Dark Domains | Chaz Just Played & Reviews
Transcript
how much should a games design be able to impact your strategy while you play it well let's discuss by shedding some light on dark domains and there and welcome to my initial thoughts on dark domains which is a worker placement game in which each player takes on the role of a city leader working diligently to expand the Kings Empire however unbeknownst to the monarchy these city leaders are secretly evil and they have vowed their allegiance to a sinister necromancer who has morbid ambitions whoops and so to give the facade of increasing the domain of the royal family the players will gather resources and construct pleasant little civic buildings but as mentioned this is all a ruse and each of these helpful structures will eventually be tainted by the player that's constructing them converting them into a bastion of villainy that serves their dark Overlord the more evil that the section of the kingdom controlled by the player becomes the more will need to be defended against the do-gooding adventurers who are questing along the landscape looking for wrongs to right an evil to vanquish in the end only the player who has developed a domain that produces the most evil will accomplish their mission and win the favor of this vile
necromancer that they serve they'll do this through the strategic use of minions henchmen monsters and magic spells to stamp out the good repel the altruistic adventurers and cover their land in darkness now as you may have guessed by the title of this video and the fact that I'm holding the box I recently played dark domains and I found this to be a game with some pretty interesting twists on the whole worker placement genre but those twists did not come without challenges of their own this is a game that can be very very brutal and and it just doesn't care what you think about that and and while those challenges are admitted part of the fun they also could become an unexpected obstacle that prevented some players from enjoying the game as much as they were hoping to I feel I should explain so to explain we need to start at the beginning with the setup of the game now I am a firm believer that most people including myself are gonna learn how to play this game by reading its rulebook I know as I was going through this rulebook I I thought that this was actually a pretty well written one overall they were just a few things in here that required additional sussing out as I was going through the game and as my experience with modern board game rule books go well it's pretty much par for the course in fact while I was reading this particular real book I do remember thinking hey this is pretty
well written you know I am understanding the concepts that this printed page is trying to convey to me adequate job rulebook adequate job there were of course some exceptions however such as how the various decks that are used in the game are described but not specifically shown in this rulebook these decks need to be constructed in a very specific way and it took some deductive reasoning on my part to figure out how to actually set up a couple of those decks but gameplay wise most of the game's mechanisms were explained really well and we're actually pretty darn intuitive there were just a couple of things that I needed to double check in the old rulebook when we encountered them during the course the game these were typically mechanisms I had an element of branching decision-making that were incorporated into them to increase the game's unpredictability and replayability while that is cool and neat did require me to stop and ask how does that work again just doing one second while I looked up power how this thing functions some examples would be good okay well here's one an example would be how the adventuring party's order of operations was carried out what kind of buildings or other things in the game they target and and how you kind of determine that and how monster placement on buildings were all of those things required revisiting the rulebook when we got to those points in the game it was explained in the rulebook but in practice it just didn't
click automatically and until we played through it a couple of times don't get me wrong though I mean these are not complaints you know these are just common wrinkles that one encounters with a game with this many moving parts these little hiccups are not anything unique to this particular game I don't hold any of these things against it nope not at all not complaints if you do want legitimate complaints well I'll give you legitimate complaints the primary criticism about dark domains that I have seen in read online was that this game gives the presentation of a worker placement euro game but then hides random luck driven elements under it's euro game veneer making some players feel that the game itself is much like it's royal city planners who seem fair and balanced on the surface but secretly have a heart of chaotic darkness inside that's not a bad analogy I should have used it in this video players are able to make their own plans and gather resources you know all they want but they're also gonna need to contend with unpredictable dice rolls when they defend the structures that they've built and the turmoil that can be triggered by cards that determine the players collective fate each round these are things that players have no control over they don't care how you feel about them they're gonna do what they want to do and by gum if it
messes up you and everyone else's plans well then so be it because these are mechanisms to have just no soul and and they don't have your best interest at heart sometimes in the pain now then don't get me wrong I don't usually mind some random mayhem in my life you know I like some controlled chaos in my games so rolling dice to defend my building against the adventuring party's wandering across the countryside didn't really bother me that much because when it came to that aspect of the game you know I went in knowing what to expect but then during our first game that we played we also encountered some really just bad luck that made the first game a real real challenge and to be honest it left a bad taste in the mouths of some of the players you want to know what happened well all right let me share with you my sad tale of woe first off it must be explained that the game uses many many decks of cards you know there's your buildings that you can buy there's your henchmen for hire there's an annoying adventure party who will come along and disrupt the den of iniquity that you're constructing there's spills you can cast and there's fake cards that set special rules that govern each round lot of cards at the beginning of each round a couple of these fake cards are pulled from a deck and their special rules are revealed and put into effect for that round now each player starts the game with several workers and eight coins at
their disposal which they will then use to take actions and obtain resources a very first round of the very first game that we played the very first fake card that was turned over and put into effect caused each player to lose two of their eight coins and then the second fake card caused each player to lose three more reducing each player from eight down to three coins to use in the very first round of the game but that's fine it's a challenge and none of us are really gonna make much progress this very first round but at least we're all in the same boat then at the end of that first round a player cast a spell that caused everyone to lose the rest of their gold all right so now nearly all of us are flat broke but at least we'll still be able to use our workers to take actions and start building up our resources again you know so so we can we can do this then the fake cards for the second turn were revealed and the first of those required all players to pay a gold for each worker that they wanted to use that round effectively preventing anyone from being able to do anything that second round all due simply to the luck of the first cards that were drawn in the game something that the players were powerless to prevent now to be fair many of the cards in this fate deck actually have positive results for the players and the odds of these particular cards coming out in this particular order is pretty darn slim it's it's a big deck of cards that's
randomized each game and this unfortunate series of events could easily have been mitigated further simply by removing those cards from the deck completely there'd still be plenty of other cards available but no one into that very first game you know we didn't know what to expect and when that series of events did happen well it wasn't mentally a bit of a drag for everybody so am I saying that I hated the experience I detested this game and I'm planning on donating my copy of it to someone who I secretly disliked oh absolutely not the next place of the game that we did do didn't have this problem well I can't help but wonder if part of what made this subsequent plays better was that I also knew what to expect going in and while I certainly would play it again this game does benefit greatly from knowing what can happen before you go into it and being in the mood for the possibility of an unproduced bubble and also unpredictable perhaps punishing game section like that sentence unpredictable and punishing and of course speaking as someone who is now an expert in dark domains I can attest to that I have seen how games can vary due to the fate henchmen and spell cards that become available over the course of the game and I know myself how to prepare myself mentally for those potential outcomes and go into the game with that certain appropriate mindset yes certain that's what experts say surgeons and you know needing to be in a
certain mood for a particular game whole deal that's it's not a bad thing you know it's just something to be aware of many many many games on gamer shelves benefit from being in the right mindset in the mood for that particular game so again this is not something that is just specific to dark domains it's just something to be aware of so as dark domains a game that is worth our time when we have all these other games in our disposal to choose from these days well this is a game that some pretty neat ideas that put some really interesting twists on the whole worker placement of genre but admittedly this is a game that's not going to be for everyone you know if you do not want that chaos or that unpredictability you know you're probably going to want to stick with a more deterministic gyro but knowing what you now know going into all of this if this is a game that does sound like you would enjoy well then I would definitely recommend trying it out and if it turns out that you like it the game can be purchased directly from its publisher laboratory H right now up until after Gen Con the first week of August after Gen Con the game's gonna go into distribution which will require fulfillment to go through some different channels and may actually reduce its availability for a while so if you want to give the evil in your wicked little heart a chance to fully blossom into the deceitful butterfly that we all know it can be well check out the laboratory H website linked in the description below before Gen Con to get a copy of dark domains using their pledge manager on their page regardless of whatever that get to decide to do with your life I do think
that dark domains is worth giving a try and perhaps two tries in order to really get the feel for the unique mechanisms and experience that this game offers now I hope that this overview of the results of my first few plays of the games has been helpful and until next time I've been Chaz Marlar from pair of dice paradise I'm done talking so take care