We Finally Played Blood on the Clocktower!
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vessel.
I'm Z Garcia.
I'm Joey Evans.
And I'm Chris Ye.
One of the biggest games to come out in the past 5 years is a um game called Blood on the Clock Tower, which is a social deduction game that is based on werewolf. and in fact is more based on werewolf than I thought when I finally played it.
Yes.
Um but was incredibly popular and has almost at conventions
dominated the social deduction games that are there. I
think we can all agree on it. Definitely
there's pretty much like a dedicated space where it's going to be played most evenings if not most during like most of a day.
Yes.
Yeah. Now, I've I didn't play it when it first came out, and then it became tricky to get the game played because the problem that we ran into was twofold. One,
it's hard to get into a game when it seems like everyone we knew either had never played it before, right,
or played it 700 billion lives it. Yeah. Living it.
And two, the people who were living it were not making a good impression on me. And that's the most positive way I can put it,
right? like problems stem up from B clockw things at conventions and stuff and I and I also when you would talk to it was almost like an evangelical thing like you play B player and it does not
sway me to that if that makes sense.
I agree it's a lifestyle game. It's become a lifestyle game where that lifestyle looks terrifying from the outside looking in.
So we got lucky at the Daire Retreat. Um, Joey talked to Ross. Did he bring it up to you or you brought it up to him?
I brought it up to him in the fact that this probably won't happen. I was like, I'll mention it, Tom, but odds are we're not going to do it. And then for some reason, I was like, yeah, why not? I got time.
I was like, wait, what?
But because I knew who Ross was and he was a really nice guy and he promised that he would keep the diehard fans out of our game.
Yes.
Which I felt for the most part happened. There was a couple people in our game who really knew the game more than everyone else. And they were fine. Everybody we played with was great.
Yeah, it was kind of an ideal first impression game I think for for all of us. I
agree.
Uh and so yeah, I think you know to say not that we didn't want to play with experienced people, but we wanted it to be a good dive in like first step into the game.
Yeah,
I think it's natural to want that feel. I don't necessarily want to learn Magic the Gathering from a pro tour player. I don't I'm going to feel bad.
They're they're hampered. They're dealing with an ignoramus for all intents and purposes and I'm feeling way behind the curve. So, I don't think it's a tall order to want that
and I do think everyone involved and especially Ross did a fantastic job facilitating that. They really did.
Yeah.
So, Ross started explaining the game to us and essentially in a nutshell the game there's two teams, the the bad guys and the good guys in in the village. It's a It's kind of like werewolf except they're demons instead of werewolves. And there is a demon
and that demon is trying to kill everyone in the village and the village is trying not to get killed.
But everyone in the game has a role has some sort of special power something. And when you die in this game, you're not dead. Those are the two major noticeable differences.
Also, there's a lot
dead. You're not eliminated is the difference.
You're dead. Not eliminated. Right. I'm sorry.
You can keep talking. I guess you have like one more vote at some point. We're going to speak in obvious in broad strokes here. So, yes, some of the things that you said are maybe technically not 100% correct. We're not trying to dive into the depth.
We don't want to ruin it for you. Um,
yeah.
No, but what I will say is when he was first explaining the roles to us, which I then found out was like the easiest set.
Yes.
Yes.
I was I started feeling like I was starting to go underwater for a moment. I don't know if you guys when he was starting to go over I was like,
"Wow, these are not some of these roles were not simple."
No. some one role was just adds two more people to the campaign and I was like that that's that that's a but I I I was like okay I think how these roles work was not obvious either like when you play werewolf you have the sear each the seir points to someone and and you say they're a werewolf or they're not a werewolf this one's like you point to two people one of them might be bad if you weren't poisoned and aren't drunk and yada yada yada yada yada and I was like wow That's a lot to take in.
One difference I see between this and werewolf. Um obviously they're very similar. Don't anyone tell you otherwise, but um it's the whole thing is werewolf is one that if you play it differently, people that play werewolf like, "Oh, that's a cool variation." But if you do something in Blood the Clock Tower differently, they're like, "You don't play it right." You know, I've seen that like on some people's playthroughs like, "Oh, no one there played it right." You know, cuz there are a lot of little finicky rules that if you get them wrong, some of the die hards are like, "Well, no, you shouldn't do it that way." To be fair, a lot of this is rest on the head of the person running it.
100%.
And and I
I can't imagine playing I mean Ross has to work for me now be my but if I play it again he was so good.
Yes.
And he kept it moving. The nights were quick.
The nights were quick. The discussion phase during the day. He didn't let them get too carried away. Uh and I think that that's part of the thing because one of the the impressions I had going into this was, "Hey, Chris, do you want to jump into this game below in the clock tower?" Do I really want to spend three hours of the con doing this? Right. And it was not three hours.
It was 90 minutes, right?
Yeah. Yeah. It was good. It was
plus the teach, right? Because if you have a good person who's able to run it and given people enough time to breathe and to discuss, but who also kind of says, "Hey, it's time to kind of wrap up here in just a minute or two."
I think that that'll keep the game moving. I I liked the fact that there was more of that um unreliability because I do think in werewolf if someone is the seer and they point at someone and that person generally speaking they get a yes back from them they're a werewolf. I mean yeah there's a role that misleads you but if you know you're the seer
you're going to get a correct read on that. I do like in this that idea of maybe you do know who you are but somebody else canceled your power or right something happened because then it allows way more sort of hiding among the crowd by going well maybe what you saw happen didn't quite happen. I like that idea a little bit. It does run into the same exact problem that Werewolf has at the beginning, that two rooms in a boom has at the beginning, which is when we get to that first discussion and they're like, "Okay, floor's open." Everyone just stares at each other going,
"What? What do we do now?"
Right. It's all
You want to tell me who you are? I do not.
Yes.
Cuz you know what I mean? Like, why would I?
I don't get that at all. And I I've yet to find I was hoping this honestly would be the one the way it's spoken of that would find a way to prime that pump.
Yeah.
You know, the only game I know that can do it and it's kind of like this is uh Deception Murder in Hong Kong, right?
There's discussion there right away because you're looking at stuff and then going that fits, that fits. Yeah, okay. Maybe not you.
But none of these other games managed to do that. at the first day. After that though,
yeah, but like literally at the beginning it's like someone going,
nominate this guy to die. Why? Cuz we got to get the game going. That sucks. That's a terrible feeling. I don't like that at all. And and can't quite fathom how it hasn't been solved really that problem. But also, if you don't, as the town's folk nominate someone to die, then you're just going to go to night phase and the demons will kill someone. So, it it kind of feels like, well, mathematically, it's better to just take a shot in the dark cuz we might accidentally get one,
right? It just feels bad.
Well, what did what did you all think about the fact that the person who runs the game can kind of
tilt it a bit to keep it even?
I think that's interesting. It makes it a little bit more of a DMing session kind of. It's like a it's like a role playinging session a little bit.
Um,
and and from what I understand, people who run the game really lean into that, right? Because they can make the set the game in like a medieval town and tell you this lavish long story, which is why sometimes the game goes forever,
right?
They can also set it in modern times. They set it in the future if they want to, right? It's sort of werewolf is about this one town. There's werewolves, it's in the past, what have you. This one's an RPG kind of. I think that's cool.
I think it also makes it very DM obviously dependent where they're just not telling the story cuz they can deviate the story depending on what happens. So, you have to have somebody that
is doing it for the experience of the players, not of themselves.
You know, you get one that loves the sound of their own voice, they're going to drag it out and just do funny things for them. So, someone that plays just just like a DM plays for those people. Well, it's wild that you know, so one of the roles is the drunkard who uh who is given is told that they are a specific role, not the drunkard, and everything they do is going to be pretty much wrong, right? Oh, I learned this. I learned this during the night phase, yada yada. If the village is doing so poorly, the person running the game can just give the drunkard correct information. And that's kind of a funny little bit, right? Like broken clock, write twice a day type of a thing, right? If he just really feels like, okay, these demons are just crushing these guys. Let's let's a little bit into it kind of prime that team with a little more information.
Right.
On that note, um we killed the head demon. Um but then
we got a liar
smeared across the board. Z
and
were the other two bad guys and they f No, I'm sorry. They I thought they fold us. I I suspect Z as a matter of course. It's unfortunate and I definitely said
I did not. But near the end of like I think he's actually a good guy here.
Yeah. There's that
there's that rule that like if the demon dies and there's enough players left and it it reverted to my role the woman
with the red lips or something. I don't know what it is.
Scarlet lady.
But then we almost ended it in the first night too.
That's true. It would have been a weird one if we kill the
angel
angel or virgin or something like that and the game just it's over.
Yeah. The um
what was it? Angel. was an angel. Angel. Yeah. Or whatever her name was. The W of the wings. Yeah.
But they were poisoned, so the power didn't work. So the village killing them didn't end the game. And immediately
I like that stuff happening. You don't get that kind of from werewolves.
Right. Right. Sure. The problem is is when not a problem, but
I it was interesting me were figuring out, but there was also someone saying, "Well, this this if this is this and this and this, then you are this." And I'm like,
"Yes, that is correct." And the more you play, that's why I want to play with people who are in the same level as me. We play most of the people had played one other game.
That's where it comes apart because there were certain things I did not get. If I had someone that played a billion times and be like, "No, no, no, no." And they would have 100% alpha the entire thing and told you all this. So I equal playing field was huge with that game.
Yeah. Yeah, but that but it it leans into that idea of how much of this game is about deception and how much of it is about deduction. And
I think that's the thing. I went into it with the impression that it was more of a deduction game
because there's a lot of roles that give information and people who say those things where they kind of solve things out and there is a good amount of that. But the fact that the the person running the game can give false information and there can be you know poisoning of roles so that information was wrong or didn't activate when it was supposed to. Uh I think it gives more power to the demon team to be able to deceive. And if you like that, if you really like deceiving people, I think this game gives you a lot of good tools to do that
more than just werewolf, especially vanilla werewolf where people just kind of accusing each other, right? The more roles you throw into it. Yeah, there's more information. Maybe I don't know, maybe you guys would disagree with me, but that's kind of the that's the how I felt after our first play. Well, I mean definitely in werewolf that's one of the negatives of were I love werewolf but most people are just villagers and
most people have no power role nothing. You exist in the game as a player and hope not to die and hope to let's be fair guess at the wrong at the bad player. I mean that's kind of it. It does feel good
to have some ability no matter what it is. It could be really dumb. It could be a tiny little thing.
I like that. I like that very much. You could do that with werewolf. In fact, a lot of the roles in this game as he was describing them going down the list. I'm like, that's kind of like in Werewolf. That one's exactly like in Werewolf. This idea of like you don't reveal who died. That's a variant in Werewolf. You know, you can play like that. So, I just think it's weird that this game caught on with such fervor
and it is 95% werewolf and the other 5% is a big book. Okay. Yes.
I don't get it. I don't get the the fervor and I don't get why the like what about it
hit at the right time with the right thing that just caught fire, you know?
I got to tell you one before you talk about the book. I think you mentioned that. But um the book like you you were enamored with that book. But um
I think the book is dumb.
It's Oh well, it goes a different enamored me. Um, I I misread that situation, but I will say it suffers from the same fragility as far as So, I mentioned so many times it's group dependent. We had the perfect group, but if you have those people that get angry when it's like, "No, I'm telling you the truth. Oh my goodness, I'm so mad cuz you're not believing me." Or if you kill someone, they're like, "Why would you kill me?" We had the ideal group. We kill someone and they're like, "A man." And they go on.
I've had those problems with werewolf. What you would have here are those people that go way over the top. Why would you kill me? I'm so angry. Believe me? Why don't you believe me?
Minor note here. One of the things I like about werewolf is when someone's really annoying like that.
Do you really?
They get killed and they're out of the game. Here you're killed and you can still yell for the rest of the game.
That is a good point. Which makes that negative that is amplifies that.
No, it's really a truth, right? I mean specifically and I I mean I'm not going to beat around the bush. I when I said we played this, there were some people I did not want to play with for that reason.
Yeah.
Sure. Um, but no, you said the book I do think it's neat that they has all that information, but that book could have been half that size easily. Half that size.
We don't Maybe not. Maybe some of those roles require some serious upkeep. Who knows? We did play just that
in No, I'm saying it doesn't need to be that thick. It could have been thin.
Yeah. Yeah. I don't know what the book thing's about. It's just it's he he puts I guess players pieces in there to keep track of what's what.
I don't know. Um, yeah, relative and seating order. So, he's got all the information that's maybe a mistake. And I asked him about that, like afterwards, you know, what if you do make a mistake and he's like, well, you just do your best to fix it.
Like if you said something wrong, he'd pull people aside and say, I told you something wrong or just change things to fix it. But
the onus, I mean, it it is there's so much on that person. Like you asked me or someone asked like Tom, I bet you would want to run this. I don't know.
Yeah, that's a lot. I I think I was okay playing it and putting my trust that everything because that's a lot to keep track of. Werewolf is a lot simpler and I've made mistakes running that.
Yes. Yes.
Yeah.
My question is, did you enjoy the experience?
Do you like the game? Would you play it again?
Those are three good questions.
You want me to answer them?
I did enjoy it, but again, I thought it was a perfect storm.
Yes.
Uh Joy alluded to that. Um what was your other question?
Do you like the game? I like the game fine, but I also feel like I liked it the first time when it was called Werewolf, right?
I don't know if it was different enough. It's possible that the hype for the game and I put this on people who've hyped it, not on me. I'm I wasn't like, "Oo, I can't wait. I haven't been building it up. They've been building it up." I think when I finally got around to playing it, I was like, "Oh, where's the revolutionary part of this? Why did it catch on the way it did?"
Mhm. And as far as if I would play it again, I don't know. I feel no I feel no drive right now to play it again. Kind of. But but you know, half of that is probably because I don't want to sully what's been a really good run,
if only a run of one,
you know what I mean?
Sure.
I think I'd say I didn't particularly like it, right? I see its merits. I see it's incredibly well well made. The fact that all those roles kind of work together and that's one recommended set I think is an impressive thing to do. And then you have there are multiple sets in there. The to the production the tokens with the felt on the back. I wasn't expecting that when he was like reach into the bag, pull out your roll. The side with the felt is the back. Like you're going to have to explain what that sentence means cuz I wasn't expecting like oh there's actually felt fabric on these tokens so he can stick it on the book and keep it in place and keep everything organized. That's tremendous. That's really cool. The book
the the what?
Flannelraphph.
Okay. Uh the but at the end of the day, I didn't really care for it. I thought the information was too nebulous, which is once again first impressions of it, right? I think that other social deduction games kind of pushed the envelope a little bit more, right? Games like Secret Hitler that have kind of this more tangible uh information track there. You can kind of see the tension build up with that central board or good cop bad cop where you look and reveal people's role cards and stuff. I feel like that gives me more towards my taste of what I like in social deduction games. The last one that really impressed me was probably uh the ship one, Feed the Kraken.
All right.
I know I'm very picky in the genre. I was I was hopeful that I would like this game more
and kind of like what Z said, it's it feels very familiar. It's impressive at what it does, but it is a lot of familiar ground at the same time.
Yeah. Yeah. Um I I like the experience and like really what Z said, this was the perfect situation. And because of that, I'm like it's kind of feels like to me one of those I ticked that box, you know, I played it. Awesome. I have no desire to play it again. I'm not interested enough in the other roles. People say, "Oh, but there's so many new roles. There's this pirate that comes in as a ghost." I'm like, "Sweet." But it's like, no, I don't want I I'm not that interested in it. I enjoy the experience and I'm glad I did it. I kind of viewed it as an escape room. I'm like, sweet, did it done, you know, move maybe I'll play it again in several years. I think you had a good point in the deception versus um deduction. I did also think it would fix that huge problem in Werewolf of the meandering around for the first 15 minutes. It does not. You know, there is it is all about is this person lying?
It is. You get a little bit of information. Sometimes you don't have the right information. So, it's all about who's a liar, you know? So, it's good, which is fine, you know. It's great. It leans in the but it is it is 95% werewolf. So, I played it. I'm glad I played it. Would I play it again? Maybe someday. It's not high on my to-do list, though. I really liked it. Like, I really liked it. I liked everything about it. To be fair, a lot of that was the people we were playing.
That's the thing. I stacked the deck by bringing my friends, you know.
Oh, I would play again. One of them's a liar.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Um Joey.
No, I was not. Um I liked that information. I agree. The very first day was a little bit like eh. But it that first nomination then the person said, "I'm an angel if you kill me." And then we killed her and then she wasn't. And then I was like, "Now we're off.
Now we know something." And people started saying stuff and I I thought from that point on I sat there the whole time. I felt like a detective trying to figure out. I knew I was innocent probably. um and trying to figure out who the bad people were and was the person we killed a bad person. I wasn't sure and I loved it. I I was engrossed the whole time and I would love to see more roles. I'd love to see more of this. I just don't know that I'm going to even though I had an amazing time. I'm kind of where Z is at. Like I don't want to
ruin this.
I don't want to play a bad experience at this now. There's also a lot of people that I I actually there's some people I don't want to play with anyone who's an alpha gamer and I know that I trend close to that being an alpha gamer, but there are people even more so and I don't want them telling me how to play the game the whole time.
I also don't want to play this game with anyone who thinks it's funny
to be chaotic on purpose,
right?
Cuz they would ruin it. They would straight up ruin the game and they'd be like, "Oh, I'm the imp, but I'm just going to kill that person because it's funny." No, you should kill the person that helps you win,
right? Uh, and also the the the dungeon master. I don't know what they're called in this game. The clockmaster.
The clock master. Yeah, the CM.
Yeah. So much depends in our heads.
Ross did a 10 out of 10 job in my opinion. Agree. Then the night that first night we put our heads on, I thought all these powers are off. So I peeked at my watch and I'm like, I'm going to time this.
And 30 seconds later, he's like,'s over. And I was like,
incredible.
That's amazing.
Yeah.
Because I read somewhere that people were like, yeah, your heads are down for 10 minutes. I'm like, "Oh man, that sucks."
That's the thing. I had my I had my power. I had to open my eyes and it's like 20 seconds in, he's tapping
and I go back down like, "Wow, that was so quick. He was so fast around there."
I I bet with a less experienced CM and a less like someone who's patch. Yeah. I I could see this game being an issue cuz someone said to me before I played, they're like, "Uh, I don't want to play any game again where my eyes are shut more than they're open." And that was not my experience.
Not at all. Not even close,
right?
But I could see if that night phase takes a while and you don't have anything to do, you are going to be checked out for a bit. So once again, great play group, great uh CM Ross, you know, thank you for that.
Yeah,
and I know we'll probably get some thumbs down here because a we didn't say the game was the greatest game ever. I really did enjoy it and I and I don't agree actually. I disagree with the 95% where I think it's like 70 at most. I think there's a lot of difference. The fact you're still alive, you can vote once. I think that stuff's cool and I think it makes a big difference
to the point I got killed pretty early on and I was like, "Oh, bummer. My power would have been really useful." So, the night phase came and I just sat there with my eyes open. I went, "Oh, whoa, whoa, no, no, no. I don't have to just sit here and watch it happen. I have to keep you got to keep playing." Yeah. Yep. So, you cheated. You're saying you're admitting it.
Well, like a second in I saw everyone close their eyes. I was like, "That person's dead. I have to close my eyes." So, I caught it really fast. So,
but what I'm saying is I mean
I think the biggest enemy I bought on the clock tower is the player base in many ways. And there's wonderful players. I know this because we met many of them. Yeah.
But I've met many of the others. In fact, I'm probably have to delete comments off this video of people coming in and tell us what losers we are cuz we didn't play it right or what have you.
Oh.
And I don't think that helps the game.
No.
Um but I'm glad I played it. Will I play it again?
Probably. But I look at it as an experience. Like I played it this year.
Yeah.
Maybe next year. and I'll be another situation I'll go why not but I have to be in that mood.
I cannot imagine playing it twice in a row because my anxiety stress which not a bad thing necessarily but just I was like the whole game when we were done I was like okay now I'm going to go eat lunch.
Yeah.
I just need to do something that's not keeping me that stress for a while. And I think people are going to say, "Why are you guys talking about it after just playing it one time and everything?" Because there's a lot of people who haven't played it yet and who want to see a first impression. And it's cool to see different takes on the first impression. I I think of this group I probably enjoyed it the least
and it sounds like
you guys enjoyed the
We did playing.
Yeah. Yeah, I did. Yeah, for sure. Yeah. I wasn't sure what to expect, but
and what I got wasn't quite
different enough, you know what I mean? But but I enjoyed it. Yeah, once it started rolling it was just I was so fascinated and I was almost sad that it ended but I also thought we had a rollick and good ending.
Great. I mean the sitting there going I don't know what to do and I was like come on just make a decision not knowing she was evil.
She knew what she was going to do the entire such a liar.
I was so that as soon as that he had asked her face completely changed and I was like I've been duped.
That was oh man. But but also I felt during the game there was several moments where we as the villagers made some goofs.
Yes.
Yeah. And with repeat plays
killing Chris.
We Yes.
No. You were killed by the bad guy.
I assume the demons killed me, right?
It wasn't me.
Did I kill you? Uh
who did I kill? I was the demon only like one night or two.
This is all admissible to me, by the way.
I killed you.
Yeah, cuz I was the fourth person. It was
Oh, there you go. Well, maybe I killed you
because it was very obvious I was a towns person at that point. There was no
hiding it. In fact, I turned my badge around. I was like, I know I'm dead.
I became a demon really, really late in the game. Like at the absolute last moment, it would have worked. Actually,
I killed the demon one one turn later. It doesn't go to me yet. It doesn't go to me anymore.
Oh, interesting. Wow.
Okay.
Well, see, and that probably makes sense if you not seen it, but there's a lot more to it. So, that's our thoughts on B and the clock tower. Stop asking us about it. Anyway, we had a good time. Thank you, Ross. You did a great job and everyone we played with.
Yeah.
All right, folks. That's it. I'm Tom.
I'm Z.
I'm Joey.
And I'm Chris.
Demon.
Demon. Yes.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Hour YouTube channel.