Dominion: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we are doing a review or a discussion I want to call a review I'm so stupid of dominion uh a relatively unheard of game uh it just hit the market you know about 15 years ago 2021 uh yeah specifically second edition but I I the small box the small box uh Dominion also came out in 2008.
we'll get Third Edition uh so if you haven't heard of dominion It's relatively known as the uh grandfather of deck building very first deck builder purest form of deck building that you can get spawned a lot of other deck builders around the same time like Arctic scavengers I think was one of the earliest ones as well um and you've just built off of deck building if for some reason this video is also one that you're seeing before anyone else's deck building is where you construct a deck throughout the game instead of building one then coming to play so was this before like Pokemon and no well those are all well those are get Constructors also which I feel differently which are different because like deck Constructors like magic is where you build the deck on your own right and then you come with it right and you hope that okay and it's also if you have more money than the other player then you're typically going to win unless you play drafts where then it's yeah drafts or Commander which is the best way to play Magic yeah uh yeah deck building is where everyone typically starts off with the same 10 card deck or at least of equal power yeah some combination of it's equal and what's available for purchase is known and available to everybody yep and yeah exactly so then it's based off strategy and how you build your deck throughout the game right uh yeah Dominion was the game I always
stayed away from because I'm not the biggest fan of pure deck builders uh we've talked about this before but I like that building to be integrated in the game I really like it when it's with other stuff like uh lost ruins of arnac Darwin's Journey um no darn sir and he doesn't have tech building does it no we just play it I'm taking it I thought uh no it has action selection that's right work replacement yeah uh do an Imperium is another one okay so when it comes to Pure deck building and the ones that I've enjoyed the most are aeon's end which actually got me to life deck building and tyrants of the underdark plink is also a classic one Clank uh yeah I like other iterations of Clank better plank in space because it does it prevents the get in get out to this Rush end game um that's probably another big one now there for people yeah so it's like what's to say about Dominion that hasn't already been said a million times uh basically the from my perspective I'd say if you haven't ever played Dominion uh but you've played other deck builders and you're kind of like me where it's like well why do I need to play that one when I like these others I still think Dominion is great like it was shown to me uh by a friend of mine and I was like yeah okay I'm familiar with that building but it's like it's one of those that like you just get really like it just it just clicks at least for me it's like boom okay cool and you get so much that goes on on your turn and the
plethora of cards that are available which is something I enjoy a lot just adds for unlimited replayability so even though it's either 2008 or 2016 even though it's old I think it still stands the test of time yeah I mean so it's kind of one of those games the original style of games where it kind of created a mechanic um this did it well like if you look at a lot of games that start at a specific mechanic it's still hard to say that they're not good right it's like people build around that one mechanic and sometimes that messes up that mechanic yeah this is just straight deck builder yeah there's nothing there's no fluff there's no anything to it it's just deck building it's purest form and it's good yeah um there's huge variety yeah so we played a set that they had in the menial but there are there's literally a deck of cards that's each one of those and you can randomly pull out I think it's nine decks 10 decks yep and that's what you play with yep and that's it and and that's kind of cool um because this one we did a cover for another newer deck builder chemical Overlord another game Elysium does it where it's like what kind of game do you want to play right these are the cards to do that I love that yep that's just always super fun to do it's great um if you love this game there are so many
expansions that just make it bigger broader in different plays through it um yeah because this one that had it to where if you had a yeah you had three different you know five expansions around this okay four different types of games um again I own dominion it's a fine game for me I don't mind playing it every now and then it's not a game I want to play every two three weeks yeah um which there are plenty of games for me I could play on a weekly bass those games and not a problem to me it's not bad for me okay um but it's a super solid deck builder Brett what are your thoughts um I don't like Tech Village in general yeah a few I like um and this is one I've actually only played a few times even though it is very classic and yeah everybody has it probably because everybody has that everybody has it everybody's played it and so nobody feels really compelled to bring it out so it was nice it was nice to do again um it's it's great yeah it's uh and I think that the timelessness it is it's so accessible because it's so simple it's so straightforward there are no complications there are no Randomness yeah that's that's a mechanic I really like in games is when there's almost no Randomness except for just which guards you happen to pick up yeah but you know what's coming you know you're you're you've got a concept of your odds yeah and you've got methods for improving them by getting rid of The Craft guards because I played deck builders where they don't have a thinning mechanic at
all right I've only played one um and it's Cooperative so it's got a whole different thought process behind it yeah there might be more but I'm only aware yeah I'm trying to think because I which one was the Cooperative one do you remember Harry Potter oh yeah I that one I'm not sure yeah I don't like that one I don't think I like it but I also like Cooperative right yeah I don't like that one that's also for like an aesthetic purpose It's like because they did the movie art yes but it's like you're playing year one which is like supposed to be the first movie but they did art from all of them from no like year seven oh really so they're like the adults it's like you could have you have the option to get the when they were in the first movie why they just brought more theme out for it um but yeah that is one any deck builder yeah that doesn't have the option of thinning is is rough because I mean yeah my deck is huge but I actively chose to not put cards in my deck that thinned it out um but yeah it and that's the other thing is like you said it's it's just clean like it is super clean like like what you said it's like at the end of the game when you're scoring it's just take out all the green cards counting that's it that's it yeah that's it and it's a great Gateway yes down to Modern gaming right that's another reason it's held up so long yeah it's still great it's still something that experienced Gamers will go hey you know Monopoly Scrabble yeah they're good yeah let's try something a little bit different yeah
and so that's where like I actually played probably the most often when I'm going to Game Day events that are geared towards people who don't play lots of games you know the cafe meetups where half the people that's the only time once a month they come and play different games yeah and they're not going to sit down play Twilight impairing with me or or learn it or even things like uh heavier work replacement games but they'll play this yeah and they'll like this and it won't take them long to learn it and again the game's quick you're done in 30 maybe 45 minutes yeah so you can instantly go and play another round of even using the same cards because then people got okay this is my strategy I kind of an idea of what I'm going for let's try this out yeah and it's one it's very hard to make a game and Dominion has done it and it's really those older games like only time will tell the newest ones but it's really hard to make a game that's both accessible to new players and experts right like I always heard before I ever played this at this game was kind of like you do nothing until you just start buying points right uh and since I had played it I'm I don't really agree with that that doesn't it's like you're yeah clearly that is your goal that's the only way you're going to win is by buying those however it's when people water down games like that this is like I can do that for Twilight Imperium all you're doing is just moving ships right and and that's
the just completing those objectives here whole you're trying to get points that's all that's all Twilight Imperium really is it's like what the [ __ ] is what is that empty statement you just said well I I think that's probably just a person who doesn't see the big picture of of the strategy of using all the other cards yeah or there is there might be like a base game here the standard cards because there's a base one right where you just put out cards that aren't super interesting but it's like okay yeah now you know how to play now we're gonna do this yeah like with the one we had was what was it called top decking yeah top decking which is brilliant yeah that's so fun I was just like oh yeah and you can see that where you're just constantly or either you're making other people put bad cards on top of their deck or you're playing cards on top of your deck or you're cleaning the top of your deck yeah so you can get the cards that you want it's all of those just super fun mechanical aspects of it yeah where you're able to pick it's like do we want a super friendly game oh here's one that every card you play helps other players but you're also helping yourself do you want a really aggressive game where it's non-stop attacks and you're like [ __ ] people over yeah right it just covers all aspects which is why I really like it because I love games where it's like I can have a wooden R in this case and just boom and here's just whatever we want to play like like a Marvel legendary Right what do we want yeah it's it's here and that's what I get off on and that is probably where I
might be a dispatched because I do own the game but I don't only expansions everyone who loves this game like their top five games it's like you just need to own a couple expansions yeah and I understand that I understand because to a certain extent the classic it's a classic so what came out with was just so different than what people had ever thought of in a game when it first showed up yeah that you don't need anything when I got into the hobby this wasn't my first stack build that I played right and so when I play it's like it's good it's clean it's fun but I think it needs a little more for the base game right especially because in since second edition came out but if we're talking about the first one or in 2008 uh that's how what is that 10 12 15 years yeah so in 15 years you start getting creative with cards you do side decks you do other stuff that really throw a wrench in things and like if you go to most game stores like you can still buy again just the individual box but there's a lot where it's an individual box and two expansions already combined with oh you're right yeah so I'm like that's why I should have gone when I first got this game because then it might have rocked up a little bit higher on my play scale yeah um but I'm just kind of to the point it's like I have other deck builders and they're all good and this is great for what I use it for which is gain new people into the hobby yeah exactly because obviously if you compare this to like Star Realms was another one that took off uh when that came out and then
hero roam shortly after when people say which one do you get it's like do you like sci-fi or fantasy right because at this hero Realms came out with more because I had like the individual characters that start but now Star Realms and Euro Realms are basically the same I love fantasy but I have them both because they both scratch a different kind of [ __ ] but they're also competitive well this is competitive as well start rooms are Head to Head yeah right strictly too uh yes they've since come out with more stuff but yes it's men it's meant to be one I and and this this isn't right right but but this is honestly So like um we played it on my brother's bachelor party yeah um which is kind of fun um because it does play well at larger groups like again we're only playing with three I played it with six and it doesn't feel any slower no and it really shouldn't like there was a time whenever you're like one big move where you have a [ __ ] ton of actions you're like I only have two copper I was like I was like can Brett go like is this a game where you can kind of simultaneously play not really because he might have played a card that would have had you draw yeah and him buying especially when Dexter came thin yeah who's buying what but it is I didn't really feel like I needed to yeah we weren't waiting more than like two minutes for you to figure everything out yeah after the original 10 minutes of waiting for him to get two copper
yeah well I'm also trying to think because like there are clearly Attack cards and there's reaction cards I'm trying to think if there's any cards that you pick a player because if I remember right all the Attack cards that I remember playing were just other players to everybody affects everyone and then like for example it's like oh you have the mode like this one is like whenever they play attack or you can reveal this to not be affected um but it seems like there's a witch I think in there I think that is each other player games so and they're and again this is we're only talking about base Dominion here so there's a million expansions there probably is one but if that's not the case then the Attack cards you don't feel like really like attacking me again right it's like now you might feel targeted if you play two bureaucrats and you don't have any Victory cards and I have all of them but at the same time I built it's coincidence and I built my deck and I got Victory cards like Brett knows that like yeah the only reason will know is you show them the one card that's the point card you put on top of your deck yeah Brett doesn't know that you have another one in your hand yeah if he plays the second one and you just happen to have it in five cards I mean I mean that was doing nothing anyway right I was doing nothing that turned anyway but then I guess my next turn but it's an attack card right I think the one time is like you played one then it came my turn and I played one which hit me twice and it's like dang it right
I don't know I think this game even if you do go super aggressive doesn't feel like you're being picked on which makes it I mean great from two to four yeah and if you put more expansions you can play it with larger numbers um yeah let us know in the comments on which expansions are like a must because I don't I don't actually own this game but I'm I'm looking for that one guy who wants to to sell all of it see that's probably like everybody I know that has all of it they have it all because they love the game yeah um and if they are selling bundles it's first edition I'm like I don't [ __ ] and I want the slightly newer yet still super Old Second Edition I've heard actually the first two expansions of a must-have really yeah okay um I think it's like darkness dark ages no Intrigue and um I think Intrigue is a must-have and then any of the other ones that are listed on the um I think there's I think there's over 10. I want this yeah and they have a big bucks and that includes what five or seven something like that but they just came out with a couple more expansions not even that long I think this year they released the news was it this year I think so if not 2023 it was 20 22. I'm sure I know it's 2022 I just can't remember it was 20 23.
um it's insane uh now uh because everyone for some reason shits on this game for its art what do you guys think of the art I think it's just yeah I think it's I think it's great for what it is it's yeah it's simple um oil painting style yeah yeah but it's the humans look like humans unlike Concordia where it's like what is that yeah it could be done very sharply defined like cartoon art yeah but I don't think that that would add anything it fits like that Renaissance yeah old fantasy painting right technically like I mean if it's the art cover yeah but I would make the same argument about what's the what's the one that we played Roman one no I think that this is pretty much how apart from that would look and the art you saw for that one was the the redone yes because the first one which was the worst the first one was rough yeah but I don't know I think people expect like high high-end art and forget that there is a certain aesthetic to what came before yeah and yeah to a certain production cost was a factor at the time production costs um the idea that I mean games weren't as big in 2008 if you really just think about it that's I got the Renaissance of the board game was early 2000s probably around that time yeah because we just talked about pandemic that came out in 2008 that probably would have been the modern board game and so like because I've researched that a little bit and it was all pretty much because of the
internet yeah so it was the rise of the internet allow people from Europe and America to basically share ideas of War gaming and things like Amazon was just coming on board where it was shipping out more products from around the world and you have this kind of day and just globalization globalization of purchasing power just kind of exploded in those early 2000s and that's the idea of board games that makes sense from around the world from around the world because I remember I was playing Katan yes and I hadn't played but I always wear a ticket to ride was known in the states right but it wasn't huge right target but when I look at the I call it the OG honest 95 yeah same with um Twilight because they came out at the same time Twilight Twilight Imperium they came out oh yeah I forgot to draw the appearance on its fourth edition yeah um but one of the thing I think about when you look at like the ogs and I consider this one the ogs is mechanic over everything else yeah Ticket to Ride mechanic over everything else yeah you can mechanic over everything else that's true okay yeah and that was great like even I would say like original um um well there's a pandemic yeah the art was terrible yeah it looks like a well even it looks almost like a prototype yeah yeah but again mechanic wise hey yeah she is solid and on the other
end of the spectrum what was that coffee table book The Game Keepers okay yeah it's nothing but art and no game there's a really new game it's let's look at pretty pictures and they're beautiful no that's not to say Obviously there are many many games that have beautiful artwork that are also fantastic games true but that's those are modern and those because this is what twenty dollars when it originally sold well probably 20 now yeah I mean but to me I think now because there's so many games out there yeah you have to do everything compared to this it has to have that competitive so art has to be fantastic the game has to be good but at the same time you're you're paying for that and they're usually crowdfunded right like and there are very very few companies and games that come out that are not Crown anymore yeah yep uh Dominion is one of them as far as I'm aware I don't think they've ever went on Kickstarter I'm aware of um now if they do a third edition for better our work and just better car quality and get everything then yeah if they were to do a third edition I would expect the art to be better right or maybe not maybe they're like no we this is our Niche yeah but I would kind of expect them to or maybe they do like a CR 20th or 30th Anniversary collector's edition maybe yeah 25.
um 25 probably but again this is a fantastic Jack Builder even though it's it's wickedly old and if it's the first one there are many other deck builders that I would still recommend yep um aeon's end is my favorite deck builder but it's cooperative and has a bunch of other stuff too and it's not a pure deck builder right uh I love Star Realms and hero Realms yep um and chemical Overlord would probably be if anyone were to be like oh I kind of want a newer game when that one's out I that one is the closest new game that I feel is like heavily inspired by Dominion oh yeah 100 if the one thing about deck rollers that can be kind of annoying is when you're buying a car and it goes into your discard pile it's like well I hope I draw that soon at the right time and with the right move yeah and chemical Overlord goes on top of your deck yeah so you're guaranteed to get it and you can hold cards in your hand where like the minion is one of those things where it's both good and bad if you can't play it it just goes to your you know yeah your discard you just kind of have to you deal with it right like don't let that upset you because that's what things that I hated about deck buildings like I don't get to use the cards I want I have to hope I draw it with the other cards that I planned on drawing it with um but because it's so quick and those problems are accentuated more in longer yeah Builders and this one's not it's like oh I didn't get that or I've drawn eight cards I drew all my actions well I guess this turn sucks okay oh it's my
turn again all right right so I haven't even drawing my cards yet yeah yeah oh you guys are done already you only had two copper after that no it's I I love it and uh it works for me yep I would agree you guys got anything else nope all right well on a scale of one to ten uh what would you guys give dominion I'll say nine nine just because it could be slightly more strategic with just a little tweak sure and again that is probably with expansions we don't know unfortunately I have only played bass um I've played it quite a bit yeah I was like hooked whenever my friend my friend brought it over I'm like this is so good let's do that set so for me it's an eight eight okay I wasn't sure if you're going to go down to a seven but no it's better than a seven yeah um but it's not at the nine level for me yeah it's not base um I I'm actually gonna go ahead and eight as well for that same reason I was thinking nine I'm feeling nine but I wanna Reserve that nine or ten with expansions right uh so base game Dominion is still eight out of ten um it's still super solid yeah so that's it everyone that's our thoughts on Dominion less than what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and everyone before whatever time of day does for you hey everyone thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that
subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you