Great Western Trail Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing Great Western trail which was designed by Alexander Pfister in this two to four player game you'll be taking on the role of cattle herders trying to get the best variety of cows over to Kansas City in order to sell them and get money which will allow you to buy better cows to put into your deck because there is a deck building mechanism in this game and you can also use that money to build new buildings out on the trail itself so as the game goes on the path in which you take to get over to Kansas City is going to be modified by the players first I'll show you how the game plays and then we'll jump into my review here we have the board set up for a three player game of Great Western trail the first thing to note are these neutral buildings here now they have little letters on the sides to show you where they can go or you could randomize them up on the board but for now I'll put the a building with the a slot next up we have some hazard tokens and trading with the Native American tokens these were randomly brought out and we put the drought ones over here the flooding ones over here and the rest of them around the board in their appropriate spots and lastly we have the job market here it's going to fill in with the people that you can hire you'll notice that in a three player game you don't use this final column over here and this is also the game clock every time you fill this up this token will go down and once it goes all the way down and falls off the board the game will be over over here you can see the starting deck that each player has it's full of all these cows most of them are value too but there are five these value ones in here and you start the game by drawing four cards off the top of the deck because that is your hand size it's denoted by this number over here you can see the four but as the game goes on you might be able to remove these tokens which can increase your hand size to five or even six each player's turn is
split up into these three phases that are shown on your player board the first thing you do is move your marker on the board up to the maximum movement and as you can see at the start of the game for a three-player game it is three but just like the hand limit that can be increased as the game goes on for your first turn of the game you actually just put your marker down on one of the seven neutral cities and then evaluate that but let's pretend the game has been going for a while and we are starting over here now we have three movement available to us so the first one will take us over to this building and we can continue going if we want to and we consume one movement point for each piece of card board that we go over so we can go one two three following the arrows of the trail along the board instead we could go one and then two two three over here following this forked path now that's because this piece of cardboard with this hazard is going to eat one of our movement now we're probably not going to want to do this because as you can see this tile has a little black hand on it and whenever you pass over a hand you have to pay a money penalty in a three-player game that's one dollar for each black hand and $2.00 for each green one but as you can see with other player counts like the two-player game it might even be two dollars for going over that black hand let's say that we decided to stop on this building right here we can now evaluate the actions on the bottom and we can do them in any order we can see there are actually three actions on this one two of them are the higher action and this one allows us to discard a white Guernsey card from our hand which we just happen to have and when we do that we are going to collect two money from the bank the starting player only starts with six bucks but now we are up to eight and we can now go and try to hire one or two people you'll notice the second time we try to higher it will
cost us two more money than normal so odds are good we're only going to be hiring one person at this early part of the game with these eight dollars we go over to the job market and we could see that we're only allowed to buy from this top row because this symbol right here invalidates any of the options on the roads at so as soon as this moves down we will have unlocked all of these people to hire but at this point of the game when it just starts we can only hire these top ones and we see the cost is 6 bucks so let's go ahead and hire this engineer right here we're going to discard 6 of our money and then add the engineer to our board you could say that every player starts with one cowboy one craftsman and one engineer so you always have one of each but when you add a new one you add it on to the left side going forward and whenever you cover up any of these symbols it's actually a one-time ability that you can choose to use in this instance if we happen to have a level 1 Jersey cow in our hand we could discard it in order to gain one certificate which we could track over here unfortunately with our hand we don't have any of those cards so we're not allowed to use this ability but we could still put the engineer down there and now we have to since we only have $2 left we certainly can't hire a second time so we can forego taking that action you always don't have to do all of them on the specific spot so with that we move to the last part of our turn where we draw back cards into our hand until we have our hand limit right now we only have three cards on our hand we can have a maximum of 4 so we'll go ahead and draw and looks like there's the jersey we wish we had before and with that our turn is over and it goes to the player on our left now that you know how it turned works I'll reef lead ascribe the other six buildings that start out on the board building B let's you discard one green cow from your hand in order to get to money and this is the way you can build
buildings out onto the map you'll see you can put the building out there and you have to spend $2 for every one craftsman point you use we start the game with just one craftsman which means we have one craftsman point available to us and if we look along the top here we actually have three buildings that only take one craftsman point to use it's also worth noting that there are these ten buildings here but on the backside of every single one of these buildings is a completely different style ability in fact of this one cost to Craftsman points whereas this side only cost one you could use all of this side or all the other or just randomize them up if you want so at this point we can buy one of these three buildings and it's going to cost us two money to do so let's say we went with this one here this can now be placed on any empty spot on the entire board but let's say that we decide to put it right here firstly you can see that it's worth one victory point to us at the end of the game if we still have this building out secondly you'll notice down here that has an ability this one gives you two money for every building you have that is in one of these force zones right here so this would count as a four spot but this one would not so if we landed on this building then we would get to use this ability down here however if our opponents landed on this building instead not only were they not be able to use the main function of the building but they will also have to pay a penalty according to the color hand right here we see this one is green now they're gonna have to pay this whether or not they lay it here or just walk through it and they pay that money directly to us as opposed to the penalties on the hazard tiles which goes to the bank there are some special locations on the board where you can put your buildings however and you'll notice these little actions on the bottom these are bonus actions you get to evaluate when you land on one of your own buildings on these spots now the reason they have
these bonuses because you have to travel potentially through some hazards in order to get to them so that's going to be one reason why you might want to try to get rid of these hazards as the game goes on and I'll show you how you do that later but these are potentially good spots to go in order to get even better benefits but you can bet that your opponents will do it they can to try to put some of these hazards in the way to stop you from being able to use these buildings well it's also worth noting that in the future you can replace previous buildings on the board with new ones and in this case you only have to have Craftsman points equal to the difference so with a single craftsman we could actually build this level two building onto the board by discarding this one and we'd only have to pay money equal to the difference as well in this way you could potentially get up to the higher value buildings for instance if you want to build this five here you might be able to do it with only three craftsman by discarding it and putting it down but of course you don't actually get the victory points for these tiles that they removed from the game but the new ones also have more points on them next we have building C which gives us two different options but on this one we can choose either the top or the bottom this lets us get one certificate which I showed you before it's just moving that cube down on our player board and this one allows us to grab a new objective there will always be four objectives available to the player and let's say they grab this one we'd immediately refill over here so if for some reason they need to draw another one they would have four more to choose from and then this card will be added into the discard pile of the little deck that we're building here now once we go through this entire deck you're going to reshuffle your discard pile and start drawing again and at some point you'll pull this objective into your hand at that point as a free action you could play it down in front of you and immediately do the bonus action that's in the top left this happens to get to
money immediately and you then put it out with your other objectives every player starts with one objective as you can see here but there's one key difference between a starting objective and one of the ones you get in the middle of the game this one right here as you can see on the bottom says that you will get three points at the end of the game if you have built one building and then you have traded with the green tribe and the blue tribe now it's important to note that if you have another objective asking for a building you need to satisfy a building for this one and for another one those don't necessarily share so for each objective you need discrete amounts of things that you have grabbed now if you play this in front of you and you don't satisfy the requirements you will lose these victory points in the bottom right on the card at the end of the game you'll notice that the starting one does not have any negative points this just gives you a nice direction to move forwards now you don't have to play this card you can just keep it in your deck and if you do so then when the game ends you could get the victory points if you do this correctly but you won't lose the negative points if it's not very actually been played into your area it's just going to clog up your deck the whole game while you are not sure about playing it the other action we can do we'll simply move our train forward once for every one of the engineers we have remember we actually bought a new engineer well now we have two of them so we can move our train twice the train starts in Kansas City so for two moves we just go one two and it's important to note you can never share a spot with an opponent so if the yellow player got to move three for instance they would actually go one two three jumping ahead over us so it's not always great to be out in front of your opponents this is also a good time to talk about these stations right here as you are moving across you'll hit these split points
where you could either go here or go down here when you go down here you are allowed to take one of the disks off your board put it on the map you have to spend this money to get this money picture points at the end of the game and you have the ability to take one of your higher people for instance this engineer right here and replace this spot on the board so you actually lose your worker but you gain this little token which is great because it gives you an ongoing benefit this one gives you one permanent certificate and another way you could score points at the end of the game this one gives you two points for every two certificates you have when the game is over in this instance we'd get to grab one of these disks from a board and put it out onto that train spot however that is a light colored train spot so we can only take disks from light bordered spots so for instance these dark ones up here we would not be able to grab let's go ahead and take this disk right here and we put it right here it's important to note you're never allowed to have two disks of your color in a specific train station but everybody can do this to one of the train stations it's just an incentive to get there first in order to grab these really nice tokens next up we have building D which gives us a new option this lets us trade with the Native Americans now when you look down here right now we just have this negative 1 negative 2 and negative 3 if we wanted to trade with this one for instance we'd be able to take this token but we have to spend one money to the bank in order to do so but we'd probably do this in order to satisfy one of the objectives that we have in front of us however as the game goes on this may fill up to the point where we have these positive values and if you traded with the Native Americans here for instance you would gain six dollars from the bank instead of trading we could simply spend two dollars to move our train forward twice and the other option now is the
auxilary actions this allows us to do a double exhilaration but you can always do a single exhilarating action when you land on any space on the board including these neutral ones your opponent spaces or hazards the exhilarating actions you have available to you are dictated by the number of discs you've pulled off of this area of your player board everybody starts with a single value in that these top two this one's really easy it just gets you one money and this one lets you draw a card and then discard a card now you notice that we pulled touken off since we went on the double auxiliary location that means we can actually do this one twice because we pull this disk off if instead we wanted to do this one with our double action we still only get to do it once because this disk still remains if instead we had pull off this disk for instance we can now execute this one once and it gives us the really great action of moving our Train backwards once and taking a cow from our hand and destroying it permanently so it is no longer in our deck there are a couple other options here they're pretty simple this just lets you move your train forward by spending one money and this one you can spend the money and move your train backwards in order to grab a certificate next we have building e which lets us discard one black how to get tube dollars but more importantly this lets us go to the cow market these are all the cows that are currently up for sale and you'll note that we currently only have one cowboy now if you look along the top you'll see our options for one cowboy we can buy one of these three value cows for six dollars we could also buy one of these four value cows for twelve dollars but we would not even be able to buy either of these of Phi value cows because we would need two cowboys in order to spend twelve dollars to buy one or with four
Cowboys we can buy one for six so the more Cowboys you have hired into your area the cheaper the cows are going to be to grab and the better cows you'll be able to grab you can also use some of your cowboy actions to draw new cows from the top and replenish this area in case you don't see the cows you in particular want so if you are able to buy one of these cows say for instance this one that would cost us right at the moment six money and we put this right into our discard and it is now part of our deck-building F gives us two different actions that are pretty interesting but first lets us discard two of the same cow from our hand in order to take for money which is a nice way to get rid of a lot of cows from our hand and allow us to draw more cows from our deck the other option lets us remove one of the hazards from the board for the cost of seven dollars now you'll see this hazard over here we could pull this off it'll be worth three victory points to us at the end of the game and more importantly we have cleared up at this spot so if we were to potentially put buildings over here to get access to these nice bonuses it is going to be easier to get over there we would have to spend quite as much time and money to activate those buildings and finally building G should look really familiar you just move your train equal to the number of engineers you have and you also get to do a double axillary action once you find yourself over in this neck of the woods you will either be forced to go over to Kansas City or you could choose to make me do some jumps to finally go over here and this is the end of the line there are five different phases to evaluate in Kansas City the first three are really simple you just go here and then pick one of these two tokens and put it on the relevant part of the board for instance we could grab this green trading tile and we would put it here you always slide these into these lowest value slots so if somebody traded with
this one they'd actually get a money we would do this again picking from these two now we could take this craftsman for instance and add them to the job market you always put them on the same row as this in the marker here and once it's pretty much full you actually slide the marker down replace it with that particular person and as I mentioned before this row is now available for hiring because the token is no longer in that spot so we go ahead and move here and sometimes you just don't have an option so we could just take one of these engineers and put them down there next up is time to see how much money we get for our herd of cows which is the cards we have in our hand first of all you look to see if you have any duplicates and you just disregard those they're not going to do anything for us and then you add up all the values here so that's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 to which you can also add these certificates this one's permanent so we will now go to 8 and we could choose to consume this one to go all the way to 9 if we wanted to but in this instance I don't think we would we now discard our entire hand and immediately take the 8 money and finally we have to ship out our cows we do this by looking at the different cities along here and we wanted to find one that matches the number we just got with the value of our hand we got 2 8 so we look all the way over here we see Santa Fe we see that it is a spot where we can put a disc down just like we did with this station and just like the station it has a light colored border so we can pull a disc off in this case maybe we increase the capacity for us to hold on to these certificates we place this into Santa Fe and then we have to count the number of these red crossing symbols that are between the new symbol and where our train is in this case there are two of them so we immediately have to pay transfer fees of $2 so we're losing two of the eight money we just grabbed it's
also important to note you're not allowed to put your disc on a city you've already traveled to so if in the future you fail to quite get to 10 but maybe you even have 9 you would actually fall all the way down and deliver over here to Topeka which would definitely be unfortunate because as you can see there are these green arrows they only evaluate when you have adjacent tokens of your color so in this instance you would actually lose three points at the end of the game but you would be able to gain a new objective and you see there's another one of those objective ones over here with that you're done with Kansas City and it's time to do this whole thing over again you draw up a new hand of cards equal to your current hand size and you're ready to go through the trail again as players continue to hit Kansas City this token is going to fall farther and farther down the board until it falls off entirely once that happens everybody else will get one more turn and then the game is over at this point everybody needs to count up all the victory points they have and it comes from a variety of spots it could be the cows that they've purchased throughout the game the building's they put on the board as well as hazards they've grabbed objectives they've claimed and several other things once you add up all those points you see who has the most points and they're the winner of the game let's now begin the review for Great Western trail by covering a few positive points the first of these relates to the very end of the trail the destination that you're trying to get to in Kansas City I really like pretty much every aspect to this part of the game where you are firstly putting out new tokens onto the board and you have decisions to make they're three different spots allow you to pick one of the two different tokens and put it out and it could be a hazard token that you put down to make it a little harder for an opponent to get to a building that they built it might be trading with the Native American spot you can put down
because maybe you can see that you'll be the first person to get there and you can cash it out for lots of money or maybe it's one that matches an objective that you're trying to work towards but I'm almost the most important one that's over here is refilling the job market putting different people into those spots and having some control as to how much money they will be depending on how many are already in there and where the token is that you might put a cowboy down at a certain price and that moves the token down and you can put an engineer down that'll be a different set of prices also you may be the first person to actually hire those new people so you have a little bit of control as to what you might be able to grab them and again it depends on if that job market token gets to bump down when you actually get to Kansas City but these are all decisions that you have to make and I like that ability to control the randomness of the game and kind of see ahead and notice oh well you know there's a rockslide and there is a lord of the flooding spots and I'm gonna try to get there first so I could put the rockslide down before somebody gets there you know that kind of stuff it's interesting also you then cash out hand and get money for the variety of cows that you have in your hand and money is the thing that cranks all the engines in this came you need money to buy new cows to put into your deck so that you will be able to get more money when you cash out in Kansas City in the future you also need money in order to put buildings out onto the board which will modify the options you have and potentially give you better action slots and you need money in order how those people from the job market and put it them into your area so you are really constantly trying to chase having this best hand possible when you get to Kansas City and this is where you actually the rubber meets the road and
you get that money but you then might lose a bunch of your money because you have to pay the the toll based on how far your train is away from the token that you put down and first of all that token this is really interesting the way you can't put two of these tokens down on any one of the cities that are in the middle so you might find yourself in the mid to late game where you have a pretty good hand and you want to put your token pretty far down along the track but you don't quite make it far enough to get to an open slot so you fall all the way down and maybe put it down to like the floor slot which can be kind of costly honestly so missing the the hurdle essentially can be a pretty big deal however the gap between that token and your train is going to dictate how much money you will lose so if you have not moved your train very far and you fall all the way back down well fortunately that means you're going to spend a lot less money and you'll have more stuff to buy stuff the next time you go through the trail so you are incentivized to keep that train moving so that you can keep the money that you just got in order to do things as you continue to play the game but it's just one more decision you're making throughout the game like how important is it to me to move that train along and then you discard your whole hand you move to the beginning of the trail again you draw a new hand and you go it's just a nice cathartic moment of cashing in on your work so far and then refreshing and seeing where you can go from there for positive number two let's discuss two out of the three different professions that you can hire onto your board the first is the Cowboys and these let you buy better cows to put into your deck you start the game with just one cowboy and with that cowboy you can actually get three new varieties of cows into your deck so that's neat you don't even
need to really invest in them that much early in the game but you will find that there are way more points on the higher value cows that you really can't even touch without at least getting a second and even with two it was so expensive to buy those cows there is incentive to get three or even four Cowboys also if you have enough money to buy the cows you want but that cow is not actually out there you could spend extra Cowboys well you know can exhaust them but you'll actually lose them in order to draw new cards from the top of the cab deck to potentially find the one that you want to buy and put into your deck so I really like the way that incentivization structure works like you don't necessarily need Cowboys in order to do well with a game but if you decide you want to have lots of big cows in your deck that's a thing that you'll be chasing you'll definitely leave these Cowboys on your player board and then we now we have the engineers and so anything about the engineers is that there is a bonus that you get to activate underneath every single one of the slots for the engineers where the Cowboys there are only two of these bonuses so most of the time when you buy a new cowboy there's no immediate benefit but with the engineers you constantly have this this thing you can do you put it down maybe you discard Jersey to get some money or maybe get some certificates you might even be able to hire new people at a discount they're really good things you can do with these engineers and then there are a couple different spots on the board right at the very beginning of the game then allow you to move your train forward the number of spaces equal to the number of engineer's you have and there are also new buildings that can be built out onto the board that are also modified by the number of engineers you have so they're just a very satisfying profession to
have a reasonable amount of because as I mentioned before moving your train along is important and the farther along it is the less of the gap you have between your train and the token you put down the more money you get to keep and having more money is always better because there's just you never really run out of things you want to spend on in this game so I really enjoy the way those engineers work also when you're moving your train along you get to you can stop it off in these different train stations and if you're the first person there you can actually lose one of your people that you hired out onto the board in order to get a permanent effect which will be nice right now and then also give you victory points at the end of the game well most of them are permanent effects and the great thing about doing this with engineers that kind of somatically works you could put a cowboy into that train station but if you do an engineer well the next time you hire an engineer you can immediately use that ability that's printed on the board again so you're kind of incentivized to use engineers to install them into these train stations to run them and it just like really everything about the engineers they're really fun aspect to the game as well as the cowboys as I mentioned before because getting bigger better cows is just a fun thing to do now you may have noticed that I've conspicuously not talked about the craftsman here and don't worry I'll be getting to them later on in the review positive number three relates to the rest of the player board that you have in front of you and specifically the way you can remove these tokens from your player board in order to won't put them down onto the slots when you go to Kansas City in order to get victory points at the end of the game as well as other bonuses but also when you remove any of these disks from your board you unlock either new abilities or the ability to do things that you've already been able to do even better and this is
just a really fun thing to do I like this in every game I've ever bumped into it with for instance Eclipse and Terra Mystica both uses as well so it's not new but it's done well here so let's talk about the auxilary actions first we start the game with two of these partially unlocked you can do a single evaluation of them so you might feel like the first disc you should take off is the secondary one of those so that if you go to one of the double axillary action spots you can do that spot twice and that's really great however you might decide you know my deck is really big I wanna start this game right from the very beginning just getting rid of cows in or in order to do that you have to pull the disk off from one of those other slots that are farther down and if you pull both of those disks off as you play the game you'll be way better and actually discarding the cows from your deck permanently but you have to work yourself towards that and then you have this big incentive to try and have big hands to cash in to these cities that have the darker border because that will allow you to increase your hand size or move your pawn faster across the Great Western trail in order to maybe hit Kansas City more times than your opponent does so just every single time you're pulling these tokens off the board it feels good in fact one of them allows you to store even more certificates than normal and I was tarting to think that was kind of weak but the last time I played it I actually used it to someone good effect and so yeah that one's maybe more situational but still satisfying to save up that many certificates and then dump them in order to jump ahead to the right spot on the the delivery track when you go over to Kansas City so just a great implementation of this mechanic and just a very satisfying thing to do while you're playing let's now cover a couple
of neutral points and the first of these relates to the role of card draw luck in the game as well as how hand management deals with that so unlike most deck builders you don't actually discard your entire hand at the end of every turn instead you are keeping the cards that you haven't spent you're kind of trying to cultivate a hand of different types of cows and in fact if you don't spend any counts on your turn well you don't draw any new ones into your hand and that is a good thing if you're trying to protect a good hand for instance but more often than not you're gonna have at least one cow you're going to try to get rid of while you are going through the trail and I like that the ability to modify your hand as you're going through the game there are several different ways to stop by the exhilarate actions which might let you destroy a cow from your hand to draw a new one or simply draw new ones from your deck and then decide which ones you want to get rid of the reason this is kind of a neutral point is because that secondary that decision of what do you get rid of from your hand is usually pretty obvious you just look at your hand you get rid of duplicates the lowest value duplicates that you can maybe if there are two that seem really similar you could try to look through discard and see how many you might have to see what you might draw into as a duplicate as you continue on through the trail but for the most part it's somewhat obvious what you're trying to do there so the decision really is is my hand good enough to go to Kansas City now or do I want to stall out and stop in another spot that lets me try to modify my hand again and if you do that well maybe that didn't work out for you and you try to stall out again and this is where card drawn luck can come into play because every time that you are doing this you know drawing two cards into your hand trying to stall out to make your hand better you are you are at
the whim of your deck and I have seen many situations where that luck of the draw was relatively swingy especially when you get really close to Kansas City where this is the last spot that you can stall out on and if you draw that one cow then you get to put your token down on like the 14 spot and if you don't draw that one cow then you get to put your token down on like the two spot and that could be a humongous swing of points based off of how that deck is shuffled and you might say well if only one cow makes that happen then more often than not that player should not get all those points but sometimes there are like three or four cows in your deck that will get you to that 14 spot but instead you draw some more jerseys or you draw you know one of the green cows and then you don't get to it you put it down on the 2 spot and that could make a break how will you do the game like I've seen situations where that takes someone from the second place down to fourth place based off of how they drew from their deck and maybe they stall out three times desperately trying to make their hand better and they got unlucky every single one of those times and that's just really unfortunate versus other times where I've seen somebody buy a new cow at the market and then they go to a spot and they draw a treasure card but their deck is gone they reshuffle their deck and they immediately draw that new count it's like a purple into their hand right before they go to Kansas City and now they just jump way far ahead and they go a lot farther than they were even expecting to and if this happens in the early-to-mid parts of the game where people are just starting to put down tokens from the dark bordered area that's a really big difference if you put down a white border token or a dark
one because the white bordered one's going to help you with one of your exhilarations probably but the dark border one might increase your hand size or increase your speed which is such a big deal with this kind of game and being able to get there one round through the trail earlier can have a large impact so I don't think that card draw block is a negative for the game because there are so many different ways that you can try to replenish your hand through discarding of cows but it is still definitely there and for a heavier style game is often more impactful than I would have expected neutral number two relates to the hazard tokens that go down onto the board and more specifically the spots where you can actually place your buildings that will give you bonuses but are at the end of a hazard part of the trail I have played this game four times now and I have seen these more risky spots used almost not at all because usually these hazards come out in a very big way and they are quite expensive to remove from the map there are buildings that can do this slightly better at a little bit cheaper but the base one on the map to remove a hazard is seven money which that is an whole cow that could be in your deck that's definitely one of the people that you could have hired for seven money just to remove one of these hazards and the moment you build one of these buildings on the map all of your opponents are going to be incentivized to try and put hazards down into that spot if they have the option to make it slower and harder to get to that building and it can be very costly to cross over these hazard spots not really with the tempo of losing the movement but really from moving from losing the money to the hand symbol on each of
those Hazards I feel like that maybe they should have slowed down your movement more but cost you less money or something like that because it usually seems so costly to actually put a building down to evaluate it at the end of those channels that the bonuses that that building entailed were not really worth it and in one game we actually had a big lack of hazards come out and so we did actually build buildings in those spots and we use those buildings to a certain degree but I'll tell you what we straight-up forgot about the bonus a couple times because well for my perspective I played the game so many times already pretty much never using those spots and then suddenly the time I actually got to use it it just skipped my mind and that's totally on me and that's why this is a neutral point because I really like the idea of the hazards and I really like the idea of building a building at the end of it so it's a bit risky and you kind of need to try and clean up your own trail part of the board once you invest in putting a building over there it's just very costly to actually remove those hazards and even more costly to try and navigate over to them to evaluate that building it's now time to discuss a couple negative points the game and the first has to do with the thing that I was most excited about the game going in which was the buildings that you are putting out onto the board to see the trail get modified and grow as the game goes on the idea of the game is that the trail starts on four really empty which with just the neutral buildings out there and as you play the game you will fill it in more and more and by the end of the game there'll be lots of options to you for you to choose as you are moving across this trail and the issue that I have comes from two different sides and I
think if either of these two facets didn't exist it would be totally fine but when I combine them both together it really is a problem for me the first has to do with the fact that you can't do much interesting on your opponent's buildings you really only get to do the fun stuff when you land on your own buildings and this is a neat idea in general because it's going to force you to try and put your buildings out in the board and it means that your opponent's buildings are going to kind of slow you down and maybe even sometimes cost you money when you go over them so that idea by itself is not really an issue with the game but when you add that in with the other side in that it's really difficult to put buildings out onto the map you have situations where if you don't actively try to chase putting buildings out on the map you will probably not do that much of it and you will play pretty much the same game the whole way through the trail might fill in a bit but it won't really affect you because you can't use your opponent's buildings all they're gonna do is slow you down and maybe cost you money but that's not interesting at all so the reason it's so slow to put buildings out is because they cost a lot of money and there is a huge incentive to nity cost of getting these craftsmen out onto your board you'll notice that I did not mention the craftsman earlier in the positive parts because I feel like this is just such a slow way of getting the buildings out that you have to dedicate your game your play to getting those buildings out I think maybe the idea was that this is one path to victory go heavy on buildings and instead not really do much deck building or do much with the engineer because you when you start the game with one of these craftsmen and you can build two or
three of the starting buildings depending on which way they're flipped over and those buildings are not that interesting they're okay but they're they're obviously supposed to be kind of jump-starts into furthering your progress throughout the game and you are able to upgrade your buildings into new ones like discarding one and putting a new one out just paying the difference which is nice and but even then you still need you know two or three craftsmen in front of you in order to do that and this is the only thing that craftsmen do for you there's no other real benefits that you have for having craftsmen on your board and the opportunity cost of hiring craftsmen instead of cowboys or instead of engineers is humongous because Cowboys get you those cows into your deck and you do need the cows in your deck in order to do well in Kansas City I have seen people do pretty well in the game with pretty good scores by not deck building much but when they do that they go really heavy with the engineers so you could try to go heavy engineer and heavy craftsmen but when I have attempted to do that it really hasn't worked out that well it feels almost too slow trying to get those better buildings out onto the board and it felt like the abilities on those buildings were good but not really good enough to warrant all of that expenditure and also this is the deck building game I want to not completely ignore the deck building in the game I feel like I kind of want to be able to do well by doing all three of these things so if getting buildings out was cheaper if maybe the way craftsmen work was slightly different and you were able to put your buildings out also escalate into those really cool late-game buildings if you want to get those like eight nine or ten cost
buildings out onto the map you are going to have to do a lot of upgrading or just get a lot of craftsmen or probably both of those things and every time you are stopping off to do this action to put new buildings on the board you are not doing other things to progress yourself to make your hand better etc as you're moving along the trail so I've never really seen anybody get a six plus value building out on the map and I know it's possible and they look really cool but it's seems so hard to get there that it never really quite happens and I almost feel like I'm window shopping you know I'm looking through the window to see all these cool options that I could potentially do but I never actually have gotten there through four plays of the game so I think that if you could not use your opponent's buildings but it was much easier to get your own buildings out in the map they'll be fine or if you could here's about you should use your opponent's buildings and then it was equally hard to get those buildings out at least you buy your opponent's putting buildings out in the map you would have more interesting options to jump onto as you are traveling through the trail and maybe if they had done that they could have increased the toll like if you want to use it you have to spend you have to give them money but it still might be worth it to you and so when I add these two together I've just found that the board stagnates you know I play this relatively long game and if I don't actively chase those buildings I'm just doing the same neutral buildings the whole time and as the game goes on it's just a little bit harder to get to them because there's more opponents buildings in the way that just cost me money and I don't find that interesting I think I've pretty much summed up all my feelings on this it's just been very disappointed with the way that trail actually has filled up in the games I played and this
leads me directly into negative point number two which has to do with interesting decision density this is a not a quick game and it's also not a light or even medium style game as far as I'm concerned so I expect to be making lots of interesting decisions while I'm playing this game and I have found that I am not satisfied when the game is over and I feel like many of the things that you are doing in this game almost feel like they're obvious decisions like you could program an AI to somewhat easily decide the clear path in order to get through the trail because the trail does not change that much as I just mentioned before I found that it stagnates in a very big way and also as I mentioned with the hand management like deciding what cars to keep in your hand is usually really obvious and the last game I play was actually a two-player game and after the game was over we're discussing why we both felt kind of dissatisfied with the experience of the game and we realized that my opponent Evan he actually won the game somewhat soundly the second half of the game he made pretty much no decisions he just ran his engine over and over again he had put out one or two buildings on the board one of them was really good it let him drop onto cars and discard a bunch based on the number of count the Cowboys that he had in front of him and once he had that setup he just did that he just raced through the the trail got a bunch of cars discarded the ones they didn't need cashed out in Kansas City well and just ran through it and really didn't make any interesting decisions and I feel like if you're playing a game for an hour and a half to two hours you want to have lots of interesting decisions and they are there I'm not saying this game is devoid of them I'm just saying the density is not high enough there's too much time spent in just
doing turns that seemed totally obvious and a big part of that has to do with negative point number one I think that if you were constantly putting more buildings out that you were able to evaluate as the game went on that the trail would fill up in such a way as to give you altered alternate options but the cost to get those buildings out is so high that you'll probably just get a good set of going and then just run that out so I've been very disappointed with the number of things that I wanted to do while I was actually playing the game and like I said we just ended the games feeling somewhat dissatisfied with the experience we almost felt like we wanted the game to go longer with some feeling like if it was longer maybe we would get a point where we were satisfied with it but I don't think we would necessarily get there let's now go into the variability of Great Western trail and I think that it is above average that really does come down to the building tiles that you are able to use as you're playing the game there are 10 tiles total and every single one of them has a back side and the abilities are pretty separated out like this you don't feel like the backside is just a slightly different version of the other side if you randomly flip these tiles over in one game and then do that again in the next game you will feel like the actions that are available to you on these buildings is going to be significantly different this of course doesn't take away from the issue that I have that it's hard to get these buildings out on the board to actually evaluate the abilities that they have on them but from a strict variability perspective I think that that is pretty strong Great Western trail plays two to four players and I've done all of those different player counts and I think it is good at all of them but there is a slight edge towards the two player versus the others
mostly due to just the overall game length the four player game that I had was a first play for all of us but it did go well over three hours which was way too long in my perspective but I did later play a three player game where we all were familiar with the game already and that still came in at about two hours and there is not actually that much interaction that you have with your opponents while you're playing the game mostly because you're not allowed to use the buildings they have on the map so the only real difference between having more players in the game is there's gonna be more buildings out on the map potentially but when you scale up the player count you get to move faster across the map so it doesn't really change the speed at which you actually get to Kansas City so I feel if there's that little player interaction when it comes to all those things you may as well play the game at two players I suppose the biggest way that you'll be competing is grabbing the cows from the cow market so there is maybe a little bit of an argument to be said that three players might be just as good as a two-player game as long as you're okay with it going a bit longer but yeah it's good at all the counts in conclusion I've played Great Western trail four times and I'm not sure if I'll be getting a fifth play in I've been alternately pretty disappointed by it and it really does all come down to that negative point number one where you have these really cool-looking buildings with all these really great different abilities on them and it's so difficult to get them out onto the board to have those options available to you if you want to get to those mid-range or even higher level buildings you're probably gonna have to replace a building you're already high on the board which means you're not increasing your decision about you were just taking away one option and replacing it with another so
you can ever even get to that old one anymore and I just feel like this game for me needed to have abilities to get these buildings out on the board more naturally like almost have it happen every time you go to Kansas City you just put a building out on the board and whichever one that you put out is dictated by the number of craftsmen you have in front of you or just something to keep those things getting out there so it's not something you have to actively chase because I like deck building and I really enjoy the engineers where you're moving the Train along I really want to get these buildings out and it does not appear you could do all three of those things while you are playing the game and I feel like if you're trying to get those buildings out you are neglecting probably deck building which is one of the more interesting aspects to the game and I think that this game does pull off deck building in the heavy game setting really well like that's not something you usually see and it comes down to the card raw luck ways that you can mitigate it I mean that was a neutral point because there can be some rather surprising swings of potential points based on how you draw those cards from your deck but there are many ways that you can draw new cards and modify your hand then I think it does pull off the heavy euro deck building thing well it's just it does not have enough interesting decision density as you are continuing to play the board because the setting just does not change enough because your opponent's buildings just hinder you they don't actually make things more interesting at all and again it's just so hard to get the cool buildings out on the map so that you can actually get them I think I'm repeating that a little bit too much but really I'm very disappointed I wanted to love this game because in general I like Alexander Fischer's games and I like deck building
and just the idea of populating the board seems so fascinating to me that this is why I am disappointed because the thing I was most interested in ended up being the thing that fell down for me so ultimately I don't think I can recommend the game and many people seem to really enjoy it and I'm glad that they do but for me this has not worked out well at this point I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting John gets games through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you can do so at patreon.com slash John gets games also if you like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching