Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stamp Swap Designer Interview with Paul Salomon

Transcript 33:38

all right hello everyone and welcome to the mill today today we have a very special designer kind of interview Spotlight to do because I am joined with Paul Solomon the sorry and a cat the designer of stamp swap ston Meyer's newest game so I am going to pass it over to Paul Paul thanks for joining us thanks so much yeah yeah it's it's great to have you on and all I want to know to start out with can you give us some background information information about your roles kind of in the board game industry just in case some of our kind of fans and viewers don't really know much about you sure yeah I um started designing games when I was a fulltime math teacher um I've been teaching math for like 17 years and when I started getting into the hobby maybe 12 13 years ago I've always been a creator of things I made a lot of music and made mathematical art for a while um I just wanted to try my hand at things so I I made a game um learned a lot about prototyping in fact from Jamie I asked uh someone that I knew had made a game I said where did you learn all the things and they said this guy Jamie um this was even before I had moved back to St Louis and the first game I made was quite bad never really went anywhere um but the next game that I worked on was honey Buzz which is a fairly well-known um um tabletop

mediumweight strategy game um and started going to the game designer Meetup here in St Lewis and then talked to one person Roy and said have you done Kickstarter and he said oh you should talk to my friend John which was John cvu at genius games and I played with John and he said it's not perfect for me but you should talk to my friend Jamie so that's how Jamie and I met um I pitched him honey buzz and he gave me some some tweaks and changes and then later on I pitched to him again um and then you know I I I think we'll talk about this a little later but sort of I didn't have a ticket to design day and uh the night before he said there was room for me and I came and play tested honey buzz and ended up meeting the people at elf Creek through that um and signed that game and and then since then I published two games with genius games um as a co-designer one was periodic and the other was genotype a mandelian genetics game and then we just released honey buzzball flavors and um now I work part-time as a teacher and part-time as the head of development for all Creek games I've been doing that for about two years now wow I didn't even realize that periodic was actually the first game I ever played at a Gen Con oh wow that's back in 2019 the first game we sat down in the vendor Hall with super cool yeah that was a fun project and it happened really

fast and um for a while John and I were like meeting every week and I was just working on every game that he had um which was very cool and I learned a ton about making games through that very cool apparently we've been teaching for about the same time just in opposite ends of the world that's about I start teaching English yeah very cool all right so I'm going to go to our next let's go with let's start with stamp swaps origin and then if want we can bleed that into kind of what happened with design day in that case already talked a little bit about design day so why don't let's get the stamp swap origin story and then bleed into what happened at the design day when it yeah so I think um if I can remember correctly this was about two years ago maybe a little more um maybe three years ago I played a game called coin Quest um which is a game about coin collectors and you know in the lore of the game they meet up every they meet up like every month for a night and they do this sort of secretive coin I don't know what it is but it's it's sort of a bag building auction game um which I love the concept of and this was early in thinking about bag building I really enjoyed that mechanism but I thought the game play was sort of underwhelming and they missed some of the development choices that I would have made but I was struck with the idea idea that um coin

collecting was a kind of underused and smart board game mechanism I I thought because um you have this cap I mean metal coins are a big thing in in our um our Hobby and uh they give you this capacity for art and then naturally set collection and a lot of us hobbyists are collectors I certainly collect a lot of little things um and have overtime but rather and I my first prototype was coins I think um but I shifted towards stamps because I love tile placement games that's probably my number one favorite mechanism uh and they again had probably a greater capacity for uh art and uh they also have this sort of like overlapping categories of set collection that I thought had potential where you can have a stamp that's from Germany and Fe features of flower and is worth $2 or you know those kind of things and is red um so I wanted that that kind of thing and I really didn't know much about stamps when I started um so I went to the local Stamp shop and I not everybody has a local Stamp shop but we do David srot is the uh proprietor of this place he runs it with his son and I went in and I really just said hey I I'm a game designer I've never collected stamps what can you tell me about about the hobby how does it work when people show stamps are there conventions what kind

of things do they want to collect are they going for complete sets or theme sets or and um the thing I remember most from that meeting was his summary of um stamp collecting was that the main thing that motivates people is I have it and you don't um which I thought was a funny kind of collector's mentality um the particulars of stamp collecting and where the value is didn't really make it into the game um but because of this I really got into stamp collecting sort of on my own and I I love that it's uh really like a cheap art collection that you can have and my wife and I went to a stamp show and sort of collected all the stamps we would want over the course of three hours and it was like all of it was under $100 total so I love that um game wise there were a couple of uh inspirations one was um money which is a a Riner Kenia game which is getting a reprint from allplay with art by an heidy because the artist from uh honey buzz and in that game you're currency trading but they're they're you know uh bills and so you have different countries of bills and different denominations um but that's about the extent of the sets you can collect but the cool thing here is it's sort of a blind bidding and then you collect the currency from the middle but you end up actually one of the things you can do is take someone else's bid and sort of swap

it with yours um so it's a little bit like bidding for turn order but also offering things to other players and there's some some interesting Dynamics um and I I only was able to play it once but I thought it was very cool the other uh which I don't even think I've talked about this before the other main mechanical concept was at at to the West I don't know if you've ever been there but I miss one of my favorite conventions y I've been the past two years it's awesome have you ever done the trade table at geekway I haven't but I have heard stories from Molly you know about it yeah yeah I think we walked through but yeah I haven't actually done it so this is a bit like a sort of white elephant gift exchange type thing where um you can you can put in up to three games on these tables and they have some restrictions about what you can put in they basically want good games and then they randomly will draw some people to come in and just pick whatever game they want and then whoever game they choose gets to go next um and so the mechanic of the game of that game if you can call it a game or a mechanic is that you want to offer a good game so that you can then get a good choice or be selected by someone else so that you can go next and stamp swap does feature that um where depending on how I cut my piles um if I create a good pile or something that's universally appealing then I'm more

likely to go earlier in the round and have more choices for what I take from someone else so that you know those are a couple of the uh the mechanisms that I sort of put in there yeah gosh you're so right like that would even occur to me geekway really does use Gamers to kind of gamify even picking games out yeah it really is in there yeah and then um inevitably uh this happened all very fast before um design day that year and actually the year before I had sort of signed myself up to show a game called stamp collectors that I had not designed yet and I thought well you know I'll put it out there and this will force me to make it and then I didn't and I just took it away um but then a couple months before design day uh two years ago I sort of made the thing a reality and was able to sign up and uh show it off and then the the play testers in my couple of play tests liked it enough I think it was the highest rated game that year um and Jamie sort of came around um it was originally designed to be in the honey Buzz world because I knew elf Creek and wanted to work with an hide seek again and naturally wanted to expand that so the original prototype was sort of in the language of that game um and when Jamie came around and looked at it he was like oh you know I didn't know it was so finished and at that time I didn't really know if I thought it was like a good

game I sort of knew that it was working and you know because of the way that design can work sometimes you know a game's going to work on the table but will it be loved or enjoyed or fun um but Jamie was excited and not that we sat down and played it a couple times and he ended up signing it which was to work with my friend was a awesome pleasure yeah that is really cool so since we're talking about that so we go from that process and Jamie has mentioned before you've mentioned before that you guys were friends first and kind of had this unique experience really with the development of stamp swap um so kind of combining that like one what was that like uh was the is there something else from ston Meer games that really like brought you to them besides I know you mentioned kind of gain reference to Jamie you know were there other reasons you were maybe excited that Stow Meer was picking it up so kind of how was all of that working yeah I there's um I mean again part of my earliest conception of game design came from Jim's sort of tenants of good game design and I still you know hold true to a lot of those sort of positive player interaction and passive player interaction and rewards and instead of punishments and um round play if possible and a lot of the things that um he espouses ended up in in Honey Buzz for sure and even my earliest sort of

thinking about honey Buzz was inspired partly by viticulture um because there's this multi-step production process where you know in viticulture you plant these fields and then you harvest the fields and then you crush the grapes and you age the wine you sell the wine um and in honey buzz you get these um you build your hive and then gather the nectar and then turn it to honey and then sell the honey um so my original title actually was apiculture which is the title for the making of Honey um well actually no the very first title was hipster uh hipster honey I think um something like that I can't quite remember but the idea was you were selling to Hipster Bears who wanted their artisanal flavors like avocado honey was was sort of in a in a a previous hipster Millennial time um so I I do think viticulture is really cool I love libertalia and the changes that um he made to that I really enjoy rolling Realms a lot and what else is on my shelf over there I've got almost all of them um I also was super excited about the design of wingspan I think that really fits my style of game especially the round scoring benefits but a lot of my core gamer group was not as excited so we don't play it that much um and then of course yeah I mean ston Meyer is very successful and Jamie is really insightful and sharp so the opportunity to try to work with him um

was sort of you know a dream I think a lot of designers would have uh that would be sort of a dream publisher and I know that at elf Creek it's like a lot of the titles we get are were their second choice you know because uh they would love to work with ston Meer though you got some pretty awesome games over there at elf Creek too yeah yeah yeah we put a lot of love and time into them oh yeah yeah I think I told you Santa's workshop and it's Atlantis Rising too right it is yes and uh Santa's Workshop was one that I helps develop and uh really proud of that game as well yeah I again an eight-year-old upstairs who you're probably like his number one he's probably one of your fans then with that one cool cool cool yeah so very cool all right so said you work a lot with elf Creek you now have stamps up with ston Meer you teach so that's right how how do you juggle all of this like do they also do they influence each other like that is a lot yeah it uh it is um the part-time workload at school uh really obviously has been amazing I did my first design when I was still full-time and a lot of my hobbies over the years um um was all sort of in my extra time you know at nights and stuff and sometimes late nights um but now my schedule is sort of like I get up at a normal time I go to work I teach first period and second period I have third and fourth off I teach fifth

period and I'm done by one o'clock every day um so today I was done at like 10:30 um so that gives me a chunk of time in the afternoon to sort of do things but also the decreased student load means that there's less reports to write less grading to do um and that suits me I I appreciate that um but yeah I I wear a lot of hats and I wear a lot of hats at elf Creek and you know my family of course takes a lot of my time and uh um I've sort of found a little more of a balance lately where I'm not as I used to be super hyperfocused on on my hobbies and um you know I would just if I was prototyping then I would just spend all of a week prototyping um but now I can sort of do that and back and forth between grading and stuff which is is has been a big boom to my teaching career um and they do feed back and forth um between each other I run a a a club at school called The Guild of Geeks which is um a lot of different guilds there's like an anime Guild and a board game Guild and a magic the Gathering Guild and Minecraft Guild and lots of geeky things um we have a weekly game uh event game session afternoon what meeting um but also I play with students in free period sometimes and a lot of the play

testers named in my games are students um which is really cool and actually the um the honey Buzz be shape was designed by a student who at the time was in eighth grade and designed this 3D printable people and that ended up being basically the final design so um a lot of that and then from time to time students will want to talk about the ideas in game design but mostly they just they just like to play and I take their feedback that's really cool very nice so I'm kind of curious because you brought up like math art earlier yeah yep does that play into I'm just I'm gonna show off this board the back of the board because oh my gosh we love that yeah it's gorgeous I didn't really have any control over that I love the way that they did that but you know the mathematics back and I I have a MERS in mathematics and um been you know obviously teaching it a long time um the background there does shape the way I design a lot and uh I look for simple schemes that sort of you know the balance systems that would be sort of mathematically sound um come from that sort of a background and like for example the combinatorics of trying to figure out if I have the you know these many colors and these many themes and these many denominations and some of them are two two of them together like how to make that um

balanced or symmetric in some way that you know I really like that puzzle um but mathematical art uh for me is something that I've been doing sort of since like third grade I remember being in the library after school I was not like a let's go out and play soccer kid um and we had just sort of learned about protractors and when you were using them and um I started you know making designs and um sort of like making Stars by measuring degrees and then like making six pointed stars and eight-pointed stars and um I remember that really well uh and then later in life I went to the bridges math art conference which is a sort of global mathematics and art conference and um worked on a lot of different pieces that you can find them on my website Paul solomon.com um and the thing there is that there's this connection between what the mathematics tells you about when something is right or feels right or solid or supported by something or reflects something greater than myself but then there's also always this personal aesthetic which is like what do I like about it and you know Finding creating pieces that are a blend between like what I personally like and what have this structure to them that's informed by something other than me is

um something I love and I think that making games allows me to do that same thing in a really different way and I honestly I think that um for a lot of people gaming is like the number one way that people engage with mathematics in the everyday world and not just the arithmetic but like the strategizing and analyzing and those kind of things so again when I design a game like honey Buzz sometimes it's about um what's going to make the game fun but also sometimes it's it's about uh if I make this choice these will be the mathematical consequences and so it is a crazy interdisciplinary space that like perfectly fits what I love to do and know about so it's it's been really I've been really fortunate to sort of fall into something like that I love when all these pieces kind of intertwine with one another that just makees something awesome then that others would not have been able to think about because they don't have those other background details right right that's really cool uh the next question I had was just to kind of simplify it and F get a little insight into stamp swap here Jamie always has his favorite mechanism videos and he's done one for stamp swap he does it for all of their own games what would you say is your favorite mechanism for stamp swap as the designer I will say um

stamp swap is very similar to a game that I love uh it's probably in my top 10 all time called is of Sky which a lot of people have played and if you've played both I think you'll definitely see the connection and um the mechanism that I actually like most in I of sky is the variable scoring objectives and that um tiles in that game almost never have an inherent value um they are uh you know they might apply maybe they have a what lighthouse on them and maybe that matters for scoring or maybe it doesn't or maybe that matters for my scoring because I have a scroll um and then the game asks you to determine the value of those things the same thing is true of castles of M King Ludwig which is another game that Jamie and I both love um there are some scoring objectives and you have all these private objectives that determine sort of your personal value for those stamps and so uh my first favorite mechanism is just having a row of public objectives that you can all score that shape the um value of tiles on the game though of course there are threes and twos and ones um which I wanted I put there because I wanted tiles to also have Universal appeal so that I could sort of create a pile that was um appealing in that sort of swap mode but uh the other one that I think is just is uh my favorite thing or the thing that I'm proudest about is just the swap itself

because it creates um this interesting and dynamic cut shoes mechanism but also allows it to happen simultaneously across you know five players or so and um really sort of creates this fast action and you know sort of uh player interaction that is Dependable in a way like everybody knows they're going to get about half of their tiles and everybody knows that they're going to get someone else's tile whereas in um in is of Sky I may get no tiles in a round excuse me and that can be fairly punishing um that game is a is quite a bit tighter in terms of what it gives you and the money economy there is much tighter so um I really like the swap mechanism and I sort of have some ideas for future games that utilize it um I'll just sort of I'll I'll spoil one here for you and we'll we'll see if it ever becomes a game but um one which would be a really fast version of this is just a card drafting version um where you get a hand of seven cards and you draft them and then everybody cuts and you trade cards um and build sets and so on but uh it's a sort of trading card game and so I was going to call it gotta swap them all and it would be sort of a Pokemon simulator um we'll see if it ever comes to fruition but I uh I'm sort of excited

about the potential there nice very cool I just kind of want to point out we've talked a lot about the math and some of these mechanics but I'm a very big theme person in board gamees and before this I didn't know much about stamp but I had a friend come over to play it with me as I Was preparing you know some stuff for the mill and he actually had collected stamps with his grandfather like through his youth had gone to the conventions like he was just tell you he was tearing up oh that's so cool playing this because it was bringing back so many good memories so I want like it's actually really cool it seems like you got the theme spot eyes like this is really how stuff would go at the convention so yeah I love that and theme is something that we we thought about um a lot in the early development of like even in our first um play with the larger ston Meer group was like you know is stamps a good theme is it a broad theme um and we obviously you try to get lightning in a bottle twice with wingspan was sort of a not initially exciting theme for a lot of people but I think of bird watching as like real life Pokemon where you're trying to catch these different species um and I've fallen into that hobby as well collecting them like on my phone with the Merlin app and um we weren't sure if it would work and then we weren't sure if we could kind of fit all of the information on the stamps in a good

clear colorcoded dual coded way that would still be visually appealing so we we looked at like comic books or you know old trading cards and wine labels and things like that but I'm I'm glad that we ultimately came we also even looked at a um an artist pitched us a theme that they were working on that um had nothing to do with you know it was sort of a fantasy world and um we considered going that way but I am really happy that we got to stance and I think I think you're right that it's you know for some people it's a miss and they're not they're not excited by it but um once they I think get to play the game that they're surprised by how much fun it is and it makes sense you you get these little tiles and you lay them down in a pretty way and you set collect and it's you know it's I think it's really rewarding yeah yeah it's you got spot on I learned from somebody and it was great so awesome yeah yeah uh so are there any kind of pulled out some I know you have some Easter eggs in here in personal touches there any you want to highlight people they be looking for yes so one is my dog Bernie is in there he is the small square red stamp that is cancelled I think there he is that's Bernie boy Mr Bernie St Louis and uh he's a bernadoodle upstairs making some noise um and let's see who else is in there

well the is in there of course Jamie always does that I'm born and raised in St Louis Y and Jamie's been here a lot of time actually Jamie So Jamie studied Japanese in college and at Wu and my best friend from high school uh Lawrence Dennis was also in that program and they they sort of pair you up with a senpai which is like a you know a mentor in a way and jimie was actually Lawrence's Senpai at uh so that was that was funny we didn't realize that till later um let's see what else is in there I gave there are two sets of tickets that are um special dates for me and my family like if you take the orange tickets my birthday is in there um Bernie's birthday is one of those and my anniversary is one of those um cool I'm gonna show everyone I had all the tickets here I didn't know which ones they were yeah and then um my the three girls and my family all have their birthdays um on the pink stamps and then for the rest of them I picked some of the lead play testers and let them choose um two of the guys from my main game group Tommy O'Brien and Matthew Roberts they show up a lot on my play testing list I let them each pick a set of three and they did like their anniversary or their girlfriend's date or something like that and then um miles Bensky I think did the third set he is uh he does a lot of the stone meire shirts like the recent one with all the

stamps on it he does the stamps yep he does the disc stamps like the new Air Mail putter that I use and love and uh he did a lot of the like I think he did the covers for Rolling Realms so um yeah so I I wanted to give back to my buddies in that way very cool yeah miles does great great work certainly yeah okay so I'm gonna kind of combin a lot of these here I feel like we've talked we've kind of hit a lot of pieces here so is there anything else you want people to know about stamp Swap and then also anything else you think we you feel like we missed and if there's anything else you want people keep an eye out for from you sure um first I want to just give a a quick shout out to Morton and the autom factory team I think they did a a sort of amazingly good job with trying to take this deeply interactive mechanism and uh make it work and my understanding from everybody that's played it is they're loving it and I think that's really cool um with stamp swap no I think uh I'm just I'm happy that it's out there and I'm glad I'm I'm so thankful for all the positive feedback people have given me and you know we aim to bring more uh joy to tabletops worldwide and it's I it's really cool um I have a couple of things coming up um let's see I have a game that was at design day last year uh was a

trick-taking game called Cheap Trick originally um and a handful of people played that I think it it did very well I yeah I think it was the number two um highest rated game uh my buddy Pete had another trick-taking game that that did really well I think was the number one uh and is signed with h a publisher and chap trick ended up getting signed with a publisher who hasn't made the announcement yet so I won't I won't spoil that and it's been reemed um it's uh the theme now is sort of like I don't if if anybody knows the like let's all go to the lobby um song with the sort of anthropomorphic you know soda candy and popcorn uh that's the art style a sort of cuphead style and in the game you're all about to go to the movie and you want to buy all the best snacks you can out of the lobby so you play cards to buy snacks um but whoever spends the most on snacks is out of money and can't go see the show um so that's sort of like a bust mechanism a little bit like high society and uh I think it's a really fun game it's actually a may follow trick-taking game as opposed to a must follow so there's a ton of um player agency and freedom of choice to try to feels a little bit more like an auction game than trick-taking game and uh I think we'll see that by uh the end of 25 probably so we're we're getting the look at Art now and I'm just really excited for that one

very cool yeah and definitely uh I just want to Echo a shout out to the atama team they do a great job and I I seem to have started just doing the solo playthrough so I greatly appreciate yeah and I'll say another thing too about that uh Morton um when he was doing all that work he does a lot of really good spreadsheet and data collecting work and actually sort of that informed the final balance changes and Jamie has talked a lot about how a game like that a game like stamp swap doesn't have to be as balanced as I initially made it because the Swap and the draft are both self-balancing mechanisms um and so you know you can have bigger swings but for the solo mode where things have to be a little more restrained and predictable U Morton was able to sort of nudge on a couple of numbers and really I think helped improve things so again another shout out to Morton yeah very cool all right well thanks so much for coming on the mill Paul we really appreciate it always love getting our ston Meer designers on here yeah thanks for having me on it was really fun yeah all right well I will hopefully maybe I'll get to talk to you again sometime was great meeting nothing else yeah yes all right well we have a great night thanks all right see you

Progress saved