Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shipyard – Action Selection in its Purest Form

Transcript 18:53

this copy of Shipyard is a 2023 second edition printing of the original game that was published in 2009 now what really makes this game Stand Out is that it does one thing very very well and that one thing is action selection so to give you a sense of this game rather than just do an overview of the rules we're going to do a talk through of a few turns so you can understand some of the thinking that's involved in playing Shipyard to understand this game we'll focus first on my own Shipyard we're several turns in and I've already acquired a lot it'll be clear in a moment how I acquired all this but for now let's keep it simple and focus only on the ship that is under construction you might notice something that appears like an illegal State these two parts of the ship don't connect so why are the tiles placed like this in this game construction happens on this row once a ship is completed it moves up here as a result the space to the left of this Stern will be made available so having my construction yard like this is allowed now let's look at what's on the parts of this ship you'll see a lot of these green platforms so what's that all about at the beginning of the game I was dealt these secret objectives which I'm going to keep face up for this video this objective is giving me points for pairs of business men and cranes on all of my completed

ships this objective is giving me points for all of my lifeboats the other tokens that are here serve as essential functions for the ship and it'll be easier to see how they're used once the ship is scored when a ship is scored it's going to go down a Shakedown Cruise through this my Canal once again I intend to show you how this all works but I want you to notice something this canal also has crane icons and a Lifeboat icon so I'm doubling up here this means I could score even more points for my cranes and boats now over here I have two employees these employees were acquired strategically during the game and you'll see how they upgrade my abilities this tile represents Commodities that I can trade and of course I'm going to show you how this is used in my example but for now just know that these things are here ready to be used when I need them now that's everything on my player board I'm now going to shift my focus to the available actions and we'll talk about what they enable me to do on my turn this is a setup for a three-person game player pieces are blocking the last actions chosen by those players so there are only four actions for me to choose from to start my turn I'm going to remove my action tile and place it at the start of the action track notice that this will turn the wheel which also acts as a turn counter there's a wooden Cube that falls into a hole after full rotation after full rotation one of these cubes is removed and that count counts down to the end of the game of the actions that are available to me

three of them are represented by rings I'm going to choose this one before I show you what this icon means I want to demonstrate a side effect of this choice for each player marker to the right of my newly placed marker one in this case I receive one coin I'll add that to my personal inventory now this ring is the manufacturer equipment action and you can see that it corresponds to this ring on the main board all four of these rings have their own action and each operates in the same way the first thing I'll do is I'll move the action marker clockwise one space if I wanted to I could move it farther for the price of one coin but in this case this is exactly what I want moving the marker only one space places me on the crane so I can take one crane from the supply this employee that you saw earlier gives me an additional crane whenever I take this action so I'm going to get two cranes on one turn now that's an entire turn and now my opponents are going to do the same thing you're going to see that old action tiles are going to be made available new action tiles will be claimed cubes will be moved and some tiles that are available to draft are going to be removed now it's my turn again and when you're playing this game it'll often be the case that an action that you want will be blocked for me I wanted to take the build ship action so that I could finish my ship but once again the action is unavailable to me so let's take a look at another way to get around this I'm going to choose the

exchange Commodities action it's another one of those ring actions so I'm going to move the cube over and I'm going to trade in one coal for a smoke stack one wheat for businessman and silk for two coins I now have quite a few coins earlier I described how you can spend coins to advance an action marker and modify the action but there's something better you can do if you save up for for six coins I can perform an additional action even an action that is blocked by another player so I'm going to spend my six coins to perform the build ship action and in this case because it's a bonus action the tile does not move what I really need are mounting points for my smoke stacks and right now these are all in a column that costs nothing I'm going to take these two to complete my ship and because I can take up to three I may as well take one more which I can use later my action phase is now over but because I've completed a ship my turn isn't over yet now I have to do a Shakedown Cruise so first I need to outfit my ship I must have a captain or the ship can't even be scored and a captain doesn't require a cabin so I can just put him right here all of my cranes and smoke stacks can be mounted on their corresponding mounting points the stoker has his own cabin indicated by its color and businessmen and any other crew that aren't stokers can go in a regular cabin but as you can see I don't have enough cabins for all of my businessmen that's

where this other employee matters this employee will let me take two more crew but not stokers and I don't need cabins for them so using this employee I can really fill out my ship with my ship ready I can now plan its route for the Shakedown Cruise but first it's necessary to calculate its speed and any base points that I'll get so a ship with one sto and one Smoke Stack has a base speed of four I have two additional Smoke Stacks so my speed is six I also get to score one point for each additional crew member and two points for each crane so this is already 10 points now I'm going to go on a cruise through my canals you didn't get to see where these Canal tiles came from but it works the same way as building a ship earlier in the game I used this action two separate times to take tiles that I thought would score me a lot of points now that I have a canal now and I have a ship I can go on my first cruise and I get to choose where I want to start so with sixspeed I'm going to start here each point along the way represents a government official who's raing my ship the first government official that I encounter is going to give me one point for each businessman and crane that's six points the next space is a blue ribbon space this gives me one point for each space I've traveled so far so to get here I've traveled four spaces so that's four more points the next official is evaluating me on safety I get one point per Lifeboat in this case

that's three more points finally I have one more space like the first for six more points altogether I've scored 19 points for this Shakedown Cruise I think it's worth noting that if I had found a way to increase my speed by two I could have hit the next Blue Ribbon space and it would have given me eight points because again I get one point per space that I traveled up to that point that wasn't the case for this cruise but I do think it's worth pointing out also note that now that my ship has left this tile I have to set it aside this is because you're not allowed to loop back to parts of your Canal that you've already been to from here on out my ship has to continue moving in this direction I'm not allowed to do a uturn in a later Shakedown Cruise Shakedown cruises happen at the end of your turn for every ship that you've completed on your turn you score the ship and then you put it in your Shipyard until the end of the game when you'll score your objectives as you can see with all of my lifeboats and businessmen I'll have plenty more points to accumulate at the end of the game now I hope you found that informative I'm really looking for feedback on this way of presenting the rules of a game so if you could give me a little feedback in the comments let me know if you thought that was just right or if you think it needed a little bit more information let me know that too and I'm still looking for what to call this method of teaching is it a turn talk through or a slice of gaml is it a w demonstration I don't really know but I need something for my video title so looking for ideas but let's go ahead now and talk about Shipyard so I always

break things down starting with theme and mechanics but today I want to start first with Artistry because I think there's something really special about this game that I want to point out before I get to the other elements of its game design that is this has kind of a new angle to Artistry a lot of times when I'm rating game on Artistry I'm looking at the artwork and I'm looking at the quality of the components often times you know figure figurines or painted wooden mles all of those things attract me to Artistry but it's sort of a surface level degree of artistry that you know usually gets that extravagant score and what I think I really appreciate in Shipyard as well as some other games by Vladimir Sushi is that the Artistry isn't in the look of the game rather the function fun of the pieces I'm talking specifically of this round counter where the players are picking up that action tile and using that to advance around counter not only that but you've also got the tray for all of the components that looks like a container that goes on a ship you've got the crane that keeps all of the tiles and all together when you're setting up this game it feels like you're building a shipyard and that is so interesting to me as far as the artwork is concerned is this a very impressive with the with the graphics I'm not very impressed with the graphics on this artwork at all but I'm very impressed with the environment that

you build that serves to add a a feel to the game it gives it a degree of beauty and it's all very functional I'm going to lead a little bit more in the side of extravagant because this to me is a creative way to exhibit Artistry in game design so we're going to start with that now we're going to talk about the game's design in terms of mechanics or theme and here I think this game despite the environment that it creates the reason you play this game isn't about building ships it's really the mechanics of action tiles I think the same thing about a game like Russian railroads in fact I feel like this is kind of like the ship version of Russian railroads where it has a theme in there there's a lot on with these ships and the the way that you're scoring I think a lot of you know how that scoring is motivated is is thematic but the the game is fully focused on uh honing in on one single mechanic and that's what makes this game fun so for design I'm putting my rating firmly over here for interaction like most Euro games this is a more isolated game however how you play the game is very influenced by what your opponents are doing think back to the example about when I took the manufacturer equ equipment action I took cranes because cranes was best for my scoring and the opportunity was best right at that moment had it not been on that position had it been on a different position I

would have to pay coins to advance the cube around until it got to the crane action that I wanted you're paying attention to your opponents watching and keeping track of the game State and seeing when the opportunity is just right so you can seize it when the when it comes your way that's really where the interaction Falls in for this game for strategy I think it's clear that this is a skill based game there are very few elements of luck the two things that do come up are the randomness of the ship tiles coming out for the build ships action and the randomness of the canal tiles when those come out but I feel like there are enough of those there's enough choices there that that's not going to have a huge influence uence in the game where like you can you can attribute losing to just not having the right tiles but I'll tell you the real challenge in this game it's playing the entire game without having any of your turns be wasted so when I've played this game I normally get about three ships sent out and of course I'm placing all of the tiles on my inventory on these ships what I don't like is when the game is over and I have tiles that never made it onto any ships because I didn't plan to build ships that could accommodate them that just means that all of the turns used for those tiles were wasted or if I have uh ship tiles that don't get a piece put on them then that's wasted and of course it takes a lot of skill to plan in order to avoid that for

complexity I almost want to call this a light heavyweight Euro game and that's because the rules are very simple there's only a few actions it's not hard to learn but it has that heavyweight Euro feel because there's so much planning involved and so much that you want to accomplish with your ships it's just very involved your in your head thinking through everything that you need to do and so it has that heavyweight feel to it even though this is not a very hard game to learn now I'd like to share my final thoughts and let's start with the negative first one thing you have to understand about me is that though I am a board game reviewer I don't like live in some board game reviewing Factory where people are playing every board game all the time I am a dad who is trying to play games with his friends and every time I bring a game to the table I have to like I have to sell it I should say hey we should play this game because this game is going to be so fun and or interesting or what whatever the angle is I have to sell it I can't just be like hey guys we need to play this game because I have to make a review for YouTube and so the challenge with a game like this for me as well as for anybody else is that building ships is a really dry theme people don't get excited about this this game so it just it doesn't look at the artwork it looks the only game that I have that's this awesome and looks this dumb is probably Concordia I hate the cover of Concordia so I have to bring it to the table and I have to say hey this boring

looking game it has such a pure mechanic so we should play it but still I have lots of games that have cool mechanics and they're not dry so how does this one rank with everything else it's it's like you've got a perfect game but it's not the game it's me I'm sorry game I need something that has a more like bite to it thematically that that's like the downside of this game but earlier when I was comparing this game you know talking about theme and mechanics I compared it to Russian railroads I mean this game has the feel of a classic mechanically driven Euro game like Russian railroads or hanza to Tanica like like those ones area control worker placement this one action selection it's just so perfectly honed down to what it does best and then you talk about the scoring like there's so many ways to optimize your score but at the beginning of the game you just have those default ways you know everything gets you know every crew gets one point all of the equipment gets two points yeah you could play the game like that but man you're not going to win unless you figure out how to use your canals well and capitalize on that with your secret objectives and you can get a lot of points that way so I think that makes it very very interesting and I can you know get people excited by describing the mechanics I wish that it had more thematic draw to it and then

um I I would say my only other criticism is that with those secret objectives players at the beginning of the game could be you know assigned objectives that kind of they're stepping on each other's toes so while two players are in conflict with each other and possibly you know taking actions or equipment that the other person was hoping to get another person could have secret objectives that don't conflict with the other two players at all so you get this runaway lead because they just happen to have an objective that the other people aren't you know interfering with and that Dynamic isn't intentional it's under the surface because no one knows what the secret objectives are and I I kind of don't like that like why do they have to be secret maybe maybe they could be face up so you could tell oh well my opponent is pursuing that so because he's doing that I'm going to count on that in order to plan for my turn but instead they're face down you have no idea what they're doing and whether that leads to an action that helps you or hurts you you're not really going to know because you don't know everything that's incentivizing them I think that would be like my my nitpicky criticism of how the game is designed I haven't played it with face up objectives maybe that's an easy fix just to have more transparency about why people are doing what they do um but in

any case I don't really care because whether I win or lose when I'm playing a Euro game like this I play for the independent challenge that I'm exper ering which is that I just want to do the best I can do you know I mentioned earlier eliminating waste making sure that no turn is wasted that's what makes this game fun so those are my thoughts don't forget to give me some feedback on how I did the rules explanation I'm really interested to hear more about how I could do better with that if I need to and uh thank you I will see you next time take care bye-bye

Progress saved