Isle of Cats: Discussion
Transcript
Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for the Isle of Cats, which is I'm a little bit behind cuz this game came out last year and I had not had a chance to play it, but I picked up a copy cuz it's on Kickstarter at this point in time. I and to be completely honest, I was like, I don't really know what this is about. So, but it is a another polyomino game, which I actually really like polyomino games. I they they're like the perfect amount of like puzzle to um like pleasure. I if if that's the the right phrasing. Like you're not overly stressed about how you're going to fit the pieces. Um but still you're not just like it's not a very obvious choice where you're just going through the motions.
Um What do you guys think of Isle of Cats? I liked it. It was cute. I knew you would like it. Uh I very much like it just having the the cats on it as well just adds to it. Um Brett? Um overall, um it's actually pretty good. Oh, awesome. Which surprises me because it includes several mechanics that I don't usually enjoy. Yeah. Um but Being of which, which mechanics do you not normally enjoy? Um drafting can be hit or miss. Okay. Um usually it works out pretty well. Polyominoes I really like. Um my mind works well to fit things together and stuff. Like the puzzle aspect and you can kind of see how they're going to fit. Yeah, and and then go, "Oh crap, I can't get the one I need." Yeah, whenever I was like, "Oh, this is going to fit perfectly." And then I nope, all the one tiles are gone.
Resource management, again, can be hit or miss. This one, there's really only a couple of resource to manage. Yeah. Um Actually really just one. Uh the fish. I guess the ca- And the cards. Uh those aren't inherently not resources, but yes. Still something you have to manage. It's a minor engine builder, very very minor. Yeah. Just just with the lesson cards. Public lessons, the the private lessons, I usually don't like the mechanic of, "Oh, pure 38 points. I win." Yeah, right. end. Right. But in this case, again, it it just seems so evenly spread that Everyone had a really good Yeah, like I Seth had five cards, you had four, I had two, and we all were pretty Mhm. And yours came up at the very end. We were working on ours a little bit longer. I handed you some that you You handed me one that was like had exactly five green cats. I'm like, "Well, I have four." And then you handed me another one that was draw random tile, and I was like, "I'm going to take those two cuz maybe if greens don't come out, I might get lucky and get my fifth my fifth green."
That's what I did with my five blue cats. I already had five and I was like, "Well, I'm done with blue cats." So, it does have a way of strategizing in that way, but it's also limited in that you can only choose two cards at a time, which is frustrating, but fun too. It could be one card at a time like most drafting is. Take one cat and say, "But I want two." Then how could I I could have never gotten two Oshax. So, anyway, um again, uh does several mechanics that I don't generally enjoy better than most games. This this game has no right being as as solid and as good as it is because when you're reading the rules and when you're understanding the game, it's like, "Okay, you're going to draft. All right, then you're going to draft cats. Okay, then you're going to manage fish resources. Then you're going to manage cards. Then you're going to do end game scoring as well as public objectives. It just seems like none of those things coincide together. Like especially as you're like if you're reading this, it's just like, "Oh, this phase is drafting. This phase is is placing. This And uh And it just seems so like initially disjointed, but everything connects in in a very very fluid way.
Um that I like as I mean because it's like it's like a sheer perfect balance of what you normally have to manage with a lot of stuff like the pre-planning or the or the future planning like the long game as well as trying to manage what you're doing right now because not only when you're drafting and it all comes down into the drafting, honestly. Um And normally it's just like like if you were to take Seven Wonders for example and you get hit with seven cards, you're just like, "All seven of these are good." Mhm. Um I don't want to hand anyone want to hand anyone any any and you have to kind of think that way. You have to think, "Okay, well, I'm going to take this card cuz that's best for me." Or if you want to hate draft, be like, "Fuck that person. I'm going to take it and it and so they can't." But in this one I did that a couple of times. Well, but Keep good cards out of your hand.
You get handed seven cards that whatever you get every card that you played out or cat played, I never sat there and was like, "Wow, you only took that so I didn't get it." Like it was like every card is beneficial to someone. Yep. Um Of course you didn't see the ones we threw out. And that's the other thing. I think that's another way to keep it so you don't cuz there's only six Oshax. So, it's like if they were played face up, you would know, "Oh, you know, this um I'm I'm going to get rid of this brown because [ __ ] you." Uh You you I would have if I had the chance. Or or you can't you can't uh card count. Right. You can't be like, "Oh, okay, so I mean, if you know there's exactly this many, but you don't know if it's in the deck still or if someone got rid of it." Yep. But yeah, it's it's amazing. You get See, whenever with the cards they're so easy to understand.
Yes. too. And it's not like you get, you know, a book and you're just like, "Okay, so how does this one work?" Like Well, it works like this unless you have this. Yeah. The only icons are five fish. Yes. And just indicating what the rooms' shapes are. Yeah, I mean, cuz yeah, cuz yeah, that's exactly right. don't mean anything. They're just these are clustered together. Mhm. That's it. Yep. They will be minus five points if a symbol is showing. Yep. Um And I I think that's fantastic. And the way that they give you ways to get common treasures I just adds to the the puzzle, but not in a way that it's just like, "Oh god, this is one more thing." You just Okay, well, I'm going to cover up this I can see that's red. I'm going to cover this up with a red cat and then take this long three or whatever you want to do. Yeah.
And they're all different shapes from the cats. The cats are all larger, cover more area, so they're easy to see where I want to place those. Those are really space fillers. Yeah, that's exactly it. And yet there are ways to maximize their points because there's the public I love the private and public how those come out. Because once again, it comes down to And I love card drafting because whenever you're handed the seven and it's like, "Okay, that is a that I this could be one of my two." Mhm. Like I have to sit here and Okay, nine points if I have exactly five red. Nope, cuz I don't have red. So, I'm not taking that one. Or you can take one that I took earlier that was like have one of each cat. Did I even do that? Nope, I didn't have a blue. There you go. I I I needed three of each color to get That was the very first private that I put down. Then I was like I had all green and I'm like, "That's not that's not happening."
Right. Um Actually, I No, I didn't have two red or three red either. Yeah. I I I saw that one right off the bat and went, "Ah, no." Yeah, I was like, "Yeah, I can probably do that. I'll I'll do that." But then the way that these shapes come out, it's just like, "Well, maybe not." I'm kind of wanting to fit it all so it fits perfectly. Um But love the love how you draft the cats. Like you're only limited by how many baskets you have. And through drafting, you can take a whole hand of seven and potentially draft a [ __ ] ton of cats, but you're not going to get any treasures, you're not going to get any any time cards. Um It's it's the the drafting is truly truly fantastic. I think honestly, the drafting almost the polyomino kind of takes a slight backseat to all the abilities you get from drafting. Yeah.
Uh or they kind of they really go Most of the strategy is in the card drafting. Exactly. And and fish management. Yeah. Actually, fish management isn't really an issue cuz you always get some before you have to pay for cards. Yes, you will always get And none of the cards are expensive enough that I felt I never ran out of fish. I didn't till the very end, but it ended up mathing out perfectly for me cuz really what I kept forgetting to do was putting out the the cats before because whenever you get your 20, depending on how the cats lay out and which ones you want, that'll probably dictate how many cards you end up keeping. That's true. But I love the fact that at the end of drafting is then you take your seven and then you decide to pay. Instead of paying as you go because then you might accidentally pay for something be like, "Oh, this isn't even useful." Or or unless you keep something out of someone else's hand when you don't have to commit to any resources to it. You just I know I'm going to slide that one away. Yes, exactly. Cat, what do you what do you what do you think about all this all the the the laying out? Any issues? Any No, no. Um I think the only layout issue I had is that every once in a while like uh I was getting a little weirded out by how the planks naturally ended versus where the white lines ended. And I would be like, "Oh, no. No, wait. No, wait. Sorry. No, I like um that was literally Planks. Yeah, if you look at the [ __ ] board every once in a while, like you see like a darker like a darker brown leads into a lighter brown just naturally happens.
Oh, I Okay, I kind of see where you where you're going. So, I would be like, "Oh, wait. No, it doesn't go that way." But um that's like the most minor complaint that I have. Um design-wise, everything is really good except for some of the symbols. The Oh, yeah, there are a few symbols that you literally cannot see. a little lost, um which is It's true. They're black on really dark. Yeah, it happens. Um I I like polyomino games a lot, so I I really liked it. There's nothing about this game cuz we played a game um Oh, what was it called? It was so It was some generic ass polyomino game. Cosmic Colonies. It was so [ __ ] like think of the most generic space theme you can think of and it's double as generic as that. It should have just been a white sheet of paper. But each each each tile there was only a limited number per player and that one was like oh okay I'm going last. Cat goes takes that one. You go take that one. Well, I guess I can't take the only one that that I could that'll fit in my board. And I absolutely despise it cuz it's like well, I guess I'm just going to get [ __ ] cuz there's a limited number.
Here I mean really you're only limited by Yeah, I mean people can draft and take some of the you might need but just how much freedom you have with the with like the the cat layout and the fact that we're all looking at different goals after the first or second turn. So we're not right trying to draft the same thing and jockeying for position. Yeah, cuz I don't think there was ever really a time that the only time I was like trying to compete was whenever I played the card that moved cats over and cat was like the only one at the time I played that she had a orange and I'm like okay, well I'll move that and make it more expensive. But really it's like oh no, I have I you get I got 20 fish. I can still pay for it and that didn't really hurt as bad. It's just really nice that there's nothing about this game that is cutthroat cuz I always like my I mean I love games where there's score sheets.
Like I love end of game scoring. They're less way less disheartening than a track cuz if someone has like a runaway lead then it's like well, why am I even trying? Yeah, it's like I I gained five points and you're already at 60. No, there's end game scoring. You're at 60 and I'm at five. I'm not getting 55 points at the end of the game. And here has the perfect balance of both end game cuz then you have the public objectives that come out that we did real I don't think I've seen that. I don't think I've seen a game where you like normally it's like oh shuffle car shuffle these public objectives like Sagrada. Shuffle these put and then these are the ones that everyone can go for. Those come out if players decide to do them. You may never have any public objectives or you might have one where it's like well, I'm the only one who has red and so you play that at the end and it's like ah I'm the only one capitalizing off of it.
But you can't hold on to them either strategically. If you have them in your hand you have to play them that turn. Yeah, oh you're right. Yes, yes you do. But if it comes up at the end like I handed you a couple that ended up being worth something. Right. Yeah, I was like thanks. I wanted to keep others more. Yeah. I made that decision. I don't feel bad about it. It it got me uh three more points. No, it gave it got me you're welcome. Like seven more points. But actually no, you gave me nine points cuz I had exactly five green. But what's also cool about that is you can I was handing cards to both of you that I was like these just cost a lot. So if you decide to keep them, that's just going to cause you more fish and I'm still going to have enough that I can rescue enough cats cuz I just have the fish available and oh look at all these three that are exactly what I need or all these treasures which are perfectly they just stay there and you have cards that you pay for to get them and they're worth three points.
Like and it's just another freedom. You're not only limited by the cats. You have so many ways to fill up your boat being a common treasures rare treasures or the or I think I don't know what these are like having them on my boat. They for some reason never went to me. I didn't have the catnip to get them over there. Also got to say absolutely think it's adorable using the box to have a cat set up. That is just so [ __ ] cute. It literally is like I don't know if there's like a reason they made it look like a target but I'm not saying that the launcher cat at it. No, but I I keep seeing things on where like if you put a circle on the floor or like a square or anything that looks like something a cat might go into, the cat will go into it. So I think that's cute too. I don't know. I think it's just I think it's just a target. It's also a target. So again, you can launch your cat at them.
Cuz I mean that's just the perfect thing because I mean I even showed pictures of Lincoln when I was organizing how he just gets in and lays lays down in it. And Zelda sat in it for a little bit. And then she's Yeah, cuz Lincoln was like get the [ __ ] out of here. This is a setup. I'm like I like put them on and I'm like what are you doing ON THE TABLE? HE'S LIKE YEAH, SO I am absolutely floored with just how solid this game is. And I mean I I mean we I have a few polyomino games and I've played a few Cosmic Colonies which was just ass. It was so The only interesting thing about was the card they had some card drafting but it wasn't anywhere near as good as this. But the we've played A Feast for Odin which is like the penultimate like [ __ ] polyomino game.
Indian Summer is polyomino. That one's That one's not bad. Then there's the 900 other generic ones like what is it? Spring Meadows and I always forget There's just the Cottage Garden. And then Patchwork. Yeah, pretty Yeah, pretty much of a Rosenberg's whole series. I feel like I have There's probably like one more that I'm forgetting about cuz there's there's just a bunch of them. Oh, My City is a polyomino legacy game. Not bad. Very quick. Very quick. It's It's pretty good. So it's a theme that I enjoy. Did the cat theme work out for you cuz I remember you saying that you're like this this didn't need to be it. I will I I will say as I was reading through the rules I said there's nothing about this that says cats to me. It just seems like you know, it's it's pandering to people who love cats which is totally fine but for me I just played it abstract. I didn't care about the cats. I didn't ooh over them or anything like that. But that's me. I just got rid of my cats so it's not that I'm a hater. It's just that I'm It's It is It doesn't speak to me. But the people it does speak to you, it it's a huge thrill. I get it. Yeah, now I will say there is a story. Like they actually did give it a theme like city legends have always told of a fabulous island where a race of ancient wise fearsome playful cats made their home. Recent scouts from Squall's End have revealed that it is real but it is threatened by the approaching armies of Vesh Darkhand who will stop at nothing to destroy the island and the rest of the world. Trees will burn and the
ancient rocks will be broken but there's a chance that these noble creatures can be saved. There you go. If the so that's why got ganked. No, remember I said they formed gangs. They're like the they're the cats from Monster Hunter. Like they're they wear little pirate caps on, scars and eye patches. And then Vesh is like all right, let's burn this little cat with its claw comes up. Yeah, or one just walks up and just like takes takes out and just right in his jugular and it's dead. He's dead now. But it is nice that yes, this is a essentially an abstract but I give him a lot of points for creativity and consistency. That's what I was going to say. Yeah, I mean yeah, it's not like this game is speaking campaign or story or anything but it is a unique theme.
Like it's definitely better than [ __ ] bars. Give us the dogs. What's the opposite of an isle? The studio apartment of dogs. The lagoon of dogs. What is the actual What is an isle? You feel smart? You feel smart asking that question? The valley of dogs. There we go. There we go. I got it. It's the exact same game. Instead of a boat, it's a wagon. They very much could and and uh printer. Just by getting a different printing of the exact same game and a whole bunch of other people would buy it and love it.
That's true. A boat of good boys. That's what they could call it. And instead of In Cthulhu. You're collecting little monsters. Instead of the target where the cat can sit in it, it comes with like its own stake and leash and then you just stab the dog. Yeah, you stab the box and then and then you you chain the dog to it. Now, this game is is absolutely fantastic. I mean the even the board layout works out and like it was I mean cuz the board the board is is the same like how like you know, where you layout. So the room layout but the where the where the treasures are are different. And the rats. And the rats. And they are double-sided. So which is very nice. Like this one has some flying koi fish. Was there a slight change of rules on the other side? I didn't remember. Oh yeah, that's right.
This is family mode. Oh okay. So if the family mode there are no points for rare treasures and there are no public lessons. So it's still rats for rooms, cat families and your lessons. Public lessons sounds like I'm going to teach you a public lesson. Looks like someone's a little lost. I'd like to lick a lemon lollipop in Lillehammer. Everything about this game works wonders. I have absolutely zero qualms with anything. I think it is a I mean the polyominoes yes, it's it's still the exact same. Like every polyomino like game has these shapes. Um, but how they went about scoring points using families to increase I mean if you got 10 of the same color that touch one another, then that is 40 points.
Yeah, so it's not just placement. It's also grouping. Yep. This this massive deck uh like there was never it's just with with this is it blows my mind so much with how the randomness of this because normally with game with games like this the chance of people top decking be like wow, okay, I wish I had that [ __ ] 50 points for having this card or something. If you have an erotic if you like furries, 30 points and you off yourself. It's just there's so many games that are like that that are an instant turn off for me where it's like you didn't do better than me, you got lucky with the your hand of cards. Even Cat getting the the Oshax over and over I was never like I wish I can [ __ ] get one those are worth 20 points a piece, you know, they could have easily just done something shitty like that. Okay. Uh like every other not every other game but like some games that I'm just like I they make me so mad. Um and it it just doesn't do that. Like it just doesn't do that. Okay, so can I bring up a possible negative then? Sure.
Just for fun. And it's a genuine question because I honestly don't know. So preface this by saying build quality, art quality again excellent. Mhm. Very nice, not overdone, still playful and fun. But I have never packed this game away into a box. Is it well organized or because it's got a bunch of different shapes and a bunch of different sizes? I I the way that the box comes completely empty. There is no insert. Um it comes all these are punched out because you put every color every rare treasures and every color besides the Oshax in this massive bag. This nice I rip it. This horrible bag. Canvas, right? Yeah. Okay. Uh so it all fits in here and then you just pull the drawstring. Then it came with bags that you just put the deck in and then the perma I mean really the fish permatiles these have their own bags. So it's just a few bags of inserts or No insert nothing that you have to try and like I mean It wouldn't work in this anyway. They could have if they did a they could have done a game trays where you but actually no you're right because then they would have had to have individual you could have I guess cuz like like oh okay yep these are these It's hard to put Yeah, it'd be annoying so they just probably went for oh just okay. All you do is take these. You have a bag for the common treasures and then you just oh these all go right back in here and it's already pre-shuffled. Like that's already pre-shuffled.
And you just fold these and that's that. So yeah, I mean storage solution it it's not a problem in any way. Cool. And it's yeah this is this is fantastic. Uh so you guys have anything else? Scale one to 10. We'll start with you Cat. Hell [ __ ] yeah, I'm going to give it a ding old I truly had no complaints other than a few aesthetic things. Um I'm going to give it a 10. 10 damn. For Isle of Me. For the Isle of well yours is okay. The Isle of Yours and you're you're you're Catherine. Yeah. And it's not even a Catherine with a C. That's actually what Cat's is short for. It's for Catherine. The Isle of it's the abundance the abundance of Catherine's actually comes with the John Green book.
I'm Brett. Um I'm a hate green fan thank you very much. I have a hard time giving giving anything a 10 but I really cannot think of anything wrong. It kind of comes down to personal preference then. Yeah, I know. I mean if yeah, I mean I'll call it 10. Yeah. Uh Yeah. Yeah, I mean it honestly I was thinking nine cuz I'm like still it is polyominoes but damn they just give you that perfect level of of satis of of puzzle to satisfaction. So many options with Multiple layers of puzzle too. Yeah. Where you place them, how you place them, how you interlock them and what ones you put together. Exactly and and not sitting here feeling like the the heaviest euro where you're just like If I do that If I do this okay then I'm going to have to do that.
moves I'm going to have to Exactly. There is literally none of that and and yet it all flows so easy. I was initially going to say that the game might feel a little too long but I really I think they they had it perfect with the the five the five rounds cuz then you just move that over and it's like oh okay time to score. Yeah. Yeah. Um there's no weird like oh I did this and now it's you guys get one more round and it's like I wasn't even prepped for that. And then just the sheer balance of that deck with the drafting the multi-use card I mean they're not multi-use but it's just like you draw them in the these are ones I'm keeping got to pay for those and then I also got to make sure I can pay to get some cats. Yeah, I think I'm going to give it a 10 as well. So Cool. that's been it's been a while since since we've given uh actually I think it's the first three-way 10.
For us yeah. Sleeping Gods I think got actually I don't remember if you gave it a 10. Yeah, I don't think you did either. So never mind. But yeah, so that is our thoughts on the Isle of Cats. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you.