Barrage Review: A Triumph of Board Game Design - By Board Of It
Transcript
hello everyone tallyanne farrell here from board of it and today we're going to be talking about one of the most brutal unforgiving ruthless interactive board game experiences around barrage now fun fact before anybody comments the word barrage is pronounced differently in american and british english and i can attest to that because i speak both yeah unfortunately the word barrage is originally a french word meaning damn and the french pronounce it barrage is set in a dystopic past where by 1930s we'd already rinsed through our supply of fossil fuels so hydro electricity is where the money's at you'll play as an international company trying to build a series of hydroelectricity producing systems in the alps and getting down to the nitty-gritty this is a game where you're going to be managing resources building dams and producing hydro electricity but at its core it's a pretty standard work placement game uh in that each of your turns you'll be putting another variable number of workers onto a work placement space and then taking the action shown in that space i'm just going to say up front this is one of my favorite games of all time and we're also going to be talking about the expansion the lake water project just because it has a few cool modules and we pretty much don't play without it and i've also just
realized when setting them up for this shot it really irritates me for some reason how the titles up here on this box and the titles down here on this box so you'll start with an asymmetric player map some engineers or workers a personal assistant with a special ability and some building materials on your turn you'll take one action either on your player mat or on the main board by paying any required costs and placing the required number of engineers on that space the main aim is to produce energy because producing energy will get you vps and money to produce energy you'll need a few things you'll need a dam either in your player color or a neutral dam you'll need a conduit which can be anyone's color but if you use someone else's you'll have to pay them for it and you'll need a powerhouse which does have to be in your color finally you'll require water when you have all this you'll put some engineers on the work placement space that allows you to produce energy then you'll take as many water droplets as you want or can use and they go through your conduit down the pipe into the powerhouse and they flow
downstream or off the board and to produce your energy you will then look at the number printed on the conduit and multiply it by how many droplets you use so say the conduit is three you move two droplets then you produce six energy and you'll move yourself up on the energy tracker at the end of each round water in the head streams up here flows downwards and follows the river until it reaches a dam a dam can hold one water droplet and for each elevation on top allows an extra droplet to be held to build some of these structures you require you'll go to your player board to build you'll take the tactile of whatever you want to build and put it in the will along with any resource costs then turn the wheel any tactiles and resources spent are then unavailable until the wheel turns all the way back around which you'll have to do manually by further building or using one of the spaces on the main board that lets you turn the wheel so the game will last for five rounds and at the end of each round you're going to be scoring for the energy you've produced and these end of round goals there's also a game end goal and these are always brutally confusing and will cause a lot of debates and arguments as you have to refer to the rule book to see who's writing who's wrong and who's got the vp
but while we're on the topic of these end of round goals we'd just like to mention some of our thoughts because we do kind of wish that basically maybe they were tiered in some way so that certain ones would come out earlier in the game and other ones would come out later in the game just because some of them seem a bit silly if they come on the first or second round like i don't know the the external buildings from the expansion or completed contracts because in the first round it's very unlikely you'll have more than one completed contract or that you'll have any of these external buildings or advanced textiles or whatever so i think it would just be maybe a little more fun if this was structured a bit better because sometimes they're just worthless depending when they come out barrage is not for the faint of heart resources are tight you can build four types of building and there are only two types of resource thus if you build a dam you're gonna struggle to build a conduit as well of a decent value because they both use the same excavator resource want to get them back well that's going to cost you all of your money to spin your construction will three times however what amazes us is that barrage never feels unfair you might struggle and grumble and scrape resources together in any which way you can but you'll look back in round five having produced 30 energy and wonder how you put together such a terrific system very true and speaking of magnificent design
raj joins the cost of doing business with strategic value excellently you see there's three different elevations on the map you've got your mountains your hills and your planes and the higher up you build the more it costs to do so but say you build in the mountains yep it's prohibitively expensive but you do get first crack at any water that flows downstream or you could build in the plains it's much cheaper and you probably get a good system out quicker but if just one player builds upstream from you they can divert any water that would come your way rendering all your efforts moot it's a really wonderful dilemma to be presented with it is one of the most brutal and interactive games out there say you've just finished building a system and you're ready to produce jokes on you you're not going to someone just built a dam right in front of you now all the water goes there first and you just get their overflow say you've built a system somewhere else and you're all ready to produce you're just waiting for the flow to come from the head streams down suddenly no water's going to you what's happening someone's built ahead of you and they're diverting water into another river those bastards and you know there's so many unique interactions to be had in barrage both positive and negative and what happens is all in the palm of you and your friends hands and what is great is that all this comes from one simple idea that water is what everyone
wants water is shed and water is hard to get the worker placement is also diabolically tight often the actions will have two spaces but the one on the right hand side has an additional additional monetary cost which maybe is alright but unless the action itself also has a monetary cost which many of them do so not only do you have to worry about what's going on over here you also have to worry about what actions you do and when because if farrell takes an action before me then i won't be able to afford it essentially every decision you make in barrage is crucial and this brings us on to something that will likely put a lot of people off barrage you see if you make a mistake there's no type of catch-up mechanic it'll definitely cost you and you'll likely lose you have to be on point the entire time you play this game just as a recent example i accidentally early on bought an advanced textile and i spent all of my money on it it turns out that advanced tactile didn't do what i thought it did so i couldn't do that plan i was left with no money to pay for any actions i wanted to do alternate actions and i think it's fair to say it cost me the game because i spent an entire round doing nothing this game is not short and it can be quite stressful at times so if you make a bad decision early on it can really make for a miserable experience
also this game is quite heavy we'd definitely recommend it to experienced board gamers and definitely consider everything we just said when considering this game and if it's piqued your interest so to summarize this section we're going to talk about why we love it each action is meaningful yet any action any other player does is probably going to be bad for you it's almost zero masochistic in the way that you interact with other players there's also no luck here and even though the game is set up pretty much the same each time each game plays wildly differently when you combine the actions of all the players with the predictable yet ever-changing droplets of water as they flow downstream each game you play is going to give you new opportunities challenges and predicaments to face you'll be kept on your toes the entire game and the unique options that your faction and personal assistant provide allow novel strategies to present themselves so the expansion for barrage the leewater project adds a new faction new assistance a new type of building and a new type of contract now the faction and assistance are fine nothing to complain about there it's just more barrage but we do think that the new buildings are a bit of a miss if you construct one it gives you access to a special action that only players who have a building of that type can take and also end game vps now whilst that special action is pretty
powerful the amount that it costs to build the building is pretty high so then it means that you can't build dams and powerhouses which is the main focus of the game and the system that's going to get you the most victory points and money now the new contracts termed external works are brilliant here you trade building resources in exchange for whatever's on the contract the twist is that you lose these building resources permanently they don't go in your wheel and this is great because first of all the contracts are well balanced and they're interesting with what they provide secondly it creates these faustian deals where you're basically selling off your ability to build in the future or provide for yourself in the future for things that you need immediately of things that you want at that exact moment it's a devilish dilemma and these external works contracts are actually one of my favorite aspects of barrage and this brings us indirectly to the play count because these buildings we're talking about they get ignored also other aspects are ignored in a three or four player game such as the advanced take tiles for the simple reason there's no time and no spare resources to waste on these actions in the 304 player game the map is so overcrowded and everyone is so desperate for the right action or water that all of your effort is spent on creating an energy producing system there just isn't time to explore the expansion buildings or the textiles and turn them
into a game-winning strategy take the tactiles for example in a three or four player game all of your money is going to be spent on actions because there's more players taking the actions you desperately need often they don't even get a second look and at two players it still is brutal but there's definitely less tightness in the fight for the work placement spaces and on the map this means you're able to explore these other things a little more but they haven't convinced us that they're worth the hassle but the good thing is because they're optional they don't negatively affect the game if someone gets them they're not overpowered or anything it's a strategy they have to work with so use them don't use them it doesn't negatively affect the game and barrage is still great on the topic of things that get passed over in barranched this unfortunately also includes the faction abilities to unlock them you have to build your third powerhouse which is totally arbitrary and a little bit confusing when you first play the game i have no idea why you would even bother having different factions if the only difference is a power that you might get to use once or twice if you do one very specific thing in addition you also get these personal assistants and often their powers are on par so i don't know why you couldn't have just also had the faction power unlocked at the beginning of the game personally we think it would be a lot more fun if you had the powers unlocked at the beginning of the game or if maybe it was just linked to getting your third building out of any type so just as a last note the components
are all pretty cool each faction has personalized wooden buildings which is a nice touch and the building resources are quite unique we also love the art direction on the board and on the box and the board is double sided with a beautiful advanced side which is free of labeling for when you're more familiar with the game it is worth noting though that there was some controversy around the kickstarter we believe many people received their copies with broken or missing components and the whole thing was handled quite poorly it is a shame because it detracted from what is otherwise an amazing game and maybe the reason why barrage generally flies under the radar we bought the retail version so can't comment on the kickstarter but one of our wooden buildings did arrive broken in summary we believe barrage to be one of the greatest games come out of the last few years claims supported by its slow but sure movement up board game geek's top 100.
if you're looking for a game that is unique strategic thematic with minimal elements of luck let me introduce you to my old power barrage it also has my favorite box artwork of all time we believe that the expansion is also something to invest in as the external contracts really open up the game if you're not afraid of a big heavy board game i don't know why you're still watching this review to be honest just go and buy a barrage already go buy it go buy it are you missing out go get it if you enjoyed this review we would really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up and please subscribe to our channel if you haven't already for regular board game reviews always with a little hint of doggo and thanks for watching we really appreciate it bye