Skip to main content
Loading video...

Atiwa - Uwe Rosenberg's new farming game!

Transcript 19:09

Hi, it's Tarrant. And Stella from Meeple University. We are excited for this review video. This is the newest Uwe Rosenberg's or one of the newest Uwe Rosenberg's game. Atiwa. So, this is about fruit bat. And it feels a bit like beep. We'll tell you all about it. We're going to give you the overview first and then what we think of it. Indeed. So, this is uh it's an Uwe Rosenberg worker placement farming game. What is the theme, Tarrant? So, in this instance we are farming in the Atiwa region of Ghana. Ghana in Central Western Africa. Um and the So, in the spirit of many of these games, you are trying to build up your farming and village area uh in order to earn points.

Now, in this one as in many cases, you've got breeding and you've got um everything being in balance. So, you start with this one little village and you'll either go out exploring and finding more terrains that you can add to your uh tableau or you can uh buy new towns and settlements and build houses uh cuz a major part of the points is going to be about building the the human settlements here and getting all of these family tiles out onto the board. You can also bring in wild animals, trees. Trees will grow fruit. Uh fruit will interact with fruit bats. So, there's lots of different things that you can bring in. Essentially, it plays over seven rounds and you'll do worker placement on all of these different worker placement spaces.

And these will allow you to gain resources mostly from these tracks on your board. Uh but in the case of gold and fruit bats, take them from the display up there. And then they have to go onto a space on a card that shows the matching icon. And so, your major reason for expanding is to have enough space to place all of the goodies that you're going to be collecting. Uh at the end of each turn All right, at the end of each round, that's when uh things start to propagate. So, your wild animals uh depending on how many you've got will produce trees. You see there's numbers under here. Once you got three, they'll start to produce trees. Uh trees, based on how many you've got, will produce fruit. Fruit, based on how many you've got, will bring fruit bats in.

And fruit bats, at the end of each turn, they can go uh you can they can fly away with your fruit. Uh and plant the seeds, so they'll come back with more trees. Thematically correct. all propagates there. And all the the cycle of life. Uh you can also bring in goats. So, these are a bit more domesticated and you'll milk them to get uh to get food. Cuz ultimately, you have to feed all of the families in your houses. And you can do that with the milk or by spending fruit or animals. We're even buying food with gold. It's really a circle of life, isn't it? Yeah, it's all It's an interesting one because you've got to try to strike a balance between uh keeping everything in balance um and getting the most points, which might involve taking it out of balance at the very end of the game. Um and you know, if the families and feeding them are worth more points, then maybe some of the balance you've set up early in the game, you break that.

Uh game plays over seven rounds. And whoever gets the the most points wins. There are a lots of worker placement places there. As you can see, this logo means that you can place your worker also above that on the right-hand side, depending on it's different depending on the number of players and the way you track your round as you move this. And hence, the worker placement space, this gets placed randomly at at the start of the game. So, this track's number four, this track number five. It also reminds you of what how many numbers of certain things needed to actually to breed the animals. So, let's say for example, seven families will give you one family, two wild animals will give you one, and two goats will give you one. Yes. So, that those differs from round to round. This is actually the one that you basically want to probably get towards kind of like mid to the end. It costs quite a lot to get the tiles, but the tiles worth points. As you can see it here, from three to 13. While these top ones might be good at the start and it might combo with certain actions, but they're not worth points, a lot of points. If any, some of them actually worth negative points.

Yeah. It's kind of like for engine more maybe more for engine building or maybe for oh, no, I need more space and so on. I think we've covered the basics of the game. There is a removable board section here and this is what scales the player count. So, fewer action spaces at two players going up to more at three and then eventually four. So, those points are coming from as I say, this, that, and the thing that gets uncovered at the end of the game. So, there's little points like little number little numbers at the bottom of the icons, that's the points you get. So, for example, if you manage to have all 25 villagers village family, then you get 25 points for that. This worth maximum six points.

And so on. Yes. So, what do we think? What do you think, Tarrant? Ah, I Okay, I I I go first. It reminds me first before playing like Agricola, which it is to certain point. But then again, I think, as Tarrant mentioned as well when we play, it feels a little bit like Fields for Arle. Light. So, it's not as heavy as Fields for Arle. It doesn't have that that crystal placement that I at least like that I'm usually having a little bit of problems with spatial rotation in my head. So, you can see there are I don't know how many like hundreds No, not hundreds. Lots of worker placement spaces. A lot of them uh No, maybe you can say, "Oh, there's a lot of them."

Don't be Don't be scared because a lot of them are pretty simple and a lot of them are duplicating and similar with different combinations. For example, this one here. You place that, you get a tree and fruits on your day. So, when you say that it gains the most of the resources you gain, you're getting it from your board. So, you can't cannot have more. You cannot gain more than whatever it is on your board that took a while to set up. So, you place it from here to here. So, if you are to give it up, you'll be placing from here to here. Gold is the one that is placing from the main supply to here and the same with fruit bat, from the main supply into your board. But the rest is here. So, with that with that in mind, so this are basically gaining or losing or paying. This one is flipping, so your untrained family is um is actually could worth polluting the area.

And it takes action to actually flip it and hence, you can also store your fruit bat on that same tile. And this is thematically I have to mention this game. I think um a lot of or most I would say most of Uwe Rosenberg's game is thematically as well, like rich thematically in the um not just mechanic. So, as you also mention um remember probably in his games, feed your meeples, which you don't particularly like. I've gotten over it. Although, they don't say it that much these days, having to uh I mean, this isn't the case where you're getting more actions and then having to feed them. It's more a case where you're getting more gold at the end of the round. Yeah, it's it's an income. Income. Income at the And points, ultimately.

That's correct. Thematically, is trained family could not eat bat. So, this is actually the issue with fruit bat. It's getting endangered. People are getting it for food, for the meat, and so on. While there's a deforestation issue in in Africa where the fruit bat has an important role in planting all the forest, like taking the fruits. This is like they're all connected, all very thematic. And in this instance, the untrained family could eat the bat as part of their food. And which is thematically correct. Like all they untrained, they could do that. They could cross You can um you draw you draw a token at the end of the round as part of income, you can get gold, but essentially, you get pollution. So, you polluted your village from left to right. So, those tokens gets to be placed there, for example. Oh, from has to be from left to right.

And it was very thematic. Um And look at this, right? So, wild animals. Wild animals could provide with food and then the trees. Um the trees will generate fruit. If you have fruit, that will make the fruit bat to come and then The goats. That's right. And then the goats. The goats provide milk and also provide food for the family and so on. And fruit bat, as you say it as well, Tarrant, it can go away with the with the fruit and then plant more trees. So, it's all very thematic. I really like that part. It feels like you are families, you are trying to have these farms, trying to plant trees, you know, make fruits and make the fruit fruit bat everywhere and then also build your village. Yeah, there's lots of ways of making everything propagate. And there's an interesting puzzle in the game of doing that in the most efficient way.

Because the more the further you are down the end of each of these tracks, the more income that you get. But then if you hit the end of the track, uh you stop getting anything. And if you run out of space on cards to put stuff, then you stop getting anything. So, it's an interesting little puzzle to think through from that standpoint. What a And I think that was what was That was the interesting part about the game. What I think though, it's like more like a Feast for Odin rather than Agricola because the worker placement is not that blocky blocky. Especially in two player games. In higher player games, it becomes a little bit more tight. So, it's one of those worker placement that you don't have to Okay, which one do I really need to go first? Maybe you will if you Because there are some kind of like better actions on the right hand side here. But it's more like Okay, which combination that I want to go first that would benefit benefit me most compared to what you think opponent will go first. I mean, there are these things as well that, you know, price more expensive if you don't go first.

But it's not that blocky blocky, which I actually enjoy quite enjoying this game. Yeah. With you know, not too frustrating worker placement, but still there are these individual puzzle in this board that you need to solve as you said as well. Yeah. And conversely, that to me is the game's biggest downside. Right. Um I think you know, I often I often kind of make uh a joke about Feast for Odin that it's you know, a game with 60 action spaces. Um it's you know, you can almost do your own thing. And at least I mean, if you're playing with four players, yeah, there'll be a bit of competition. If you're playing at a lower player count, there's you can kind of do your own thing and never see each other's meeples. And this is this is almost more extreme than that.

Each player has three actions. I've got the three player board here. There's something like 32 action spaces and a total of nine meeples is going to go down. And for me, once you get to that stage, once there's so so many excess spaces, it brings the multiplayer solitaire element of it to the extreme. And once I get to that point, I just I don't feel I'm making uh that many interesting decisions against the opponents. Certainly, there was competition for the this uh bit on the side had the most valuable actions, I think. Um you could do the most things at once with these ones. So, there was always competition there. But you kind of like need to build up your Yeah. belongings, your items engine first before getting the most out of it.

Like this one, you get gold based on how many of these tiles with the this icon you have. And then you have at least four, you get to flip untrained family to train Yeah. one of them. Yeah. And there's a big part of the you you can fight for these um cards as well because these are all like very different types of cards that will accept different types of things. Like if you want to do a lot of bats, you get a cave that has space for eight bats. Uh step kind of has two of everything, so it's more of a a flexible type of one. Um But even so, you know, there's kind of different ways to go about everything. So, you're not going to get that badly There's not one that's clearly better or worse than the other. There are some that are situational. Or just get it randomly. Or you can get it randomly.

But there are six spaces here and for a four player games, you can get the the tile that you want. But this is really important though. You don't want to punish yourself too much to not be able to get that, hence being not efficiently getting your unable to place your resources when you get them. That's That's really bad. I mean, that's your view. I would rather have some more punishing decisions to make. Um that was part of the joy of Agricola was that you know, the resources would build up on the space and it would get more and more valuable and uh sometimes you just really needed to be first player and get that big chunk of resources cuz you knew that it was going to be so much less efficient to get those going forward. I didn't have that feeling here. And that to me was the That to me was its downside.

Speaking about Agricola, I picked this up from Essen and they also have at the same time the Essen release all-in-one box of uh improved version of Agricola. It's like all everything in one giant box. I was like, I like I would prefer Caverna to be honest. I mean, people have got preference. Do you prefer Caverna or You don't like that mining thing, do you? Because you can get away with that. Somebody can get away with the mining. that I don't like it, but it does force a path. I do I do find that the I do like Agricola and the how tight everyone going for the same sorts of things Right. is. And this could I mean, this could be like that. Everyone's kind of going for similar um a similar set of things and I just wish it were I just wish there were more challenging choices. All right. Well, I really enjoyed like I really really enjoyed this. I really enjoyed my game. The score was close. It shows like different part results in similar similar score.

Um and this area, this is good. Like at first, how what? Do you have to do that? There's a card that lists you steps, which ones goes first, which is really handy. I would really recommend to use that card when you play, which Terrence is going to bring. Help cards? Help cards. Yeah, the help cards are really good because there's quite a few steps. Not as many as Feast for Odin's, but this is made in Essen. There's like set up and the feeding, how many that's really handy. And how many um how many do you need to collect um what to get the breeding benefit? But I think it's it's it's very enjoyable without being too frustrating. I know that you do thrive in more tight more frustrating.

You like things get more frustrating. Uh yes, uh I really like if you like Feast for Odin, you probably like this one without the special rotation that's the thing that I I don't prefer. So, that's really good. Yeah. And I think you know, considering it as Feast for Odin light, I think it is a good comparison because you do have things that combo with each other. You do need to create space for things. You do need to plan your sequence of things uh well. Uh and there's a a number of different ways you can go about it. Have you played a Feast for Odin? What do you think of that? We actually have how to play video for that one as well. So, check it out if you want to see or refresh how it plays. But yeah, I I really want to play this again like after immediately after I finished.

Um it was a bit late at night at one stage and then the other stage like people are leaving. So, um yeah, so I definitely would definitely recommend this. There are plenty of um you know, I say it is a fairly multiplayer solitaire sort of thing. There's a lot of games like that out on the market at the moment. They it is a um popular style of thing. So, I just yeah. Not for me, but Yeah. Um it is a very good example in that It is definitely for me. So, uh we don't always agree, but that is okay. But Terrence said that he would play it again as long as higher player counts. So, this is also it's placed randomly and there's different type of uh different type of terrain tiles, but it a lot of them are quite similar though.

They're not like that big difference. Like there's one that's focused more on the trees. This one's trees, but it lets you put bats in trees. That's quite nice. It does actually It'll drive your strategy. It's kind of like the cards you draft in uh in Agricola, I think. Like you get you get these and and it will drive you in a slightly different direction. Well, this one's a lot of Uwe's games can do. Well, this one's uh similar like one stack has got a few and um but they all are the same cards and exactly the same thing. So, that's basically it. I really thoroughly thoroughly enjoyed this game. Hopefully, you would find this enjoyable as well, but I won't blame you if you don't think that it's your type of game. And hopefully, this has been useful if you think that it has somehow, it would be really helpful if you can please hit like button and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so. We do videos like this, how to play, play through and so on. I'm also on Instagram. Find me there as well and hopefully, we'll see you next time.

Thanks for watching. Bye.

Progress saved