Carson City Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general in this video we're going to be talking about a western themed euro we're going to be talking about carson city and in this game you'll be buying plots of land in the wild wild west you'll be building buildings taking actions that will eventually allow you to buy victory points that will allow you to win the game and in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we tell you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not carson city is worth your time and borrow today and in the future so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below we'll see you after this
bollocks so to start again you put the game board out in the center of the table and every player is going to get 15 one revolver one road 12 property title and three cowboys and what you do you dump the excess cowboys into a reserve next to where you put all your other stuff yeah so now you need to figure out where you're going to stick the start in building you're going to roll both the black and the white die and you'll see that each die corresponds to one of the axis the x-axis or the y-axis i can never remember which one's which but you roll both dice and then you'll come to a point in the middle and you'll stick the starting building on that spot right you'll then stick nine mountains on the board in the same way you'll stick the revolver token on its spot on board and then you put the turn counter on the star position so castle city is a game that is divided into four rounds and there'll be four phases in each of the rounds first phase is you're going to be able to choose a personality the second phase consists of you sticking your cowboys on the board the next phase is where you will take any actions and perform any jewels that arise as a result of taking the actions and then you do a little bit of boring end of round cleanup right so the first phase the phase where you're going to choose one of the personalities you'll just look at the available personalities and then you will take one right you might have the sheriff and the player helped by the sheriff gets a special sheriff cowboy from the general reserve and this allows him to select one action without fear of being attacked right well you might have the banker and apart from being a wanker
when you choose the banker you immediately receive nine dollars then you've got the chinese cooley oh for [ __ ] sake when you choose the chinese callie you immediately receive two roads in addition the price of any building is half or you might have the captain and the player helped by the captain immediately pays one dollar to get an extra cowboy from the general reserve or four dollars to get two extra cowboys from the reserve or nine dollars to get very [ __ ] cowboys from the reserve [ __ ] hell mush so all of these personalities add a little bit of flavor to the game when you take them they're going to break the game in a good way right so next thing you're going to do is you're going to be able to place your cowboys onto the board you've got several options when you do this you can choose a parcel of land in which case you'll stick one of your cowboys on that land and also reserve that parcel of landfall later you can choose one of the actions on the board we'll go through them in a sec when i've stopped babbling on about this [ __ ] you can attack or defend a building in which case you'll place one of cowboys on a building and that will allow you to attack it right or you can pass if you are a cowardly bottling bastard so now i'm going to do something really really boring if you get bored just fast forward i'm going to tell you what actions you can do right you can take the wages action and this means that you can't have a duel on a square which we'll talk about a little bit but each player receives four dollars for each of his cowboys on this square you've got the ammunitions space where you'll take the free revolver token and this will bolster your ability to defend yourself or attack people later on in the game you'll take the roads where you'll get three roads to place on the board at any time during the game you get the the crappy roads title that lets you take one road you've got the parcel
purchase this will always take place regardless of whether anyone's on it or not you can actually can't put anyone on it so it will always take place right and this is where you'll be able to purchase the parcel of land that we talked about earlier you'll take one of your plot tiles and you'll stick it on this space but you'll have to pay the amount of money depending on how many things are around it like mountains and [ __ ] like that then you've got a building construction right there's seven of these and each giving you the right to pick a building at the price indicator and when you take one you'll slide them all down and then you refill it like you do in all the other bleeding euro games right and then you'll place the tile that you took and you put it on a parcel of land that you own you've got parcels income and this says that you get two dollars for every parcel of land that you own you've got the cowboy income and this means you'll get two dollars for each firepower point you've got then you've got the gambling income you'll roll two dice and you'll receive the amount that you rolled on the two dice right then you've got another one of these orange mandatory squares that you can't actually go on you'll get the estate income and you look at where the little arrow thing is pointing on your tile and then you'll get that much income for every building different buildings give you different types of income i'm not going to go into all that crap but if you're really really interested you might as well just stick your head down the toilet because it's the same sort of thing then you've got the parcels victory points you'll get uh one victory point for every two parcels of land that you've got you'll get the cowboy victory points and if you stick your meatport on air then you'll get the amount of victory points corresponding to half your firepower rounded down then you've got the estate victory points you'll get the number of victory points corresponding the number of buildings are placed on your parcels and then you've got the buying victory points and then you'll be able to just pay to pay money for victory points like
why wouldn't you so as you go through all these actions in all day it'd be like a sort of snake like thing on the board you take your meeples off and you'll put him in front of you might have a jaw in which case you'll roll a die or if you're using a variant you'll pull a tile out but you'll add as many revolvers as you've got to the die roll and the player that wins that will win the jewel and they'll take the spoils of that jaw whatever it is whether it's like maybe taking a pass of land or taking an action right so once you've done all that [ __ ] then you'll do a little bit of cleanup you'll mess about with all the buildings and all that sort of stuff you'll get a certain amount of cowboys extra to play with in the next round depending on what round you're in so like maybe in the next round you'll get an extra one or whatever look at the cash limit of the character that you chose in the first place right and you'll have to discard any money that you made over the limit of the personality so the game ends after the fourth round every building house or mountain gives two victory points to their respective owner you'll get one victory point for every six dollars you've got left over and a player with the most feature points finale thing this is really really original to eurogas by the way we'll be the winner of carson city so what do we like about carson city so the first thing that we like about carson city is that the personalities add a much needed strategic depth to this not only do they give you a game breaking special ability that's going to help you out when you must need it but they also give you that pesky cash limit that you've got to be aware of if you've got a banker you ain't going to have no trouble i have because they've got a high
cash limit but if you've got sheriff for instance you're only going to be able to keep 20 at the end of the round so it almost seems as if the more powerful the ability of the personality the less cash they're going to be able to hold at the end of the round right so that is a really really interesting decision to make are you going to choose a personality that gives you money that will maybe allow you to buy those victory points on the old sneaky snaky thing or do you give yourself a personality that's going to allow you to build your engine and wait until later on in a game to buy the victory points that you need to win right love it second thing we like about this one is that the way the buildings rotate allow to keep track quite easily of the bonuses that they give you there's none of this dominant feces dominant species thing where you're gonna have to constantly re-evaluate the board every time you change something you're gonna turn a building round to reflect any changes and it makes it really really easy to analyze the board and it means that the game doesn't slow down like a lot of these other euro games yeah so the next thing that we really like about this one is it's got a lot of variants in the rulebook that really probably work better than some of the cool rules like for instance the mice right variant where you're going to be given a set of tiles to mess about with instead of trying to accumulate the revolver tokens means that it's a lot fairer and it's a lot more simpler in it because everybody's going to be drawing six tiles from the supply and you're also going to be dumping that random buy roll when you're having jewels yeah you're just going to be playing these tiles so i like the variance in this maybe i should have put them in there's
cool rules but it doesn't really matter because you could just throw that out kaya duh so what don't we like about carson city so the first thing that we don't like about carson city is that the theme seems to go missing in this game i mean when you put the ball down it's just like a grid it looks vile it's there's nothing linking the board to the theme other than the old personalities there's not really anything to anchor the theme down and when you're playing this game it just feels like you're juggling a load of random mechanics and the theme is like trying to talk to you through one of those old 1970s partitions that your parents used to have in your house so yeah the theme whilst it's there on the cover yeah you've got that sort of that bloke staring at you with a gun but then once you get inside the box apart from the personalities it really ain't there next thing we don't like about carson city is there's just too much going on in this game not only have you got to worry about the old personalities then you've got to try and think about what all the bonuses are for each building you've got to think about proximities how close you are to mountains you've got to think about linking your building to the start and tile via roads and it just seems like somebody's put a sausage in a vegetable casserole no i mean so the final thing that we don't like about carson city is that fact that you could buy victory points just for money means it limits the scope of the game what you're going to have in this game right every time we played this you're going to have this mad scramble to sort of build your engine up and then there's going to be a load of competition
to get those victory points in maybe the third probably more likely the fourth round right and that means that it might be the case that your engine you built up on the board isn't going to have any bearing on the fact that you're going to be able to buy them victory points because there's just too many random variables if you leave out the miters right variant and you're just going to be relying on those random dials it might be the case that the action you can take is just literally going to be taken away from you because you threw a die and it went into the cat ball so it just seems like this game is sort of funneled into engine building mad dash for victory points so is carson city worth your time and bother today and in the future so we are going to say probably not right this is an ugly yet challenging euro game that seems to disconnect itself from the theme with some really stiff mechanics right personalities almost managed to salvage this game from a mess of disjointed mechanics but ultimately this one is a bit of a paradox it can't decide which came first whether the mechanics came first or the theme came first it feels like one all the other has been pasted on and for that reason we can't really recommend carson c if you're after a game like this then i would go for something like chaos or maybe pillars of the earth pillars of the earth is a lot simpler and it's got that choose your action resolve in sequence which this has but it doesn't feel like somebody has vomited on your slippers right so there you go that's carson city remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment
in that section down below if you don't mind we'll see you next tuesday
you