Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 New things in Great Western Trail Argentina vs Great Western Trail 1st and 2nd (that we like)

Transcript 31:52

foreign and Stella from people University today we are very excited for this new series and this is Great Western Trail Argentina which we will start with so a lot of people asking what are the differences between the first or the second edition what's new in here so we are going to answer those questions for you hopefully and there we have the top 10 new things in Great Western Trail Argentina yes so we'll we'll count through from ten to one based on what we liked probably more what I liked um we had to pick one of our orders so you may disagree with my uh with my order but that's all right we'll uh we'll get uh you'll hear them all one way or another yeah yeah well out of this top 10 but those 10 are the most significance and the things that we like now we assume that you know and you have like Great Western Trail if you haven't we'll link our how to play video for Great Western Trail the first edition I was loving looking watching that video recently because that was one of our older videos it was a bit of a first addition from our side yeah let us know if you have watched that one as well so this yes this is the first one the next one we might do something

like top 10 interesting games that we played that month and so on so watch out for that without further Ado let's start with our number 10. so number 10 is what I'm calling uh hazards free parking Style because it kind of replicates the uh the well-known Monopoly house rule on free parking it's a house rule it's not an actual rule but in this one it's an actual rule so when you uh Wander through a hazard from one of these um we'll talk about what the hazards now are they've turned into the ground Heros but we haven't explained that yet they fill the role of the hazards from the original game and when you go through one you pay the money onto these little circular spaces here and they basic that basically Waits there for somebody to clear that Hazard and whoever clears it gets that money so it's sort of a continuation of what I know was a change between first and second edition Base Great Western Trail which was increasing the amount of money you get back from the band of tracks and Hazard tracks this one continues that even even further I love that because then you can time your movement and in time where when you're going to clear clear up those hazards or those new

recruits which we will talk about later So Gone is the uh Gone is the Trail of destinations up at the top of the board and what has replaced that is a series of uh nameless faceless ships I suppose down the side uh which work in much the same way so they've all got a number and instead of choosing a city to go to you choose a ship to place on you can still only place one per ship except for the cheapest one or the most expensive one those can hold any number of ships this is when you go to Kansas City which is now buenos areas and these are the strength of the stock or the beef that you bring the breeding value the breeding value that's it and which which you can still pay or increase with the with the certificate thank you and you can still put your engine building disks on there yeah so we'll see later and it's one of the big changes is that these ships will um will take off and introduce these ports and this is a whole different mechanism but in terms of replacing the um the stations with the ships here they are it's it's not a it's not a big change and one thing that does come in is that okay these ships are going to sail away through the game and they will leave the row and then randomly two new

ships are going to come and I don't know if I love the fact that they come in randomly because you can you can get an unexpected shift in lots of expensive Ships coming at the start of the game or the cheapest Ships coming and that's going to change things up in a somewhat random way yeah so I don't know if that's my favorite uh change I might have had then come in in an order myself but I understand because then you would want a increasingly higher number so you can keep going there yes and these ships are going to sell based on this uh at certain points that we're gonna ship and as Terence say it's gonna ship there and then that's a whole new mechanics that we are going to talk about later yes okay the number eight difference and this is an obvious difference from the title uh is that it's set in Argentina and that's just kind of cool I like that I like the way that this Trilogy has gone out and New Zealand's going to be the third one so it's picked places that have a cattle history and have have built the game around that so this you know all the the characters have taken on a more South American look and the names have come from that side and it's just nice to acknowledge those different um areas there's different areas in their side of the industry uh so it doesn't change the doesn't change mechanisms of the game at all but that is one of the changes

all right number seven is the uh akaraku this is one of the new cattle that you can purchase the the cattle on offer are essentially the same as they were in the base game um Second Edition yep um but we have this one new cow orange colored cow only worth one in breeding value relatively cheap to get at the start of the game so it gives you and it's two or three victory points so it gives you a cheap and simple uh cow that you can go and get the first time around the board which I think is nice Cowboys always used to be a tough thing early on yeah this at least let's keep fighting for the Cowboys yes this one at least lets you build your deck up a little bit uh more quickly if you wanted to start doing that so I think that's a nice bit of flexibility that's been added uh it also we'll see shortly this may be a week in breeding value but it's strong in this new mechanism of strength and that's another another benefit to getting in and getting it early it gives you new type of engine build um which we will talk a little bit more about shortly uh yes that is uh number seven the karaku cow yeah at least you get these cheaper one it's good yeah it costs you four pesos and one Cowboy or Goucher all right number six the granjaro mechanism

so this is this is the first big one that we're discussing we've alluded to it a couple times already um the hazards and the bandits uh which were the teepees in uh the first thing as well all replaced by this new mechanism which is the grand Heroes and so they still fill up these Hazard tracks and they still you still get a benefit for building on those housing tracks and you may have to pay the money although you can get it back but unlike in the base game instead of being yet another thing on the board that you have to pay money to get rid of now there's a whole new mechanism called strength and strength works so strength Works in a fairly industrial interesting way you can build up a little bit of strength by clearing these icons on your player board you can build up strength by hiring employees who have strength icons looks like Star Trek or Boomerang it does look like a sideways Star Trek um and these these guys are a little bit more expensive they cost an extra coin it's actually a stick goal or something yes but otherwise your major way of doing this is to discard cards from your hand and gain the strength on that cow so essentially you're using your workers and your cows to help these farmers and when you exhaust your cows and use

them to help these Farmers you gain exhaustion cards which they are negative points they choke up your hand and deck you can take them into a cattle delivery and trash them as a benefit for holding them in hand and weakening your overall breeding value but otherwise you can hang on to them and lose points so it becomes this new it becomes this new thing you can do with high value cattle that's probably the first thing normally you would in the original game you'll just get high value cattle in hand and then just hang on to it until you reach the delivery point now there are other things you can do out here and you can spend that strength either by landing on a farmer and spending the strength he requires or going to a building that lets you take Farmers from anywhere on the board once you've then done that you've got a couple of different things you can do you can either leave it you can either do what you used to do with the hazards which is just collect them and score them for example objectives with them um you get a little bit of money from clearing them as well or you can pay a big chunk of money or get this money that we put earlier or you can pay a big chunk of money and recruit the farmer as an employee and so it's this fourth row of uh employees on your player board yes and I think what I really like about that is you know the hazards and the the hazards

and the bandits always felt like yeah now I've got excess money I can spend it and get this thing that's going to score me points but now there's an engine building side to it oh yes I really love that one because it links in with the way you build your deck it kind of adds these um little interlocking mechanism that wasn't there and of course we can discard those chalked up cards with some buildings or and some actions yes and when we go to Buenos Aires indeed I do think the strength mechanism now makes it a lot easier to take these um off the board because you know the base game you were always so tight on cash that's true those hazards I always felt they stayed there through the first half of the game now that you can do it with strength and you can do it with this again seven strength on this orange cow that you can get first time around the board really cheaply let's bring back that orange cow is this a like some sort of superpower superhero cow of some sort it looks pretty normal I guess low breeding value High strengths I'm joking here it looks pretty normal but it's a Superman cow karachu karaku yes so it gives you quite a quick way of getting a lot of these off the board which you need for the engine building and but it kind of changes that complexion and it also I think you know maybe it makes the risk spaces a little less risky to go into there's a

there's a few things there I do enjoy those options as well not just put it out for objective more motivation to clear them up more actions to do it and you can just do the engine build as Karen say because there are other buildings that give you this is another thing that we have to talk about is the grand new currency yeah so that actually that's coming yeah so that affects that too for engine building yes yes number five this game is shorter um shorter by shorter by turns or Loops anyways I don't know if it feels shorter when you're trying to uh interpret the new things that come in but there's one fewer row on this track and the in-game marker starts one row further down it means you've got more choice of employees at the very start of the game which is nice but it also I what I found with the shorter game and the fewer times around is it became um became much more critical to get that extra delivery and to really time your movement around the board there were there have been a lot of times where I tried to to race ahead to do that extra lap from you because I know the proportionally it's a bigger impact in this in this shorter game it's very I feel like it's very tight in that way oh I'm entirely in that way but you can get more money with the sale action

things which we haven't really talked about but look at these you know you want to have more cards to have better quality stock and the black one that you can unlock doesn't start until there so you have to move pretty far away and then this one also you have to move you have to have strength of nine so that's very good it takes just that little bit that little bit later in the game to get the really good upgrades but it really you know it's always been a game with that snowball towards the end yes with it being tighter uh it feels even more so that way Did we tell you that we love this

this second one and the Argentina and cannot wait for New Zealand okay next number four so this is something that I guess it's a little more subtle from an introduction to the game but the so the three old Hazard tracks are replaced with the Pharma tracks in a pretty typical way but then there's a fourth Pharma track that interweaves with the buildings in a much more direct way so there's seven potential places for the yellow colored farmers and they all come out of the sea bag I believe so plenty of them can come out and what it means is that if those are allowed to build up then you've got a very expensive path to get through these last couple of buildings particularly if there's important buildings here or if you've chosen to build in the risk spots up here so that adds this whole extra complexion to the the placement game and I mean we're not experts at Great Western Trail we don't play it competitively I don't know competitive players can can pick optimals between any of these building locations for kind of more casual players um I think that adds a more direct way of getting uh disruptions and Hazards and slowing other players down on the board rather than just yeah rather than just

because in the original game all you could do is build your own buildings and that would slow everyone down a little bit now you can fill the top of the board with farmers and that gives them that gives you this other way of slowing players down and I I really like I really like that I do I do like that as well give chance to have more these workers out but but we are going to talk about this maybe shortcut for it that's still coming yes that's the time that's a sign mechanism which yes which we'll come to I almost saved it Terence kicked me under the table so uh that is it next number three number three is uh our new currency or maybe even our other new currency because strength is kind of a currency yeah um but this is another one so it's it's the grain mechanism we've gone from a game that really just had breeding value and money to one that has breeding value money strength and grain you know what I like the opposite way of uh terroristica to turn over that's right you know what I like about this grain it's not something that you need to feed your workers all right keep going tarent so grain in effect grain replaces you have to pay grain to put um to put a disc on a ship and if you can't pay the grain then you have to pay some of your profits from that delivery so it's essentially

it's replaced what used to happen with the train it's kind of divorced to the train from the delivery part of the game which gives the train a different different purpose and and I like that that's yeah it doesn't feel like a big change but it's essentially completely taken too interwoven mechanisms from the first game and just pulled them apart yeah and then one's a bit of green so that side of it is quite good the grain how you get it so you can get it really efficiently if you get a lot of these uh Farmers on your employees I alluded earlier yeah or you can get it in an inefficient way mostly by these auxiliary actions so there's new auxiliary action to buy Grain it's a slow way to do it um grain becomes so to say where it replaces the railway mechanism is that you can you lose some of your profits but then grain is also critical for the port mechanism which is a big potential source of points which is coming late coming later and you can't substitute for money there so you've got one mechanism where you can substitute for money in one where you can't and yeah I just really like the way that has um that comes into the game it gives you these different options um there are different buildings that will let you gain or sell grain as well for different effects so you can use it in a

flexible way like this one Green Space is like it's like eight in the first and yes first one yeah yeah that's true we didn't even didn't even make our top ten but the uh the forest the forest combo buildings are replaced with grain combo buildings and there's one side of it that gives you green that way uh there's one side of it that gives you money yes so yeah grain is new grain is good grain of salt just great grain of wheat grain of wheat it's like all connected all especially number five it links up a bit with numbers five and four so this is yeah we just said that the the railway is no longer related to deliveries um so and slowing down with putting the workers there yeah so it's like what's left with the railway station is it all just stations and station Masters no what we've got now is a way of shortening your Loop Journey yet so we spoke about how as you could fully choke up this with farmers and make it a really slow route to the end but if you as you start to bring your train through this track you can start jumping off getting on a train and going to Buenos Aires early from here from here so I can skip three Farmers if my train has got to six I can skip these I can skip

six farmers and potentially a couple of buildings by having come out to here I can get all the way around here and Skip like a third of the map um if I go really big on trains and so it gives you this new this new thing that the train offers instead of making your deliveries cheaper now makes them faster now it's a way that you can get those extra couple of deliveries in a short game versus your opponents now it's the left is to go for forward rather than the right go forward yes that's true right right rat which is backward red bad green good yes yes if I'm moving here I'm now going uh to the left so I think that's I think that's a again that's it doesn't feel like that big of a change but it's a really clever way of using the rail to give you an action efficiency rather than a money efficiency and it's all all these things are about diversifying everything away from that single money currency that's true but then again sometimes you want to go to the building that is still there yes you have to if you are doing this you have to plan your strategy around uh not visiting the building the building in Space Age and at the moment I've placed uh engineering uh it's not the the first recommended ones but yeah you're likely to lose one of your move your engine spaces but there's this one as well which there is that's the same so so yeah if you're going to go big on

that you've then got to rely on not doing anything with that particular building so I really like uh I really like the different spin that puts on it so do I just shortcut just get there I do find that in the first and second edition I feel like I want to go to all buildings oh I need this one I need to get money I need to forward my try and so on but then I also need to go to Kansas City so at the start of the game you need to start the game I want to go to every building to kind of an engine build or get resources and then get kind of I thought okay next time next time I will shortcut I will just jump ahead three steps to Kansas City but the next time comes in more building a piece so that has not happened so this actually helps me to just jump straight ahead and then get to volunteers we're probably just revealing our horrible um strategy here I I can't imagine that was a strategy I can't imagine how substantially a competitive or Central player would want to share with us yes about three laps and just efficiently destroyed I do I do feel like once I play this game however short or long it is I almost want to immediately get to to it again oh I should have done it I should have done this I could have done this and whether I'm winning or losing usually losing Terence the winner or maybe our other friend's a winner but this is one of those that feels so good

feels really great engine building and you just want to jump right to it again after you finish okay and number one um conspicuous by having not been mentioned is the new the new Port mechanism so what is going on here when you make a delivery to a uh to a boat when you go here step by step and then when you make a delivery to a boat it goes to there when the marker passes the correct color of anchor your boat is going to sail away and deposit your disc over on the matching port there's the anchors color yes um and you start with one disc over there for the start of the game as well then every time you make a delivery so the number of times you can do this action is driven by the number of deliveries you make which then again gives you know it comes back to these shortcuts and speeds and all this sort of thing you can pay an amount of grain based on the quadrant of where you are to move your disc out here and get either a big influx of money or points so the the AV board which is the first one uh in play we've got you know there's there's little influxes of money and there's big influxes of money you could pay six grain early on

to get 12 dollars and three or 12 pesos and Three Points so if you go early on farmers and get a whole lot of grain you can get this big cash influx quite quickly you can leave your list there for measly two no depends where you are sorry zero two or five yep discs can stay there then as you go to Rotterdam the costs and the benefits increase and then Liverpool huge points of on offer in Liverpool so this one here is 20 points um you actually you can't even hold this side if you go there on the most expensive ship gives you a grain discount and that's actually one of the only ways to get nine grain to stand on it for these 20 points you can only hold eight grain yep so what I and I'm covering up there are some in the middle here as well this will depend on your Play account how many of these are covered or uncovered I think what I like the most about this is that you can't stack discs on these These are first come first serve and that was always what basic Great Western Trail was lacking for me was for something that was really competitive and competitive a big competitive race yeah and if and so this has it and it brings in this really sensitive timing type of thing like you've got to be really careful I know you've always had to kind of be

careful about giving being the one who gives players the best new set of cattle now you've got to be really careful about being the one who delivers and gives everyone else first chance to start moving their discs from here down to here so this becomes really critical the purple ones which are where you get most of your Liverpool points is so close to the end of the game and again timing is critical and you need to you want to be fast or have your train um have you train bypass so that you can really you can get those ones down and move them from the lower scoring ones the highest scoring ones it's not cheap definitely it's not cheap hey Grand there as well so you probably need to have you you would need to have grain there somewhere yeah and so you can't substitute money for grain here so yeah but this one you can you have you can use money uh and money yeah so you know the first time around I felt I found myself just stopping and doing a lot of double auxiliary actions just to get grains so that I could move into one of the high scoring South boxes and that's the um the objectives now have north south east west quadrants that relate to this uh which is nice yeah you didn't have lots of uh these workers so you that's not how you generate grain at the time

another thing that I really like about this is there's a couple of ways to bypass this side of things and get your discs over here without having great cattle and without having great timing yeah so these couple of um farmer bonuses just let you put a disc straight over there that's awesome and there's a couple of buildings as well that just let you put a disc straight over there so here again there's lots of different ways it feels more generalized then um than the original game which felt a little bit specialized yeah uh there's two sides to this board as well so this is just money and points but if you flip it over there's some other uh sundry goodies here moving a train picking up uh picking up a certain cattle things like that so yeah yeah for me this is the this is the best thing that the new game adds and it it really makes the timing of things really precise I like it so in summary those are all the 10 new things that we love from ten to one of course there are a few other things as well that came already from the second edition things like this token here I love this the introduction of these token so you can draw two and discard two especially when later on in the game you really need that really good stock or when you have really bad card you could still

draw bad but you know you can just use that it's a good it's a good little lock hedge and this was and this was first introduced with the rails to the north just a second oh yes first introduced with Edition ones rails to the North and then it became part of the base of the section of the second edition there you go we got all three so would you you still play these two now that we got Argentina I would probably prefer Argentina but I think because there's three or four new and tricky interlocking mechanisms I might still start players off on basic Great Western Trail yeah and this game by the way plays one to four players there is now a solo mode with the second edition uh Argentina is also one to four with the solo mode still the lovely approachable and sweet Alexander feista with with not met online with chat online he gave some tips for some of his games which is great and in summer we love these games we we love uh probably now Argentina the most because of those things we we just share with you and those are our top 10. if you have any thing that you want us to discuss please let us know for our top 10 or top new things series and if you have played Great Western Trail first edition second edition and

this Argentina one please let us know what you think we really need I really like we love to hear what you think about um any of these which one's your favorite what's your favorite mechanics and so on and thanks for watching thanks for listening if you find it useful it will be really helpful if you can please hit the like button and subscribe to us you can also hit the meatball in the corner and and hit the bell and you get notification when we have new videos like this one a review how to play my short and sweet life playthrough and so on I'm also on Instagram hopefully we find each other there and thank you so much for watching see you next time

Progress saved