Skip to main content
Loading video...

ISS Vanguard Review: A New Frontier for Narrative Games

Transcript 16:36

hi everyone tally and Farrell here from portavir and Welcome to our review of ISS Vanguard the new Cooperative story driven campaign game from publisher awaken realms for one to four players in Vanguard you'll take control of four different areas of the ship alternating between ship management and Planetary Exploration turning to gameplay the core is Dice checks and dice manipulation which pairs very nicely with exploration and Resource Management now obviously this is a big box narrative experience but what's interesting is that through the Planetary Exploration your actions your decisions what you discover you'll create a branching narrative which means there's also some replayability here in the campaign and we should say we're very kindly sent this to review by publisher awaken Realms but one thing we'd like to keep in mind is that we are aware of this game when it was originally on game found and being crowdfunded but we decided it wasn't for us it wasn't our cup of tea so think about that when we review it because it will be interesting to see how we feel now that we've actually played it and if you're interested in getting coffee after the video I believe it will be open or is open for late pledges

right so how to explain this behemoth firstly it's a story driven campaign game which means that the goal is to really experience the story and play Until the End of the campaign the gameplay moves in a continuous loop you'll be exploring some planets taking back your findings to the ship doing some ship management visiting different areas of the ship before you go back in the loop and set up the next planet for exploration and so on until the end of the campaign the Planetary Exploration could be considered the bulk of the game in the classical sense here you have the map which is placed in the middle of the table representing the planet and characters to control you'll each take turns and when you turn you can do two actions of which there are five options you can travel from one location to the next you can prepare by drawing a card you can rest where you'll get back some of your used dice you can lift off from the planet and you can also do a special action which is typically how you interact with the various locations on the planet and how you move the story forward if you've ever played any of the Nemesis games then this portion of the game has quite a similar feel many of these special actions will require a dice check which is the core mechanism you have a number of dice in three different colors most of which have different faces and all of which have a wild symbol and a danger symbol during a dice check you can roll as many dice as you want in an attempt to get

the required success symbols and you can also play cards to help you manipulate the dice and get help from your fellow players sometimes the dice check will just require you to roll certain colors of dice whilst other times you have to land on the specific symbols often rolling a danger symbol will mean that you failed a check or result in some other negative effect during the Planetary Exploration you'll uncover story logs which will move the story forward and allow you to make all kinds of discoveries once your mission on a planet is completed you'll head back to the ship once there any injured crew will go to the med Bay your discoveries will be unloaded and maybe your ship's Mission will be updated then you'll get to decide where the ship goes next and what it will explore or what planet to head to next after that it's time to prepare by visiting different sections of the ship Each of which has a different ability maybe you'll go to production to acquire new equipment to the barracks to recruit new crew or maybe you'll go to The Situation Room to diffuse potentially dangerous events after that you'll assemble your Landing crew and head down to the Planet of the hour and then repeat add infinitum now that really was a brief overview because there are just so many little clutches and side mechanisms that we'd need way longer than a 15 minute video to get into them all this box has so much to give and for us it was the exact experience we expected

from a Box's size and from the blurb of the game we'd even go as far to say it's awaken Realms magnum opus and we will note that we haven't played so many of their games but Vanguard really does feel like a distillation of everything they've learned from their previous games the exploration mechanism from Nemesis the elaborate storytelling of Tainted Grail and so on yeah I mean the second you unbox it you can feel the care and consideration that's gone into it and from the beginning you've got a wonderful kind of instruction sheet and how to put everything away and get everything ready for your first game you then have a really wonderfully engaging tutorial which takes you through how Planetary Exploration works and gets you straight in now there's a lot to learn but it never feels like a chore because of the way they get you through it and everything here is top-notch the storytelling the art the components and as a tip of advice definitely get the companion app it elevates the gameplay especially because there's voice acting so it makes the story logs much more engaging although the voice actors maybe Hamming up a little bit too much when they get to be snarky and there's a lot of snot flying about coming to the gameplay the dicey core is fine it's not a wow mechanism but it's very solid and it works and one thing that's quite good is you have a lot of

ways to midflake the dice so you don't get stuck with bad rolls and players can also build their dice poles which means they can kind of take on the game the way they want which is always a fun and engaging mechanism on the other side from the tutorial to where we are now 20 30 hours in and the dice haven't really the dice core hasn't really evolved in any meaningful ways and I could see this maybe becoming a bit tedious to some people you know especially when we get to another 20 hours of it or a second campaign and so on what we do really like about it though is that it's up to the players which dice they roll and how many which means different players can approach the same special action in various ways we do also think it's smart that the majority of the gameplay is done via the dice rather than needing to keep track of six different elements of a character and all of the kind of various trackers and tokens that might come with that at the end of the day though is just a mechanism to push forward the story and the exploration elements the story is excellent and most importantly it's engaging and it's a major factor in why we want to keep going back to this over and over even after we're done reviewing it or so importantly it feels like there's enough branching narratives to go for a second playthrough even if they are minor story Beats during exploration there's often just not enough time to see and discover everything so a second or third playthrough May well be rather different exploration is handled via a pre-printed

map with card slots cards are placed onto the various slots on the map and represent the different locations on a planet and will typically have a special action that you can do which allows you to interact with that particular location there are also paths between the different sections which will often require you to spend dies to cross and sometimes you'll be asked to read aloud a passage when you enter a new section which furthers the story it's an evolution to the way exploration Works in Nemesis however like the dice checks this isn't particularly revolutionary and it doesn't really evolve throughout the campaign however the scenarios are rather different one time you might be doing some peaceful exploration on an alien planet whilst another time you might be involved in a high-pitched battle against the odds this is crucial in keeping the players interest which is further helped by the fact that there'll be different mechanisms and threats appearing on the different planets be aware though because these missions you're engaging in they're dangerous you can get injured and if you take too many injuries you'll have to be evaced off the planet failing the mission and we really love the way this combines with how the characters work generally how the characters work themselves so it will essentially play a section as a player so I'll take security for example and there's a big deck of recruits and each recruit has a unique backstory unique artwork unique name and

you'll eventually have a collection of people who work in your sector and you can send them on missions but their disposable they can die and what's fascinating is that it increases the tension in the game because you'll do multiple missions probably with the same characters you'll come to know them you'll rank them up they'll become stronger they'll get you out of tight scrapes and it means you care about them and you don't want them to die and you might even begin playing the game differently based on avoiding danger and I think that's really fascinating aspect of Vanguard well I will say also that's quite funny slash horrific is because these characters can die there's actually a memorial wall in the back of the ship book where when they die you slot them in but when you slot them in you get a reward based on where you put them which means that these characters dying is good and I understand that if characters dying usually things are going bad so the game's trying to give you a leg up a little boost but I have to say it was pretty damn horrific when half of our security section died and the entire the entire ship's morale increased that's really messed up looping back to the ship book this is a tremendously engaging aspect of Vanguard and it's actually an evolution of the way these narrative games handle upkeep and upgrading essentially you have this binder which represents your ship and in

it is a lot of card sleeves much like what you used to keep your Pokemon cards in back in second grade and as you explore you're going to gain cards maybe discoveries maybe ship upgrades and they'll all go into this awaiting folder when at the beginning of the session you kind of start setting things up you'll go through the ship book page by Page and you'll slot these cards where they belong and interact with different areas and this is tremendously fulfilling even better the ship book provides a lot of interesting decisions typically you'll have very limited resources to move the ship around and explore or on which locations with on the ship that you will visit usually you'll want to see and do everything but can't so it just keeps things really engaging because you then can't wait to get back to the ship book post Mission and attend to everything that you just couldn't get around to last time changing tight Isis Vanguard it's an excellent game but it's not a perfect game and while we haven't encountered anything game breaking that makes us not want to plan there are a couple of minor niggles you should probably be aware of first one is if you're interested in this get it because you want to experience the story you want this campaign kind of game and you want to experience all that has to offer don't get it because you want to play a tight tense Cooperative game it's not all that cooperative all you can really do is if you're in the same section as another player you can roll one dice for them or you could

add a card to kind of help them along that's it but we will say there are a lot of Cooperative discussions when it comes to the narrative elements progressing the story or the best way to explore but you definitely don't have this crunchy working together to over overcome the game puzzle that Cooperative players are looking for in fact in the Plantera exploration you could all go off to four different corners of the map and just meet back up at the end of the scenario and not a lot would change besides it may be being a tiny bit harder second there's a lot of set up tear down and admin that comes with Vanguard was a lot of it is actually mid game which means you can't have it set up for when people come around and jump in they have to be part of the admin otherwise they're going to miss important decisions and probably story beats as well now from starting a kind of session you'll go through the ship book and that will take about 20 minutes and to be fair to the game this is very engaging admin but then you'll have to spend 15 minutes probably setting up the planet and getting yourself ready to go down sorting out your characters then you'll be playing and there's constant admin during the exploration because you're discovering things so you're drawing cards all the time then you have to kind of clear up the planet book as you do the after planetary ship book and you kind of put the stuff away and organize and catalog and this means that a session from start to finish can be up to four hours and this is just something that you need

to know because you'll probably have to be able to set that time aside to really get the most out of this game or be able to leave it set up on the table indefinitely lastly as we touched upon earlier a lot of the core mechanisms don't meaningfully evolve from tutorial onwards and it's quite possible that some of you will be getting pretty tired of them by hour 20 our 40 our 16. the one thing that we did find really tedious even now is on or during Planetary Exploration you'll often have a card uh and you know a location card and it will have a track on it and every time you get a success you move one up this track and so this means it's going to take multiple turns or attempts to kind of progress that location crack that puzzle go through but it's really not interesting to just do the same exact challenge over and over and over particularly if it's taking multiple turns or rounds or involving multiple players and you're all sitting there doing the same thing especially as it occurs all the time and it's used as kind of a crutch when there's something important hidden behind that like location check and it's particularly frustrating if you just don't quite have the right combination of dice that that check needs the final thoughts we haven't actually completed Isis Vanguard but at the point we are now about 20 to 30 hours in it

actually seems to be expanding and opening up and allowing players more exploration and more decision space so what we can say is that this has been an excellent experience and if you've been in any way interested by ISS Vanguard it's probably worth your time the story thus far is superb the scenarios are varied and different and everything is held up by a rock solid core of gameplay there are a few minor issues but definitely none that would stop us from fully recommending it and in fact we're pretty eager to get the extra content and expansions which is a pretty big turnaround from not having any initial interest in ISS Vanguard yeah and I think we're also quite interested in maybe doing the second review post campaign yeah to see if anything changes or stuff happens that's worth thinking something campaign post-mortem yeah so that was our review advice says thank God we hope it was helpful and we would really love if this was helpful that you would consider subscribing if you have any questions please ask us down below and thank you for your time see you next time bye bye bye

Progress saved