Memoir '44 Comparison - with Tom Vasel
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Bassel and today I just wanted to talk a little bit about the newer version of Memoir 44 which came out late 2025, the original version of Memoir 44 which came out 20 years prior to that. And uh I wanted to just compare them to see what the differences are. I love Memo 44. It is a very light war style game based on the Commands and Colors system from Richard Borg. It's one of my favorite games of the genre that I've ever played. There are many different versions of it. Memoir was one of the games that put Days of Wonder on the map. So the new edition, just spoiler alert, does not change much at all of the game. It's more of a cleaning uh slight refinement, a 1.1 maybe 1.2 version. Let me show you the differences. So, let's start off comparing the boxes. They changed the art and it's almost like an unnecessary change in a sense. Um, sorry about the stickers here. Uh, the I like the original art. It looks almost identical.
I guess the main reason this one looks more war, this one's a little more cheerful. I think I like the original one better, but I will say that I think that the they probably change it just so you know which version you're buying. That would be my guess. And then after that, let's just take a look inside the new one. So, it has a nice plastic insert here with boxes. And in each of these boxes, they have all the stuff for your troops. And this is really nice to have these boxes here. You have one for each of the armies. So, we'll compare pieces a little more now. So, the top row is the new stuff. So, first of all, you'll notice that they instead of having these be a player color, they are a neutral color, which I think is a good change. Secondly, the new one is just a teeniest bit bigger.
And you also notice they changed the colors, which I think is useful because while the new gray and the new green would be really hard to see apart, but even the other ones weren't clear, now it's very clear. You can see gray versus a much more olive green. So that looks good. And I think they did a better job with the artillery. First of all, they look different. The original ones were the same. Now they have a different model for each and they also just sit on the board better. But this is again barely noticeable. The bigger deal is just the nice trays to hold them all in. Now here's where they made a very big different quality of life change. The original one you had your little card stands and they weren't bad, but the new one just looks gorgeous and it's also a little bit rounded. These slide in better. And you technically, so the original one sometimes you could put four of these together. Now you just need to attach a couple of them together and you are good to go.
And it's just really nice. Here I can't do a comparison because a long time ago I got rid of the wooden dice in my game and upgraded to some plastic dice. I think I had a third party make these for me. I can't remember where I got them exactly, but they were wooden dice. They weren't great. These are much better. They're very clear. They're easy to tell. They're rounded corners. I love the new dice. And this is another quality of life. These little poker chips that they add for targeting, but more importantly to say which of these people are you going to be using. So if you have a unit out in the board, you can say I'm activating that unit. It's just useful to remember what the units are that you all moved. And then once you're done moving them, have I attacked with each of them? These are great. I love them. Nice reminders. I'm being real careful with the boards here. And I'll tell you why. Because which one's which? As you can see, if I open this one up, grasp. Open this one up. Grasp.
They look almost identical. The lines are a little more defined here. And the same goes for the terrain. The new terrain. Again, how do you know which one's which? This is new. This is old, but they look pretty similar. The cards have more of a just their ease of helping you change. So, this is the same card. Three units on the left flank, but this shows only the one guy highlighted and it's just a little clearer. But honestly, that's not much different than the rest of the cards. The cards are pretty much the same. They just made minor changes like the one I'm showing you here. One of the bigger changes here are the rule books. Well, the original game you have the rule books and the scenario book together. The new one just has the rule book and then the scenario book is separate. Now, things are very similar.
They're still the same thing from the offer. They show the components. They just worked it so that it's a for a new era. It's they have very different looks, but the games are the same. And in fact, when we get to the the uh the new one here, or this is the old one. These are the old scenarios. You can see the scenarios look very similar. There's a big difference that there are 22 in the new game, and the original one only had, I believe, 17. They had 16 and then one overlord. This also has an overlord. But it just comparing the two overlords, you can see they are essentially the same. They show how you put the stuff on in a slightly different way. And there's a little bit sometimes there's a little bit of extra stuff. I think in one of these they're like, "Hey, here's a historical note about the flag of honor." But other than that, there's just five more scenarios in the new one.
Honestly, if you own Memoir 44, there is no reason to get rid of it and get the new one unless yours is all beat up. The new one is great. It's better, better dice, better uh trays, slightly better miniatures, uh the scenarios, more scenarios, but that wouldn't make me get rid of one and get the other. And if you were at like say a thrift sale and you see the old one on sale, you're not missing anything out by getting it. The new one is nicer. It's cleaner. If you've never got Memoir 44 before, you should get it. It's an amazing game. It's great two-player game. even better if you take two copies and put them together and play Overlord, which is four against four. One of the best ways to play Memoir 44. Um, I don't know if they're planning to make new versions of all the different expansions because that might they'll work with this. The miniatures will be slightly smaller on the old expansions, but they will work with this game in many ways. So, I don't think that's an issue. And there's still some things from M44 I love to to get from the past. They have a big uh scenario booklet, which is hard to find.
There's also a lot of great expansions for the Russian campaign, the Japanese, the Mediterranean. So, I'd love to see some of that stuff come back. But as is for a base game, this is a nice slight upgrade. You don't need to redefine a game when it's already really good. So, new one's great, old one's great, slightly better to look at. So, take that as you will. I'm Tom Vassel, and you've been watching the Dice Tower.
Hey, uh, thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh, we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We've links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel and I hope you enjoyed this video.