Skyrise - Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about skyrise and our copy was provided for review but the thoughts in this video are all our own and I also want to mention that roxley is set in my hometown of Calgary Alberta Canada but I've never met any of them so all I did was inspire me to wear this jersey skyrise is a two to four player game designed by Adam wise Gavin Brown and Sebastian POA and it is a reimplementation of the 2008 game Metropolis it's an auction game about building a city in the sky let's look at how it plays you start skyrise with a handful of buildings a player board a secret objective a few Wonder cards and a few floating islands waiting to be built on on your turn you place any one of your available buildings on one of the islands either in the middle or next to another building and then in turn order other players can outbid you by playing a building worth more than yours in an adjacent space and this will continue until all but one player passes the winner gets to erect their building and then start a new bid and repeat the process there are a few things to keep in mind when bidding and building the first is your secret goal which will need four buildings in one kind of neighborhood also the shared goals which want players to build in specific places
or patterns the island control goal which gives points to players with the highest building on each island and tokens which can change neighborhood values and provide endgame points after one round players score Island control and Panorama objectives and then get access to their second junk of buildings and their wonder which is like a super building with the special power chosen from one of your Wonder cards and after the second round players add up points from the key to the city for finishing first island control Panorama objectives secret objectives structures in various types of neighborhoods and the tokens that they have collected and then the greatest architect is named so this really combines bidding as well as like an abstract strategy game cuz every time you are placing out one of your pieces there are a lot of different things you're considering you've got to consider if you end up winning that do you actually want your piece to be on that color or if you win it is that the token that you want but also usually especially if you're starting with like a small number you're assuming that you're going to be out bid so you're really trying to think ahead of where you might want it to end up if it ends up like increasing and increasing and bidding yeah yeah there's definitely a few things to to think about but I think that's kind of one of the most interesting things is when someone out bids you they have to go adjacent to
where you are and then you go adjacent so you're always thinking okay if I go then they go then they go then they go then I go then I'm going to like kind of close them off into a corner because what you want to do is end up so that no one can go next to you then no one can outbid you and I think that part is really interesting that's kind of where the abstract strategy is thing this is also kind of an area controlly game it's a little bit hard to describe the auction that's definitely an auction game and then the and then it's got that like bits of all this other stuff in there too but yeah I really do like that how it combines the auction with that when you're thinking about where you're actually placing that building and so often too you win and you really didn't want to win yeah and that can be tricky too because you only get so many I think it's like 12 buildings that you're putting out in total yeah something like that maybe a couple more so not too many buildings and so each Place really does matter and you might really want to make sure you end up on a certain color to make sure you get your personal goal or you might be really gunning for a certain color of neighborhood tokens so that might be really crucial and especially early on it can be difficult to choose to spend one of your tall buildings because you might really really want that spot now but once that's spent then that means that the other people can outbid you and that might be an issue later yeah I've definitely gotten that problem before where I've outbid a few times and then all of a sudden my buildings are like in the 20s and 30s and everyone else has got these big ones and I I just can't I
I just have to watch them run through their buildings and then Place mine right at the end and so that is definitely tricky also with those scoring um tokens because as you add those to your rows that is changing how much you're going to score for each building in that color at the end but it goes up to six then it drops back down to four so unless you're going to get a ton of those cuz every extra one you get is going to be worth 10 points so from your fifth token onwards there are each going to be 10 points which is really a viable strategy but if you go six and then you drop down to four and you've got a bunch of those that can kill you so if you can like almost trick somebody into taking an extra one of those tokens and that's definitely happened that that can really really sync you and you really want to be paying attention to which color you have of those tokens as well because I've ended up in situations where I've gotten one of the neighborhoods up to a value six and then I look and I realize I actually don't have any of my buildings on that color at all I'm like oh what a waste yeah so I do appreciate that that this is very rules like like the rules you need to know is just bid a taller building put it next to the other building but within that there there is you know a fairly decent chunk of strategy it's still this is still like a pretty quick game and it's a lightish game but it's interesting because it's like like like I say it's it's rules light but strategy kind of a more medium weight game and it looks really nice so let's move on to
components so in terms of components we have got the retail Edition and there is another fancier Edition and that one we don't have it so we can't show you it but if you want to look it up online what you're going to find is it's got a bunch of different sculpts of these big plastic buildings they're really pretty and it's got these plastic things that the islands sit on top of so they kind of look like they're floating and it's got double layer player boards there may be some other stuff but that was kind of the key things that I noticed this one has these like chunky wooden buildings and I kind I kind of like the chunky wooden buildings yeah I think the chunky wooden buildings work really well and the numbers are nice and clear because that's one of the key components and what's interesting is we haven't played the old game but for this version all of the numbers are unique so depending on which color you're getting you're going to have completely different numbers so you actually might have like the strongest medium height building or like the strongest lower height building and so I think that plays a little bit into the strategy too of like oh do I think they're going to increase the level of the building and I think the numbers are nice and clear which is really important because you really need to be able to see at a glance what numbers everybody else has left yeah and I think in general most of the stuff is nice it's got this nice big board that shows like a sky so it looks like your islands are floating there are a few small oh and I I really like before I get to the tricky I really like the uh the player board have eight different um like famous Architects on them and I like that or famous Architects are people I guess within that world one of them is is
Fritz long who made a metropolis which is a movie that I've always really liked so so I appreciated that as well um I will say though that some of the artwork because some of the special goals are like how many blimps are or like where are you connected to blimps or where are you connected to windmills and stuff and that stuff does get lost both because it gets lost in all the art on the board and it gets a bit lost under your buildings where you have to kind of place a little bit mindfully so that you don't cover up that important bit of art yeah and when you're going to score you really have to take like a bird's eye view or else you might easily miss that but that that said I do think the neighborhoods are definitely nice and clear I think the colors are quite distinctive they are meant to represent like different types of Industries like one of them is Artistic one of them is commercial I don't quite get that Vibe but I do think it's better that functionally like the colors are distinct yeah that that is true and I like that one of the colors is brown brown is not used enough uh another tricky is sometimes the borders we found like a little squidgy generally we can tell and I think once we've kind of figured it out we can tell but there are certainly times when someone plays and we're like oh is that adjacent is that diagonal uh these are all small things I feel like we've had a lot of complaints this really doesn't warrant a lot of complaints this is quite a pretty game and I do think the retail is plenty like I don't know that I would really want the big box that I would need need to put those chunky plastic buildings in I guess if you really need that stuff but I really think that the the wooden and
everything that we got in this box is plenty for me I'm not wishing that I had the the bigger box yeah definitely I think the retail looks really nice moving on to replayability there are a few different things and so one of them are the Panorama cards which are your goal cards there you'll only ever use two goal cards in addition to like the one that's regularly used and that can make quite a big difference for where you're choosing to place your pieces you also always have a personal goal card but the personal goal card is always tied to having four structures within a colored neighborhood and and that that is it yeah and I I do wish that there are other kinds of personal goals cuz once I realized that I was like oh okay like it's just I just want this color and I get that like kind of mechanically that makes sense cuz everyone's on an even playing field but I really would not mind even if that felt a little off-kilter I wouldn't mind having a few more of those um and those those ones that you put out for the what are they called Panorama cards for the overall those generally tied to the board or to the the placement of your it's kind of the stuff that you would expect there is I think a decent range of those also all of the tiles for the city are all you know a little bit different that definitely does make a difference some of them are kind of like have a one of them has like an island in the middle of a lake and uh so they they do have some like different features that do change things up a little bit Yeah and how they connect as well so it is nice that the for boards are disconnected so how they lay out and
connect will be different too and the Wonders make a difference as well so you don't use your wonders till the second half of the game but you get dealt three cards for like a special power that they get it's what they score when you get to put them out and they can score like up to 12 points and so that can make a big difference too at two players you get dealt five cards and you get to choose two of them for two different wonders so they make even more of a difference at two players as well yeah I do like that because like I that's one of the things I like in the two-player game we'll come back to that in a sec but I do like that I've got two of those because those special powers all feel you know they all feel really nice and those wonders always win when you put them down I think there's one that beats all the rest and they do have some unique stuff like there's there's one that counts as another building there's one that you can just play at the start of bidding but yeah those those are cool and I also like that which one you choose decides the player order for the second round as well because if you choose a more powerful one it means that you're going to start later in the round so it's a little bit of a trade-off yeah and other than that I think just because it is an abstract strategy puzzle game there is a lot of replayability in that because how you are placing your buildings and how the other people are placing theirs as well it's just a constantly like changing puzzle yeah I think this is definitely one of those sorts of games where you're kind of figuring out the strategy so you want to play a few games to even figure that out and then once you've got that you've got that head to-head with the other players who are
all trying to outsmart each other and I I do enjoy that so let's talk about the player count so we did just mention about the Wonders that in two players you get more of those than you do in four players the other big well the obvious biggest thing is you got more people to bid against and let let's just cut to the chase I do think that this is a better four player game I do think it also works well at three players but I'd say at two players it works but if you were only going to play it at two players I don't think it's quite just a like a two-player game yeah the tricky and we have played a bunch of two-player games and I do like it at two but I I agree you would want to get this if you know you're going to play it at least sometimes at three or four but then you know you've got it a two and you can definitely play that and it does feel you know it's that little bit of a chess match where you're trying to get each other in a corner and it it it does work but the nice thing at two players is it is just that back and forth and you can kind of mess with the other person and like CU you can see exactly what they have so you can plan a little bit better of making them put out those big buildings and then taking advantage of that and then beating all of their little buildings and that race for the um for the key at the end for that 10-point key is is really interesting too at four players you've got a 10 and a four point for who finishes second but if four players it really is that that feels like what it's kind of meant to be where each person's bidding against and you've got a lot more variables and you're using a lot more map and that the strategy for
controlling the different islands all of that stuff just just gets more interesting yeah it definitely does and I would say too that like at two players you're more likely to end up in a situation where at the end of the game one person has like three or four buildings to place and the other person has none meaning they get reign of where they want to place those buildings so that does make up for somebody getting like the 10-point key maybe but I think it is more interesting when you have three or four when usually there might be somebody that has like maybe two buildings at the end and not necessarily like a bunch to put out left at the end and it could even maybe it could even be a strategy to almost Force the other person to take that 10-point key and then just have free reign and just put the rest of yours just really cherry-pick everything that you want to take to like get the perfect system I I don't know I haven't tried that now I wonder about that so there are going to be slightly different strategies with the different player counts so that brings us to final thoughts who do we think this game is for and this is very much still I think a light game I think it is a game that you can teach to players who you know aren't super deep into the hobby I think it is really accessible because it does fall in the the rules light category but there is enough strategy there but I think it would be taret targeted towards people who first of all like auction games and like abstract strategy games because if you don't like either of those I think they're equally as entrenched yeah I think so and it it's interesting because it doesn't call
itself an abstract strategy game and you could argue that it is more area control than that but it definitely has that kind of feel it's got that kind of outthinking the other person in that way that you would expect from you know from a chess or a hive or something else like that this also does remind me of another game that came this year Tower up and Tower up is the I feel like the much lighter version I enjoy both games but this is the slightly heavier auction version so if you like Tower up but you want it just a little bit more this might be worth a look for you as well and it looks really classy so I think that classic look might bring people in as well and it could be something that people see on the table it's like oo what is that game yeah I I I really like the theme to this I really like those different Architects even if they don't play different I just like them I like looking at them I love the colors of the different buildings I think it's quite a clever game but it is quite a like quite a quick quite a simple game it just has that strategy built into the playing against your opponent and it does tend to work better we think for three or four players compared to two players and that is it that is skyrise from Calgary based Rox League gam so are there other Calgary based games that you might recommend or more likely are there other auction or building City games that you might recommend thank you so much for watching as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game