Viscounts of the West Kingdom: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for vi counts of the west kingdom which like i mentioned in the run-through is the third installment of the west kingdom series you can check out our run-throughs for uh paladins and architects on the channel if you want to know what we think of those but what did you guys think of vi counts of the west kingdom yeah i like this one you did you did yeah awesome devin it was okay it was okay it was okay not bad i uh i enjoyed this one actually probably the most this one actually is my favorite out of the three there was no stupid cathedral mechanic where it's like oh that's how you went right there was no cutthroat dumbass nature where people are just going to inevitably just steal from people for just because of the potential that they might do anything it's like always my turn just to stop you from doing it's [ __ ] that game yeah and paladins uh was a little a little grindier than than most and i felt at the at the early game if you made a mistake you were punished with your different colored worker placement sections um but uh each of them are radically different uh from the last so if you do enjoy this west kingdom series you can get all three and have a completely different uh game which i i do appreciate so first things first uh the art is absolutely disgusting i i despise i despise his or her his art it's so gross and you know obviously it is it is made to be that way like right it is very intentional they are
every single character is obnoxiously hideous but i always like the boards the boards are always bright and vibrant with some detail but yeah i hate the characters um anyway uh yeah this one i would feel is actually in in comparison to the other two kind of mid-tier it's not as complex as uh as as paladins but it's not as light as architects yeah um yeah and i very much enjoyed because whenever i was reading the rule book and watching the now the play i was like oh this is going to be weird like how everything kind of worked how you have the corruption and virtue track which is in all of the games with the corruption track and stuff and that's always kind of a thing um but uh here instead of like having to worry so much about debts and and deeds like i actually like this balanced mechanic where it's like if you're gaining debts it's not the worst thing in the world because if you have a lot of debts like we didn't even i it was actually some shock at the end where we you and i were going virtue build and then at the end it's like oh we only get those points cat's actually benefiting getting [ __ ] 12 huge points 12 points from the uh from all the debts that she got i encourage you to go kind of back and forth right which since both me and you were going pro uh deeds yeah it ate through that right i was definitely going bad boy build right and which was not intentional but um i also found
didn't make me eat absolute [ __ ] yeah yeah because in in the other ones it was basically a track if you went down the track and the worse you got it made things cheaper like in architects i think it made it cheaper to do actions no paladins whichever one but it basically made actions cheaper but you were accruing debt the whole time yeah um but i believe in the other ones the debt that you flipped was worth like a point i think you got like one point or something uh for actually flipping it and so it was always interesting but here i actually pretty much thoroughly enjoyed the track at how they go back and forth and you can go all like all debt build you're gonna get a lot more money which money is huge in this game uh more so than we thought in terms of being able to be like oh i just want to use you for your uh for your symbol pop them off you need money to do that and to recruit to build your deck a little bit better you need money to do that right if you're get a [ __ ] hand of all ones and you're like i need to go over here you need money to do that but i think that i think actually almost every strat is incredibly balanced and i thought that way in paladins as well um architects i didn't think so it was like if you're going cathedral there was one way to like yeah unless you all ignored it but here i think from first to last was 12 points you had like 45 right and i had 57 um and devin had 44 maybe 47 or 50. close cloak
yeah i was in between ours yeah yeah and we all went radically different in terms of how we were gonna play yeah um but that one makes you think this game is okay i mean it's got it hits a lot of the same notes those previous games i mean you got your work replacement here i mean i guess this one's a little less worker work replacement it is more resource management i guess i know you know the terms the building yeah deck building there you go um i mean it was still like it's still a good game it's fun to play uh i don't know just because it felt a little underwhelming compared to the i think paladins definitely had me kind of like whoa well this one's got a lot going on yeah and i wouldn't say too simple i don't know it had a different mechanic yeah like the movement kind of irritated me um and how like get like to get anything like properly done i mean when you got a little later in the game and you had a few symbols of crew it wasn't this bad but like definitely early game if i want to do any any one particular thing it took me like three actions like yeah go there well when i did crew money and then i had to go to a place to spend trade symbols and then i had to go to the place to actually use the symbol i just collected and then i can build a thing or i can grab a transcript so it yeah i mean it's not bad um i like the dismiss action not that i used it once i don't think uh that you can just get yourself a free resource so free you can get it simple and get a free symbol i mean unless until you get that other thing that i ignored where they're
just equal one i mean some of them were just way too pricey um this is a game where i actually think you can do a little of everything yeah and you'll benefit from it instead of like oh i'm i went pure castle that was my my choice right um but and that's like no one yeah definitely no one like competing with you there yeah it makes it just you know farm city right yeah because i was like oh my god that is a mechanic designed to be competed for exactly because it's like someone's going for it we should have all been going for it right because they're bumping me off more right um and i like i like that i think that the fact that because getting to the middle actually takes some work like i had to actively place people in certain areas get to a certain spot so then i could get those uh combos um and it actually wasn't as fiddly as i thought it was going to be like i thought this little piece i thought was going to be like oh oh [ __ ] oh like an infomercial right oh no yeah and it actually wasn't that bad um but yeah you guys like completely leaving me alone i was just like once towards the towards the end it was like okay they're gonna go here oh and there's oh there's three of mine again and then these are gonna pop up and go up and then it was just you guys just handed it to me but that was only mine i also think like with leaving you alone like there's there's two sides to that story too is like obviously you got to do what you want to do but devin was so focused on like okay well i have to do these several multiple things just to get this in the end and for me it was
just i was just kind of having fun walking around the board trying to build my houses yeah so we all definitely had like that one thing that we were trying to do it was funny because i started out being each other huh and so we didn't affect each other right and it's funny because i actually started out the game wanting to do manuscripts and then realize once like once basically the third blue didn't show up i was like okay well i'm just not gonna keep fighting for those and i'm just gonna go castle so i went castle you went manuscripts um i went i wanted like a like a full virtue like i felt like manuscripts and the deeds would really work together which wasn't actually too bad but i think trying to go strictly virtue like i was actively trying to it's hard to point but all the way over and um yeah i just and then definitely the way their balance mechanic works here i absolutely hated that really because i worked so i mean yeah i know it was like a factor but i didn't really like recognize i was like oh i'm going to be making plenty of points to more than offset whatever the hell they make but then i never really read them right here's 12 [ __ ] points and eight for the runner-up but that's also the thing is like you got 16 points off of that yeah but it's like compared to however much she made up like so it wasn't worth as much right compared to the one guys by the way she got 12. one two three 12 34 15. she got two more points than you um i got six seven eight nine ten i got 18 yeah you're right
because when i say you get 12 yeah you got 16 points yeah so you guys still get your deeds well you got four points so actually you had 20. so you still got more points out of that whole build than we did because i got 18 total right and she got uh 16 total and so you got 20. so you actually still ended up right i know but it's still you know when i the way i was doing my bills like i wanted to just do all that yeah like this was going to be like a whole like half of my this was going to be the first and then the second like now and then dabbling in the buildings i want to do a little bit of everything which i did yeah and i was just kind of frustrated how that kind of like oh okay whichever runs out first than the other people right that we're doing the opposite get uh benefit yeah um which i'll be interested in was helping cat uh and i mean because the game can be played in a way that both of them show up like we could have played where these all ran out too and so then they just both kind of go off yeah so then you would have gotten 12 points i would have gotten eight and cal would have gotten four and so it kind of but i feel like with that kind of setup it'd be almost a net even um because someone's going to be getting it's kind of i feel like it would have ended up being the same um but still yeah kind of like that was one of those things it's like what devin was doing to get the manuscripts i was also doing to get people on the on the castle so i was having to take sips to go the trade get the resources um recruit people that had the symbols i needed uh and none of us because i don't think i don't think this game immediately screams deck builder but it
kind of is it's not you don't have a you you have your uh a market to hire people and you have multiple ways to either discard them from your hands so you can get some card draw advantage or be like well i'm going pure castle i don't need the laborer and the stone person you know the labor oh i i didn't take them but so you can thin your deck out so that's all you're getting so it's like so you don't have to run for resources as much so then you can be more efficient and none of us i think i removed one and cat removed one and i just removed the squire because i just could and i didn't like how it looked well you also weren't going for those symbols this is also um and then kind of with the buildings it wasn't like building something never hurt and you didn't have to go left to right which i enjoy because i could have tried to accumulate some like early game potentially get some people with hammers get some stone and then build you know one building that lets me gives me that symbol so i really enjoy the symbol idea i think that's a really cool mechanic um and for as for the movement i think it's an interesting puzzle and i don't think it's as crippling as it's it's almost made out um because it's like with most worker placements you are kind of you're doing set up setup major action almost you're kind of doing that small stuff and then you get to do your big thing right which works for me cat what do you like about it what do i like about it do you have any negatives because i do have negatives um negatives
because i have two that come to mind and one of them you probably won't have a problem i think they actually affect devin and i most in this game and it was annoying oh you go then okay well the first negative is there is absolutely zero appendix to explain any of the end game scoring yeah so that's absolutely dog [ __ ] yeah um and it's like if you're gonna have end game scoring symbols that aren't on this card then you need some way to explain it that's true uh that affected devon a little bit more and then the one that you have so many mechanics to cycle through these cards but zero to cycle through the manuscripts so we if you're trying to go for that having a set of four for the 16 oh better hope i get lucky and that that color shows up because that's hard work to get through those because some of them are they're they're really expensive so it's random and how they how they come out yeah i felt like we got like all the expensive ones yeah i was just like i can't do [ __ ] right the first one i only got because it was it cost three and then the second one i went for because it was a three and then you pointed out luckily there was a six so yeah and you got points off that yeah um i mean there's i mean don't get me wrong they're all good like i like the manuscripts a lot i think that the extra set collection bonus as well as like this one seven instant instant tower yeah in centaur build um so it's like oh okay well if you're going for that like the the cross symbol well that means i don't have to collect seven stone like i have those so that i can just try and build that real quick and
also it's a gray which is you know would have worked for me but trying to get the cleric bonuses which they're not that big of a deal they're only three points but the extra symbol that's what i was trying to grab early and even the blue one which actually is a little bit nicer gives you two yeah so instead of just the one like everything else gives so i think this game is incredibly balanced i just think the lack of an appendix is is really a weird misstep it it definitely doesn't help anything because yeah at the end we're like well like we think yes uh devon you just channel up all the symbols yeah right um that's how weird because some of them are really good like this one for not this one this one for example it says you gain a free manuscript of a three or four cost so there are a lot of ways for you to just get free stuff which i enjoy to help with the laborious task of being able to pay for you know seven uh seven symbols or uh or seven stone or seven whatever eight you need eight to place four uh people i don't think i ever had eight if the artist had came out early but this is one of those games where who's available at the time that's kind of the strat you're going for because you need the people right to be able to do things yeah uh yes okay what would you like about it what do i like about it um it's it's because you said you didn't like paladins i didn't like paladins but i don't remember what i didn't like about paladins other than i think i was just kind of put off by the art and i was just like we'll have to try it again i was like it's kind of icky
uh i like that despite looking at it and listening to the rules because listening to the rules like you were explaining movement and all and you know the rules um i was just kind of like this is gonna be [ __ ] weird i don't like i like i wasn't really sure how it was going to go because i remember not liking paladins but i remember being okay with the the cathedral one architect architects because he kicked our ass because i kept stealing her like arresting each other but i remember just being okay with it because that is the only way to win at that game and just weld them you know which to be fair again it is called architects not arrest people it's it's called something but um i feel like this one just has a good middle ground kind of like you said earlier where you can it is definitely learnable it's teachable um it's it's definitely playable i mean it's not like it stands out so i guess like is a good word like i liked it yeah so yeah i mean i can't really rave about it yeah i wouldn't rave about any of the west kingdom games right yeah yeah i feel that um the movement didn't bother me too much um really i really just made a big circle and sometimes went down there though so i wasn't really making crazy moves um yeah i'll yeah i also wish there was a way to cycle through the manuscripts like yeah you know drawings on the weekend something like that i don't know um i i like i think i already mentioned it i liked um that even if you chose to
go with um criminals it didn't like totally yeah it wasn't like oh i guess i'm getting a negative 30 points right you know whatever right kind of it's like okay well we know people are going to be criminals like that that's just so the game almost wants you to go like have criminals in your in your things there are four out of five of the spots are criminals right now and the antagonist is a double criminal absolutely not he just gives you he just gives you but he's too wild that's pretty crazy that's a girl i don't give a [ __ ] they are monsters they are all horrendous like they i would behead in a post-apocalyptic video game these are the characters that they would use as the enemies like you would not be comfortable leaving your child with anyone not a single person i don't know the labor they eat them nope labor wouldn't eat them would definitely eat them or he would just he would just uh do child abuse through neglect that's what that's what the library would do or just forget about them he kind of looks like the guy that would go to work yeah on that like and forget them right yeah i mean yeah i i just like it um right nothing too crazy about it it uh i think devin once said it it does what it sends out i guess but yeah i mean that's i mean that's really it the mechanics i think are solid the game's balanced i never felt like uh like we were doing anything or because whenever i was putting all those people i was like i still don't think
i'm gonna win i don't have any buildings built or and i looked over and saw you had all those and honestly i think the only reason is because this hap the balance mechanic i was like oh thank god i have two more than he does so i get eight points awful uh so that's my that's the only reason i won yeah it's um i mean i have to say these i mean these west kingdom games they always kind of hit like a similar note but they they do a really good job with the mechanics yeah i have to say there's usually several things you can do and they're all usually very balanced right and it just it feels like you're really thinking and you're your build's almost always unique and it usually kind of comes together and they're usually pretty close there's never really like because some games are like if you go a bad route it's it's very punishing right and even with because they have corruption on all of them like in some way or another and whereas you know okay this is west kingdom i understand that it does look similar like you said it hits the same note they they still feel different um but familiar familiar yet different yeah uh but i've i have always enjoyed that in the three in the three games where it's like in in corruption like like for example the one with the track and i'm pretty sure i don't know which one had the track but it made it made like whenever you had to pay coins to do an action it made that cheaper i think that was architects i want to say it was architects as well but it's like so you can go corruption and have a lot of your actions free and that's great but there's also multiple ways for you to hire people
that increased you to get out of it because i believe you were you were criminal the whole game and you were able to build yourself out and make it almost to the top um so it's not just like well i'm down here i guess i'm always gonna be down here and that's gonna suck for me you you have the the flexibility uh in the game so these are really good i mean architects definitely is my least favorite i don't like the game really at all but i know a lot of people do um and i think they build a cathedral every time i don't know what they do i don't maybe they don't play with three that was kind of our problem yeah yeah but i i i think they do a solid solid job as a work replacement a kind of a next step instead it's not gateway i wouldn't even say architects is really gateway yeah uh but in terms of in terms of likability it's this one paladins and then architects in terms of difficulty i would say it's uh in terms of uh like hardest to easiest it would be paladins this one architects i think architects is definitely the easiest one to learn um what do you guys think would you probably would you guys say you you like paladins more than this one i think it has been for a long time i feel like i remember like being really engaged with palettes well it also it paladins had the different colored workers that you needed and the purple were criminals so if you used them you bumped you had crit you had and to do certain actions like it's like oh to build this building i need two red and a green and you drafted your workers and you got to keep some over over the
course of round around uh whereas architects you just had i think 20 or 30 yeah and you just accumulated and the more workers on this yeah because the concept was like oh well they're going to jail so they're so it limits it right right um so and then this one the worker mechanic was actually incredibly unique you didn't place workers unless you were placing them in the castle yeah which is cool these guys were your main workers yeah the cards were a lot whereas the cards and paladins were kind of meant to either for instance bonuses or you recruited them into your religion or whatever and they were endgame points because i think that's how i ended up winning was i i started recruiting a bunch you started doing like the crusades that's it yeah that's it uh so yeah um so you would probably say paladin's this one than architects um like difficulty in terms of likability oh likability it's been so much to play the others you throw it against the camera and then you pick up the camera yeah well yeah i'm gonna go paladins uh architects i don't feel like i hated it that much uh and then this one i would say this one's along the same lines no oh i will i will i will bump it up a little higher than um architecture architects yeah that whole send them the jail mechanic was a little strange yeah i mean maybe different maybe it was just that the way we played
yeah and then trying to get them out of trouble is weird too well you said yeah yeah and cat i'm assuming this one architects paladin yeah actually that is correct neat yes so on a scale of one to ten unless you guys have anything else to talk about i do not one more time i would just like to reiterate cannot stand the heart yeah just wanted to really hammer that in i think it's unique hate it but it is it is unique you know who the artist is and who the company is based off the art i will say i respect it because yes he definitely has his his stamp on this game for the art no i have seething hatred for shem films okay
shem phillips uh it's awful it's awful awful awful awful bad and you should feel scale one to ten i'm going to give it a dang old six five and a half really yeah isn't that weird like it's just kind of like it's um the more i was kind of sat on and i'm like it is okay you literally you went this whole this whole review by saying you like it and you're like this is good i really like this six no no no i did not say i really like this you did i said there's nothing that i can rave about i like it at the very beginning you're like yeah this is really good yeah and then i kind of started to go a little like the zealous got a little less it's an opinion i can have one you are not allowed to have opinions anymore don't you rave about shem phillips phillips's great artwork now do it why don't you do a complete 180 10 out of 10.
10 out of 10. well what's your score for it then eight big boy eight yeah i think this is actually a solid game like i said there's no there is no glaring wow that's the strat and and work replacement games are really in any competitive game or it's like that's that's it well i just get the game solved don't have any interest this game you can go in any way like i'm going to keep this one and paladins because they're radically different uh and uh and and have different levels of complexity yeah i enjoyed the movement i enjoyed the the symbol uh like the set collection the uh the the track like the moving track uh and the in the work replacement yeah i enjoyed all of it so devin i think i'm gonna go with my normal my average i'll give it a e seven seven i will give it a seven it was an above average game it's fine i mean whenever you play it too much you know if you hit the table again i'd be like okay yeah i could do a little better this time right but um yeah cool cool all right it's [ __ ] whatever your score was four five and a half one drop the average i did bump it up i'll bump it up to a six that's where i was that's what i was gonna say so i'll keep it as six um i just don't think well guess what this is what we're playing every day oh [ __ ] until it's attended you're gonna [ __ ] love it all right so six seven eight uh really seven and eight uh that's our thoughts on vi counts of the west
kingdom let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this year hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you