Skip to main content
Loading video...

Great Western Trail: Argentina Review

Transcript 23:10

thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to drive through review 765. today we're going to talk about Great Western Trail Argentina and so what this is is a brand new addition addition's not really a good word but a new version maybe no it's a new thing in the Great Western Trail Universe let's call it that because it is very very very similar to the original Great Western Trail but it's that of course in Argentina you're going to be kind of rustling cattle driving it through the country of Argentina and in this case shipping it to Europe and lahav Rotterdam and Liverpool specifically and so as a lot of the similar mechanics so what I'm going to do with this video is I'm going to go down to the table I'm not going to give you like an exhaustive how to play but I will talk about what's different and then I will come back and then tell you my thoughts and why I never want to play the original again spoiler there but let's go down to the table I'll try to uh sell my point of why I think this is way better and then we'll talk more about that at the end though so let's go down to the table okay so I've got the game sort of set up here for two player or even a solo game I'll show you some of the solo stuff first thing to note here is you have the map and so you're going to be traveling up and down just like you did in the

original going all the way up to here until you get to this spot where you then make your delivery and you'll be moving your Cowboys you'll be going to different buildings the starting buildings are randomly you know put out if you wish and then you have in this case instead of Native Americans that you'll be interacting with you have these Farmers here and so there'll be some of these Farmers that you can actually recruit to your main board which is a different change there uh and then you've got here the train which starts at kind of the opposite end of the board instead of moving right it moves left and you can get the stations and all that kind of stuff and put your discs out there and some of your workers and then it'll come down the side of the board and then hit your little end point you could hit this multiple times and score extra points now the one neat thing about the trains is it really is not tied to kind of your delivery threshold there is a way to do that but it's a little different here but you can see these paths see that one go up there and that one there so as you are moving your characters through here instead of having to go all the way to the end if your train has reached let's move this guy here reached or passed um that little spot on the route you can actually circumvent and shortcut your trip to the end of the board to make your delivery and so you can see here if we just zoom all the way around you've got these other routes here so you can really make these laps a lot quicker and so driving your train not only does it

give you little station bonuses and other things along the way but it can really you know shortcut uh your path there so it's really cool and the other little neat part of that is I mentioned the farmers a little bit you can see there are spaces here and you can see there's a space there there there so as you start to move towards the end there'll be these little blockers kind of in your way which again will be charging you uh money because the little black and green hands on these depending on the player count you have to pay one or two dollars to the to the bank there so that'll be another reason you want to kind of shortcut that so you don't have those in your way slowing you down because you only get certain number of movements you know per turn and costing you more to get to the end so that's kind of a neat little wrinkle there the rest of this stuff here is pretty much the same you've got your little different Little Helper workers down there you go through different types of cows that are worth the different victory points different values when you go to deliver them that's different now there is an action on the board to basically go and recruit or help the different farmers and you can see there's a little value here a little Focus it's like this one has a seven you know this one here it's got a six there's different colors and there'll be different bonuses for collecting different colors and things like that based on the bonus cards but then you also have these here these little like scythes so this is a value of four and you'll be able to unlock certain things on your board that'll give you extra size some of the helpers that you can recruit here and hire will come with

size so when you take the action two and this is the space here where you can do that where you can sort of help up to three Farmers then you can spend a certain number of size to recruit these and if you use cards to that because it is feasible to build up your engine so you don't have to spend so many cards but based on the number of cards you use to recruit them again based on the number there because this will help sort of improve focus up there we go um based on the number of cards you spend you might take one of these cards here one or two of these These are worth minus two points at the end of the game and they can be trashed and discarded like other things if you go make a delivery so at the end when you get to the end of your route if these are in your hand so you kind of you don't really want them because they're worth zero value but if you're in your hand when you make a delivery then you can get rid of them basically trash them at that point but again anytime you help them it's kind of like uh it's like effort or exertion you know so you kind of It kind of wears your deck down a little bit which is something that the original never had you could thin your deck down you could build it up with some of these higher ticket items but you're never anything like sort of trash cards you know like in Dominion or other games like that their deck building games you have these cards that kind of clog your deck up so that exists now in this game and then kind of staying on Farmers you can see there's sort of a fourth row down here so you have here your Cowboys and your like your Architects and then your your train Engineers and all that stuff so these are basically the same when you do recruit a farmer

then you can either keep them face up and there might be other bonus cards like I said here here's an example of that so if you've built you know two buildings and you have a green farmer you'll satisfy that bonus so you can leave this just off to the side of your board they're worth two points like that anyway so if you just put them off the side it's worth two points if I put them face down you can pay a cost you can see this one costs six six eight and then you flip them over like that and then this will give you a grain when you do that and this one will give you a grain and so on so when you get grain we'll just move this up you start to crew grain and there's other ways to get grain in the game as well now grain is something you need when you do your deliveries so the first thing you do when you move all the way to the end there is you'll be look over here to these three delivery spots law of Rotterdam in Liverpool and everybody will start with one of their discs here on lahave so let's take a closer look at that one so here's lahav you can see we've got the two discs there the starting disks with the instant that you you get to the end of the track you make a delivery you can spin grain you can see here it cost one grain three grain six five grain and let's say I had one grain I can take then at the time of my delivery and move this to one of the sector Parts in the sector here so I can go oh I get the four extra bucks there or if I had some extra grain I could move it here for example get five extra bucks and that'll give me two points at the end of the game now in a

two player game you put this little thing over the top so it would cover that so based on player count you'll cover or reveal certain spots there and there's other ones so if you have here you can see there's an A and A B side of the map so you can kind of you know mess with that a little bit like if you go here you can move your train up three spaces and you get Five Points so there's some variability in there which is kind of nice to have so once you deliver that make the delivery the first thing you do is spend any grain that you have so you want to get some grain along the way and this is you know used to feed the cows you can't just take a bunch of cows you know hundreds of miles without feeding them so that's that's what this kind of comes in now as you get cubes or discs over here and I'll explain how they'll get to either side you'll get a little bit of a discount so this gives you a plus two grain discount and just by having these discs here you get victory points this one is zero because you start there but if every disc you have here you get one point and if I make a delivery I've got you know two grain discount so I only need the three grain to go to here because it's five minus the two and so on so anyway after you do that then you're going to total up your cars let's say I went there with this so I've got these two are matching right so I only count one of them so two four five and let's throw our mistakes say we had the little medallions here so we got we can spend that we can get up to six if we want and then we can take one of the discs off of our board just like the original and this is our kind of delivery track which is now broken out into these tiles unlike the original so I've got six so I can go ahead and put it on this one if I want to you can only

have one on each of these and these are different Little Ships so let's take a look at the six so if we put it on the six one thing that we can note is we can pick one of the bonus cards just like we could on some of the spaces in the original and it's going to cost us two grand now if the grain you have to pay right away when you deliver and you have to pay it you can't hold it if you've got it if you don't have enough grain then you have to pay out of kind of the income that you receive so I'll get my six bucks but for each grain I can't pay with actual grain then I have to pay two dollars so if I had no grain I would go here get six bucks I have to pay four back because it's two bucks per grain which is okay it's not the end of the world and then of course in this case you get a bonus card and this is where this ship will deliver to so if we zoom out and then take a look at here so as you know players deliver they'll be filling up this board with workers just like in the original and remember in the original you'll refill the cow Market at certain points but here you actually will ship deliveries to the different colored ships there so the first time we tick past that we're going to deliver all the yellow ships and then on the green ones and then all the purple ones and you can see here the different colored ships there but where do they go right so all the yellow ships don't all go to the same place now I'm going to talk about my one component gripe well it's actually kind of two let's use this as an example here so the other one the first component gripe is this little thing is hard to see and when that's out on the board there it's hard to see where that bonus

card thing is it just kind of Blends in for some reason so I mean it's happened to us when we played it we're like oh I should have took a bonus card you know three turns later the other thing is like okay you can see this yellow ship delivers to that anchor see it's kind of like this off-white gray thing and then this yellow ship delivers to that kind of Darker brownish one on the two side right this one blurs that darker brownish one on the one side so you're delivering to the color of the anchor not the background if we look here and we'll just kind of try to zoom in there so there's your kind of off-gray one for Rotterdam and there's your kind of darker brown lahob one which isn't focusing and then there's like a black one like a solid black one Liverpool so you've got to kind of parse these kind of Shades here of those so yeah it gets a little tricky there and then again of course you've got the sides there you've got the one and the two so if we look here we're at Liverpool if it says the one you'd put your disc on that side right and if it's the two you want to put on that side and if you're on the two side you always get that grain discount for putting your disc out there so that's my only kind of component gripe is these tiles right here a little bit harder to read so that's all that pretty much the differences in the main game we'll Zoom down here to the solo game it looks a lot like the solo game again in the second edition uh it's got a little bit of a different idea here with because you're

maintaining the grain you have the kind of the the card deck now this doesn't change this this so this kind of drives the actions and just like the original second edition you move your the figure certain number of spaces based on some logic and then it just does the action on the bottom the action is not tied to where the building's at and then there's three decks of these difficulty cards and these are where it will deliver and then it'll have a little variable here x so sometimes one of these cards see if I can find one now for example this one simple it'll move X spaces and that will go up and that'll be you know basically a bigger number with harder difficulty decks of these deliveries and then this will tell you kind of the order it will deliver in on the first try and so on it doesn't have to spend grain or anything like that but it'll just kind of you know take up space um on the board so that is pretty much the gist of all the changes we'll go back to my talking head okay so that's a rough overview of Great Western Trail Argentina covering most of the differences in the game uh let's talk about all my three pillars I will talk player count I only played it one and four players and I liked it at all both player counts um I don't know that it would make that much difference I like the original at all the player counts and you know uh so yeah I mean that to me doesn't really make much difference the solo game is really cool in this uh it's it's about the same you know as the second edition I like it the thing I like about the solo game I'll just reiterate it here I've said it before is it will kind of pick a strategy and kind

of go at least for a little while after kind of one type of thing either like you know getting lots of cows building lots of buildings Russian to train that kind of thing so I like that that it will kind of play up differently and sometimes it'll kind of switch strategies like it'll get you know it'll change its mind and that's kind of a neat I really like that it's a neat aspect of the solo game and I really enjoyed that in the four player game we played it was great I love the interaction of it and um it's not a lot of direct interaction but kind of the pacing of it and figuring out where people are going being able to build stuff in their way you know that whole thing is really neat so it kind of retains all of those great qualities of the original there uh play times the other one this is 75 to 150. yeah sure it takes two to three hours midmost three hours with four players I don't think it even took us we played with somebody that hadn't even played the original at all and this is the first time they played this one and it was my first time uh playing it as well uh the new edition than this one I played the original Bunch but I think it maybe took three hours but that was with rules you know it went pretty quick so you're looking about two two and a half hours uh the solo games go really quick that can be done in about an hour you know I like to take my time so uh I think you could theoretically get it done quicker now uh to me I kind of spoiled at the beginning I won't play I'm gonna give my copy of the original to the other friend that played for the first time because he never played original he's going to have that copy I don't need to play that anymore

um to me this just does everything better it just improves on everything and it's almost like you know the expansion for the original I did not care for actually at all I thought it just totally made the game up and just was like this whole other mini game thing with the with the way the train worked and the delivery stuff this feels like uh like a fixed version of that expansion right it feels like they read it but they were like oh we've got to start start over we can't just do it with the original game and do kind of what we want to do with the expansion now this is a little bit speculation on my side but this is what it feels like it's like oh well we really want to do this other stuff because we want to kind of add on to some of the cool elements of the game but we've got to start from the drawing board to do that and then they did it and I think that it really really pays off the main thing I like here is the delivery stuff and the train because the train was a little bit more tied into the delivery in the original because based on how far your train moved was kind of how much of a sort of penalty incursion cost it sort of abstracted the whole Logistics of the delivery part but they've made that a little bit more simulated here because you've got the grain side so you've got to manage that you got to have some grain for your cows you know you have to have it by the time you get there but theoretically the idea is that you have you know suspended across where you went so anyway so you've got that side of it and then when you deliver you've got these

different markets that you can deliver to um and these different little kind of idea of you know getting kind of special bonuses for delivering to certain markets beating other players there so before there was no like competition for certain things you just kind of went and delivered your your big old bash but you can kind of position it so you're like oh I'm gonna get on this boat and because he's either going to give me bonus cards it's going to let me to remove kind of the black background discs and or get to this certain location to get an extra bonus there which is kind of kind of dovetail with some other bonuses and things like that because some of the bonus cards are like you got to have a disc in a north and a South quadrant all that kind of stuff so it all kind of fits in there really cool and you've got to have that grain you know kind of engine kind of going underneath the covers and it just adds that other little layer of strategy there to that and then the train though is still super important because you could do you can still do like a train strategy which I've seen work a lot is even the original where you kind of drive that train you just get that going but here it directly affects the length of the path that you have to take which makes sense because you as you build up your kind of rail engine you'll be able to make those deliveries a lot quicker once you get them to a certain point the idea is that basically you know you put it on the train and it gets to the harbor uh you know the next day or something like that so that and that feels just way more you know thematic and interesting that way and I like the

interaction frankly of the farmers versus the Native Americans that was kind of I don't know what the right word is like whitewashed a little bit in the original this makes a little more sense because the in the original it was implied there was a cooperation element there which did exist to a little bit of a degree but I don't think that was largely the degree this makes a lot more sense The Cooperative side uh because and you can actually recruit the farmers and they can help you and they can help you in different ways they can help you with your grain engine they can help you um you know score some extra points and kind of work on the side like not as consultants but it feels like you kind of pull them off as consultants versus you know applying them directly to kind of your grain engine uh and that's that's kind of a cool aspect a lot of the buildings of course interact with all this new functionality so that stuff still works but it's just to me a much tighter thematically experience and it and even the thing like adding the cards that are like the junk cards to your deck I like that that element is there because it it doesn't really need a lot of help in the deck building it uh Department but it was nice to have this and I like that extra thing those cards have that extra ability to it gives you another reason to spend those cards which is going to help theoretically your deck at the end of the delivery but you're going to do that a little bit of a cost to get those into your decks you're like gosh because sometimes in the original you're like you get things so like I can't quite work how to just get the

junk cards and so I can have like a full straight flush you know or whatever cards I think you don't want to flush to the opposite of a straight flush into the delivery spending the cards to get the farmers kind of works for that Advantage but if there's a little there's that little extra penalty of taking the zero card so it kind of balances itself out so it's a nice kind of decision space to live in um yeah so I mean the final takeaway is uh I just did a review of the top games on BGG this one the original was in my top 10 or something it was going to be in my top 10 I've settled on the list yet I'm going to do my top 50 here pretty quickly and this just knocked it out of the park and I'm like oh my gosh like when is the right time to do a top 50.

you know as new stuff comes out I'm like that other game I don't care about that anymore but that's that's what this is done like to me it just works in all the different ways there's a lot of variability with it you can flip the ports on different sides and different stuff I mean there's a bunch of stuff I didn't show you too um but I just highly recommend this game if you've not even played the original just skip right to this one it's a little bit more complicated for sure it's it's kind of like Great Western Trail Advanced you know it feels like there's an expansion there so you know you might try the original because it's not quite as much going on uh with this one but to me this just fires in all the different cylinders and um I mean I talked about brass Birmingham in that video uh that I just posted the other day and to me that was kind of what it is this is doing what brass Birmingham did for brass Lancashire the original brass original brass is freaking awesome game but Birmingham adding that kind of extra wrinkles with some of the ways you can deliver with a different beer things that you can deliver and all it just scratches it right up to like Mass absolute 100 Masterpiece to me and you know I still thought the original brass was pretty much a masterpiece I still think the original Great Western Trail was pretty much a masterpiece so seeing somebody actually able to improve on something in my opinion so good is just awesome and so I think that's what you got here with Argentina yeah I had a joke with my friends um and this is prior to Brass

Birmingham taking the number one spot I played this and I was like just shut the hobby down because I really like this camera I just trying to be enthusiastic here but and also not try to make too much of an idiot myself but I played this and I was like just shut it down any more games that's like this isn't good just shut everything down they can stop printing Great Western Trail New Zealand you just cancel it so good this is so fun I love this game I'm just kidding you can still print that I want to try it but uh all right thanks foreign

Progress saved