Skip to main content
Loading video...

Children of the Colossi - Board Game Review - Can't Make An Omelette. . .

Transcript 19:36

Hi there, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken Mele, a show where I devote my time to raving and ranting about board games, but usually more the latter part if we're honest. This one intrigued me. This is Children of the Colossi from Cosmo Games. This is from debut designer Jakopo Salia. I hope I'm pronouncing that remotely correctly. But this one intrigued me because not because it's an area control game because area control games admittedly is probably down the scale in terms of my favorite like mechanics. You know, I don't go mad for area control games, but this one had the appeal of having movable locations that had the action spaces on. So, normally you would just have a board with action spaces or a fixed map with spaces. This one has a map, but then it also had action boards where these things are moving around the map as they go along. It's like, well, okay, so a potential weird logistical nightmare in itself, but it's like, yeah, okay, that's something a little bit different. We haven't really seen that before. So, the question is, jump in it. Can it set itself apart from the crowd, or is it going to be just like every other area control game out there? Just dudes on the map. What the hell?

Get on with it.

In this game, you are competing over areas on the board to collect these different eggs. These eggs are laid by the Colossi, which are these giant titans, kaiju, big creatures, big riding mounts, whatever you want to call it. These basically roam around the landscape and have entire cities on their back effectively. You are competing to reach 10 victory points, which is the end goal of the game. So, soon as you hit 10, there you go. You've won the game. And the idea is is that it's kind of twofold. It's area control, but it's also worker resource management in a sense. You have a bunch of these little workers. They're dotted around the board. Some will be in the chasm at the beginning, but others will be dotted around the various areas. And these areas, depending on player count, will be filled up with some negative spaces, but otherwise they will be filled up with potential eggs. Different colossi that you have in the game will have different eggs and troopers will do them. But there's also some common ones as well. And these fill up the little spaces. As soon as one of these gets full up to the brim, a battle occurs between the players that are there. And then we see who wins the battle and who gets the most eggs out of the deal. But the idea is is that each car site comes with its own action board. So this is one in particular. And these have different action spaces where you have a hub at the bottom where a bunch of your agents will gather. And then what you do is that you can effectively do an action that is adjacent to the space that your um one of your guys is on or the bottom hub. But if you're willing to spend spark as a resource, which is essentially another resource you can get during the game, you can effectively chain together multiple actions as long

as you're willing to pay the cost and have the available agents. The different goss have all sorts of different sort of variations with their actions. I mean, some allow more freedom of movement, some are better at getting your guys um like, you know, buffs in battles. Some of them have like little quirky rules to themselves, but there'll be marginal differences and marginal bonuses. And even the eggs that they that come from them are going to have, you know, slight differences in how they operate as well. There are five in the game and you only choose three. So there is an aspect of variety there. But the glass eye are actually on the board itself. So you have an impassible area here, the chasm. Other than that, once you have done your turn in doing agents, you will then take one of these class and move it across the board. So you will basically move one from there to there, usually of the one that you've done an action for. And you know, obviously with this colossi moving around a board, you might be in one area that you're like, "Okay, fine.

I my agents are on this particular board doing actions, but the colossi is here, and I kind of would like it to be over here where these other eggs are." You've got to move it over there, or you've got to use actions to glide on and off the colossi themselves. So, you can actually glide your people off this board and onto the actual map, but then you can also hook people from the map back onto the colossi itself. So there is a essentially a a constant moving nature of the action boards across the map. The battle sequence works essentially with uh each of your agents being worth one strength. You know, a fairly typical easy way to resolve it. But you have these battle cards and you will select one of these and it's very much one of those games where you play one and then you have less to use in future battles until you spend a card to actually recover them all. But these do different things. Like they will give you certain buffs in battles, but they also let you move units in and out. They might even let you run away and get a little bonus.

You might even be able to earn some points or spark depending on the circumstances. You know, not not every one of these is just about screwing over your opponent. There are some sneaky little tactics and ambush like strategies you can throw in here. Uh whoever wins the area is going to get more benefit than the rest, but everybody kind of gets a prize. It's just that more eggs are likely to go to the person who won the battle and everybody else will get like a little bit. Maybe they'll get an egg or they just won't get their choice. But the idea is is that these eggs when they hatch, I mean, some of them are just worth straight up points, but some of them will have a newborn ability that is dependent on the colossi that you're using in the game. The different colossi also have certain cards that you can grab from them which basically give you like a a quicky little bonus, but again, they're unique to the colossi. For example, this uh like red dude here, you know, has potions that you can grab, which, you know, give you a benefit for using the potion. Uh the green colossi, which uh I believe is this dude here, basically has a lot more ways to move your guys across the entire map rather than just from where the coloss is. So, you know, you've got a bit more long range freedom of movement. You know, they're all unique in that regard. And this is kind of how the game plays out.

Everybody takes it in turns to do actions on these various boards of which there are free to move around the map. Wait for the eggs to come out of a drawn bag effectively depending on the actions that you do. And once they fill up, do the battle resolve, collect the eggs, collect victory points, and try to be the first one to 10.

Well, that went okay.

All right, let's address the elephant in the room here. Okay, I needed to be the fly on the wall in the meeting that discussed how they were going to produce the game because some bits work quite nicely. I do like these giant minis as you know the Colossi. I do like the fact that you know there is you know relatively straightforward graphic design although the iconography is not the most intuitive in places. There is a lot of uh reference guides that you have to consult you know and such. So it's not the most easiest to grasp off the bat. And I do like the artwork on these Colossi boards. I mean, the the artwork on the Colossi themselves looks really nice. You know, I like the background of these boards. They're all cool. But you you might have noticed something that's uh somewhat big. I mean, I mentioned the word elephant in the room. How big's an elephant? Well, how big is this frigin game? Jesus Christ. This this thing is huge. I mean, this is a game that warrants more table space than something like a Lerner game, Galactic Cruise, and any of those other ones this year. Look how big this board is. I mean, this is this is just I can't even fit it in the entire camera frame, you know. This is just the main board. And it only comprises of, I think, three, four, five, six, seven, eightish, you know, locations on it. And all the locations are is just the vents where the eggs appear. And that's it. There is nothing else in these areas. I mean, it's weird.

You've got like a really nice picture of a Colossi on here and on the cover and some, you know, interesting terrain sort of features on the inside of the box and that and even the rule book's got a nice cover to it. But this is all really muted and boring. It's just a muted color palette with five bits on it. And I get that makes it a little bit easier to see what's going on so you don't have too much like, you know, clogging your visual senses. But then if if all this board is meant to be is just a muted color palette with five vents in it, why does it need to be this huge? It's insane because think about it. It's not just this board you need. You need three of these. Three of them. I'll say that again. You need three of these on the table, man. I mean, I have a Geekism table here and I struggle to put things in an area on this entire table in a way that's easy for people to visualize because the other problem is that you've got this board, you know, in the middle, like hopefully in the middle where people can see the agents. Fine. But your agents are only like this big.

They're very tiny and yet they're standing in a space that's [snorts] huge for them. And I get that. So you can have a lot of people in the same area, but there must have been a way to maybe do like one little dude is worth one and then maybe have a big dude that's worth three or five and then you could easily just put them in a smaller space. The Coloss are nice big minis, but they don't take up much space either. There's just no reason for the board to be this huge. And when you've got these like Colossi boards around it, they're not going to be in front of everybody. So somebody's going to have them right next to each other or something like that. the other person's going to have to stare for miles to see the the other board and see it. And granted, they are they're big, you know, they're done with big icons and that, but I don't know. I just feel like the the whole thing could have been scaled down a few notches, you know, just to make it a little bit more easier to get to a table because it doesn't have to be jumbosized.

Please excuse the crudity of this model. I didn't have time to build it to scale or to paint it. And this really doesn't help with the iconography and the reference aids because, you know, you have a little reference aid or two yourself, a double-sided card, but it's got a lot of text on it. And granted, it explains a decent amount on these cards, but you should shorthand it a little bit, not just have it be a wall of text, but then the reference aids for each colossi, there's only one card for each one. So, you put it next to the Colossi board, which means it's miles away from at least several people around the table because it's next to where the board is. And there's no iconography guide per player, which again, reference aids. Come on, people. So, you've got to pass around this board, but sorry, this back of the book, but this back of the book isn't comprehensive for all the iconography in the game. I mean, particularly with the battle cards, you know, there's some iconography on here, and I legitimately, even to this day, struggle to remember what some of these do without having to read the rule book on them. They're just not the most intuitive. And that's kind of like the the main bug bear with this one, because it sounds like I'm completely ragging on it. Don't worry, I'll get to the good parts. But the biggest issue this game has is a barrier to entry or two that it shouldn't have. I mean, it doesn't need to be this big to take up so much table space. There could have been some better like reference aids made that shorthand things a little bit. You could have had personal iconography guides. You could have made the iconography just a little bit more intuitive in certain places. I mean, the movement ones especially are a little bit tricky to figure out. And it

there's just like bits and bobs here and there like having this having these reference cards for the colossal like across the table and and that it there's just bits and bobs here that make the game a little bit more fiddly to get into than it should be because when you actually boil down the rules of this game, it's not very complicated. The area control here is fairly bare bones. It is basically a case of put your guys here when it fills up with eggs, count the strength, count the number of units you have here, and resolve a battle card. They're very straightforward. That's not necessarily a bad thing. It's good that it's streamlined in that way. And yeah, I suppose I made the slight comparison for like 10 victory points. This, you know, we've seen this in more games than just Dun and Beer, but the idea of playing a card to muck around with the combat, you know, we've seen this in um oh, what's that? What's that one that uh oh, it's it's the sister to cichlides or something like that. It's the I don't know. I'll find out and put it on the screen. But uh it you know, you had that game where you played combat cards before combat. And I like this mechanic because it does throw a little bit of an extra span in the works and it does allow you to play some little devious tricks to try and earn points or earn like movement and stuff even if you're not necessarily intending to win the battle. And yes, it's important to win these battles, but you don't necessarily have to. You will still get a prize for being there and participating. It's just the winner gets a bit more. So it doesn't it doesn't feel quite as restrictive or as punishing as some area control games can be where if you lose you get diddly squat.

YOU LOSE.

GOOD DAY SIR.

Everybody gets a prize. I just get a bigger prize. I kind of like that. I like it that you you know failure does not mean nothing. You know it's we can be a little nicer than that. the but it just means that trying to learn the game and trying to teach it is just a bit more tricky than it needs to be and the size of the scope of the game doesn't help you know I feel like it just feel like certain things could have been done to make it a bit more user friendly now those being said that being said when you actually get into the game play that bit is the fun aspect I do really like this concept of the coloss moving around and being representative of the board so you know if I want particular actions from this board or if I'm trying to get my obelisk built on it. It's like a little side mechanic or, you know, other things on here. Then obviously I need to be where this guy is. But if this guy's like tripping around all over here, you know, over this side and I'm over here, it's like, well, how do I get to it? You know, do I like move it in this general direction or hope it comes back around to me or do I, you know, use other abilities to get to where it's going, you know, failing that? Okay, I might just have to leave this colossally for a bit, but it's okay. weird, you know, horn spider thing or whatever the hell this thing's meant to be, you know, is coming around. And it's got its own little quirky rules and some of its other little things. I can get wisp tokens and do stuff with that. And this is cool and it adds to the replay value because you do have five of these and you only use free and certainly the combination of free that you use does have a fairly dramatic effect on the game. I mean, for example, you know, this one here is good for freedom of movement. you know, there's a lot of

ways to hook and glide and get across the entire map. Take this one out of the game and suddenly are a little bit more restrictive on that front. So, they do have an impact. And in the future, if they ever expanded the game, they could just add more of these boards for even more variety. And that would be pretty cool. Uh the, you know, the the eggs themselves, the little newborn abilities, so you can actually have a person riding around or a little newborn dinosaur going around the place.

Hey, easy with the head punches, fats. So,

it's nice. It adds little unique quirks to each game and the combination of the class A is definitely going to you know make you know not make or break but you know it's it's definitely going to have an impact. It's impactful as to how the game goes and I would like to see this kind of done more often where you know there is a moving platform for the area control and the actions aspect. We don't see that a lot in game. So this one does have an essence of originality. Game goes to two to four players 30 minutes a player. That's pretty accurate. You are definitely looking at a good couple of hours to finish a full game of this. You know, it may only be 10 victory points, but every point is consequential. So, I mean, you know, you really are fighting for the points. And, you know, it does take a little bit of time to get there, especially when the rule book could be a little bit better and the iconography could have been a bit easier. You know, there is definitely some FAQ moments that do arise. You know, there is there is pictorial examples in here, but there's also times where it's just quite a lot of text. So, you know, I have seen better rule books for sure. Thankfully, the rules themselves are not crazy complicated in this game, but again, it's just these little irks with the iconography and how the thing is so big in that. They just get in the way of making this as streamlined as it possibly could be almost like it just needed a little bit of extra time in the development room, you know? I could I could really see a second edition of this being like like amazing, you know, like where they go, right, let's just condense the size down a bit and not make it quite so ridiculously big. Uh,

let's get the rule book, you know, get an editor in, really make that rule book sound, and maybe just tidy up some of the iconography and produce enough reference aid so that everybody can easily see what all the stuff means. You know, I just I think if if if all that was done, it would really improve this game a lot. In its current state, it's fun and I do enjoy it, but it's a hard one to bring out. It's just it's going to take a little bit of extra time. Like, if I bring this out, I need to have a quick glance over the rules again. Just make All right, so hang on. That works like that. That works like that. That icon's like that. All right. Right. I'm good. I'm good. I'm good. You know, once you get the hang of that, then you're in for a good fun time. But it's it only it basically makes this game good, but it caps it good. It can't get any better than that because of its uh issues with user friendliness, you know. So, you know, I wanted this to be great. It could have been excellent.

Even this could, you know, it's got an original style of area control with a fairly streamlined combat system with a good amount of replay value. And as much as I think the board looks very boring, you know, there is decent, you know, artwork and that to be found with regards to these boards. So, there's good things here, but it's it's hindered. it's, you know, it's holding itself back from being particularly great and it just makes it very tricky to bring out. So, you are going to have to bear that in mind. That being said, like I say, for a debut design, I think this is a good foundation and maybe a sequel game or a second edition of this could improve on it and give us something that, you know, really does surpass other area control games. But for now, it's decent and it's good and I think I can give this one a seven out of 10. It's a It's a recommendation, but just, you know, it was banging on for a six maybe, but I do get some enjoyment out of this. And I do like this whole coloss moving around, the variety, and having to juggle my workers between, you know, whether they're on the board contributing to area control or on here contributing to actions. It's a good juggling [clears throat] process. It's a good It's a good twist on the whole sort of resource management combined with area control. So, we've got a good foundation here and it's good enough that I can recommend it, but the caveat is that it's just regarding way too much t it needs too much table space for what it needs to be. So, you are going to have to bear that in mind and you're definitely going to have to work a little bit with the rules and the

iconography to make certain it's like, you know, really ingrained in your head, especially when you're teaching it. I think the first game, if you're learning straight from the rule book as your first game, it's going to be a long one. It's going to be a tough one. You know, you need a good dedicated teacher, I think, to get the most out of this. But if you can get past those initial barriers to entry, you're in with a pretty decent fun time. It's just could have been great. [clears throat] Could have been great. But it's just it's holding back and I don't want it to hold back. I want it to go all the way. So, a good start, but we'll have to see if anything comes from this in the future, second edition or expansion or anything to try and make life a bit easier. But for now, it's this was a good effort. We are reasonably satisfied with the events we have seen. So

that's it for me on this episode of the broken people. If you like what you see then please thumb up on YouTube and thumb up on board game when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my Essen content. There is so much to get done and so much already in the editing room that I have lost count. So there is so much uh stuff to do and I doubt I'll have it all done by Christmas. So uh you can look forward to some more Essen content in January along with probably the top 10 of the year because I doubt I'll be able to get it done by the end of December anyway. There's a lot of games, a lot of stuff to cover, but hey, I'm enjoying getting through them. So, this is just one out of many. So, take care and remember, regardless of whether you want to live on top of a giant stegosaurus or some two-headed hydra beast, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.

Progress saved