would be for a super fan of the game like me, even though I haven't played it 10 to 15 times. Mhm.
Or if you're just one of those people who like of course always you know if you are going to enjoy it or not. But I think like if you are like oh I played all the different advanced characters in the base game I want some more. Then of course this is a good one. But I think like if you're a super fan of the game you should actually get it. Yeah.
And that's the end. Hope to see you at Spiel. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes. I'm
And you've been watching this channel which is Board Gaming Rambling. Subscribe. Byebye.