Decorum: Discussion 2.0
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for decorum and typically uh this is actually the second discussion so you can definitely go check uh out our first one and what we thought after I think about three games in so we are uh we've just finished scenario 13 and have decided to call it as a series because this game became more and more frustrating to play and not in a fun way and not in a fun way and so this this game like I think I I want it I want it with the app like I think that the two-player scenario um now they're going on in a story they're just so wildly inconsistent that it becomes the more frustrating the more you play like and I don't like to do series whenever we're forcing the episodes right like where it's like hey you want to play take orbit it's not because we want to play it's not like me and Devin playing Midori and are actually excited to play right this is like ah let's just [ __ ] do it you know and but then we get scenarios that are like yeah okay great we did a good job yeah but then the very next one it's just like what the [ __ ] is this so I think where the issue lies because on
the and at this point actually for this discussion did you play you haven't played this three player right no okay I have so I've played this with three players so I can kind of talk a little bit about that um but with the three player or four player games they have star ratings to hopefully decide or show you hey here's the difficulty this is a level one star for four players it's probably an easier one for four and then you can go into you know three stars the two player ones don't have that and I find that so vile because you just you're blindsided because you think oh I mean what it should do is increase in difficulty as it goes on right but then there are some that you come in where it's like number 12 that's like oh okay yeah we did it in 12 turns yay and then you do the one before that where it's literally like this is [ __ ] impossible where I spent an extra 10 15 minutes with both cards in front of me mapping it out and it took me a while so it's like how does anyone expect people to get it done with limited information when someone can't you know barely does it with perfect information and I find that a problem in a game that's of this style um cat with a girl overall thoughts overall thoughts is is I mean I remember being like you know excited to play this game like it's fun
um it's just so like it's it's like I don't know if anyone's ever been in this situation where it's like you're having fun you're laughing with a friend and like all of a sudden that friend like [ __ ] snaps and it's just like I thought we were having a good time right or like something like that and it's like all of a sudden you're uncomfortable that is this game like the game we played right before this one number 12. we were having a good time it wasn't it wasn't like necessarily hard it was it was just stinky enough I started reading my conditions for this one and I immediately like I said it at the beginning of that playthrough I was like I don't want to do this like I don't want to do this yeah just because I knew I was gonna throw a hitch and things and then it turned out that you just had something that was so confusingly written or stated whether it's because of commas whatever it it made yours undoable yeah like yeah and it seemed like it was directly contradicting mine which we know can't happen but you're confused you can't ask me for help yeah until we get to a heart to heart and by then it was way too late for us yeah exactly and just life lesson and I think I mentioned it in the in the run through was okay like the first I mean there this is this is a difficult game to design like I get that like you you want to make it you want to make each scenario unique so you're not feeling like you're put in the same places same things in the same places uh and I applaud them for that I think the design of this game is brilliant but because you do that then you run into snags of like people are either gonna
think that the scenarios are broken which we've been guilty of thinking this is impossible and then we end up doing it um or you have someone get perfect information to see if they are possible and they are but just not in the actual game so it's like why play the [ __ ] game if we can't even beat the beat the puzzle don't make a losing scenario just because you can yeah like and and like so because of that and you have 20 scenarios which I actually find are a bit much uh well in everything this goes back to like everything just has to be a campaign nowadays that yeah I know and it's like I mean it was kind of neat whenever you're like oh wait a minute we just played a game with those people and now they've moved on yeah this is kind of like uh the story of kind of like the video game unpacking where it's like oh hey we're getting a little like story going on that's that's pretty that one was only four chapters but uh but the thing is is like what's also the problem with that is because people probably aren't playing five or ten scenarios by the time we came back to it it was like who's this person I vaguely remember so there's no actually cohesive Narrative of the story that you can retain uh like they're not so memorable yeah I'm like oh yeah Steve whoa yeah to be fair I did remember Steve um but I will remember specifics about him right so but what I'm saying is that because you have 20 scenarios which are a bit much and it these are only one time play because once I know your conditions I can't come back and play this one right therefore
when you run into badly written conditions it breaks the game yeah and we that was happening more and more frequently yeah like again I one I'd be like okay yeah you know this is kind of snag it's still kind of frustrating because I'm limited now because the app technically isn't out not technically the app isn't out at the time of this recording that this is it if someone if someone hates apps and board games as well which we're not one of those people I love apps and board games I love assistive apps I think an app for this game is brilliant it's a smart design but if they [ __ ] up in the app they patch it if someone doesn't want the app and and and they've played through and they come across 13 or 11 or whatever I saw someone saying 19 was an issue well sorry now you're just out of content yeah and it's not like the designer is going to be like you know what let's read release packs they're just not going to do that right very rarely do companies actually come out with something and granted they could put it online as a PDF and you print it off but it's like it's not my [ __ ] job to fix your game like I'm sorry you you know didn't [ __ ] like hire a rider to make sure that these conditions were crystal clear because that's the stupid thing they don't have to be ambiguous yeah they need to be very clear-cut here's exactly what the for you do yes what you're doing might seem contradictory to something else but that means you have to do something else different yeah on the board that's perfectly fine for it to be written so
piss-poor essentially means I actually paid for an incomplete game this is a game that some of the ones well to be fair again the best example is the jam session that one was just hard but doable but I we understood all the conditions it wasn't like what the [ __ ] does do these mean we understood what they were we just either started you know got off on the wrong foot and then just it was very difficult to mesh this one was incomprehensible which is the same as releasing a video game that has bugs in it yeah and that is what makes me extremely frustrated and as I started looking I was like three designers huh and what I what I also think is I'm not gonna blame it on as far as the card language goes I'm gonna blame it on they need an editor because they need someone who is completely removed from your process who can come in and objectively say I think this is what that means is that what you meant and if they're like no then be like oh well then we have to you have a problem yeah because when you're working in like a think tank you know you're with everybody and all of a sudden you do start to like Vibe and Jive and you're like this is making so much sense yeah you're surrounded by Yes Men well not even just yes man it's just that like you've probably heard it so many times that you're like yes that makes sense let's go with that final product you need somebody who doesn't even know what this game is about to be
like if if you had to read this could you tell me like plainly I know if somebody read to me each room must not contain any object that matches its wall color I'd be like oh okay so the wall pillar can't match an object yeah that makes the most happy it makes sense but if you read what you read to me off the street I'd be like can I what like yeah and no and I mean you're exactly right either have an editor or and I can't I'd be I mean if a designer if if Ben or whoever any of these three want to clarify I'll rescind it but it comes off as if you did not play test every scenario sure you probably play tested to make sure it functioned as a game I hope uh but because you have scenario base where they're all radically different conditions then therefore you should have play tested every scenario and multiple not just the one that caused us to quit the series but that happened probably in 13 games four or five times it happened enough to be like this is an established pattern yes um another thing about play testing is I know it's probably hard to get a group of people but like I would feel like every scenario would have to have a different play testing group it all has to be very stereo yep and that's why I'm saying probably what they um I'm just gonna say what they should have done is develop the app first if that was their intention to have an app that would just be a big [ __ ] bonus too and it was the app was was announced at the same time it just wasn't it just it just isn't ready when the game came out so yeah so then you
yeah so then you don't play test it and if they did play test every scenario I guarantee you whoever wrote the scenario was there with them and explained it to them so they didn't have those questions and that's a fundamental problem with a lot of disc games in general that when they get play testers they're playing with them right and it's like no you need to give them a piece of paper and you need to get the [ __ ] out of there yeah because you need to be like behind a behind a one-way mirror right like a two-way whatever it is yeah and then just be like taking notes so when you come back and then you know like let's say this should have went out to everyone it's like I need you we'll pay you or someone to play every scenario and document scenario one fine you know maybe one question here because it's the first scenario and as you went on scenario 13 this one didn't [ __ ] make any sense and yeah and it just it just goes to show that they didn't go through the scenarios with a fine tooth comb because it happened multiple times again if this was the first one that it came across it's like yeah that kind of sucks but whatever all the other ones are golden right and we've had I mean we've had more often than not good scenarios right uh but as we kept playing it was like it became more of a chore because I'm actually very curious was it more of a chore to play because you didn't like the game or because for me it was becoming more mature because I was hesitant I was scared to come across a scenario like this again no it was it was I would say the only time that I was ever like I'm not having fun I'm not enjoying this is because
things had gotten to a point where like I felt that we were getting such weird information in those scenarios that I was like I knew that we were in a scenario like that and I was like I don't want to play anymore I immediately want to give up because I know we can't do this like and that's because again a pattern had emerged now the first time I felt like that I was like oh I don't this is kind of a chore because it's making me think really hard it's like okay sure I never saw it playing this was a chore I just knew that when I put my foot down today I didn't even I didn't mean to come off as like we're only playing two games I just knew every time we played more than two games something funky happened we got some weird scenario and therefore that developed the pattern of it almost came across as Charlie did Charlie did one uh Harry did too Drew oh Drew did [ __ ] three we gotta let Drew [ __ ] do it okay then it's like okay yeah we'll leave right then we have Charlie Harry okay number six [ __ ] sucks you know and that's not that's not exactly how it went but it did seem like every two or three games we were getting some weird wonky [ __ ] one that is either yeah some guy tried to be like Oh I'm gonna make this one it felt like a stupid it felt like a push or like card game like yeah like you can either play or you like you can or you can hold or whatever the [ __ ] they call it stay or eat my ass on the table or you can stand yes and snap your [ __ ] on the table yes I felt like we were we were getting real good we were getting real good and then we got one more yes and then we're like what the [ __ ] yeah uh because the
game for its theme for a game that's pretty much an abstract strategy game yeah is it feels thematic like I like the fact that you do something and like the way that the scenarios go is based kind of like okay here's where I'm gonna kick off and sometimes that's like that's the worst way and then we start then we start raveling and going down a rabbit hole where it's just it's just not working yeah but in other words it's like okay I started off here oh you didn't care about that and then you do it's like oh that works for me and this people might you know people might hate that they might hate the fact that you have to start off on a very specific way for the scenario to work out instead of it being like you know what I'm gonna go after this condition and whichever condition I choose like if I went after the you know all rooms must be painted the same color that shouldn't fundamentally break it if that's the one I choose to start with you know at the end of the day in 30 rounds yeah yeah it should all no matter how you start it should be achievable yeah and I think that's what I was trying to say earlier when it's like you can't just make a scenario that's broken yeah just to make it where like that's so like yeah where it's like some people where it's like hey like there's a meta to each scenario where it's like well the to beat scenario 15 you have to start here yeah okay well No One's Gonna know that and because you can't replay them yeah it's not a trial and error game yeah it's I mean it is a trial and error game but it's not like oh well I started wrong on that one so
let's redo it no I know exactly where your conditions are so now we can just strategize which is also kind of a weird thing it's like they went very vague on this rule book where it's like so how much can we talk like yeah like is it literally just supposed to be yay nay or or neutral yeah because that's also very hard for me because I just have a lot of words inside well that's the thing and it's like but then that's not fun if that's just where you're going yes no or or I like it I hate it or I'm neutral is whatever I love it hate it yeah it's and then it's like okay well now that we have we've had two heart to Hearts so you know two of mine and I know two yours okay can we strategize about how we want it on the on the table like whenever we were playing 13 it's like okay well then it has to be blue yeah and that's just kind of our head space but it's like well maybe it doesn't maybe it maybe it has to be a different color but you just run out of time and you're like well I guess we lost that might as well throw these away because now we can't replay it yeah there's like no point so there's this kind of like as as you play more and more scenarios those kind of very little things grow into bigger things and then it becomes more of like a well I played through all 20 scenarios 12 of them were good eight were bad I guess that's this game I guess I'm done uh and that just that just kind of sucks uh the app itself uh I was able to get kind of a preview at Gen Con this year and that was pretty cool
um I think the office is going to be fundamentally just a better way to play this uh because therefore then you're not limited then it doesn't oh the scenario sucked who cares like we we pull up the app you know generate one okay put in the code here's what we got oh wait this one blue I didn't like this one okay I have literally millions of combinations so who gives a [ __ ] I don't care that I'm now down a scenario exactly yeah yeah that'll be fun when that comes up yeah and it's like for the record I'm not getting rid of this game I like it uh I'm not as high on it as I was because I saw my score when I was looking up does anyone else have these clarifying questions on uh BGG no uh but it's like okay so either someone it clicked for someone and that made sense or how many people are playing this at two players probably more often more often than done just because it it seems designed as a two-player game four game people don't have a lot of friends there's more scenarios than for two players than there are for three and four so I would imagine but it's like how many people are going out and getting this game this seems like a very Niche kind of game yeah you almost like a couples game I was always getting fog of Love kind of miscommunications see that yeah yeah because it is it's supposed to be about passive aggressive like yes everyone's like they're either a couple or a roommate but like you can definitely tell that like I just feel like this is a game that it's like play with your missus yeah I play with a couple like and which brings me to three and uh four players to before I haven't played at four but it just adds another person uh
so the three-player game is I actually think it's very good it's very hard uh and but it because you're given cards that are your conditions so like instead of a two-player game where we read it out and you can just keep rereading it you can't do that in a three-player game because whenever you have heart to Hearts you have cards of your conditions and you hand those to someone so you have a heart to heart with one other person so if it was me you and Brett playing it would be like okay we're having a heart to heart cats not mess it [ __ ] with me as much but Brett is so bright I'm gonna tell you this condition so here's the card with that condition on it that he holds on to as a reminder it's like because you keep messing with me on what I need so now you know that but and then you could tell him something and then he could tell you something so I could get no information from and that's just kind of what makes it difficult is you have to decide who gets you know what condition to reveal uh and you have five heart to hearts in a three or four player game but and then you also have roommates like you have these little tokens that it's like yep okay well this is me and this is you and so we hey we actually have rooms that we need to be in so it adds a little bit more I think I think it works really well as a three player uh as a three-player game and I mean I would imagine a four player game but it's rough it's it if you get the same exact vibe uh but yeah it's it's pretty it's pretty difficult
um so yeah I just kind of wanted to talk about that because we I had to play a three at the time of the first discussion so I wanted to continue the series um because I was like we can probably we could probably push through I mean we got to all the way up to 13. but at the end of the day I I didn't I was gonna get more and more mad and start to legitimately hate the game if we came across another [ __ ] off scenario like this right like I kid you not I I had to restrain myself I was like well this is [ __ ] useless I was just gonna rip it and be like it's trash because it is it you will one it's like yeah and I say that but it's like I bet you if we went to two like number two I'd probably [ __ ] forget oh yeah yeah with my memory like yeah but it theoretically is supposed to be one time but yeah it's because of the way this is worded it's it it fundamentally breaks it um I agree I agree because even once I once we revealed our objectives I was like let me see it so I can read it myself and I was like it's like okay well it can't obviously mean this but then again it doesn't make sense like basically it was either they all are they they have to be empty and nothing else can be empty yeah or they have to be greened but then other stuff can be empty it just it just did did not work and I was
like if I come across another scenario like that I'm going to scream I'm gonna flip my lid and I just don't want to do that so basically what I've resolved myself to is to either this becomes a game kind of like turing machine which is a purely logic game where this just gets pumped out and who gives a [ __ ] about the story because there really isn't one and we just go you know what let's do number 20. right you know let's just pick one of these and do it or I say to hell with the rest of the two player one time and we'll probably play them just for shits but we're no longer going to play them cohesively on the channel or just play them randomly and then just wait for the app to come out and then just play it every now and then with a nap yeah uh yeah so that's that's kind of why we're doing another discussion that happens usually when we finish a series or if we're done playing a series because there's usually an underlying reason for that on a scale of one to ten what would you give decorum and I think I you want to know what your score was I think it was the same as mine um I had this at a nine okay I was gonna put it at a seven because it's got some Kinks to work out yeah and it can be worked out I'm excited for the app though yep that's what I'll say yep that's exactly where I'm at too I'm gonna drop it from a nine to a seven Riding High on the nine because it was kind of like new and this was a very unique way and the theme does work uh and the stories are kind of cute um and it is kind of nice that way as we read them we're like oh hey I remember that person uh if you remember them
but yeah those those major issues is a fundamental break of the game not saying the scenario isn't not saying like this particular one isn't solvable I would I'd really like to know if any of these are legitimately broken because that would really [ __ ] it up but the the the lack of the lack of play testing for scenarios the consistency of running into more issues than not and the limited time play was does kind of show showcase itself a little bit more so yeah that's why it's dropped down to A7 which is still a good ranking this is a pretty big drop from nine to seven but yeah I am also looking forward to the app and that's our thoughts on decorum uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you