Evolution Review
Transcript
welcome to John Gates games today I'll be reviewing Evolution this is a tableau building game of survival of the fittest as you use tactical cardplay to adapt to the different species on the board and the changing food supply first I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review all right so how do we play Evolution at the beginning of the game each player starts with one species which is denoted by this little tracker here we could see that it's a very tiny species because it's got a body size of one and we see that there are almost none of them because has a population size of one each player also Begins the game with four cards because at the beginning of each turn you draw three cards plus one for each species that you have now each player is going to pick one card from their hand and they're going to put it face down in the middle of the table on this Watering Hole tile here it's got a really pretty side but for the sake of this video let's do the easier to read side so that means if I take this card here and I put it face down later in the turn this card is going to put three food on the watering hole each card on this spot is going to add food to it but we won't reveal that until all the actions have been completed once everybody's put a card on the watering hole we move on to the action phase we start with a player who has this totally awesome start player token in front of them and that player will take as many actions as they want to on their turn uh all actions consist of spending cards there are four of them the first thing you can do is you can just discard a card in order to increase the body size of any one of your species you can also discard a card to increase the population size of any of your species uh you can discard a card to create a new species so I put that guy
over here and boom we got a new species and they are a one one so those are the three kind of like basic super easy things you can do with your cards however the fun part of this game involves all the different attributes that are actually on these cards the fourth type of action you can do involves simply taking trait cards from your hand and putting them face down on top of a species that you already control if you're playing a two-player game then each species can take two different traits if you're playing a three to six player game each species can take three different traits these traits are going to stay face down until every single player has taken all of their actions now that both of our players here have taken all their actions we can flip over all of their traits and we can move on to the feeding phase of the game the first thing we do is reveal all the cards on top of the watering hole and we add food to the watering hole equal to the sum so we have 3 minus one here so we're going to get two food from the bank and we put them down on the veggie side up for the sake of this video I'm just going to put the food right here in the middle and now we start with the starting player and each player is going to take one food action and we're just going to go around the table until all of these species are no longer hungry or they no longer can actually eat and let's talk about the different traits that we have associated with these species now because this is really where the flavor of the game comes in on how each of these species can differentiate the first player species has a long neck and a hard shell we can see that the long neck gets them one plant food from the bank when the food cards are revealed and this doesn't actually come from the food pool here it comes from
off to the side and it immediately goes onto the species board here saying that this creature has already fed even though feeding actions haven't actually taken place yet the hard shell says it gets plus three body size when determining if the species can be attacked so for its defense it's effectively a size four species the second player chose to make a carnivorous species we could see that it can attack and eat other species but it can never eat plant food it also put attack hunting on here which says it gets plus three body size when determining if this species can attack another species so we look over here we see that it is effectively a size five when it comes to attacking other species and I'll explain why that matters in just a second so we start with the first player and they get to take a feeding action we have two food in the middle of the table but they've already taken a food for their long neck this means that their species is actually not hungry anymore you're never allowed to take food on your player board that is greater than the population size of your species so for this first turn the starting player is just going to pass on the feeding phase and now we go to the second player in order for carnivores to eat they have to attack a different species they never get to take food from the center of the bank and in order to attack another species you have to match two different criteria the first is that you have to have a larger body size than the species that you're attacking the second is that you must have traits that negate any defensive traits that the species over here might have for instance there is climbing which says a
carnivore must have climbing to attack the species so they're safe up in the branches unless the carnivore evolves as well we've also got burrowing which says this species can't be attacked if it has food equal to its population looks like uh player one probably would have preferred to have burrowing over long neck because they would have been immune in this situation there are also several defense cards which affect the species that are to the left or right of the species with this trait for instance warning says a carnivore must have the Ambush trait in order to attack a species to the left or right of this species right here that species itself isn't protected but it protects the ones next to it we've also got cards like symbiosis which says this species cannot be attacked if the species to the right has a larger body size than the species so there are lots of different defensive ways to stop a carnivore for from getting at you but there are still several ways for carnivore to negate these defensive traits so our carnivore over here has an effective body size of five versus our herbivore who has an effective body size of four so the carnivore can attack this herbivore over here this means that for their feeding action they attack when an attack happens the uh the species that gets attacked loses a population so they would go down on the track in this case since it's at one already it goes to zero and it's going to go extinct but we'll handle that in just a second now the carnivore is going to feed equal to the body size of the species that just attacked so the body size is actually only one since this hard shell only adds to the defense value so you would take a meat token from the bank off to the side
it's the same as the food tokens just with that meat side and you would put that on top of the carnivore over here and now we would go back to the starting player the moment a species loses its last population they go extinct the first thing that happens is you take any food that's on this board here and you put it in the little food pouch that is associated with that player this means that player is still going to get the victory points for having gathered that food the next thing that happens is this species goes away and the last thing is you take all the traits that are on that species and you discard them from the game and then that player is going to draw cards equal to the amount discarded back into their hand so they have a bit of a rebound on the following turn at this point the starting player has no more species to feed and the second player has no hungry species because it matches its population and we are now done with the feeding phase all food that that is on the watering hole actually stays there and Will acrew from round to round one more note about feeding if you ever have an animal that is still hungry which means it has a population size that is unequal to the amount of food it has gathered during the feeding phase and there is no more food to be had in the watering hole or if this is a carnivore and it has no more valid species to attack then at the end of the feeding phase before you take the food off of your player board you will reduce your population down to wherever they were able to feed at essentially that population dies off and only the ones who are able to eat in this round are going to continue on
throughout the game if this means that you actually go extinct because for instance an animal did not have any food then the standard Instinct rules apply at the end of the feeding phase each player will take all the food that is left on any of their species boards and they'll put it inside their own little personal Food Bag uh essentially logging those victory points for the end of the game at the end of the turn the start player token is going to move around the table to the next person to the left in this case it would flop over here and we start by doing a draw phase where we draw three cards plus one for every species in front of you in this case this player would only get three cards but remember they draw drew those two cards from the extinction and this player over here will draw four cards because they have three plus one the game will keep going until every card in this deck is dealt uh if this happens during the draw cards phase at the beginning of a turn you will Shuffle the discard and finish dealing out cards to every player however ever if this happens in the middle of a turn due to Extinction then you will Shuffle the discard and do one more full turn and then the game is over at the end of the game each player is going to pull all the food out of their pouches and they're going to get one Victory point for each food in there then they're going to get one Victory point for the population size of each other species so the species would give three victory points to this player and the species would get four victory points for this player and finally you get one Victory point for every trait on species so one two three victory points over here for this player versus over here the body size we give them three points then plus one two for the trade cards over here
then you compare the victory Point totals and see who was the winner for my review of evolution I'm going to explain my thoughts on each item of this list as we work our way down so let's start with the positives the first thing that I really like about this game is how the theme integrates into the mechanics and really comes out feeling like natural selection and survival of the fittest is happening on the table as you're playing you have these species and you are constantly adapting them to a a changing landscape if you have a climbing herbivore for instance and an opponent makes a climbing carnivore well there's no reason to be climbing anymore the only reason to climb was to get away from opponents so suddenly you might get rid of the climbing and put hard shell down but in the process odds are good in that previous turn that climbing carnivore jumped up and ate some of your population if you didn't go extinct it's almost thematically you can think that the ones that survived were the ones that were kind of already evolving hard shell so to speak it's it really kind of feels like that theme comes through with the mechanics as you're playing the game uh sometimes it kind of feels like maybe survival of the fittest comes ACR across too strongly as certain species start to get kind of unkillable but I'll explain that kind of thing later in the review the second positive is I love the mechanic of having a hand of cards and giving as many actions as you want just figuring out the puzzle of what the best thing to do with your hand is and you mix that in with with this game with playing cards down uh face down until everyone has taken all their actions so you have imperfect information you have
some idea you could see that opponent put down one card and they increase their body size in the first turn and you're thinking the only reason they do that is if that face down card was a carnivore so that they could attack somebody so now you're automatically thinking about maybe going defensive because you're kind of hedging your bets that that probably is a carnivore and there's lots of that thinking that I really enjoy seeing how many face down cards people have played what cards um how many cards people discarded to increase population or body size can really be tells as to what that species is going to become but you don't know so you have to play with that imperfect information and do the best you can with your hand and I just really like that mechanism the third positive is I have to highlight how amazing the art and production quality are in this game every single card you play Down has this gorgeous piece of art the front of the box has this vibrant amazing scene it it makes me want to put it like this on top of my board gaming shelf instead of like this unfortunately I have to do it like this to save space but I want to just put this out there and just leave it like that for the whole game uh the design of the game is also very good in that as you're playing you have these little species player boards and those might not be the prettiest things in the world but they get the idea across very easily you can look around the table and get a very uh good idea of where the species are and how they're doing just through the design of those um those pieces unfortunately the text on the cards is a little small but every player gets a very extensive player Aid that has all the card uh information on the back and it's got some uh turn order stuff on the front also every single play raate has a scientific names section which is actually different
between the play raids and it lets you name the creatures you have based on the traits so you could say oh if I have an intelligent carnivore I could call it a it's my smarty Nom Nom it's GNA be attacking your uh Flocka Digger you could just it's kind of fun to be able to just talk about those kind of things as well so uh the art and production quality super topnotch really really love the look of this game on the table the first neutral point I want to talk about has to do with how impactful that starting player token is and how little control players have over it in fact zero control it starts with a random player at the beginning of the game and it just moves clockwise once after every single turn but it has very big impacts on gameplay uh two of them in particular the first is that that starting player is really in the dark when it comes to playing their actions out they have not seen anyone else play any traits they haven't seen anyone else play any body size or anything like that so they don't know what's going to happen and that's they're at a disadvantage there the flip side to that is that they get to feed first which means they might have an species not go extinct when someone else's might because there's not enough food in the watering hole or even just that first food might activate an ability that is on that creature that would make it invulnerable I wish there was an advanced variant that would cause the starting player token to move differently than clockwise for instance maybe have it always go to the player who has the strongest or the the largest uh species or the most species and then have feeding always start with the person with the least species that kind of thing to try and balance out a couple of the concern I'm going to talk about
in just a little bit but I just feel like there is room for slightly more interesting mechanic when it comes to that starting player token the second neutral point has to do with large carnivorous creatures and specifically the pack hunting card the that card gives the creature plus three body size when trying to figure out if it can attack anyone else and this card alone versus any other trait in my opinion in the game is super powerful early game as a first turn play playing a carniv carnivore card down and then a pack hunting card there is nothing that anyone can do to defend against that well they could have a hard shell if they don't have the hard shell which also gives plus three to defense there's really nothing that anyone can do about it it seems like the the best defense is to be the not the best Target like hope that someone else's species is going to get attacked by that pack hunting creature but it's going to eat somebody and it's probably going to be effective for several rounds and the biggest problem I have with that is that it launches that carnivore to the state where it is never going to die it often becomes like a 66 Beast that just just kills things throughout the whole game and I feel like that accelerated jump into being so powerful with the pack hunting card is the problem if that pack hunting card wasn't there that carnivore might actually have a die out at some point because it couldn't quite eat something I feel feel like once a creature gets to a certain size and this isn't just carnivores this has to do with herbivores as well once they get to a certain size they kind of become unkillable uh now you could say oh you
know group think maybe we just starve out the watering hole and it's going to go extinct because there's not enough food and that's a potential thing but in actuality when I've seen this play out usually there's just one Mega predator and then one or two Mega herbivores and then everyone else just kind of gets destroyed by the mega Predator the mega Predator can't get at that Mega herbivore and everyone else is kind of at their Mercy as I mentioned in the very first point this really does play into the survival of the fittest motif of the game unfortunately it it isn't the funnest thing to be a part of especially when you are at the being attacked end now I'm not saying that that apex predator player always wins in fact they have not necessarily always won but it has such an strong impact on gameplay that I feel like I feel like I might just play without the pack hunting card I'm not sure about that just see what the happens with a couple games to see if it's just a little bit more difficult for these carnivores to get a foothold and if they get a foothold that's fine you that's good gameplay but I feel like it's almost too much of an acceleration early game into what will become just a dominating figure throughout the game play my one negative Point has to do with how hard it is to claw back into the game once you've been smacked around by a carnivore early on and maybe have a couple species go extinct this largely has to do with how you draw cards you get three cards plus one card for each species you have in front of you and if you find yourself on the second turn uh third turn with one species maybe zero species and then back to one maybe two but then it goes away you are going to slowly fall farther and
farther behind to the person who is able to keep that first species and maybe make a second one and protect that one while maybe having that first one be a carnivore and maybe even going up to three they're just getting more and more powerful while this person is just never able they're not necessarily getting weaker they're just they're just staying at a low power level while other people are getting bigger and bigger uh this has to do with what I mentioned with the starting player token earlier where I feel like if it was to be modified slightly so that the starting player was always the person with the most species maybe a tiebreaker on the largest species then they would always be playing their actions in the dark so they'd be at a slight disadvantage to compensate for how strong their situation is uh and the flip side of that being to the the feeding phase if you always had the person with the least amount of species feeding first maybe they could claw back in as far as victory points are concerned so they slightly less likely to go extinct or lose as much population versus the players who have all these species in front of them and you might be thinking well when your species goes extinct you get to draw cards from the top of the stack equal to the trait cards that were on it but you are still at a pretty big card loss because you spent cards to make that species you probably spent one or two cards to increase population or the body size to try and protect it but then somebody played pack hunting or something like that and they still kill it off you um you just find yourself slipping farther and farther behind it almost makes me want to draw a card no matter what just for that species that died to help get that person back into the game but I'm not going to do too many balance tweaks on a game I've only played three times at this point and so
far this has been the only aspect of the game that's kind of brought down my enjoyment as I'm playing in now let's talk briefly about replayability the game comes with 17 tra cards it's 18 if you happen to have backed the kickstarter and that seems like quite a variety and and it is however many of them are quite situational and many of versus many of them being very powerful kind of all the time with some very obvious synergies where um you I've already started to see creatures come out from game to game that look very similar that being said replayability is going to be fueled by the Adaptive nature of the theme and the game because you're not just going to want to make this one super thing and it's always going to be great every single game you're constantly adapting to how much food's in the watering hole what are the carnivores looking like if you're the carnivore what are those herbivores looking like with our defenses so you're certain cards going look better or worse in your hand based on the game State and I think that's going to give this game a lot of replayability now let's talk player count this game plays two to six players and I've only played it three times so far I've played the two three and five player games so I'm going to start there the two-player game worked quite well the only difference is that you discard 30 random cards from the trait deck and each species can only have two different traits on it I really enjoyed it however uh the feedback I got from my opponent and I definitely have that feeling too is is that there's almost too much information in a two-player game there are so few species out there that it seems like the most analysis paralysis happened then because you feel like you really could track every single possible
thing that those traits could be that your opponent just played and it seemed to slow the game down a little bit which is crazy because it was a two-player game versus the five player game for instance and even the the three-player game to a certain degree where there is so much uncertainty that you just kind of decide you know what I cannot get to AP in this situation I just kind of have to do the best thing I think I have with my hand hedge my bets and hope that this is going to work so two-player almost too much information you can almost not head your beds enough three-player worked very well however three player is going to be the longest game in my opinion because you don't take any cards out of the deck and the deck is your timer so you're going to go through that whole thing um so the three-player game I felt went maybe a little bit too long but I definitely enjoyed it I haven't played four but I have played five and I suspect four was probably actually The Sweet Spot for this game five player also worked better than I was expecting I was kind of ready for lots of analysis paralysis or maybe not just just lots of downtime because that's four different players who are going to play all the hand the cards in their hand however it didn't really seem too bad because like I said there's just so much uncertainty that you just kind of have to kind of like ah this is a pretty good combo I'm just going to do it and hope that it's going to work also that's so many players drawing cards from that deck that in that five player game we made it once around the table we play it was five turns long uh it took about an hour and it felt it felt good like it didn't feel like it was too short it didn't feel like it was too long I think I'm kind of hesitant to play six players I kind of doubt I'll ever go quite that far because that really is a lot of people and the rule
book suggests you play all your action simultaneously which I think is you know then people are going to kind of cheat they're kind of doing that but they're still kind of looking around see what other play people did I don't think I'd recommend six but uh three to five worked very well two works if you're okay with a lot of analysis options in conclusion I've played this game three times and I have come dead last all three of those games in the two-player game in the five player game I have been the worst player and every single time I've played I've enjoyed myself now I've had several frustrating hands you know I talked earlier my neutrals and negatives where I'm just like oh just that 66 crazy Predator over there just keeps destroying me and he can't attack his primary leader I mean it's pretty obvious I'm not winning that person over there is winning but they have defensive hurting and all this crazy stuff they're also at 66 and they can't be attacked and they're just eating so much food every turn and I'm getting like one or two points a turn while I'm constantly trying to survive and constantly going into extinction because I can't CL my way back in however I've always enjoyed myself I've always ended every game Dead last and thinking man I can't wait to play this again this is a really interesting game so it when you're thinking about purchasing this game understand that there can be some frustrations but I feel like it was almost just helped by the fact that the negative attributes just f bed into that survival of the fittest theme where I'm just thinking I'm not the fittest but I'm participating in this really cool gaming experience where I'm just watching Evolution happen right in front of my eyes so I've really enjoyed playing this game I will continue to I hope that the
neutral and negative points I had won't start to change my opinion we'll kind of see how time goes on but at this point I definitely recommend playing this game it is super cool if you enjoyed this video and would like to see more please subscribe to my YouTube channel and please leave uh feedback questions comments I'd love to hear back from you thanks for watching