Mansions of Madness vs. Resident Evil (Going Analog: Episode 9)
Transcript
want to feel old it was over two decades ago when gamers first explored the sprawling mansion resident evil zombies puzzles and not enough bullets filled this mysterious house of horrors and jump-scares mountains of madness from Fantasy Flight shares many similarities to Resident Evil scary mansion check mind-bending puzzles check gear an inventory check the main difference well besides us being a board game in not a video game mansions of madness trades t-virus bread zombies for HP Lovecraft II and creeps set in fantasy flights Arkham Horror universe here's how it plays the second edition of mansions of madness features a companion app that acts as the game master instead of having a player have to play the game master so the app is actually going to set up the scenario for you tell you where to place tokens and monsters and run you through puzzles masterfully unlocking content as the game progresses each round players will act first taking up to two actions each such as moving attacking maybe if this monster is right here they could use equipment such as these bandages to heal or they could interact search or explore by selecting these icons on the app and seeing what happens for instance this may open up a room right over here and the app will then tell you to place tokens and appropriate spots such as here and here
and also spawn monsters Nick scary for anybody fact-checking me right now I totally made up the situation so as not to spoil the scenario so after the investigators move and take actions it moves on to the mythos phase so the app again is going to run you through this and it will tell you maybe some background story or you might be given some choices to make or it will also move some monsters and have them players take turns interacting with the game until they either achieve their objectives or time has run out which causes them to lose his mentions of madness a modern horror classic like Resident Evil let's see what the going analogue reviewers think hey I'm Hilary Goldstein and we broke into dance shoes house while he was off on vacation because he had a copy of mansions of madness and we were like man I really like that game we should play that yeah if you don't know me I used to work at ign.com so I know stuff about video games and then I play a lot board games including this one joining me is Stephanie Palermo Stephanie works at Capcom she works on resident evil hustle about yourself what do you do at Capcom I do PR for a ton of games at capcom including a bunch of Resident Evil games most recently in Resident Evil 7 biohazard and Matt Hickman who is here because he has a beard and that as a requisite for the show it looks very nice by the way I well done yeah no one could even tell it was fake
Matt also works in the games industry what do you do man I'm a producer I worked at Sega for a long time Bennet some indie companies and now I work at oculus cool and I think it's fair to say that we're all fans of Resident Evil so that's the videogame side but also we're big fans of mansions of madness and we've all played the first edition before we've all three of us to play the second edition a bunch of time so I'd say unequivocally we're the foremost experts on magnetism an is in in the world yeah absolutely yeah yeah so when we talk about the goods Stephanie why don't you start like tell us what are the things that you love most about manchas Amanda's second addition about second addition I mean the very quickest and easiest thing to go into is the abbot of course I mean I played so much of the first edition from maybe ten years ago as when I first started playing and I think and the the worst part of the game was damming just setting up really because people can't help you set up you have to do everything in secret and set all the cards out and this cuts all of that out so the app makes this setup breezy you get right into and can play with people so outside of that app right because that's that's a cool part but you love this game even the first edition so yeah so what is there is there more at the core of the game that kind of keeps you coming back and playing more and more I like the co-op element of course to it and the fact that it's really narrative narrative lis driven I fight a lot of the Arkham universe came like Arkham Horror and not more recently ultratour mansions and of all the games in that universe this very far in a way has the
most narrative driven aspect to it and more thematic than any of them for sure I thought because we we played before we recorded this and I thought it struck me that the thing that you seem to love the most was how we lost at the very end of our scenario and you read you exclaim like this is why I love this game do you want to talk about just really quick the best boy in the scenario but just the situation that we were in what happened to you and I really have lost more at this game than any other for a game that I loved so much losing is really fun in this game and it is not easy to win and if you've played any Arkham game that most of them are very difficult to win we got to the very end and we like we're really racing this key so we could get out of the mansion and escape while fire was blaring everywhere and at the last second I went crazy and my wind condition before I opened the door was that I became a pyromaniac and just reveled in the fire and we all died just one move away from the door that it was it was any memories I said the thing you should never say in cough games which is like oh we're basically gonna win this and yeah we got it is gonna be easy we you're already by the door no this is done and the one thing that couldn't happen happened and we lost and it's burned to death in the mansion those scenarios are so magical and there's so many different instances of that that can come up even if you've played all the campaigns like they're they play out differently every time you play yeah I mean I think to me that's like that now
I understand why Charlie Brown always keeps trying to kick the football like this game is a perfect example of that it is it will do that thing we're it pulls the football away from you at the last second and yet for you know you're like no this time let's set it up again yeah yeah tying into the app that's one thing that's great about the new addition is instead of playing the same scenario that's laid out the same way and it's the same stuff the app will switch out the lay-up switch out the tiles switch out the monsters and like as you get expansions it takes the same mission and makes it totally different and that's that's pretty compelling especially the first time you discover that's what it's doing it's like oh my god I just unlocked a whole nother game within this game I bought yeah because you could feel when you when you get the game you could say oh well there's only five scenarios and that doesn't feel like it's worth a lot but there's a lot of surprising amount of replayability sometimes they're just things where it's a really obvious choice where I I didn't go through that door where I her to know it's the first time but then I did the second time so something is gonna happen some guy might live or die or whatever yeah based on that choice but there are there is that element of randomness and then when you bring in the different characters sometimes their ability you know even though it can seem very simple can sometimes be the difference between you know saving the day and turning into a pilot yeah yeah I think also it does sort of avoid a lot of the co-op games tend to have a thing where one person tends to be the captains I do this do that feel like most people tend to have a lot of agents see like oh well discuss strategy of like oh I'm gonna I'm gonna do this on my turn so if you can fend this guy off I can do this thing but but
I've never played the game where someone was like okay you do this and you do this and you do this yeah I mean it's speaking to that point the way they lay out the scenarios gives you so many choices from the beginning you know which you have to be cooperative you can't say you go there I'm gonna go here we're gonna press this because you don't know what's gonna happen and it encourages you to split up freaked out that you've split up try and figure out a way to get back together and exchange things it it's just just a really well-crafted game and you can you can feel all the things they learn from the first edition folded into this one and going into loving losing it's all the build-up to it is so great it starts out so slow and you're doing mundane things like opening drawers and looking at paintings that you see into the heavens and all that and then all of a sudden there's a mob and there's a you know some crazy serpent monster and you're running around give me a knife give me anything I gotta fight this thing and it's just it's just such a great tension building game and to have it in a board game is really singular that's actually one of them for me one of the most resident evil parts of this game is not just the monsters are gaming right there's monsters in the world and you have to fight them but the fact that they're both very resource-limited games where ammo is really scarce and Resident Evil very literally like healing items and an ammo for your weapons and things like that so you have to really think about like okay should I kill this guy or should I run away and come back for him later or board a room or whatever the case may be and this game was very much has that element to it where it's very strategic should I fight this mob like hell no
they're gonna chase me around this whole map and I'll loop all the way around because why should I waste time on that and that's mansions resource it's time because the more time you waste the game has it like a quiet behind-the-scenes timer that you can't actually see but crazier things happen as you waste time all right so hard to believe but there are some things that we don't like about this game Matt why don't you tell us kind of wanna one or two your pet peeves so yeah I mean there's not many I really like this game but like look at this guy he's rad he's super awesome detailed model all these little guys and then they're on these bizarre like chunky black boxes and I understand from the first game it's held like a card net held chits and all that stuff but in this game that stuff's all in the app for the most part why do we still have these crazy chunky bases you know and you buy expansions that a more monster you're stoked about them and then you're stuck like jamming them on these little bases and it's insane what's crazy is that there are some monsters that have abilities like flying where if you didn't know that they're on the bottom of the base so to find that out you actually that turn it over and then they fall off the base right which I'm just gonna leave that guy laying there to show you it's a what's surprising about is that I mean Fantasy Flight is known for like great components right and this is these are not great the fifth part is not a great component yeah I mean just just adding to that we went so far as to 3d print our own bases for these characters so that they wouldn't they
would be more fixed to the to the maps and blend in a little bit more than having to keep black black faces all around okay so if you get past the are there any other concerns that you have about this game the one other thing I'd add that's that I can think of for a negative is that there is a lot of little fiddly bits the rules are pretty straightforward for the core gameplay but there's a lot of little things like oh if a monster enters this room does he attack one person or two people or does that happen before this and you pull yourself out find yourself going like this quite a bit which it's at least it's alphabetized and easy to log but oh wait maybe it's not in that rulebook actually it's in this real book oh that's right the fire rules online yeah we didn't see investigator investigators yeah so there is a little bit of that for me like we own like pretty much all the expansions we own all that stuff they're pricey and when you first plug them into the app you're like oh man this is giving back first edition where I got twenty mission no you don't yell like eight yeah and so you're looking at a big investment lots of monsters lots two tiles and you're kinda like oh man like this is a big investment for not many unique missions and that sometimes can be a little shocking there's no replayable right right for me I actually think my biggest issue is that there aren't that many unique missions but also there are almost no short missions like the shortest mission is like an hour and a half two hours it says but I've played that mission before and how to take three hours right and then there's also no short hard missions
so if you want to make it more difficult that is actually like oh well enjoy eight hours of playing which I mean it's a fun eight hours it is a day of gaming but I wish that there was at least one more mission that was hard but short so that I was an expert in the game and I just had two hours instead of well we got at least commit four or five hours uh you know I think the other thing is that there is in the same way that there is with most narrative games are certain like D&D is that you know your group is gonna probably determine your what you get out of this game so if you don't take on and love that narrative element where everyone's reading out the things that happen and right if you don't get into that like I don't think the experience is much fun and that that really just is about your group and how they go and I mean that's been my experience when when people don't want to kind of read the things and kind of have some fun with it and enjoy the role like then the game the gameplay itself isn't strong enough support it just turns into skill checks yeah does role fail role fail take some cards and you die and it's all about making up great voices from monsters and old men maybe you could maybe you could close this out voice I have a voice so I think I actually hear shoes car pulling into the driveway so we should probably wrap this up so what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna hand you guys Johnny was here hi man it's hard to even remember no definite purpose first you can have the cheese color die and I'll create a white die now you're gonna roll the die and the number that you get is going to be
how many words you have to sum up your feelings about mansions the madness okay ready okay boom I think he's gonna be upset if I roll on the game not that he's done well that's pretty good so Matt would you go 16 wow that's a lot of words I got 19 I think this happened last time well I've got 11 words so we've got a pretty good amount of words they're gonna be touchy that's gonna be very talky hmm so we've all taken a moment write down our thoughts based on the number of words were allowed because of our dice Stephanie wrote the most words because she has 19 would you like to read us what you wrote sure it's titled mansions of madness a love story fanfic by Stephanie Parma there's no count as the 19 words nails are that's the title there was no rule that I couldn't have a title that's fair this game brings my cold heart joy the manic spooky surprising most enjoyable game to lose embrace your inner pyromaniac awesome you guys having titles too weren't even listening beautiful yeah it was really nice but I know that Matthews is gonna be beautiful er because it's shorter you have 16 words to work with you just write game at the bar look I could get him up with a good title if you give us the title of your piece board game in 16 words hmm that's very austere there it's xplory fighty puzzly monstery risen and evilly the great Robert co-op love crafty and fun why are these basses
such [ __ ] oh that was really good mine is titled mad shoes review as you remember that she was not here no and I had 11 words which I think real writing is about editing editing editing but I do think you'll agree that it's better than your guys thoughts which is this game is very very very very very very very Cthulhu mm-hmm cathartic Cthulhu yeah it's very good to go you couldn't even like make it a pun so now that we've given our thoughts it's time for us to actually give our boats so who's gonna work is we're all gonna vote at the exact same moment so there's no cheating off others each other's papers you can give two thumbs up which means like why I love this game one thumb up which means still pretty good game you can give a sideways which you're like I don't know how to be decisive about things you do a thumbs down which means like poopoo and since she was not here special edition rules you can give two thumbs down so everybody ready get your fists on the ready I'm gonna count to three and we're all gonna vote at the same moment okay don't look at my hands okay one of them has a quarter in it I'm trying to guess which one it is one two three do we owe them right - yes so uh yeah that's the first time that we've ever actually had
ongoing analog my everybody gave double thumbs up whoo that's huge yes because when shoes here he actually doesn't allow it but I say rules example to know that he stifles us so they have it right it's like mansions of madness second edition better than the first edition mmm a great game if you're looking for something that's narrative maybe has a little the feel of a resonate evil game into a board game uh you know and that's it and I hear shoe come in in the door right now so we should probably get out of here oh hi welcome to a very special episode of Shaun baby gameplays you know on baby gameplays this one is about the majesty of Jesus Christ and I've already screwed it up because this is Bible quest the Old Testament version where I think Jesus Christ was I think he was a fish in that one it's not important it won't come up because this is a game of exciting Old Testament knowledge for the whole family because like most Christian games it's a lot of trivia so you're trying to get your people through four little gates using your knowledge of the Bible and again this is the Old Testament so what makes this different from secular games is that you're a [ __ ] [ __ ] if you touch another player they're gone for like ten minutes like they lose their chips you steal everything they lose turns like if you were to land on a
trivia question you might get something like Adam and Eve had many children named three listed in the Bible which is I guess to make sure that you're not using like extended universe names because like Adam and Eve and all these alternate realities and universes and reboots they had some weird kids so you'd go Cain Abel and Noah jimJam and jimmy-jam that's not the right one Cain Abel and eNOS and now you're stuck trying to answer this question meanwhile the person you landed on hasn't played for 20 minutes some of them are just crazy like it sounds like you're in court and someone has accused you of something it says one day while Cain and Abel work in the field came became angry and and killed Abel true or false like this seems like the kind of thing that's like not just a yes-or-no question you're like okay yes I killed him but he was a snake at the time I really I don't know a lot about the Bible this is a 40 page instruction book with lots of questions like that some deep Bible cuts but let me get to how to win the game you get through all the bridges by filling out God phrases like for example seek the kingdom of God if you can make that with your Scrabble tiles then you can move on to the next section but like I say it's a very cutthroat game and these are really like nice sentiments so you'll be like serve one another [ __ ] it's it's a first change don't know what they made this game or who would play it so
this is the back of the Bible quest box and you can see this picture was taken before the arrests one of these children was never heard from again and the other one is not technically there's you can see from this child look she's a prisoner the father uh strangely enough in the innocent one here it's this lady in the in the sweater that masterminded the entire thing Bible quest for the family the for the non-traditional family who enjoys Bible trivia okay about five years old
the [ __ ]