Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dark Domains 2nd Edition Review

Transcript 25:49

hey everyone this is me at the end of the Viking this is dark domains now dark domains is a game that I've had in my collection for quite some time uh and if you've been following my channel uh you'll know that I have massively reduced the amount of games that I own I'll talk a little bit about that in my uh my final thoughts and that isn't what I'm here to talk about I'm not here to talk about reducing the number of games in your collection what I hear I'm here to talk about is I'm here to talk about the fact that on this game a game that I really enjoy uh is coming out with a second edition and they are enhancing the base game and actually adding some expansion materials as well and so I've dusted off the old review jobs because I don't do this a lot uh as far as this goes I mean but um some friends of mine that run this company they knew I liked the first game and they asked me if I would be willing uh take a little bit of time to make this video and talk about what I liked about dark domains to begin with and then comment on the changes and then also uh talk about the new stuff they've added so I'm gonna do that now um and then we'll come back here and then I'll talk a little bit more about this game um the expansion stuff what I really like about the expansion and also just you know how this game has managed to stay in my collection after I have massively called it over the years all right let's do that years ago about four years ago in fact uh dark domains uh is a game that I

still have in my collection uh I'll talk a little bit about that in my final thoughts but let me just tell you right now at least for me uh that is pretty High Praise um when I did the video for this I couldn't wait to get the production copy of it because the original video was for a crowdfunding campaign um the designer and also the Publishers are friends of mine and so uh when they asked if I'd be willing to take a look uh at the game look at the enhancements they've done to the first edition of the game and also look at the expansion material uh I was I jumped to the chance because um yeah I was really looking forward to see what they did uh speaking of enhancements I am not gonna go into a full on how the game is played thing here uh I am going to uh just talk about um the the noticeable changes if you've played the first edition of the game if you want to see how the game is played I strongly suggest you go ahead and follow the link in this video because that will go back to the preceding video I did for dark domains because um in a nutshell the gameplay with some tweaks and changes it's pretty much the exact same thing so okay this is dark domains um you are a person that's been hired by the king to uh to revitalize this area of the of the world but in fact you are actually evil and you're trying to corrupt the portion of the world and you're trying to gain as many evil points as you possibly can uh and the person who does the best job of that will win the game so uh just go and like

I said let's just start off with some of the enhancements so it as with any game one thing of working in the board game industry that has taught me uh over the last eight or nine years now um has been that it doesn't matter how many times you play test the game doesn't matter how many times you take a look at it doesn't matter how many times you uh mess with it um you're gonna miss something you're gonna uh need to go back and somebody's gonna say wow this would work better if you had just done X and that is new uh it doesn't matter what Cam that is not a fault uh to the first version of this game of Amy the first version of the game I've played it I love it I enjoy it um but they did things to make things better and sometimes it's just as simple as adding a Tracker board which is like one of these and you can see I have one right there as well instead of having you know like umpty number of different resources that you have to have in different stacks and what have you in front of you now you can just have a token and then you can say how many coins do I have you know how many uh fire elements do I have how many workers do I have those sorts of things you can just keep track of those on this player board and also the the tracker board also gives you um the phase board over sure whether it's like a big phase board right there but now each player will have a phase board uh in the past uh you had a a figure that was the like the person that represented you at the beginning of the game like which uh what type of uh like the Avatar if you will

um that you played with um now you have these right but you're gonna get a couple of those uh and then that will determine your starting resources and after that you just kind of ditch it and that's been seen in a lot of uh modern games now where you kind of get a card that's randomly given to you at the beginning of the game and that determines what you start with whether you know and it's just you know different uh resources um like elements that you have things like that you just get to select those uh this game also has uh spell cards which you know are located over here in the past the spell cards were just like a big giant deck now they've kind of divvied it up to the different types of spell cards so you can grab and you have a better idea you can kind of cultivate do you want to have Attack cards do you want to have production cards defense cards control cards um you have a better idea of what you're grabbing when you're when you're actually taking your spells and so you can kind of Point yourself in certain directions if you will uh as far as the type of strategies that you're going to implement as you play the game I should also mention that there are just less of things now like the spell deck has been I believe they said it was had so there's less spells now uh in the game uh so it isn't one of those things where you have a giant deck of cards where um you never actually get the card you're looking for uh yes which which you know I've always I've always thought that was weird when you're playing a game that has like a stack of cards it's like you know like that big and you use like that much of it in a game and so

you could play the game probably like 20 times and there'd be cards that you'd never see because you're never getting through them so that's the thing where they've they've kind of ditched um some of the cards in some of these Stacks uh the building cards now if you play the game you you will you will build like this is a market and then later on you will twist the market into being like the black market you know by making you know an evil place that you go um so the building cards have been again um balanced refined and now there's less of them so you get to see those those cool things that you really want to see like here's you know here's the castle uh that when you when you turn it becomes the evil Fortress you know like you really want to have a cool castle and build that in your in your domain and turn it into an evil Fortress but what if you never see it when you're playing the game stuff like that and that was actually kind of something that that kind of poked in my head a little bit too because you have these long this long string of cards these buildings um and and buildings are really the key to the game because they create production uh you get to put monsters in them uh you get to like you know and and they just become part of your domain board but like there was never uh like when people would take them you just replenish them at the end of the round and the only way you ever wiped Everything clean was if nobody took any buildings which never happened it would rarely happen this is but now you know with less of the building cards like you get to see more of them again really really good choice as well uh for the development team in

the design and I should mention speaking of buildings and this was ingenious and then also one of those things where it's like so you have a building like let's say you have this market right and then and then you turn into evil black market and it's on your board and yeah the Scrabble monster and let's say you have this air Elemental guarding it um but despite your best efforts um when the adventuring parties come out and attack they managed to destroy you know they kill your monster they kill the black market they and and it's gone and and in the in the past it was like oh you know you you lose it you would be gone and it just like because they they blew it up but now um when this is this is awesome you don't have as big of a murder feeling uh you just flip it back over it'd be oh they they eradicated the bad it's no longer a black market it's just a normal Market again and of course you can you know send them send a minion there on your next turn just to turn it into the evil Black Market again as well but um and that works for all the buildings uh you no longer have the building destroyed out from underneath you uh when the adventure is successfully attack it um which I thought was a really really really good change uh you uh the first player token uh it in the past you had to go uh to the location on the board to have the first player took a move if nobody selects that the first player token still moves it still moves clockwise around the board um I like that uh obviously because um you know you'd always be in a

situation where because you only have in a work replacement game um even though they did I thought they did a good choice when they designed the game of making the when you go to the first player token they gave you some coins as well as getting the first player token so um it kind of uh enticed you to go and there but there were a lot of times when nobody would go and take it and so the person who's going first just kept going first over and over and over again and and because nobody else wanted to like you know quote unquote waste a turn to go there but now uh the first player turkey will still revolve around the board clockwise at the end of each round and the other thing the last thing that I really really noticed with the change and the enhancements to the game were the henchmen uh when you when you and again I'm kind of touching a little bit on how the game plays but in the there's these spots here where you get to you get to claim uh these henchmen they give you special powers and there's these uh two henching henchmen in the far-off lands that you have to just hope you get a good one like here's oh well that's not bad the arch Lich arsus uh months per turn you can convert workers uh into evil which I think is kind of neat you must slay them and turn them into Undead or something but um regardless uh the henchmen there were there were there were like lots of tension they were super cool and then there were some that were just kind of like you know and um and and the ones that were were all either like removed from what I can tell in the game and replaced with something better or they were enhanced as well and that made um

the henchman spots even more fun to go to and even more cool stuff uh but that's uh those are the things that that have it improved upon um so if you if you played the first game and there were like aspects of it that you were like oh I didn't really like this I didn't really like that um just know that the game has been rebalanced um given given a given a good once-over if you will and uh it has has been improved um in some ways they're like evident and more evident than others but overall just a more enjoyable play experience now you might have noticed uh this board over here this is the expansion board and um not only uh do you have this expansion board but you also get a bunch of other components that get added to the game now I should mention that this board is not going to be this small this is a prototype uh it will be a larger board and this one will just go on to uh alongside the board like I did over there but it'll be a larger one and there will be a designated spot to kind of just put it on the game board as well uh it is is a spot that once again you you place your minions or your workers into these locations on the board if you want to use them uh and if you remember um any or if you never played the game finger with um workers that are placed on your player board uh to um take actions that are on your board will um will go first then workers that are placed on there will go second and then you will do the

the actions that where you've placed uh on the main board as well I remember um the main board has that cool aspect of where you start with number one go to number two and there's kind of like a path that you follow and you and you process all of those things slowly one by one kind of thing so um but this one doesn't have a path you will just uh you know satisfy these before you actually get to go on to here and these spots are pretty straightforward um uh when you when you go up here uh to the black pool um when you activate that you will be able to just gain uh two elements of your choice if you go uh to the black Library uh that allows you to take two spells from one of the decks of spells that are over there and the final thing is the uh market and when you go to the market there's all these different conversion rates that you can do where you can actually convert evil uh into one of these resources over here like workers or or you know and this like here you convert one evil and and turn it into two workers for example um you know or one evil becomes two wood and you can also that you can see the arrows kind of go back and forth and so you can convert the other way as well um you'll notice that this spot is huge just like this bottom over here is huge for the Builder's yield um you can uh in either spot uh any number of people can use that that spot but you can only put one worker in that spot but you know but you can do these

exchanges as many times as you want so that's kind of one of those cool things there now that player board um you also will get a bunch of uh cool new monsters and it's kind of kind of tough to see this but like you know Phantoms and here's haramuto and if you kind of guess like with like the black pool and the wing Kong market and egg Street Library um this is definitely taking an Asian feel uh to it like if you will uh um like remember when d d actually had like the Oriental Adventures book that came out that had ninjas and stuff in it um you know so that's kind of like I think that's what they're going for here I I don't know for sure but these are cool you know a free but these are just more exotic um new monsters and you get a bunch of these and you get to add those to uh your monster Decks that are over here um you will also uh get a bunch of more Heroes you know you have a knight you know kanushi uh buso you know so once again staying with the theme there's a Samurai and you get um some henchmen as well uh that are once again uh themed for the expansion and uh you get uh some some cool new buildings that you that you also will get to build and those these are added to the deck as well and then finally um you get more of one of the coolest things about the game and I once again I said I was going to talk about the rules one of the coolest thing is is that they have these like um these this Fortune deck and the beginning of each turn you

take these two fortunes and you turn them over and depending upon the cards that you draw there's certain um aspects that will take effect that turn and affect how the game is played for that turn and I I this is one of the coolest parts of Dart domains I love that I love this aspect of the game but um you get even more cool Fortune cards um that are added to that deck so you can do play with them and I should mention as well that the expansion is super cool because uh there actually are two ways that you can use it you can just use it as a way to just add a bunch of cool stuff to the game and you can just add this stuff to the decks but there's also rules that give you um an aspect of like if you want to actually inject more of the expansion into the game it actually has rules of how to make sure that all like the cool new added material that you're adding to the game um gets added in and you see that more prevalently and I get why they do that right you know it's like if you if you have this game and you've played it lots and lots of times you've kind of seen the same monsters seen the same henchmen and so on and so forth you're like I you know I got all this new stuff I want to see that new stuff right away um they actually do include rules on how to add it into it um this is like the perfect kind of expansion for me it it just um I think if you've watched my videos for a long time or if you watch my podcast gear weekly one of the things I

I really don't like is when there's like I have a game that I love and I enjoy playing and I think it's awesome and then all of a sudden somebody was like oh hey you know we got this we got this new way uh to play that game that you love and awesome with this new expansion to come just just throw away those old rules let's just go ahead and do some stuff and I've never been a fan of those kinds of expansions but I I love expansions that just give me more give me more cool stuff that I can put into the game and to keep it fresh and interesting and that's exactly uh what this does but um you know basically this took a game that I already really really enjoyed and it fixed it in ways that I didn't even know it needed fixing uh because I already enjoyed the game and and made it cooler and then added some cool new content and so I'm really excited uh to see uh what the final results if you will are going to be once this game if the second edition of it comes out with uh the expansion material but let me talk about that and some other stuff and you know me I'll ramble uh in my final thoughts all right so that is dark domains uh as far as the new stuff goes and as far as uh like the the new expansion board and how you know those things have enhanced the game and also just made the game a little better so uh you know dark domains I mentioned the this is still my collection and if you've watched my um weekly uh show that I do uh with the industry folks and uh some other the

other v-log stuff that I've done I've talked about the fact that at one point my collection got to several thousand games I don't never I never counted it if I had to take a guess it was between four and five thousand board games and it was way too many and and I had a situation where I had to redo the flooring here in the basement my wife and I uh redid the whole thing ourselves and I had to basically clear everything out of here and this is where my collection was and I took all of my collection I moved it to a storage locker and when I got to the storage locker and then when I finally got to the flooring um I basically sat there and I said you know I I didn't miss hardly any of the games hardly any having any of them on my shelf hardly any any of them just being available to play and I realized it was just for me anyway it was just silly to hold on to them so I've been calling it and I'm getting rid of them and getting rid of them getting rid of them and um you know I'm I'm down to a more manageable number though I don't know I don't know what the exact number is but the reason I'm telling you that is because when I've made up my mind as far as Windy River games or what games to get rid of um it's come down to just like do I see myself playing this game and dark domains is a game that has consistently hit my table uh you know and played with my group on a regular basis and so it was one of those no I can't get rid of that because it's pretty cool and that was before I heard that they're gonna

make all this cool new stuff and what have you um so for me anyway and if it matters to you at all uh for somebody who's played thousands of different games in the last you know whatever 16 years I've been doing this in the hobby um you know I mean it has to be something pretty special for me to keep it and you know I mean it is it is definitely um one of my go-to uh medium heavy Euros uh with you know a work replacement aspects and resource allocation and plus timing uh timing uh allocation as well is something that's so huge in this game and um there's all kinds of things I really enjoy about it I love pulling the two cards the two Fortune cards and seeing what weird aspect is going to be affecting the world at that given time and and how it's going to affect the way what you get to do uh I love the timing of when do I convert you know my my my you know good building into an evil building you know and and how am I going to affect the process as far as my resource engine you know as far as the stuff that's being created for me like when can I comfortably switch those things over um trying to determine you know which portion of my domain is going to be attacked by those goody goody adventurers and trying to prevent that from happening or being able to defend myself again or wanting them to attack

me because then I can earn more points more evil if if I succeed so all of those things are things and a lot more that I really enjoy now um with the expansion material and what's been enhanced I I went into it in in Fairly good detail uh in in the section about uh the middle section of this video but I can't express enough the types of expansions that I really really enjoy um like and and some of these I I'm trying I was trying to think of other games I could reference that um really really show up for me as far as expansions and I mean and I sadly because I've been doing this for so long uh they're all like older games and so I wonder how many people are actually going to understand what I'm saying but like like the old like the older worker question game also something that I've kept in my comment uh collections uh like Pillars of the Earth added an expansion to it and all it did was just add more stuff and it and it added a board as well but that board just synergized perfectly with the other places and other work replacement spots you have and that's what like this does it adds this board and it adds like a new spot that you can use and the timing of the how that board processes is incredibly important because it happens before the main board and so you can use that to set up what you're going to be doing and and so I like that I I like I've always liked games that you know there's work replacing games where you

go to the spot and you get the coins or you get you get the wood or whatever and that's fine and but to me when you have that added depth of work replacement it just kind of adds another layer it adds another you know just I don't know trickery for lack of a better word that I really really enjoy and so when I had that extra board we had the timing adds new things that I can do you that can also then I can you know the stuff I do that will actually affect the rest of the rest of I do in that turn those are things I really really like and and I just and but then it doesn't actually like change everything as far as the way the game is played I mean yes there's another level of timing and other another spots and other things that you can use but you don't have to deal with like okay remember how you learned how to play that game now throw that away let's learn it again and and and and try again with a brand new game and and what that says is a lot of times in those games that do that it's because the game that they had before the brand new one just needed you needed to actually do that because of the fact that it wasn't uh it wasn't any good I shouldn't say any good I mean but there was something wrong right and there was something there was an issue with it that needed to be changed he'd be fixed because it was better and that was the cool thing about this is that your domains to me was would just play great and it was awesome and I didn't see that there was anything wrong with

it and there isn't you could you could buy this you know you saw it in a store shelf you could pick it up right now and you need to have fun with it but things like this this board to track your track your your uh your resources yeah it's just it's it's just so much better better than having just giant piles of resources all over the place trying to manage them you can just look at a Tracker board and track things down and that's ingenious and it's just in it's something that like somebody probably had a light bulb moment and said why are we doing this why do we have all this stuff we could have just done this it would be so much better and so stuff like that the the enhancements that they've done between first and second edition um were things that made the game made him that was great even better but weren't needed if that makes sense and and so that's why like you now I can see dark domains you know once I get all the cool new experience well I have the cool note but the official cool new expansion and stuff like that once I have that I can absolutely see myself having this hit the table even more um just because they've kind of just you know with the expansion material pump some new life into it and also just made the game better people

Progress saved