Skip to main content
Loading video...

Battle for Rokugan: Discussion

Transcript 26:14

viewer discretion is advised hey one welcome to the discussion for battle for Roku gone uh okay so let's see where to start um I really like this game it was fun I think it is a it is a very very solid area control pretty much yeah just an area control game with a slight element of cutthroat like we were talking before Elmo if you heard us that this looked like a competitive game that didn't piss me off right yeah like I wasn't sitting here like once when you raided I was just like ah more deflated cells like I thought was going to defend in there's nothing you can do nope I just raised it the ground so so yeah so what's let's go ahead and talk about things we don't like because there still are a few things that I don't really like but they're they're very very minor um okay I don't actually I like and dislike the raid I don't like the fact that there's nothing you can do about it it's just like hey I happen to get this token that's gone forever by the way because it happened goes before everything I will just kind of the last ditch that everyone has access to I got mine first and I used it first because I wasn't not even necessarily thinking like oh I'm not gonna waste this I just weighed it down yeah but when I laid it down I

didn't realize that it was permanent permanent and you've got to be careful with that because I did wind up blocking myself off so it's one of those things where you can't be too quick to us well you didn't braid I did yes [ __ ] destroyed everybody crazy cuz how many do you guys have I have one you're worried I have my rage so you would have been have to yeah well that's my unicorn clan comment was raped so I was obviously diplomacy yeah mine was blessing okay so you actually have you're the woman with the +3 blessing right right so yeah I mean you're right it is just a last-ditch effort screw everyone over and I just made sure we did play it right because you can only play with your shinobi or that were next to any area you control so you can't just randomly just rage somewhere right just for shits like you can't just do a Navy raid which is a pretty much stay in place you can't do it uh so I mean yeah that's pretty much the only reason that stopped me from completing my ability which is not maybe why I'm a little bit more like [ __ ] the raid good and it also it so gave you the territory bonus without just I mean because technically you did own the territory it was like what was left yeah what was left of it um and my who raided this I was me not that your blessing because I went first so get my

diploma city and diplomacy sorry and I mean I guess the raid helped you and I still cuz I was able would get the bonus for that I was able to just be true so yeah that's um which actually brings me to another it's awesome it's not really a complaint like it doesn't hamper really my but it could be a complete for a lot of people is that this game is a lot of fun and it's very thematic in this is Roku gun this is the area where all the clans are this follows the same problem that the Game of Thrones board game has where it's so thematic that every time you're going to start in the same spot so you can't ever really start somewhere else to play differently you're really I am a I'm at the dragon I'm at the top so I have to come down but I guess they do have Navy which kind of allows you to swarm a little bit and I don't know let's should know be yeah that's true so it's really not that bad but the Game of Thrones one is just if you're the Starks you're coming from the door that's the only way you're coming down so yeah this one is a little bit more free-flowing I think they learned from that in the setup also where it's like you know set up elsewhere yeah yeah and then you kind of spot me mr. B yeah I'm started down there so but once again you're still mainly and yeah you don't really have to defend your your area you need to tell you don't [ __ ] I want to live down up there the mountains suck great and then you just start coming down here um that's pretty much that's all I got I would agree I guess honestly for

complaint wise I never felt at one point that anything was Opie I never thought that anything was unfair right right yeah this uh did you feel that the the that the clans were different did you feel like that yeah just make ability I mean are they powered his [ __ ] I realize he's hurt funny enough only happened once true and I was like look we're to happen and at the very end and I was like you suck because once you place it there I was like wait it's defined us that like she made her two shinobi and she's gonna win that tie and I can't defend it because I needed the reason why I didn't defend that was because I needed to defend this because I was like well with my blessing I waited last I would I think my to know B was either first to last I'm not getting called out like he's gonna be like hopefully I'm I'm surprised I was so happy to you took out her thing into the because I thought you were gonna take I was like damn easy still has those cards completely forgot that you didn't use your cards well I kept your bonus I was like my shinobi which you would have tied with him I did mainly I didn't make me forget about that part yeah I think I was caught up in like oh I don't want to waste it this wouldn't eat me actually cousin would've had this additional to with it top of the pot you're right she hadn't been one under me yeah actually

26:25 223 yeah I mainly I mainly just kind of do what I do with every new game that I play I just kind of accidentally forget about it right right I yeah I took those cards okay so speaking of which I think that the claims are different enough I don't think their way to the Matic to where someone's gonna be broken you just get a slight ability somewhere that's not always good well like mine just allowed me to draw an additional token side a little bit more control but it's no it's no like inherent like obvious that oh well you're using your ability if you don't know what I'm drawing right so this is like it did help cuz I always I never really had weak tokens I don't know I halfway through the game I realized oh wait a minute I'm pushing my weak - these aren't coming back once these tokens are gone they're gone so I was gonna be like oh I was here ground five I was gonna have ones like I [ __ ] up because I didn't realize that and Igor's was was ties which made it very weary kind of thematic you'd really think about it hey I really don't want to mess with the crane because they're gonna [ __ ] me up and that's what I really love because I feel like the cranes was not like whoa that's thematic but like very appropriate because with the you know new wind ties because basically I just think of it like they have silver tongue they talk to you out of it kind of [ __ ] like that they I need to told you and kill you yeah challenge your champion yeah I've trained all my life in this one singular purpose and you who have practiced in

just better battlefield combat that was amazing because I played it and then you were like oh we only have one and I was staring at my second one and I was like oh god something yeah combat I'm glad the combat Toby's all the same - because okay go use your rate doesn't really through about another rate and then you guys didn't notice I have a high blessing yeah you oh now we know to play him face up even matter really anyway because once you did something it was like oh okay hey yeah I can't [ __ ] with it because you told me there's a blessing there so it just it didn't really matter a lot your ability I'm trying to figure out how it's the Matic you know well because they're they're all horsemen that's the whole follow that they they move so rad yeah they can I see they can fans Lee quickly reinforce an area while yeah give you like and you guys like your ability like mine yeah and it worked very well for my play style I mean we're just coincidentally how if that's really how it works like if you Bluff into an area I don't feel like what you get a bonus it said neutral areas get bonuses like natural bonuses because especially because most the time you're getting like most I meet you would control it no into the lines all afterwards yeah like

it's like he's like if I still placed like a defense like a bluff there but I still control this area why wouldn't I get that bonus already because it's basically you just talking [ __ ] like yeah that's right so I can understand like a bluff if you played at something I mean you could I didn't realize even play Bluffs has shinobi as well where you just place it and it's like oh [ __ ] that's a really I didn't realize how strategic that no Bluff token is you did I was sitting there and I was like [ __ ] you can I only held that one I was trying to do my objective and I was like okay I think I'm good I think I'm good there and then I wasted everything didn't matter anyway because you raided that was it right here place one at the last second you guys were like it's a [ __ ] done you really think that wasn't diplomacy and I'm like [ __ ] you guys were freaking out like that's gonna screw my attack over because that's how I'm good because I realized because I was down here really quick I was in here really quick and I'm so we're hearing here really and in there at the beginning of the game so the only two places I have left was here or the only place I had left was there I was like okay that's how it that's you only wait and get in what you said wasn't diplomacy I was like [ __ ] that's gonna I can't get in again and then that's what I use my scallop to look then whenever he was well I throw I tried to throw him off I'd be like [ __ ] you yeah well I was gonna get out but then I think you should change in me I did soo Jin Jin Yeah right man what [ __ ] up with was I was gonna bail I was gonna swap it with my wife and just leave the fluffs there right right because and that's why I choose ended

because I was like who the wife's you Jinja your defense or her attacker fits of diplomacy so I have to look at it so speaking of which let's go to the card play which I also really really like like the fact that hey everyone gets to Scouts and everyone gets lunch you Jinja you know that they all do the same thing there's no secret oh oh p-card that no one else got to get right um except for these yeah by taking it over so the scouts are like this game is just so very very useful in all of its actions so if there's no waste I mean because if you get a scout then even if you know it's a bluff you're like okay well that's the one time I get to use it now one-time use is very interesting I think makes it very important and makes them makes us even an even more just a layer of strategy but it doesn't add like input like an a priori it's not this isn't a brain burning game where you're laying all these cards means something right and so I really like that and the surge in you is like fine this one time I only get to use it be worth it and so I I think that's that's really cool I think that was that Shadowlands card we just tossed more years I'll - there's that one and it was like a four and a five from bottom I was like I thought you were gonna take out two of mine but you broke it up and I was like okay I mean I sorry I got the

bottom line that was raised from the dead okay well here he is again right back now it was fun to watch and I'm just soaking feel like yeah yeah it sounds like the rules made it seem like there's gonna be a way stronger penalty like Oh lose ten points or so you know I figured it'd have to do with something like - an honor if you do yeah negative on earth yeah that's why I was like why would you go there like mom really wasn't actually too strong cards so you get a meaty yeah mine wasn't even a that bad it was hey take a control out of a shadow province and I was like okay you don't get honored for it anyway so that's no that's a no-brainer bring my five back yeah [ __ ] you telling this I could surrender Shadowlands card block my shadow but still her cap because I well it still did kind of screw me over because I had to bring my five back he said I was gonna bring back my diplomacy to hold down another area which I I mean it's due it's because in hindsight it's like it would've been nice to hold mine their from the raid but then I wouldn't have been able to get into the crane thing with my five like I did so the card play and the territory is awesome because you can play you can go back and forth and play and we kind of messed up there with the where we played them but I don't think it made the get through the game mechanics favor but yeah you pass until unless someone plays and if you play no one then they just until everyone passes well like the

way there's some of those cars rate you can't really use my very beginning like the Shadowlands car like you can't burn characters on the up key so the Shadowlands one it doesn't beat both of those safest aren't your placement thing okay the other ones the territory ones here are during the upkeep phase and all of those were placing those special tokens so that's why um that's how I lock this down because like oh I need to play this now so you like that can you not bring your wiper with a red and a piece oh I wasn't certain I was asked that but anyone get away with it right well I say it yeah because I was like old there's no way I can attack I did read it it says the only way to remove these special tokens is with a rare piece right so you could have done it I mean if you were 18 because I if you had known me you probably would have read it earlier well I didn't want to read there because I would oh yeah yeah music Apple so though I am happy piece this one I think that would believe me know is here I could take the other two and then oh so I definitely just as soon as that happened it was over for you you still could have done yours you could expand this way and so that was that was destroyed you could have spanned around them oh no that was beat yes that was nice you could have gone nothing although you still have a few options mine was probably the only one that was feasible until the very end and I knew it when I read it I was like

maybe yeah this give me the last moment so territory cards are awesome because you can lose them like you don't use them they might take your territory oh yeah that's true so speaking of that I also want to say about the other cards I really like the secret objectives I always like secret objective see it kind of gives you a goal they're gonna just attack and just to attack you haven't drive I wonder why you oh I guess they were already yeah they're not thematic they're just later you're just happen to be attack the crane oh but you get six on there because at the end of the game if you control either the crank Apple over two provinces in the crane territory you earned six honor so you could have if you had taken these two you would have gotten six honor and then plus your 4c was broke out of ten if you had taken these to you we've got an 11 told mine that would have gotten 10 and cap would have gotten 10 just for doing it so it looks like the secret effect is also a different you know ability points what do you guys think of the first player how I like to remember what yeah so what they do is everyone who's playing um actually so the way the setup works is actually heavy notes mine wasn't in there yeah never setup starts who ever gets drawn first their cart gets removed because they're never gonna be first player again almost heaven you know be a

tiebreaker but like yeah it just went to master Texas which happened to me me because we start there and then there's only four cards so he's got to change each each round I also like that a lot I think everything they did so far we've talked about has just been balanced very well right right I can't think of a single thing that throws it in any in anyone's favor because the even the territory cards are not they're good and they're very useful and they helped you but everyone pretty much will get a chance hello what was the crab crab added the harbor the lion added oh [ __ ] a +4 honor token oh it actually covers a eight places printed value so I got that I could have placed it there now it's worth four and the unicorn was promised to you control and a province controlled by an opponent you swap your control tokens and with all control tokens in the opponent's problems Mike yep so cultural exchanges over here now okay so so yeah so they're all they're all good and they're not just titanium you know hey I'm the unicorn so I get the unicorn territory that's what I thought it was that's why I did all of mine on crane here touring you're like oh we let her have the crane all cycle of course it's my idiot oriented do you think this game lacked because we have three people and it plays up to five and thanks so much I felt pretty involved constantly right

right yeah there was never like a moment where it would be a lot would be very interesting to find there's to be a [ __ ] medically yeah it's like if any number people like kind of like rally together and they get certain [ __ ] [ __ ] but then you're gonna hopefully rally with someone else to help you I like the territory or the control I really like that hey you're getting what you get and once you use them they're gone I really like that with the combat tokens I like how there's there is a lot but it's not like dice luck where you just like hosi okay and you're gonna eventually get your strong yeah rally yeah you know so you're never screwed the entire game I like its thematic it's like you can't just stay here and go oh oh oh you know the swarm one border yeah and say oh I play yeah yeah so it's just one token per border and you if you're being attacked you can only defend you can't like really attack back cuz it makes sense because it's like one token is essentially in a party so it's like your armies aren't gonna cross each other you're gonna meet in the area I think is really really smart because that was also a different element a strategy I thought were like she would she play some token I was like oh [ __ ] I can't go I can't go around so it's like okay this whole because I would like my Shinto once again that message into my shinobi I couldn't break out this way because I couldn't come this way because she defended it like and I'm like okay well

I can't go because you were gonna defend it so much nobody was the anyway so they definitely made it to where you're not stuck and this game's brilliant i/o complaint but it's a good complaint which doesn't make the complaint I want more like there's only two territory cards for each area and there's only two of each for these so I just want more of these like I just want more you know cards more special objectives I just want it doesn't even doesn't need to add any more clans has all the main clans come from antis but they just got added as a clan and the lore they don't like to change they just want more variety within the cards it was my same complaint with cry havoc if you remember that the game is really good I just want more versatility with just the side stuff the strategy I love so anything else you guys think of a slight artwork it is really good they definitely got that feudal Japan look so yeah oh it's also I'm very important even mention this way this game's not that long this game did you know he said it was gonna take about 90 minutes for three players and it took we started at nine and we ended at ten to twenty five yeah yeah and I do love that when a game actually says god it's time right picadome pisses me off more than being like like something gonna be an hour in three hours later I'm sitting here and

I'm pissed off yeah cuz it's not like whenever you're doing battling it's just flip flip oh hey there's a three-to-two I mean there's no dice early yeah there's no okay so this is gonna happen yeah but I got oh well I gotta fly small efficient yeah yeah yeah this explodes and then it's just it's just so quick so streamlined so scale one to ten yeah you know I didn't really do it for me why also that I'd without--without probably understand like Oh hold on I do have one more question you said nine though do you think that this game is only a niche game do you think you have to know more or helps yeah I think the reason why most people because not a lot of people are in this world in fancy flies just bringing it out and making it popular and it's games growing but yeah I was wondering if I would only like this game because I were in a write if it wasn't I mean think okay I'm not gonna write it as if I didn't because I am in it so I can only I've only loved it for like audits strictly for that yeah like I wasn't what I I haven't played a legend of the Five Rings as much as you guys have I had to quit and I don't know as much lore as you do all

I know is that the cranes were very much like me they're very stubborn they're very pompous yeah they're very passive-aggressive and so I really only knew it for me and I think I think as long as you have like general background information you will enjoy a bike I still think that without it you would still enjoy it okay okay obviously 10 perfect five average one it's not even a game it's like it literally doesn't work as I do it 18.5 really well did you give an acronym nine so that's that's why it went high that I actually expected field I expect it to be a little bit hotter do you want more of it I don't know I just you think you want to play it more I might have to yeah I just felt like maybe you it's very easy to learn super basic concept you know do you think an Akron is growing on you and you want more meat I know you want more brain Bernie it is it is just expect cuz I'm engaged I just there's just that slight bit is this maybe okay I'd say that's fair I think I know where you're talking about lights I don't know and there's so do you like a zest for me so I understand yeah it's just there's somebody I think I'm already talking about there is something about it that still is just not help I all right I'm

gonna give it a 9.5 like I really like this I actually like this better than an acronym surprisingly only only and the reason why I keep bringing up in Akron is when we just played it into because I gave that a 9 and that was that's a really good game but I think for the strategy that's escape oh then we gave me the same element of strategy buddy because it gave me the same this is quicker then wrong I'm like I said I really like an ACME I like I like the theme but I also really love this world so yeah it's just enough and there's just enough difference between the players that were not just doing the same thing like tokens are different slightly that now if we play that you know continue to play more we know she has more diplomacy you have more trade I have no blessing so that brings in more strategy so it's just it this this was a definite hit for me so nine point five eight point five and nine that's it everyone so that's our thoughts on battle for Roper gone let me know what you think in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoy the video if you want to support us you can go ahead and click that link to go to my patreon account if you have any suggestions you can go ahead and click the link in the show notes below the girl of my BoardGameGeek list other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of data is for you

Progress saved