Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why You Shouldn't Play CLUE Anymore

Transcript 19:11

the board game Clue known by its proper name cludo in Europe had its 75th birthday this year and I say it's time to take it into the study and bludging it with a Candlestick because as board games go it's outdated and redundant today I'll give you six reasons why you shouldn't play it anymore and recommend six modern mystery games that are way more fun reason one it wastes your time if you don't roll high enough to move you'll get stuck in the hallway and can't do anything on your turn I think it's Mrs peacock in the kitchen with the dagger you can't solve a murder in a hallway dear boy that would be frightfully Unbecoming what are you a butler servants not only is it boring to do nothing on your turn if everyone else learns something and you don't that's unfair and you'll be playing catchup like James Donaldson who missed two weeks of school to go to Disneyland I looked him up on LinkedIn and under job it just says loser in chronologic Paris 1920 you get to ask a question every turn and get crucial information that will help you solve the case someone's been poisoned at the Paris opera house and it's your job to find out who did it in which room and at what time before anyone else works it out ah the French dastardly creatures I suspect he suffered a heart attack when asked to be modest on your turn you pick a character or time of day and combine it with a

location card to get some information the chauffeur was in the dance hall at 300 p.m. this is what comes of overthrowing your monarchy a servant taking in the Arts whatever next I love how simple it is you get your answer and then bang it's the next person's turn your sheet has a map of the Opera House for each time period so it's really easy to track where everyone was and you know that every character moves rooms every hour which helps you make leaps of deduction if the journalist started in the grand foyer then he couldn't have possibly made it to the musical by 300 p.m. because he's lazy and it gives you those moments of feeling clever that you want from a mystery game you're also tracking the victim the man who was poisoned you have to work out when they were in a room with one other person that's when the poisoning took place clue is as slow and arduous as trying to kill someone with a Candlestick because you're being drip fed the information whereas in chronologic whenever a player gets private information they also read out some public info for everyone else so you're constantly learning things that take you closer to solving the case all that moving around in clue is just delaying you from getting to work you're like a detective with a 2hour commute here you save all that time for actually solving it so they can make it a more interesting mystery and somehow it's still a shorter game the only slight downside is that the solutions to the cases are fixed so there's only enough

for 15 games in the box but honestly wait 6 months and you'll never remember who did what and where and it'll be a new game again or sell it on and get yourself the other two games in the same series if you used to play Clue as a kid and you're looking for that type of deduction experience now as an adult then this is the perfect upgrade it's cheaper half the size and a lot more fun if you want to buy it or any of the games in this video there are links below reason two it's drab and dull for a family board game to capture the attention of kids who'd rather be vaping their Roblox we can do a lot better than this lifeless Relic I'm sure the children of 1949 thought a tiny meta revolver was the best thing ever but then they hadn't eaten candy in 10 years if I could pick one game to take clu's Crown as the family mystery game for the 21st century it would be mysterium it gives us the same murder in a creepy mansion that we want but actually does it justice with stunning artwork and a fun dose of spectacle for starters one of you plays as the ghost of the murder victim you've got to tell the others who killed you where they did it and what weapon they used but you can't talk because you're a ghost what's that good God man enunciate instead you communicate by giving them psychic Visions these cards that are full of surreal imagery it seems the murderer is an

elephant on top of a watermelon with an orange on its back case closed you're trying to lead each player towards their suspect but giving Clues with these cards is like trying to write a birthday card with jelly you want them to guess the seamstress so you give them this because the oranges look like her pin cushion well it's not the seamstress she looks like she's never eaten an orange in her life in fact let's turn it over it's so wrong it's distracting you're playing cooperatively trying to win as a team so you're working them out together and there's so much room for interpretation that everyone will have a different take on it ah yes the telephone wondrous invention I used one only last year H it's a means of communication so it simply must be the postman well yeah but that bit's yellow and so's that yellow as the ghost having to listen in silence while they misread all your Clues is a brilliant form of torture and good practice for becoming a ghost and having to sit through your own funeral once you think you know the answer you place your crystal ball on the card and the ghost will reveal if you're right which is always a tense moment because everything is a hunch in this game you're never sure if you've got it right wrong I've met some ghosts in my time I'm from Victorian London but you sir are an appalling Apparition a disp a Fant to Menace but if you do get it right you move on to working out the location of the murder you've only got

so many chances to crack the case before the clock strike s the sunrises and you lose the game you can't have a psychic Vision in the daytime the ghosts are in Australia then mysterium is so much more entertaining than clue with its big reveals and last ditch guesses trying to solve it together makes it a bigger deal it's the difference between the passion you get trying to win a pub quiz for the team versus doing Wordle on the toilet only one of those is making you shout out loud hopefully whereas clue is an introspective game taking secret notes on your own bit of paper mysterium is much more sociable the detectives are talking the whole time and it's a lot more fun trying to read your friend's mind than work out which three cards are in an envelope the best thing about clue is it setting but at its heart it's a boring family game mysterium starts in the same place goes in a completely different direction and delivers a murder mystery game that feels nothing like clue and is much better for modern audiences if you want a smaller shorter version then try the spin-off game mysterium Park but I personally prefer the Grandeur of the original reason three is it doesn't make any sense your character in clue can be the murderer and you don't know that you did it you then spend the game finding that out and publicly reveal it to everyone else guys I just remembered I killed them in the study with the wrench congratulations you've won 20 years in

prison I would have gotten away with it if it wasn't for myself most murderers know that they murdered someone and are trying to keep that information secret and that's exactly how deception murder in Hong Kong Works you're each given a secret role and the killer wins the game by not getting caught one player is the forensic scientist they know who the murderer is and they help the detectives by answering questions such as the location of the crime and the cause of death trying to point them towards the murderer because every player has weapons and evidence in front of them that could tie them to the murder for the detectives to win they not only need to catch the right guy but pinpoint the weapon they used and the evidence that places them at the crime scene so if the crucial piece of evidence is antique the fic scientist might say the location is a living room but that could just as easily lead to car in front of other players this is the convenient fog that the murderer can hide in living room that must point to the oil painting or the book A book in the living room it seems we're not only dealing with a murder but a fire in the library as well the game is one long conversation as you try to work out who done it with everyone throwing around accusations and protesting their innocence it's like a scene from knives out but with less dodgy accents you can only get so far with the evidence sometimes you just got to go with your gut look your friends in the eyes and decide which one is lying to you look you can tell me I'll make

sure lrad goes easy on you did you kill that man no he blinked that's enough for me send him down as the killer if you try too hard or say too much you'll give yourself away on the other hand say too little and it will seem like you're nervously hiding something the pressure of being The Secret Killer will have you sweating which means the feeling you get when you pull off a win is like nothing else haha I fooled you all wow but you were so the best defense is a good offense yeah you were pretty offensive yes my apologies I've never used that word before whereas in clue you're taking turns in deception you're all involved at once which means it never gets boring every moment is a chance to catch your friend's mask slipping this type of game isn't for everyone you have to enjoy the in-game arguments and not be upset by everyone calling you a liar it also needs a bigger group to play it from five to 12 players but for the right people these hidden traitor games are so much fun and deception is a great one to start with reason for is it's the worst who done it Story Ever Told a character walks into a room and makes a suggestion of who the murderer could be I suggest it's Professor plum in the dining room with the lead piping they are wrong so another character walks into another room and makes another suggestion and on it goes until someone finally gets it right no no sleuth worth

his salt makes suggestions clue I'm afraid these imbeciles haven't got one it may be inspired by the great murder mysteries but it has none of the story the details to follow and the twist and turns that you get with a Sherlock Holmes novel and that's exactly what you do get from Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective every case is like a mini novel that you explore in your own way you read the introduction telling you who's been murdered and where then it's up to you to decide how to approach the case you want to interview the victim's brother so you look up his name in the directory of London and pay him a visit turning to the right page in your book to read the encounter all the lights are on at Richard Allen's residence as we arrive on his doorstep he invites Us in and we sit in his tasteful living room Mr Allan is there any more information about your brother that might help our investigation the brother shows you a mysterious necklace he found so you hunt for local Jewelers who could shed light on its owner the game doesn't tell you to do it these are the choices you make if you're switched on and no one's going to admit they killed him you've got to follow the evidence spot the inconsistencies in people's stories and question their motives you'll need to take notes and talk it out with your partners to work it all out it's it's got to be his ex a crime of passion yes the only woman I've ever trusted was my mother I have the fondest of memories when I was 9 years old she smiled at me once as the story unravels you'll jump

between which suspect you think did it just like you're watching a who done it on TV but unlike that you won't get to the end and be handed a solution once you think you know the killer you open the envelope and have to answer these questions to win the game I love playing this game because it makes me feel like a real detective and the Mysteries are so well written that they keep you guessing for ages once you've played a case it's done you can't play it again but each one will take you a few hours and you get 10 cases in the Box plus there are four boxes to choose from some players don't enjoy how much reading you have to do in this game in which case I'd recommend trying perspectives or Chronicles of crime instead I'll put links to my videos on them below reason five is you're trying to solve a murder and the game keeps holding you back with pointless restrictions it's Miss Scarlet in the billiard room with the Candlestick up up up you're not in the bilard room so you can't make a dramatic accusation unless you're in the room where you think it happened this is basic stuff the irony is you're a detective but you've got no agency and worse still is that when someone accuses you they immediately drag your character into their room so you spent all that time getting where you need to be and now you got to spend another four turns getting back there old board games do everything they can to defer the enjoyment of their own game this from the generation Who Loved abstinence before marriage these guys just can't get enough of waiting modern board games

get straight to the point in other words they let you have fun on the first day and that's how it goes in paranormal detectives you're trying to solve a murder who why how and where and on the first turn you can ask who did it like in mysterious one player is the ghost but this time they communicate through stereotypical ghostly ways a Ouija board some tarot cards drawing something by holding your wrist to move the pen the ghost has to somehow answer an open-ended question like why did they kill you by shaping two bits of string have you got any idea what that is afraid not dear boy being the ghost is great because you have to get creative with how you get your message across one of the challenges is to do a 3 second charade how do you show that you get hit by a train in 3 seconds and to solve the murder there's not the boring multiple choice that you have in clue deciding between a dagger and a Candlestick the answer could be anything and every time you play it'll be something completely different the ghost is given a little scenario that tells the story of their death so they've got a lot of info to some somehow communicate without being able to talk and yet it totally works each turn you get a tiny sliver of a clue that starts to build a picture in your head and it feels like such a Triumph when you finally make a guess and actually get it right another criticism of clue is that if you try to win and

fail you're out of the game the beauty of playing with a ghost is they can check your answers they tell you how many you got right but not which ones so you can just carry on playing it's a competitive murder mystery like clue you're taking notes and making leaps of deduction like clue but it doesn't feel like doing homework because the way you get your information is so much more fun if you want something silly that feels more like a party game that you'd play at Christmas paranormal detectives is the one to get reason six to not play Clue is you can't play it with young kids because it could give them nightmares and not just from how boring it is look I don't know when people are teaching their kids about Bloody murder these days but if you want a mystery game that you can play with four to 8y olds then you should get out foxed you play as detectives trying to catch a cunning Fox who has stolen a delicious apple pie an apple pie this crime is most unsavory There are 16 foxes who could have done it and you need to catch the right one before they escape you'll playing cooperatively to try and win the game together which makes it great for playing along with kids because they they can help you with your turn if you're tired from A Hard Day's Work you move your characters around the board to collect Clues but you can only move if you roll the symbols you need on the dice okay so it might look like I'm recommending a game that has the same dice rolling obstacles that I criticize clue for but but this sort of thing is

fun for 5-year-olds it isn't Fun for 25y olds I don't know how old you are but you look 25 and because out foxed is cooperative it's not unfair like clue plus your failure has a purpose it's the game's timer if you don't roll what you need that's when the fox moves closer to escape if he reaches the end of the path then you lose the game when you get a clue you will check whether the guilty Fox is wearing that item of clothing by putting the token in this ingenious Contraption you see at the start of the game you put a random Thief card in this slot and when you place a clue toile over the hole and pull out the tray it will reveal a Green Dot if the thief is wearing that accessory if not it will be blank it's such a clever way to reveal information and it's perfect for kids to use plus it avoids all the fiddlin of getting your information from the other players like in clue as you work out the thief's Wardrobe you'll start to eliminate foxes it can't possibly be until you're left with the thief if you make a correct guess before the thief escapes then you win the game and the chance to play it a 100 more times that weekend out foxed is a great starter board game for 4 to8 8-year-olds that helps teach them deductive reasoning and then on their eighth birthday after they've opened their presents you can tell them all about gruesome murders so they can play one of the other games on this list and you'll have given them the greatest gift of all a childhood without bad board games those are my six modern alternatives to clue if you'd like to

buy any of them there are links below if you like this video please subscribe to the channel to see more like it and you can support the channel and get exclusive content on my patreon link below I'm John perus thanks for watching I

Progress saved