Skip to main content
Loading video...

Star Trek: Captain's Chair First Impressions

Transcript 12:27

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today so this video is going to be a quick first impressions of Star Trek captain's chair this is a game by Nigel buckle and David kxy the are the designers of Imperium the set of deck building games based in a more antiquus civilization type of experience that has a lot of the S similar systems ported into a Star Trek theme right and so this was released earlier this year and I got to play this in person and so I don't have a physical board or I don't own this you know I don't have a physical board to show you nor is there a way to show you this online so I'm going to rely on some pictures here from Board Game Geek so if you are familiar with the Imperium system it is a deck building game that involves a lot more than your average deck builder such as Dominion Clank Etc and in this game you are thematically a captain of a fleet in Star Trek and I should interject that I am not a Star Trek fan I mean I not opposed to it but I just don't know the lore behind most of it but essentially in this game you are playing through building your deck crafting your deck with cards that are specific to your captain as well as acquiring them from a market you are

battling for three different planets that are always offered in this Central Market by sending teams and ships there to have the majority to control it take it on your side get the points and effects Etc you're advancing on tracks that have scoring abilities at the end of the game uh every uh Captain has their own special goals that they have to meet or they can meet for bonuses and points for the end of the game and so on and so for I'm not going to go into all the rules but essentially the way that you acquire cards from your own special deck as well as the market is very similar to how Imperium works you have lots of different resources that these cards are used to activate with or to purchase from and you also have these action tiles three for each and so there's kind of an open-ended way to take mechanism or mechanical actions in this game game so uh some of cards for example require no action token to be placed and flipped over some require one to be flipped over and some cards have multiple different actions that can be taken and so there are a lot of different options that you have with these cards they're not necessarily multi-use but each card may have multiple uses on them and so for yeah it's it's too small to tell here on the screen but anyway moving on to the pros and cons of

Captain chair captain's chair as based on the comments made by those on Board Game Geek summarizing them this game is a very deep and strategic game very similar to the depth mechanical depth as seen in Imperium uh but it is very well thematically integrated the solo play a lot of people who enjoy David uh turx solo games would really enjoy this it's a little bit more involved than your average solo experience if you are you know used to those and playing those um you do have I believe four to five Decks that you can play from or captains rather that you can play from and they each have an asymmetric way to approach the game for example in the game that I played I was Captain peard and he really focused on gaining allies so uh for example and there's Captain bicard there uh for example I was really focused on this middle yellow track gaining like diplomacy points essentially and getting these purple allies into my deck and onto ships right that was my goal oh and I forgot the captain that my father-in-law was playing I think it was like Charan or something like that they really enjoyed having uh cargo cards uh so like weapons Etc on their side so so very different approaches to the game uh

that you can kind of follow if you have certain uh captains they have their I guess predestined way to play the game but you can approach it any way you want depending how the cards are it is a very competitive game it is very much a two-player battler for you know the the planets that you have available Racing for cars that are available in each market as well lots of satisfying decisions from people who have played this game and I will say there a lot of positive comments on this game as you saw in the beginning this game is overall average rated an 8.8 out of 10 for some though this game plays pretty long it can be very analysis paralysis prone because each card has you know two to three different ways that you can play them uh I guess some memorization is required I didn't really see that as a you know as a uh a hindrance or as a feature of this game uh and so yeah some rule book issues hard to play casually because it's so long and and pretty deep if you're coming into this from the experience of Imperium I guess I'll get into this now with my and I'll I I won't go through every single one of these but getting into my own opinion on this game I rate this game as 7.6 out of 10 I think this is an excellent game I really feel like this game is a more streamlined version of the Imperium

system and maybe so I have played Imperium before like I mentioned before and I I played it once or twice and ultimately sold it because I felt like it was too much for me at the time I played that game probably 3 to four years ago whenever it came out it was around the time that it came out and maybe you know my tastes have changed a little bit since then but I mean I I do enjoy deck builders but it just it felt a little too nebulous a little too Solitaire I suppose like I was kind of solving this really you know diverse and complex puzzle on my own part of the board without much interaction with my other opponents uh granted that was a while ago and so I might be missing out on some you know interactive opportunities that I've had with uh with plays in the past but Star Trek captain's chair I feel like is more streamlined and focused and I think the theme does help I some people might be nitpicking the theme but I I felt like this is a very thematic game I think every card was tailored to kind of represent who they are or what place it was in the show and so that is fantastic and I think uh I mean there are some Liberties taken I there was one comment for example about how you must control the planets that you're going for maybe that's not the intent for every single Captain it's not all about you know war and having a higher military presence essentially I don't

think it's necessarily represented as military in this game but it you know maybe there are some opportunities that it's not as thematic as one might hope it would be uh a lot of the negative aspects or comments on this game revolved around Captain Kirk not being in the game so I think that I remember listening to a podcast a while ago where the designers and the publisher of this game kids will have Kirk coming out as a future expansion so I think Kirk will be coming to this game including all the characters from the original Star Trek so that is fantastic and other than that you know the the game itself was really fun to play I I think yeah these are this is a pretty interesting game it's not one that I would come back to a lot because it is long to play uh I'm not really interested in playing it solo I think the the solo modes that are offered and designed by tury are a little too much for me to enjoy with the limited amount of time that I have to play games and so I I prefer something a little less uh less brainy I suppose but if this were like in a digital format where everything is taken care of then I I think I would be a little bit more interested in trying this out and exploring it I think there's a lot of depth to this game it's a lot of depth that I'm not necessarily interested in at the moment I I think you might know what kind of games I prefer if you've listened to this Channel or watched it for a while now and so I suppose if this

theme was different right if it was like Lord of the Rings or some other IP that I'm more interested in then sure I probably would give it more points for that for like the fun Factor but essentially yeah I the interaction was more apparent in this game compared to Imperium but I did feel like it was mostly just for those planets and perhaps Racing for some cards on the market that were offered there so not too much interaction uh and I appreciate that it's not a a negative impact or take that type of interaction I think this is the type of interaction that I like but perhaps if there was a little bit more involved it would be more interesting to me I suppose but yeah mechanically it was you know a totally fine game it was really interesting to you know put together the the deck that I was slowly crewing throughout the game trying to col some cards and and make sure that my set of cards worked well together it was fun to explore but I think this game does have some depth to it when you look at all the different types of cards that are available and as you try to uh perhaps explore different Avenues with different uh captains you know they might want to pursue more of a I guess quote unquote military presence or battling four planets and Etc or one that is more diplomatic I think it's interesting to pursue that but it I think it would be really cool to try to win without

focusing on that too much and see how that works so I think there's a lot to explore in this game if you like Star Trek I think you will like this game if you know Imperium then this will be an easy step into and I think it was for me and so I I appreciate the Simplicity and the streamlined nature of this game compared to that it might be a bear to learn if you are if you are coming into this as a newer board gamer or you know perhaps a Star Trek fan that is getting into games and you see this deck builder and think oh this might be similar to a lighter deck building game like Clank or Dominion it's not and so that might be a barrier for some however I think if you do put the time into it there is a lot of richness uh to this game uh with the theme and it's very nostalgic for for those who understand and know Star Trek and I can respect and I think if you're willing to put in the effort this game will be a lot of fun oh one last thing I do appreciate that this game I mean it is solo and you can learn the game at a a simpler rate with the cadet mode in the solo version I haven't played that myself but I do appreciate that it is two players like I think it would be cool if it was like three to four players but I I appreciate the paired down nature of this game to just be against someone else right I think it since it is a long game that makes it a lot more manageable and it portrays the game as a battler head-to-head between two captains and so I I I do appreciate that as well but

anyway those are my first impressions on Star Trek captain's shair let me know if you had the chance to play it yourself and what you think of it so thank you for Consulting with me today hope to catch you on the next one if you schedule an appointment with me and we'll see you then thank you

Progress saved