Retro Reviews (Ep. 2) | Ticket to Ride, LotR: The Confrontation, & Malarky
Transcript
foreign how's it going everyone I am Dylan this is my cousin Carlo and we are back for episode two of a retro reviews uh actually in the last episode we we asked people if they had any or had any other ideas for for this series because we weren't sure of fresher reviews was like too straightforward or whatever and the the most of the response we got was that retro reviews is a good name and it kind of just indicated exactly what people would come to expect and we can come up with anything that was as simplistic and as obvious as to what the the video was gonna be about so we're sticking with retro reviews um I mean we we make the rules around here so maybe at some point we will change okay we determine what's retro and it's sort of the sword for retrospective anyways because it's a look back at older games it doesn't mean it has to be a 20 plus year old game but it was some very old ones today especially compared to last episode These are very old yeah in general I think our rule was we were trying to the games have to be at least five years old to be covered on here and I think we're we're no problem this episode yeah sure these are these are gonna be I think the oldest one is 96 is that what it was yeah and the newest one is I think 0405 so even the newest game here is still very close to 20 years old so yeah so again if you haven't if you can watch our first episode the way we look at these titles is we talk about them and our experiences with them today and then rate them based on whether three categories kind of like how we do I want to play it skip it but this one is whether it is aged well um oh God age well classic or yeah go in order classic then aged well and then showing its age there you go yeah so showing its age hvl classic and one little tidbit I
just want to add about that is we do factor in how long the game has been out for so if you look at the last episode for example we talked about something like voyages and Marco Polo our final verdict was like if it had been out a lot longer maybe would have called it a classic but based on it was around seven years we felt just shy and said it had aged well so we do really factor that in but uh yeah I think that's about it cool all right and we're each gonna cover one and then we sort of jointly cover the third game at the end yes exactly so three games total and I'm gonna start uh this one off with the game our oldest one on the list from 96 this is the game I used to play growing up as a kid um and then uh I still don't I haven't tracked down my own copy but I know you tracked this one down at a flea market or something yeah like three bucks so we do have one in the family again which is great uh and that is a uh I was gonna say a bluffing game it is but it's an imponderables bluffing game called Malarkey uh so Malarkey is it is all about lion it is all about bluffing and that is why I love it I'm not that's not to say like I love lion but in games I guess I kind of do it's super fun to like have to deceive people it's one of the reasons I like um hidden roll games is because of that deception having to like see how long you can keep it up how effectively you can keep it up Malarkey the reason they call it an imponderables game is because they will ask you basically your group will get a question so I'm going to read one off the back just as an example and so one could be why does Mickey Mouse have four fingers a question that you might be like oh you know I've never thought about that before and that's really kind of the response you get to most of the questions so I never really thought about that everyone is going to have to think about that question you're going to hand out
these cards one person is going to get the actual answer to that question everyone else is going to get a card that says Bluff or you have to Bluff everyone who gets a Bluff Court has to come up with a fake answer that is as believable as they can possibly make it while the person who gets the real answer has to put that real answer into their own words after everyone's ready you're going to go around and everyone is going to say their answer and then you're all going to vote after on which one you think is the real answer so you're trying to effectively Bluff to get points um and I can't remember all like this is one of those games where like there's multiple ways to get points like it's like if your answer gets guessed get a point if you guess the right answer get a point and ultimately like yes we we track points and yes someone wins that's really not why we're playing it's one of those kind of party games yeah but but I will say it's if you if if you bluffed and someone picked yours and you tricked them I think you get two points instead of three points like which makes sense it's giving you the reward for having like succeeded at basically fooling them right yeah so it plays three to six players um I'm actually surprised I mean and I'm not but like that it doesn't play higher because it's a game I feel like could incorporate higher players yes maybe it's just that each round with each seven people making a pitch while they're people making a pitch or whatever might just be yeah but I think of snake oil and how like you we accommodate like almost any player countless snake oil yeah and like with malarkey I feel like if they would have just included more cards like just having the option to be like well we have eight people here now you're like we don't have enough cards play Malarkey you know what I mean for sure I guess technically you could maybe make some homemade ones yeah they would all have
to be homemade so they don't match or they don't look different from the bluffing ones exactly but um so yeah Malarkey um I'm gonna just say my verdict first so my verdict is showing its age but this is an interesting one to talk about because I still love playing Malarkey I've actually played it two times somewhat recently I think once was 2019 2018 and then the other one was 2021 so I played it relatively recently um as well as played tons of times growing up and when growing up we were playing this with our like parents like people are much older than us and more recently played it with like people our age and also when we were kids we were playing this as teenagers compared to now yeah exactly different times in our life and I think that the reason I'm putting show in its age is not because I I feel like the gameplay itself is showing a stage it's that the question specifically I remember the last time I played I can't remember I can't remember examples I wish I would pull them out but there was just some that would come up that we had to take out because now where we are you know 20 plus years later people knew the amp they weren't imponderables anymore yeah or they just weren't relevant and it was like this is this is something that clearly is from the 90s like the question it's almost like if you were playing like a 90s version of Trivial Pursuit it would be that that version of Trivial Pursuit is showing its age questions about like celebrities that aren't relevant anymore question but like the AM FM radio and things like that it's like I listen in the car on my phone like there's all these things that take you into another era which in a way it also can create for some interesting situations yeah maybe you're playing with younger people who aren't familiar with these older
things that are even more imponderable yeah exactly but you do miss that kind of like what happened in the last 20 years and all the and like you said a lot of these we have answers to yeah so I feel like that's where the game's showing its age um and I'm making that distinction because if it wasn't for that I probably would have said aged well because the idea of bluffing is being done in in Hidden rule games in games like Balderdash that are very similar to this or seem to be you know I don't know which one came first I think I think but regardless like it's in that genre that I think is still aging well but I just think that this version of that genre isn't and I I mean I selfishly would love to see a new version of malarkey just because I like it I prefer it to Balderdash because of the imponderable plunderables aspect is so much fun but I would almost just rather them if they were going to do that I'd rather someone just take this idea make a brand new game with like updated and ponderables or a new thing with new rules and like taking a modern board gaming ideas and conventions that we've seen in other party games and finding a better way to do it like we don't need to maybe have the the flip cards anymore because there's a better way to do that and maybe there's just a maybe Beyond impondo there's another thing that maybe will age better that people can you know replace that idea with whatever it is I'm not a game designer I'm not gonna be the one to come up with it but if they came out with a modern you know 2023 version 2024 version of this type of game of like the Balderdash genre I'd be all over it so it's not that genre that's showing its age it's Malarkey's questions specifically yeah which is which is too bad but at the same time I still have tons of fun playing it in
2021 I just feel like it's it's one that if I were to start playing it regularly and put into my like party game rotation I feel like it wouldn't take long for me to be like I don't think I can play Malarkey Much Anymore yeah I think these questions aren't gonna live up to the expectations so yeah honestly I was fully Expecting The Nostalgia but I have to give you credit because you've said before in the past that you really try hard to separate yourself from Nostalgia and when you've chosen to talk about this one I kept thinking he's probably going to have it at aged well and I was on the cusp of thing if I was covering it it would either be just on the bottom edge of age dwell or just in showing its age and I think I fall in the same spot as you because even just the size of the box like how many party games do you get these days that are this big like yeah people who have growing collections like it's hard to justify keeping one party game that you like you could fit just one code name so Clover and maybe one more in this box alone but some like it's still like he says a lot of fun one or two things I want to highlight real quick that still make it like hold up well is the scoring thing is actually something that I think deserves a lot of credit because these days a lot of party games the scoring is meaningless and we just play rounds until you're kind of bored of playing or whatever yeah and even though it's not all that important in here you really are still rewarded like I said like when you see the scores at the end of the game the person who bluffed best or was best at um even to the trivia of knowing which one to guess like is usually going to win so it is still rewarding to play with that system yep and one of the funnest things that can happen in this game is when you are supposed to Bluff or was it that you had the right answer but then someone bluffed and they came
up with the right answer yeah but exactly and then it's like called the Malarkey so then you have to now come up with a new Bluff even though you were supposed to have the right answer because the bluffer stole your answer and it creates this new dynamic because it might be the person to your left you were sitting there planning your bluff you knew what you're gonna say and then Dylan goes and he comes up and you're sitting there going oh my God he's stealing my oh my God he's stealing what I was gonna say and you're suddenly on the spot having to come up with this new thing so I like I really encourage anyone out who hasn't played it to at least try it because there's a lot to like but um yeah and I do agree with you ultimately that it is showing its age just but you can't feel like it's it's an old games what 25 some 27 years old and I will say this falls into the same trappings that a lot of these style of games do or games like um like no communication games and stuff like that where it's gonna be so group dependent because I played this where it's a Miss with the group specifically because people can't wrap their heads around how like the idea to Bluff like it'll come to them and that you can tell they're bluffing because they're saying like I don't know it's it's this or whatever it's like yeah like like or or someone has the right answer and then they pick up their thing and they try to read again like what was it and then let's say well now we know you have the real ads like yeah there's little trappings like that that if people aren't really committed to the idea of like you you have to try to make this like you know as there's there's a word for like preserving the Integrity of Rights like the rules and the game right exactly in the same way that like in a game where you're not supposed to communicate like the mind or something yeah yes and you start communicating it ruins you know what the experience so Malarkey has trappings like that and it's especially group dependent because
some people will feel very uncomfortable having to Bluff this is less imposing than like a hidden roll game but I feel like there's enough there's a chance here that someone will like feel uncomfortable with the idea having to Bluff or getting into the position where now the Malarkey happens and they have to come up with it on the spot like I love when that happens because I keep the straight face and and I'll just like make up a lie in the spot and it's part of the rush of the game right and it feels so great if people buy into it some people it would you can they wouldn't they wouldn't be able to I've had I've had it where someone has said well you just said my answer and it kind of ruins that right then the round is basically then just over yeah so it's it's very group dependent but and if you especially if you're playing with someone who's not as good as Blackford doesn't want to and they get unlucky and get dealt the bluff card every round I've played games of this where we finished the entire game and I have I didn't get the bluff card once right here and then someone else got it like four times so yeah another small little flaw but yeah but either way yeah I I still love this game I still love playing it and I think it is just because I will always love the idea of having to fool my friends around the table and now and how effectively I can do it if you ever see Dylan somewhere to Convention video or something you'll just know if he goes like this episode he goes well it's quite simple really that's the tell that's the Telly's life well now I'm gonna go well it's quite simple really into all these different hand motions uh yeah that is malarkey it is showing its age but it is still a fantastic game yeah cool I'm glad you covered that one that's the old uh childhood yeah last in the past there okay so now uh the one I'm covering here is this one was released in 2002 originally uh it's a very difficult to find game these days
um but if you can find it I highly recommend you check this out this is Lord of the Rings the confrontations this is a two-player only uh asymmetric game basically it's an updated Lord of the Rings themed version of Stratego so uh I'm gonna try not to do that or should I throw it in the game yeah throw in the game that's right on the gang versus Sauron and his cronies and uh no it's good versus evil of course one player starts as uh the Frodo and the fellowship in the Shire and the other side is Sauron in the uh in Mordor and you're basically trying as uh as the good side you're trying to either get Frodo to uh Mordor or as the evil side you're trying to either kill Frodo or get three of your uh units through your um figures or whatever into the Shire to win the game yep all you do on your turn is you're moving one of your pieces forward into a space you can never move sideways or backwards uh generally each of the characters has its own unique ability a unique uh strength value so it'll have a number on it and then a little thing of text and so when you move into a square that has an enemy unit you'll basically flip the pieces around to reveal to your opponent what you have and they'll reveal what they had or let's say I move in and they had multiple enemies I get to pick I point at the back side of one I don't which is which and they'll pick or then they'll flip that one over and show me and then we're basically going to resolve a battle sometimes the text on the units will come into play immediately and you won't need to do anything else to resolve the battle but most times you're then going to each have the opportunity to play a card so you'd start with I think it's nine cards or seven cards in your hand you each know what the other
person is holding and we have I think five or six cards in common and then there's a few differentiating cards and you basically get to each pick a card in secret and then we'll flip them up and then we'll add the card either strength or text ability to the current uh sort of strength and ability of the characters we'll see who wins one of them gets removed the other one stays on the map and we just keep going back and forth like that until someone meets one of the end game conditions so it's a very fun game and it kind of it's interesting that we're talking about with Malarkey because there's a level of kind of deception and you can do it's not a bluffing game or a deception game or anything like that but there you can play with a certain level of that because knowing what your opponent has or doesn't have um and when you kill a unit you see what's off the board and there's the process of elimination of trying to figure out okay they have this many units left they have six left and they have lost this many or whatever what's most likely okay if they got something on the right side of the board they're probably trying to sneak so and so through you're trying to piece this stuff together but your opponent knows what information you know about them so they can play around that and try to send a different you know unit that way that makes you think it's someone different than it really is from the first time I played it I really enjoyed it but I wondered is it going to hold up after multiple plays or is it going to be like once you figure out the best way to play a certain faction or like oh this is a really good strategy and works every time and I've been really surprised with each subsequent play how much more depth and strategy has come out with each subsequent play I've played this now with I think five or six different people and even different levels of Gamers like I showed this to my brother-in-law and one when
playing against him and then I went and taught it to my nine-year-old nephew and he beat me twice in a row playing the game for the first time I had already played it like eight times before and I was like what like it's not like a high luck based game or anything either like but it's it has this thing where it's easy enough for a new person to get into and they're still going to have a chance of winning because there's that uncertainty of you can take those risks and sometimes they do or don't pay off so the better player isn't always going to win but if you play this game with someone over and over like having played this with a certain friend uh like four or five times you start to see little things progress and a meta starts to develop and that one time that you you know sent Samwise one sorry one way with another unit and you made your opponent think well that's got to be Frodo with Sam because they work well together and then they went and checked and it was actually Gimli and Frodo went the other way and snuck his way into Mordor like now next time you play are is your opponent gonna try that again so it's like this building system that continues like that overarches from game to games you're playing with the same person so there's a lot of stuff to like here um I know you've only played it well we played one session where you got to play both sides of it but it's been a little while what did you think of it so I really like it and my favorite part about it is what you described about at the beginning and throughout the game not knowing where people pieces are and like where like you can guess you can you can say like you know it probably makes sense that this that fro like you said Frodo and Sam are together here or that the ball rock is here or whatever but you can use that expected expectation against your opponent or whatever as part of like the hidden information in the game and I think that
what that's what makes it so replayable and and so much fun is that the idea that you can come up with a really good way to play Frodo in the gang where like every time you play them it's like I have my strategy is to do this and it seems effective but really you can't account for every player and how they're going to approach their affection where they're going to position and what how they're going to buy into your lies or your truths or whatever depending compared to how someone else does so it's in the same way that like and this might be a weird comparison but uh um and I swear it's not Feast oh my God no but like you know in Magic the Gathering right like there or in in tcgs in general you can have like The Meta with Decks that are widely considered to be like oh this is the best deck of standard right now or whatever and you can craft that really good deck and you can say like it is shown to win but you can never you sit down with a new opponent you can never account for what deck they are bringing to the table and it might perfectly counter your deck it might like you know you just don't know you can come up with a great strategy and you can sit down and your opponent can play in a way that like you're just not EX expecting or take chances you're not expecting or position their units in a way that you're like why would you have done that yeah and then it's like you can't really get mad because it worked against you right like that's what makes it so fun to come back to and that's where I think that I could see myself you know if I played this over and over and over again I wouldn't get bored except maybe if it was just like you and me constantly playing against each other maybe then we learn each other's strategies and and then it loses interest but even then if we start changing the way we approach maybe it doesn't and one of the brilliant things I think this does is
the fact that it says specifically the rules that the ideal way to play is to play twice where you play the game and whoever wins your score is however many pieces you had left on the board so regardless of your opponent if I had let's say three pieces left on the board or three figures I get three points then you swap sides play again and then you do the aggregate scores to see who wins so it's that kind of thing we've talked about before lost cities with the multiple rounds where in going into the second game I adjust like if I'm only down by one point I don't need to have like a landslide Victory if I'm going in ahead Five Points maybe I just need to play safe so that second game always is different based on the first one and I didn't mention the story it's not just a random setup you get to pick your pieces and I played once where I just did it randomly just to mess with my point I'm like I'm just gonna put them out randomly because that way you can't anticipate my moves and they were just like wait what the guy messes with them but you can again the replay value of the game because of the ways you can do it and you could just like take the whatever it is the Knight Rider the black writer that just says you can advance any number of spaces first turn of the game you can be like I'm gonna see if I can get Frodo there just move across the board you might turn over Frodo the game might explode in the first turn of the game like yep so much fun uh this is a classic for me I guess I hadn't said yet you probably guessed if you're watching but for a game when I first played it I wasn't sure but with each subsequent play it's gotten better it the depth has continued to increase for me and the fact that like I never really got hooked on Stratego that much when I tried it when I was younger but the fact that this took that system put the Lord of the Rings theme in there and makes these characters actually feel thematic um and it's a 20 plus year old game now it's like undeniable it's a
classic for me it's now one of my favorite two-player only games nice yeah I agree I I I'm sorry I don't I don't have a rating myself because I just haven't played enough of it right but I am not surprised by classic I don't think I mentioned at the beginning but if in case for some reason I didn't this is a writer kinesi design so yeah it's really tough to find these days there's a lot of versions out there that have been printed but yeah that is Lord of the Rings the confrontation nice okay and our last one which is going to be our joint game we have two different versions of it here uh because we're almost kind of saying this as like the system itself maybe maybe excluding some of like the outliers that change the rules a lot but these two are very similar um and that is Ticket to Ride and Ticket to Ride Europe and the two versions we're talking about here so um there are multiple versions and multiple different map packs like the reason I say not like all versions of ticket to ride is because like rails and sales for instance is very different and right probably like these two it's it's just you get get the different map in the tunnels is like the biggest right and I guess just for quick context maybe we should mention which I haven't played a whole lot other ticket to ride so like I know there's Nordic countries like we say you're listing them all I think I've only tried the rails and sales version that was the co-op one right or the teams one nope nope rails and sales or was that the Asia maps that we played once that was
it was just a different like that one is a different version of ticket drive that has like yeah different they had a whole bunch of different rules but because I've heard good things about some of the other ones especially like Nordic countries and there's a couple other ones yeah anyways our experiences mostly with these ones and some of the other older ones but uh yeah why don't you tell the folks a little bit about ticket ride and how it plays in case for some reason they don't know yeah sure I'm gonna just do this so it's easier um so Ticket to Ride is a game that you are just establishing routes using these little your little uh colored train tokens on a map you're doing so by using colored cards in your hand all the cards in your hand are just the only thing that matters is the color of them um and they're all just like a train with a different color and I think there's wild as well um and you're basically deciding to draw two from the top of the deck or two from the market or a combination of one for the market one the deck where if you take a wild you only get the single card you take the wild um if it's from the market and you're adding into your hand and then you basically if you want to lay your trains down on a route where it takes four trains you need four of that color you put four of uh your trains down it completes the row between two cities you'll have tickets destination tickets is that what they're called yeah destination tickets yeah destination tickets that will say you need to make it from Winnipeg Winnipeg is on the map which is pretty great Winnipeg to um I don't know like what's where I don't know what Chicago Chicago I don't know uh and so you have to complete this route um and so you might be trying to complete multiple different routes other people might come in and notice what you're doing and block you or also be trying to complete certain routes and getting in your way it doesn't matter how the way you get if you complete that destination you get uh that destination
ticket you get the points that are listed on the ticket at the end of the game your your points will be all the destination tickets that you did complete minus the ones you didn't complete and in addition to every single time you lay down like say like for uh a road that caught takes four trains or six trains there'll be different points you get from doing that as well so there's multiple ways you can kind of a strategies you can you can adopt to try to like get points you can we we play that game on BJ where someone only did their first two destination tickets but then just got all their points from laying down big uh you know roads yeah between four and six like we had so many cards left at the end they absolutely destroyed I've never seen someone play where they didn't draw destination tickets one time and get that high of a scoreboard yeah so I mean yeah it's it's a fairly simplistic game once you know the rules like there's not there's not a lot of complexity there um but there's depth in terms of like how you approach it and also because there's different a different map in this one A different map in this one map packs like you can change the game just from playing it on a different board even with the same system so yeah there's some very slight rule changes too even just from the original up to um tickets right Europe like in Europe there's the tunnels uh that you can use and there's like the stations and there's I think a couple other parts where you can use where you have to have tracks with specifically just locomotives which I don't think the original version has but um the game does I think we should really talk about the fact that how different the game feels across player counts because you're on the same map you're not like obviously there's the certain spots where it says with two or three players uh only one of these two routes can be used so there's certain places where it tightens up a bit but
the map is the same and you definitely feel when you play with two or three players that it's way more open I I was playing with five especially like this game is brutal with five players it is cut through you can't hoard cards in your hand for as long waiting like you kind of have to start getting things done early the more players yeah because if you get blocked you need to have enough time to adjust your your plans whereas with more players you can kind of take it slower wait wait wait see the lay of the land where other players are going or the other opponent if you're playing with two yeah and then kind of go about it and there's also the way of like you can play this game casually where you're really just focusing on your own routes or you can be mean and you can look at what someone else is doing and say I know they started here and they started there and there's only one way around and I know I don't really need that route but if I put just two two trains there that's gonna totally ruin their plans like maybe it's worth it and I think that's something that comes up only the more you play this game and with similar people and it starts getting more cut through and competitive I do a lot of them don't have to be that way and I do a lot more of that of me personally in the two-player game yeah because and in the two-player game specifically because it's easier you're only managing what one person is doing yeah it's easier to be like well I'll get the points from this little two two train tracker but also block block them and stop them from getting potentially tons of points so it makes sense to do that even just quickly to slow them down and then go back to what I'm doing it can sometimes devolve into like everyone just block the two people just blocking each other and then you you really it becomes more about like collecting to make big roads than it is actually finishing your destination tickets but uh but yeah how about we each say our verdict and then we'll say why and we'll each take a turn to explain why we we landed on that sounds good okay so I'm I'm saying it's a classic same okay okay cool I was very
close though I was on the cusp I almost said aged well but I did ultimately end up in classic yeah so for me the reason it's a classic is because even though this simplistic system like like I I think it's been done probably better in some other games and even games where I don't even think it's necessarily been done better I just think that like I I think if castle of Destiny for instance like Castle Tuscany has a similar card system to Ticket to Ride and I don't know what I'd have to really think about which one I think does it better but I think that you know with almost 20 years having passed and stick a dried came out it's not that there's not a game that does the system better it's just that ticket to ride is still the easiest the one that I can think of is the most successful accessible most fun or maybe not most one but just very fun and it just feels it feels like coming home when I sit when I play ticket drive like it I know it I never forget the rules like it doesn't matter how long has passed it's it's one of those it's one of those type of games where the rules are so straightforward they just land with the board almost reminds you all the rules just from looking at it um and it plays super super fast like even if you're playing the physical version compared to online or a digital platform it's everywhere I mean whatever version you're playing it plays really fast and you can get a game done relatively quick order um it plays well at all the player counts that I've played it out like I think I've I don't even know if I've played it at five and if I have it would have just been once but I just upgraded all clear it just very Cutthroat with five yeah and two three two three and four I think three was almost one of my favorite player counts because at three
you still like the roads that have the two um some roads will have two tracks on them so if someone takes one you could theoretically take the other one and not be blocked but in three players that's not the case you only as soon as someone takes one the other one's axed off so that makes it a little more Cutthroat with three people competing for sometimes just the one track on the board but there's just something about it that that combination of simplistic rules and the satisfaction of like trying to complete a destination ticket and then being thrown off your course be like can I go around about way here um I I personally I think I still prefer Europe me too but I've played Europe so much less and I still love the original that it like if I if I do ultimately like you're a better which I think I do it's it's very close like it's it's negligible I think the first year we did like our top 50 I think I put Ticket to Ride I think last year I did Europe maybe I did your both of them like they're both they're both yeah like even the I have one map pack that is the Asia map pack and like whether I play with that or the base game it doesn't matter to me I find I find all the have their own nuances and they're fun in different ways I just think that the system itself is a classic and a game hasn't come around yet that is completely replaced Ticket to Ride For me even if it's done similar things it doesn't hasn't done them all in combination quite like this game does yeah that's fair honestly it does so many things well for a game of its age and part of the reason why I ended up Landing in classic is when I thought about the last episode we did where we talked about pandemic as well and so and I started thinking too in comparison two games that came out
around the same time give or take a few years but those big kind of uh more popular they're still sort of not the mass Market games but stuff like uh when I think about you know carcasson pandemic Ticket to Ride Alhambra Seven Wonders like all these games that kind of came out within probably like a 10-year span this for me is in is with like the Carcassonne group in terms of like this is still a game that I would love to play any day yeah this holds up way better than again just to compare with last episode we talked about pandemic the original of this holds up in my opinion much better than the original pandemic because pandemic now has multiple versions that almost everyone would agree are like undeniably better than the original pandemic this is still really really good I don't think there's people out there or a lot of people out there who would say like oh get this other version of Ticket to Ride the original or Europe is like you'll never go back to it once you play like these are still very very good games they have simpler rules than something like pandemic again I they're not similar games into the way they play so I don't want to stress too much the comparison to pandemic but even just if you're showing a new player or something or someone doesn't play a lot of games the idea of being like in pandemic it's for people who are Gamers and get play a lot of games it's easy enough to understand the content like oh these cubes represent diseases and whatever but for someone who doesn't play It's kind of random like what are these cubes and why is this big deck of cards in here it's just a real world like you put trains on a map to get from one place to another anyone can understand that everyone knows that concept the game is so easy and the other thing I love is that you can play this game without even talk like sitting around the table being competitive you know having drinks
whatever and it can be that no one is really like talking about the game you could be talking about your weekend and talking about other things but you're still invested in the game because sometimes your turn is just draw two cards or do this route but you still feel engaged there's I don't know there's no doubt yeah there's a simple dancing that turns fly by and there's this Simplicity and every time we come back to it it always plays Super quickly everyone always goes yeah man I forgot how good that is that really holds up well like it never never feels like a game I'm ever gonna get rid of so it's one of the best Gateway games that's because like everything about the rules think about it like how many Trends do you want to lay down for so how many cards you need four what color cards do you need the color of the track boom yeah like you don't even have to ask what do Wilds do it's like it's pretty awesome like there's like other than where you can like how many cards you can draw the whole one thing or telling people about the destination tickets there's a couple little things but for the most part anyone can play this yeah and it's just yeah just a very pure yeah simple game that's even a destination ticket like you you draw it it's like what am I trying to achieve the two cities that are there what I want to do link them how many points do you get the number in the bottom right like everything I know that seems like well there's a lot of games to that but like everything about this is straightforward like that where if I'm introducing this someone who doesn't play board games there really isn't like a rules teach section like normally we set up a game it's okay time to teach the rules this is a game where it's like yes you're doing that but it's almost like while you're while you're setting up while you're trying to it takes me like two minutes to explain that because the tickets are right like in general like especially because if it's someone who hasn't played games before they're not going to care too much in my experience about the strategy on that first game where like like I don't I
need to you play it so much how am I going to beat you or whatever it's more dribble like let's just have some fun playing take it to ride yeah and so it's more just like these are things you can do in your turn let's even just do a round you'll get it from one round and then you're good to go and I'll say right now I was this close as of a few days ago to thinking that I was in the um aged well side yeah and then once we played with that person on board game arena and they absolutely wrecked us with that strategy that was like no I'm convinced of classic now because the fact that I've played this upwards of like 50 sometimes I thought it was like like not very good team or anything but like okay enough the decent win rate and stuff into I've been absolutely destroyed to that extent with a strategy I've never seen someone really do before and it felt like you and I had no chance once we got a certain like distance into the game it just kind of solidified to me like nope you can make a really good plays you can outplay people in this game it's not just a simple family game so yeah take it to ride will this ever uh will this ever have a chance of cracking your top 50 or is it just never I'm glad you brought that up because when we did our top 50 two years ago or last year or whatnot it wasn't even that close and then this year it got into like the 50s or 60s and I feel like it was because I started playing it on VGA again a bit recently I realized you know what I wasn't giving this the game the credit deserves and I thought I was kind of like over Ticket to Ride for a while but no it still holds up really well so I could see it getting into the top 50 maybe in like the 40s yeah in the future but it's never going to be like a top 10 or 20 for me right yeah me neither but that's good to know cool those are our uh our three games so these are the Retro views we had a recap here Malarkey
I'm saying it's showing its age but on the higher end Lord of the Rings confrontation you're saying is a classic and then we are both saying that ticket to ride and take a try Europe in this case a are Classics um so we had technically two Classics I know showing its age nothing is aged 12. yeah one or two of those last episode yeah yeah so yeah let us know how you would rate these three retro games um and uh always let us know in the comments too if you're liking the series I know we got a lot of great feedback last time we've got people just saying we love seeing older games covered because there tends to be a tendency in our industry at like new new and there's like a thousand board games released every year yeah and we can't always find games that are like 20 years old to cover so sometimes it was going to be like seven eight year old games whatever but yeah and if you have suggestions for things you'd like to see us cover drop in the comments below you know we can't promise we have played them all or have access to them all but we'll do our best uh especially if we see ones popping up frequently yeah otherwise let us know what your ratings would have been for these three games between uh showing its age well or classic and otherwise stay tuned for the next episode we'll keep doing these retro reviews for sure thanks for watching we'll see you next time foreign