Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mycelia: The Strategic Mushroom Game Review - Mushroom Magic!

Transcript 26:43

hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and this is our review of my Celia the Strategic mushroom game by split Stone games my Celia is all about them mushrooms it is mushroom magic yeah and uh it's the perfect game if you're a fun guy and if you're a fun guy you should probably hit the Subscribe button absolutely do it right now if you like mushroom if you like ball games click that button and uh some mushroom might grow around you you never know never know maybe cck find out let let us know if that happens and if you are also a fun guy fun people like fun clothing and fun t-shirts like this fun t-shirt yeah absolutely it's a great t-shirt than very much go and check out the into the M Link in description for some amazing clothing with a 10% discount on top of any other discount you can find on the website amazing Mt let's figure out how my Celia plays yes let's start this episode

Melia is a competitive game for one to four players that follows the life cycle of fungi you're going to be growing mushrooms to score points sporing them to expand your network and eventually seeing them Decay to unlock special actions myia plays in up to 90 minutes designed by JJ Neville and published by split Stone games the board is made up of lots of triangle tiles you can see that represent different environments and nutrients that the mus need to grow on a turn you're going to perform two actions from six options you can move your mother mushroom up to two spaces on the board you can send spores out from one of your mushrooms into the different terrain expanding your network to do so you'll roll your wind Dice and that will tell you which direction the spores go in this case this direction you can fruit which is to play a mushroom card from your hand by spending spores in your network that match the requirements on the card for example this one needs green and two red so I take green and two red from the network to fruit this mushroom it will go onto my player mats and the mushroom will go onto one of the areas of the board where I took one of my sports from you can discover discovering is getting a new card from the open market adding to your hand the mushrooms all have different requirements abilities and point values you can explore exploring is to adding a new tile to the map this will give you more places to go and send

your spores and finally you can Decay once you've spored twice with one of your mushrooms on the board you must Decay that mushroom that will go underneath your player mat unlocking a new ability for you to use potentially for the rest of the game the game ends when a player has decayed mushrooms in each of their four slots and the person with the most points is the winner so Matt let's dig into the mechanics of this game but before we do I just want to say that this is bit of an unknown hit for me this was a big Kickstarter hit it was it was um it came out of Kickstarter around a year ago um so let's say autumn 2023 um and he broke the internet literally broke the internet did very well and it's being delivered to backers basically now by the time you see this review it's probably there or very I started seeing on on Instagram like a few copies already to the to the Packers so and um uh Stone split games split Stone game um again this is a onean band publish company so he he basically started his own Publishing Company he designed the game um if I remember right his brother did all the all the artwork for for the mushrooms but it's basically been a oneman band that he went and I was he was like and never did a game before but it my Kickstarter and people really liked it and there is a reason

why and there is very much a reason why he did a fantastic job explaining what the game is explaining what the rules are and um and and just like showing it to the people receiving feedback changing the games depending on the on the feedback some more of the some the production choices had been moved by the people back in the game and that is fantastic and it's just like Big R Applause to to the absolutely bringing this to the market so let's dig in as we said to the mechanisms of the game um we only really briefly mentioned it but something I really do want to talk about is this sort of sort of not really area control or kind of area control peace control I guess um and how it sort of links with this weird triangular map setup I find it really fascinating M because you don't really see much in the way of those sort of triangle tiles in no you don't no you you don't is um it's quite a unique quirky uh modura map um it makes a lot of sense once you start playe because you will have your your wind dies that will just go one of the three directions your spores and how they're shap that they go out on all of that and on top of that it creates like a very unique map every time and um yeah and the fact that you're drafting so when you you're taking your explore um action you're going to get one car from the one one to from the the the the top and uh having a look at what the color

is and decide where that one goes um that is basically adding a lot of replayability because every time the board is going to be very different absolutely yeah yeah and that yeah that's thing that's very special and then the next things that we need to talk about it is on top of the map of course you're going to put the resources there normally resources are in your bank normally nor you take them from the board and put them here but in this game resources are on the map they stay on the map you can spend them from the map however yeah they might have your colors but they're not all yours absolutely I think that's really important to dig dig into in this game you've got this lovely little uh tile here with this lots of red pieces but my mother mushroom if it sort of wanders along here a those are now my pieces to spend as I wish uh if I've got a tole with lots of uh um lots of different colors like this one for example it's got blue it's got yellow it's got red it's got green I can move my mother mushroom there and I I now control these pieces and it doesn't really matter about the color of the pieces what matters is the color of the terrain that they're on yes so these for the purposes of making new mushrooms are all green they're all green uh and I can choose to spend other people's because my piece is now controlling this uh in general bigger pieces control small smaller pieces yeah and it's um it's a very um um simple but at the same time with a lot of De area control

mechanisms it's it's great it's it's not it's very unique you will get you will need a few minutes at the start to kind of like get into the rhythm of uh what piece does what especially when we talking when you start talking about the networking of sports uh but once you get there that probably we should talk about it quickly um is uh just a p Joy yeah it really does uh start to make a lot of sense once you played a couple of rounds so the network is important your mycelial network and that is a link of all of your different colored pieces an unbroken link if I want to build a mushroom or say grow a mushroom sorry uh with uh sort of green and brown uh requirements or green and red requirements I need to have an unbroken l of of green uh green and red or green and brown in this example blue player has access to Green um but doesn't have access so red here uh because uh this mushroom is controlling the bigger piece controls the smaller pieces if these were over here instead then you've got this unbroken link of of these resources that I could spend to grow mushrooms that have these requirements um it's really fascinating because you can just be a right Gip and move your mother Mushroom in the way to sort of then break that chain of resources so then that player doesn't have access to them anymore that's right it's um it can be really really cut through it can be cut through it could be very dynamic as well

it is it is um it adds a lot of interaction within the on the table like within the player on any count you play with two three four the higher you go the the more cut Thro it it becomes because the the starting map is always the same M so you need to explore so to get more toes around to get a little bit of more like um but it's you can be as cutr as you want even with the with the two players you can you can deliberately just like trying to stop what the other player is doing and uh if the other players leave you to be well that's good because you GNA do whatever you want you're gonna just grow your Mushroom Kingdom yeah absolutely so moving is incredibly important let's talk about the spores a little bit matter we talked about how the network roughly works you need an unbroken chain of your pieces that you control and then you can use all of those spores um your mushrooms will will have different numbers of spores that they'll spit out different mushrooms will have different numbers um they can Spore a maximum of two times before they then have to Decay eventually yep and when they Spore you're going to be rolling this wind Dice and that is the sort of little bit of randomization in this game which will tell you which of the three sort of borders the spores will blow over yeah of the of the triangle that's why this mechanism really really works with the Triangle map with the with the with sport going out in one of the one the

wind carries different and it's it's very thematic it adds that randomization yeah it's a little bit of randomization yeah um that I like it's not this game is not random no this game is not R this game you can plan what you're doing it's you can have a strategy yes you can react with tactics depending on what the other games what the other games do yeah what the players are doing what cards are available in the market Etc but still got that a little bit of um uncertainty when you when you start doing your turn that is never a bad things I think yeah it rewards good planning right because when you Spore you're always going to Spore where the mushroom is and then the wind will carry it so with good placement of the mushroom and growing them in good places you'll always have access to to those colored resources yeah exactly and that's that's the whole point of the game it's you need to have a strategy it's the Strategic mushroom game it is a strategic mushroom game with a nice Hefty spicy dose of tactics as well and Cutthroat and and a little bit of cut throating Matt we talked about moving and sporing and and growing uh new mushrooms which we dig into a little bit more uh all of the mushrooms have different uh Nutri nutrition requirements different terrain requirements and we talked about that a little bit um but the amazing thing about this is not only do they give you different amounts of points some mushrooms obviously the harder ones to grow are worth lots of points yes they give you abilities and these make the game really special yes so um one of the

action you can take is the decaying mushroom because again this is very thematic so you got your mushroom combing up your mushroom sporing a couple of times and then the mushroom eventually decays Decay and it goes back sad times for another cycle but once you decayed each one of the mashroom at the bottom of the of the cards will have a special power so as soon as you Decay it you will have some of uh e so for example don't know you can get sport um or draw two cards or whatever yeah some of the others are um for the rest of the game for example one will tell you like oh your mother mushroom now instead of moving two for the rest of the game it will move three or instead of sporing two now spores three or some other ability or some of some of them will power up the next mushroom growing on the same spot so it gives you like ongoing effect for that specific mushroom that you got the the DK Powers um are not not infinite it's not not unique to to each card so you will see that more or less you got those that probably like still like 20 25 difference out of probably 60 70 cards um but good enough they're different enough um however you can be trying to pull out the best combo you can and

someone can be just faster than you and finish the game before yeah right the game ends when four mushrooms are decayed in each of the spots or five depending on how long a game you're playing so um Matt should we talk about the production yeah let's go production let's do a proper section because this is Matt I think they've done a great job with the production especially it being a independent game uh launched on Kickstarter um not with any sort of major publisher backing the production's pretty great I can't actually believe that they it's just like is from the from the cardboard that they use to the artwork to the box I mean it's it's beautiful box look at that look at those mushrooms uh to the insert like the box it's got amazing it's like this insert furry insert yeah with all the players you got your boards here all the inserts are absolutely perfect I love good inside um I I I'm I'm speechless um because it's just like off like I love the artwork the artwork is in this style that I just really enjoy anyway which is this sort of naturalistic Darwin esque drawings of all of the mushrooms it's almost sketched it's great the cards are very well laid out um it's something like I I

would say this is the the um wingspan of mushrooms there you go it's the wingspan of mushrooms it's a very wingspan type Vibe on the vibe on the cards and the layout of the cards where you got the um the the nice picture the nice drawing on the top with the uh what the the the card and and the special action is I can see they they took inspiration from wispan I would be surprised if they didn't because it's um it's very but it it works so why not absolutely why not yeah the coloring is uh fantastic um kind of this funky Tile Design is unusual almost kind of like a Celtic pattern on everything here yeah um I'm not sure about the the the reason for the pattering but it looks pretty cool I think for me I think on the tiles I might have actually preferred more like um a hyper stylized like different types of Earth or terrain you know like a forest okay so so less abstract a little Les abstract a little bit more slightly more real like yeah not not Cascadia but you know what I mean in terms of the maybe might might have been more to my liking but I certainly don't dislike it I think I think that would have been difficult then to divide the the red from the brown I don't know maybe but you know that I just a thought it does what it needs to do does what it needs to do absolutely in terms of the actual

player boards and these sort of segmented boards depending on how long a game you want to play these are great these are double thickness so you've got little spaces for your uh your Spore trackers to go triple thickness triple thickness triple thick oh yeah there's a little SL insert the card straight under it it's actually very useful actually sort of slightly ra so when you DEC you see a little slot there yeah there is this little slot yeah at the bottom so you basically just insert the card at the bottom and it stays there and you and you just see what DK P you got on there that's actually very clever yeah and this is one of the that the guys did um because of the the of the backers so absolutely Round of Applause for that yeah fantastic I think the production that is is pretty first class it is uh I said it before there we go Matt let's talk about who this game is for so Matt who would you recommend my Celia for uh to all the people there lost mushrooms full stop simple as that first as first uh secondly um U if you even if you don't like MH I I know that the theme could be bit quirky yeah uh cuz it's not it's not every day he like oh I want to play a game about mushroom there are very very nice games about mushroom moral or what's the other card game you have fungi fungi funi fi also

known Mor El but um yeah that's yeah um but uh it is an era control game and it is a damn good ERA control game yeah if if you like a lot of interactivity in your games uh this is an interactive strategic game that you can really get your teeth into there's plenty here to really get competitive about as well this isn't a chilled out nature-based game it is it could could be if you maybe if everybody around the table aren't really nice then just like doing their own but if you want to win you're going to have to step on some mushrooms yeah right you're DEC some mushroom there yeah you have to stomp on some mushrooms a little bit in order to to get ahead and if you like a lot of of that interactivity in your sort of strategy Euro inspired games this is definitely definitely for you Matt where would you put it in terms of our complexity ratings CU I think we had this discussion I I'm I was saying actually almost Advanced but you think more towards the top of intermediates I think it's the top of the intermediate game cuz it's definitely um the rules are simple enough the bulk of the the rules are simple enough for um for a beginner SL intermed game uh there are a couple of things for example the um the networking of the sport uh understanding how the Wind Blows the the the um the

spores out um it can take control ET it can take slightly more than a than a beginner game or or a basic inter so I think it's that just like just a step below of the advance okay I think that's entirely Fair yeah sort of top of intermediate step below yes yeah interesting but if you if you like stuff like nature team games uh absolutely ever go yeah uh because it's not it's very nature based just like you is is very fun to just have a look at the cards getting the name of the oh dude the names of all the mushrooms are am Latin names as well they're a good love they're a good love you should see some of the cards you you all have a good love about it um but um so even even something like are you fan of wingspan yes give it a girl yeah this is actually if you you're going to say if you're if you're a fan of wingspan this will be I think for yeah he will definitely be with you yeah I think if you're someone that likes to and R about decisions and I've had this conversation with you I this might slow down a little bit because there is you have six options and you take two of them and they must be different yeah and so the order of which you choose them and which ones that you choose to make the best of your turn and then all of the different cards that you've got and sometimes combined with all the powers that you have might slow you down a bit so if you're prone to that I mean this might do that to you

I mean tap is always around the the analysis paralysis is is a thing I don't think that this is bad as other games but yeah I I see why you say I don't I don't 100% agree because you at least one of the action you do is always going to matter uh but but yeah I can see it happening I see I see people with a lot of AP trying to like uh make the most efficiency out yeah yeah could be a bit of a challenge but other than that I think this game flows pretty well absolutely let's do the rating then final thoughts let's do it okay um before we do our final rating uh let's throw up a couple of recommendations so if you like this game or if you like the games we're going to tell you about there Al one of the other there's some alternatives to myia one of the main alternatives to myia we've already talked about we've talked about both of these actually winman of course is inspired by you can tell by the way that the cars are laid out um by a little bit of the engine that you can build around you know once you Decay your mushrooms it' be similar in in wingspan you build a little engine you can go uh from there and I think it's yeah there is definitely an analogy to made be made there wingspan is significantly less interactive yes this is way way more interactive that's why I prefer this the W yeah me too actually uh and then the

other one uh well they they come out like mushrooms like mushroom um this is completely different game is a card game it's a two-player game but it's about mushroom and is a really good set collection to player game absolutely have another one to think about so Matt I'm going to go to you first uh do you want to give us your final thoughts uh and how you feel about myia I think this is definitely recomend recommendation for me and I will say to me for me it's more than a recommendation if you know what I mean okay well we'll see we'll see we'll see what about you I think it's great um I was really surprised when we played it and what I love about this game as well as the sort of the interesting way that you build a network of pieces and the sort of area control type which I think is fantastic I think the rules are really clear and straightforward this game feels different it feels like it's doing something interesting you say something really ride earlier uh while we were playing and you were like this scratches a different it it does it does something unusual um and it does it really well there's elements that I recognize from other games but how it's sort of How It's expressed here and all tied together is quite unique and it has its own mushroomy flavor yes a interesting mushroom broth it is uh and I think it's absolutely fantastic Matt so do we think this gets

the board shid seal of Excellence Let's do let's do it together let's do the thumbs up thumbs down so three two one go it does get he wasn't sure until I did that but yeah it's I think it absolutely does for all of those reasons it has a wonderful production it does something in a unique and interesting way it is highly interactive um which we both really enjoy abut absolutely um it is strategic with a heavy dose of tactics in there as well um It's a Wonderful product yeah we haven't said earlier but setup of the game and pack it down super super quick that's always going to get you bonus points for me yeah absolutely and it's it's just like is in in this category in this this life High intermediate game is absolutely fantastic and uh yeah I can't stop like praising about this game he wants to play it straight away so uh after this after this review so Matt let's take it to the end I won I won a lot keeps winning stop winning so what did you think have you backed my Celia have you received your copy are you still waiting for it has this game excited you has I and by the way this is coming out retail uh September October 2024 so like straight away and grab a copy maybe around the world yeah if you are watching this let

us know is this coming to Essen yeah are you going to sell copies at Essen and if you are then that might be a chance to pick one and we highly recommend that you do absolutely 100% let us know in the comments below what you think of Melia and if if you are excited about this game uh also things that you should do Matt are uh like the game leave the comment and most of all if you're a fun guy like hit the Subscribe button come on be a fun guy hit the Subscribe button absolutely make sure you do that also make sure you check out the rest of our content as we release new videos twice a week every single week for you and we will catch you again real soon C

Progress saved