Vantage - Game of the Month July '25
Transcript
Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games. This is my game of the month video where I talk about the most interesting game that I played in July of 2025, and that was Vantage. Now, what you're going to see here is normally a Patreon exclusive segment, but for the most interesting games that I play, they go up on the main channel. Now, I talk about every single new game that I play in Patreon exclusive episodes, and you can learn more about that by going to gettingames.com/support. I also want to ask that if you enjoy this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button for the channel. And if you have thoughts about Vantage, please leave those as a comment down below. All right, let's talk about the game. So, Vantage, this is a big new game from Stonem Games, uh designed by Jamie Stegmire. It's my understanding it took like eight years to design and it's a lot. Uh if you're looking at the image over here, uh the first thing that you experience when you get Vantage, uh I guess I should preface this. I got a press copy, so I got it relatively early. And when it arrived, I was amazed at how heavy this box was because it is solid cardboard. This game has over 1,700 cards. And I say over because it goes up to 178 over here, but then there's a spoiler pack with extra cards, and I did not count them. Although, you may notice that the spoiler pack is open. Uh, speaking of that, I'm not going to be spoiling things here today beyond a tiny amount. like you're going to see u a couple of item cards out of 1,700 cards and you're going to see one location card. I think there's like 800 or so
locations. So, you'll see one of them. Um it's not even the flashiest one. It just happens to be the one when I took a photo. Um there is a pack right here that says spoiler. You rip the thing off when you're told to. I'm not going to talk about what is inside this, although I might briefly allude to the experience of opening up a spoiler pack and the very first time we played, but it's a lot. Um, as you can see, there's a book of vantages. Uh, there's a book of secrets, and then there are seven of these story books. So, let's talk about the mechanics of this before I discuss the one play. I've only played it one time. It was just a few days ago. We can begin by looking at the player area. So, this is the tiny spoiler thing going on. The main um thing that stands out about this game is the name and the mechanic of Vantages. So, you have this little standandy that you put in front of you and the idea is everybody's crash landed on a planet. It's a fully cooperative experience and you see things like you are standing on the planet and the vantage card is literally what you see.
You're standing there looking at this and everybody else is around the table with their own little standy and their own card and you can't see their cards because you're not standing with them. Like I'm over here, you're over there, you see something, I see something else. And you know, we crash landed on a planet. We have got spaceships. So we also have the ability to talk to each other. You know, it doesn't explicitly say this, but it's heavily implied that you are on radios discussing things. And so, no one else is allowed to see my vantage because they're obviously not inside my head. But I can describe everything that I see. So, in this vantage right here, I see a little chest, like a stone chest in the middle of a clearing. Um, I think there's a little bit of water off to the side. There's a mountain. There's some trees. I can say all these things. There's also some descriptive text at the bottom, which I'm allowed to read. I can say anything I want about this card except show it. and my opponents are going to do the same thing. Now, I am uh this person right over here in this play. I was Saurin the Navigator and you're going to have a little grid in front of you as you play the game. You start out with just your one card and as you start to explore and do stuff in this world, you're going to get new cards like spells and equipment. In this case, I have a glider and a techno technommancy is a spell that I got. This is pretty much all the spoilers that you're going to be getting in this video is these four cards right over here. So, what you do in this game is on your turn, you do a single action and then the next person goes and you just keep going around and around the table. You've got a surprising amount of things that you can do for that one action. Uh, the first thing to point out are location actions.
There are six different types of um actions that essentially happen. And in fact, they're kind of listed here on the side of the box. Uh, these pertain to some like standard ideas like the blue one is move and the red one is overpower. But if you're looking at uh this one right here, blue says push. So you have more contextual thematic names for the generic actions that you're doing, which I really like. I I like that, you know, it doesn't just say move, overpower, take, um all the other ones that I can't remember off the top of my head right now. It says very specific things like pick makes sense because you're trying to pick a lock. Dismantle makes sense. You're trying to like rip this box open. You have all these different things that make thematic sense. So that's super cool. But mechanically, they have their own kind of backbone. Now, when you do an action, you state what you're doing.
Like, I'm going to examine at location 471. And this is where these books come back into play. Uh, so for examining, that is a purple action. So, somebody else is going to take this purple book. There are seven of these books. The purple one relates always to the purple action. And they're going to read a skill level and then a brief blurb about what's going to be happening. And then after you pass the skill check, you get to do the thing. And this is a surprising thing about the game that really sets it apart from lots of other games in this genre like Seventh Continent is that you always succeed. The question is what does it cost you? So the way skill checks work is you have dice and you are going to roll dice equal to the number of the skill check. For example, maybe I'm not sure but maybe the uh examine has a skill check of four. That means I have to roll four of these dice and you can see a whole bunch of them here on the the central playing area. And I can mitigate that by spending skill tokens. Um, if it's purple, then I can spend one skill token to roll one less dice. You could spend one skill token for me to roll one less dice even though you're somewhere else on the planet. Again, I think you're talking on the radio saying things like, you know, oh, do this or do that with the the lockpicking. Thematically, it means you just roll less dice. Then you're going to roll the dice. And again, you always succeed, but these dice are going to do things like lower your morale if you roll stars that can't be mitigated or your time, like just the time that you have available. I don't know if it's oxygen or whatnot, but you have time that you lose. Uh, as well as health. I guess you could just get um
hurt. And I I say that you suffer these effects when it's not mitigated. And by that, I have to talk about these little squares on the player cards. This is where you put dice down so that you don't suffer their effects. like over here uh on my player card, it has a little hourglass. That means I could put an hourglass die there and then I don't lose one hourglass time effect. Uh it also has a lightning bolt, which means somebody else could use one of their dice that they roll on their turn to put down here and not suffer that effect. So essentially every effect that's not mitigated by spending skill tokens to not roll dice or by putting these already rolled dice onto cards, that's when you go down these tracks. And this is important because once anybody reaches zero with any of their tokens, you read a little blurb based off of your mission that you're on and whatnot and then the the run might be over. Like you might just lose essentially. Well, sorry. You might just stop. Let's talk about why we're doing things in this game. And you might have noticed at the very beginning I said experience. This is a game. I'm not going to wade into the whole um is it a game or not uh thing, but I will say that it's unusual in that you don't really win or lose.
You just do stuff. You know, the idea is that you crash land on this planet. If you actually crash landed on a planet, I mean, I guess you lose if you die. I'm not sure if you can die in this game or not. There is a health token, so maybe that's possible. But you just do stuff like you're like maybe trying to get off the planet or maybe you're trying to learn things about the locals. Maybe you were coming here to research it anyway and now you're on the planet. You're like, "Cool, this is my idea." And the rule book actually explicitly states that you can end whenever you want to. And this is interesting. So, I'm going to start talking about the play that we did. Uh, this game plays up to six players and I was at this convention and four of my friends really wanted to try it. So, we played a fiveplayer game for the first play and I knew this was probably going to make it a little bit longer, but you know, that's fine. Like, let's just go for it was the idea. So, I taught the game relatively quickly. I mean, honestly, I I accidentally taught you 80% of the rules right there.
There's a lot of little rules as well, but you should understand the the high level. I guess I didn't talk about moving, but you know, when you look back at the card uh for an action, instead of doing these things, you can like move to location 100. You swap out the vantage, you put a new card in, you see something new, you tell your friends, that kind of a thing. So, uh I won't beat around the bush. It was a three-hour game and we all had a really good time. Uh this is a convention. Like, there's lots of games to play. There's five of us. It was a little bit loud. Uh, you may notice my voice is slightly froggy and that's because this is a few days ago and we had to like do a lot of discussing and talking about things as we were playing the game. And I remember when we were approaching the 2-hour uh mark, I I mentioned that to everybody. I was like, listen, the rule book says we can stop whenever we want to. We don't have to hit one of our um ending like positive conditions um if we want to like move on and play something else. And there was a resounding no, I am not done. I want to keep doing stuff. So, it's like okay, cool. Let's just keep going. So, we kept we kept playing until we hit an endgame condition. Uh, speaking of those conditions, at the beginning of each uh play, you're going to randomly get a mission card. For us, we were liberating our home world. I guess this is one more tiny little spoiler card. There's a lot of missions. Um, and if you complete the requirement on this card, then you read a thing and you have the choice of stopping. You also get destiny cards. We don't see any here, but by the end of our play, we had like four of them, which seemed like a lot. Just by doing things, it's like, oh, you did this thing and that thing, put a destiny card
down, which relates to the thing that you just did, like maybe keep doing it or maybe find more things that are like that. And it uh very explicitly tells you if you complete a destiny and you like resolve it, then that's going to end the game as well. But you don't have to resolve it. You can wait to then finish your mission. You could also not finish your mission and continue going until you finish your destiny if you want. So you could kind of keep going until you satisfy one of these. You could satisfy multiple destinies. This is a long way of saying you get to decide when you're done. Even if you hit a threshold to end the game, you can keep going because you're just here. You're just experiencing this world. You're just doing stuff. So that is a really important thing to know about this game, about the experience that it's giving you. Um is there tension about oh my gosh, we're about to lose. Well, you know, if one of these tokens is getting close to the bottom, perhaps because maybe you don't want to stop because maybe you're halfway through a quest line or you have a specific thing that you're trying to make happen. Um, so then, you know, you maybe try to make that not happen. I will say I didn't really feel any tension in this game, which isn't that surprising considering it doesn't have a win or loss condition, but playing with five players means that there are a ton of cards that can absorb dice. We all start with one card, but by the end of by even the middle of the game, we all had like two or three of these cards that could take a bunch of them. And the die pool does get bigger with the player count, it's two extra dice per player. It just seemed like the scaling of extra players didn't necessarily match that. Like all of us had way more than two more slots on our cards by the midame. So, we didn't really worry about this track. I think
the lowest anybody got was here at three over the course of the entire three-hour game. So, we were just focusing on doing our stuff. We were chucking dice like crazy and we were able to mitigate things. I remember uh I actually ended the game. Uh I kind of pushed the end of the game. One of the destinies was very much like, okay, I'm in a situation to press this button like five times and then the game will end. I'm trying not to spoil things here, but um I knew that was the case and so I just started pressing it cuz I wanted to move on and play something else. We've been playing for like two and a half hours at that point. I was enjoying myself, but I'm at a board game convention. I want to play more things. and everybody else seemed like they would have been happy to play like five hours, which is fine. So, I kind of spoiled their fun by pushing one of the destinies as an endgame condition. And the last thing that I had to do was a nine skill check. So, I had to roll nine of these dice. And it was still fine. The like all the different things, they just absorbed them. So, I was a little bit disappointed, slightly disappointed at the lack of tension here of wanting, you know, I want the game to go on. I don't want to hit zero. I'm about to, you know, lose all my health.
And I think a big part of that again has to do with the player count. I'm not going to sit here and say don't play five players. It's bad. We had a really lovely time. But of course, you have to wait through four other people's turns where they're reading stuff, they're doing stuff. Turns are in general snappy until they are not snappy. Uh I'm not saying there's analysis paralysis. I'm saying this game has some stuff in it that I was not expecting. I'm not going to spoil things, but there was one moment in particular, well two moments in particular that again I won't go into details where it was like we're doing what now and suddenly one person's turn takes like 20 minutes because of stuff that is happening. Uh you know once again we have opened the spoiler pack and stuff and that was really cool. Honestly, I had no idea the scope of things that were inside Vantage. And that's again as spoilery as I'm going to get, but it was a very cool moment when we saw a couple of these different things that happened.
And I think a big reason why people didn't necessarily want to end when I kind of pushed the end is because they had their own goals. And I was really surprised at the narrative some people were able to piece together. And I think it must be just good game design that the locations you can move to can kind of orient things together. Okay, I'm going to do a slight spoiler about something different. uh very high level. I'm gonna say that one of my friends uh was going along and found this sentient being and he ended up like talking to the sentient being and the sentient being taught him how to dance. And then later on he had the ability to use his dancing prowess in a competitive situation in the game. And that was just really cool to see him work towards that. He actually practiced his dance before he did the thing. He saw the thing coming and he's like, I got to work on my dance moves. That is so cool and not at all what I would have expected. And again, this is just a tiny little anecdote compared to some of the other things that we saw in the game.
And it makes me super curious about what else is inside this box. I mean, obviously over 1,700 cards, that is a incredible amount of stuff. And I really liked the little journey that I went on, which I'm not going to spoil. Um, it definitely there was a kind of a a thing that I decided I wanted to do. there's another uh player at the around the table who just straight up got a quest. It was like a card put down in front of himself and it's like do this thing and so he was working on that quest and he did not finish it before I ended the game and I think he kind of wanted to but you know I it was three hours I think it was ready to kind of push it towards the end and that was the first experience that I have with Vantage. I mean honestly the biggest disappointment that I had with the game uh disappointment the biggest negative let's talk about two things. The first thing, no real tension with the dice rolling. On the last turn of the game, like I said, I rolled nine dice and I didn't really even care. The second thing is putting this game away.
There's so many cards. Like, as the game is going on and you're moving locations, you slot new cards in. But at the end of the game, I had a deck of cards like that thick, all with different numbers on them, uh, from the grid, from like the items that we found and the spells and the potions and the, you know, quests and all this stuff that need to get sorted back into these decks. And I probably should have crowdsourced it, like given one stack to each player, but I didn't. We're at a convention. I just kind of threw them into the box and I was like, I'll deal with that later. And now I have to deal with it. So, not a very big deal. So, that's Vantage. That's a super highle take on uh you know, that's that is my Vantage experience uh with five players. We all agreed that we had a great time. Again, people did not want to end, but we also all agreed that three players is probably a significantly better player count than five players. And I bet it plays two players really well as well.
So Rishi says, um, what does it feel like timing between the players? I feel like unless I'm very invested in everything, timeout between players could be quite long. I talked about that a little bit, but I think I will talk to the investment element. We were playing at a board game convention, so it wasn't the easiest thing to to hear, but like I said, I was kind of vested in the dance competition that was happening. I was vested in uh a couple other spoilery things that didn't happen. Um, there was one moment where somebody did a thing and then a couple of rounds later I had the chance to undo we're pretty sure the thing that somebody else did and I was like I'm not going to do it. She was like, "Don't you dare." And I was like, "I won't. I promise I I'll I'll go a there was investment there." And like I said, most of the turns were snappy until suddenly they weren't. Rishi says, "My opinion is short. I think it's a clever design. I would compare it to lands of Galsier. it would work for so many people who want more exploration with light rules but a good amount of uh secrets. Uh also the free flow of the game would really uh work with many but for me I think at the moment I am at with my board gaming motivation I would get over the game quite fast. That makes sense. I mean again it's it's a kind of an odd experience uh going into it. I knew a bit about the game when I requested the press copy. I did not realize for a game that has mechanical stuff, you know, uh going back to uh this grid area, you could see that you're getting items, you're getting new actions and stuff that you can do. It's got decent mechanics, solid mechanics
that I really like. I was surprised how um free flowing and loose the actual end of the game was. I was expecting something maybe a little bit more concrete, and that's that is not really a problem. Like I'm not saying that's a flaw with the game or anything. Um, if if anything was to come close to an issue that I have with the design, it was just the lack of tension at five. It just seems like we should have had more dice in the pool to feel that overall tension. When it comes to the stuff that you can do and again how free flowing this game is, it's astonishing the number of options. Like I I brief I talked about the fact that every location has six different actions. You can only do one of these, then you have to move on to somewhere else. But the player cards have three different actions on them as well. Most of the items that you get have actions on them that you could spend your whole turn on. The missions have actions. The destinies have actions. So many things have actions. So you have like a dozen or two action options depending on where you're at in the game and how much stuff you've been able to acquire.
And you only get one turn. So I think again if it was three players, I'd feel a little bit more invested in trying some of the odder things that I could do. Uh because, you know, it's going to be my turn again relatively quick. But um in this case, I kind of stayed on the main story lines. Uh one person did the uh did one of the player card actions. Nobody else did any. There's a buy action. Nobody did it. I'm curious what it does. There's an equip action behind this boost cube. Nobody did it. I'm really curious to see what that is. Uh Rishi says, "I'm sure I would want to try and play a bit. I do not think I'd want to play until I see it all." No, you do not want to play until you see it all. I think you're going to be over the game long before you see even half of these cards over 700 locations is ridiculous, honestly. And every single thing has its own unique piece of art.
Like from a component quality perspective, this game is astonishing uh that it even got made. Like it honestly truly incredible. And then you have all these booklets with all these things. The book of secrets, which we barely touched on. Uh the book of Vantages never even got opened in this game. I did have the opportunity to, but I was kind of steamrolling towards the endgame condition at that point, and I decided to just kind of keep moving towards that. So, I'm still curious what the book advantages is, but I'm I I have my own uh suspicions about that. To wrap this up, I will say I am looking forward to playing this again, but I doubt I'll play it with more than three players. And it's very possible this game might make the rounds in my play group. Uh some of the people around the table were really curious to try it. And so, they might have a chance to uh borrow it and explore that one specifically at two players. And I'll be curious to see what they have to say about that experience as well. Those friends in particular played like entirely through Seventh Continent. So getting a comparison from them would be fascinating. I think.