Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Crew Journey to the Ends of the Earth. Comparing all The Crew Games.

Transcript 16:58

Hi everyone, it's Dayna and that's Taran from Meeple University. Welcome, where we will do The Crew 3: Journey to the Ends of the Earth, which plays three to five players with two players variant.

This is designed by Thomas Sing and published by Kosmos, who published and designed the previous two.

We have explored the space, the sea, now we journey to the inside of the Earth. And this is a race against the clock, literally a clock Indiana Jones style. So, we're going to start with an overview before we get to the review. And we are also going to compare from The Crew 1 and 2, which we played a lot.

So, this is the third version of The Crew and the core gameplay is the same as the prior versions of The Crew. It's a cooperative trick-taking game. It uses a deck of cards which has four suits running from one to nine, as well as a trump suit running from one to four. This time, yes, this time it's helicopters. That's what we've got instead of rockets and submarines. And as in the prior games, you'll have a task that you're collectively trying to achieve. It might be having certain players win certain tricks or certain cards or things like that. And really what is All of that is the same. What's different here is the type of quest and the type of tasks.

If you are not familiar at all with The Crew or trick-taking, we do have a video of how to play of The Crew, the first crew. So, I check that out. I will link that in the description below as well.

So, what's changed here is what you're trying to achieve. What are the tasks? And the game is broken into stages through this book here. So, you'll have all these stages, most of which have these paths. And you've got these decks of objectives. And whereas in prior crews, you've been trying to meet a large number of small tasks, in this one every hand you play will have a single task to complete. And how difficult or easy that task is, you'll know because you'll get to pick from two based on the difficulty, but what it is you won't know until you've chosen it. And so, uh let's look at a couple of examples here. This is a very simple one. No trick may be opened with an eight or nine. So, you would simply play the tricks. Doesn't matter who wins them.

All you have to do is make sure someone doesn't get stuck playing an eight or nine to open the trick. Yeah, relatively straightforward. Here we have a level two, three, or four depending on your player count. Uh each trick may contain at most two colors. So, you can see if you're playing with three players, that's relatively straightforward cuz you just have to make sure that uh you don't have each player playing a different color, but at five players, you've got to work quite hard to make sure only two different colors are in each trick. And so, that's why it ranges from two to four. Uh this is a success or failure kind of trick uh kind of task, sorry. There are also some sliding scale types of tasks that have this compass on them.

So, here for example, tricks must be won in a clockwise direction without skipping any players. The mission ends with the first mistake. So, you would have to go around, essentially win one trick each round the table, and then wherever you stop, you score uh you score difficulty based on how many you achieve minus a certain number. Uh so, if we were playing three players and we got eight tricks out, we would score two because the score in this game is the difficulty of the task. So, if you succeed at it, you're trying to get to your airplane. And so, if I succeeded at a task level three, for example, I would advance three steps. And the clock advances one step every time. And you just basically race the clock to try to get to your uh your plane to escape.

Now, the other thing that uh the this book will bring into play is you can see here, we're just taking a train from Aachen to Constance. Train is very simple. But as you go on these other tricks, they have some other icons. So, here are boots for example. Boots force you They slow you down cuz you're walking, so they force you to pick the uh weaker of the two tasks that you can choose from. So, it's going to slow your progress.

Yeah. And you can see that it's slow in one in three player only move one step. That's like super slow. It's basically you need to race against the clock. And one is eight good enough. Especially if we get failing tariff.

That's true. Uh then here we have from uh in stage three, some of these have skis and some of them have scooters. And they're going to combo with the cards that show the skis and and uh scooters. So, when the skis get played, that's going to mix things up a little bit. It's going to force players to uh pass their hands around. And there's all various icons that will have these effects. There's also a few special stages which are resolved in different ways.

Yes. So, you can see different continent. Which continents are you at? We are obviously in Australia. I don't know why I say obviously. We are in Australia. I don't want to assume you know where we are.

Yes. Are we in here? There we go. Sydney to Buenos Aires. It's a lot of a lot of ground to

Well, that's Yeah, you can see that's getting harder and a variety of things.

Melbourne never gets in the game.

No. Very sad. Well, I will get some of our Melbourne design mobile Mel- Melbourne board game designers to design games about Melbourne.

Yes.

We are going to review this The Crew and also compare with the other two that's already out, and we're going to say which one is our favorite The Crew.

Yes.

Tarrant.

So, the comparison here, it is all in the tasks. The original Crew, which really, uh, broke onto the scene with this, uh, cooperative trick-taking mechanism, it was mostly about winning certain cards. So, each player would be dealt, or you would draft from a, uh, central deal these task cards, and it would say it would say, "All right, if I take the red four, it means I have to win the trick which has the red four in it." And you would go through there about 50 quests that were getting more and more tricky, and sometimes they added an extra rule, like, uh, ones have to win tricks or things like that, but it was mostly a similar type of task, and you were just focusing in on that.

And getting harder, obviously, from one to 50.

Yes. Then the second Crew, which was the Deep Sea Adventure Crew, played in much the same way, but it had a bit more variety of tasks. So, sometimes it was getting certain cards, sometimes it was never winning a trick with a certain color, sometimes it was winning a trick that, uh, the sum of all the numbers was very low or very high, things like that. But that was it was all about winning tricks at the right time. This one is more varied. So, there's only ever the one trick, and, uh, sorry, only ever the one task. I think I've said that twice now. And they're arranged, they're quite a mixed bag of things. Two crew members left and right must win of the first player must win the same number of tricks. This is a difficult one. No trick may be opened with a pink or yellow card.

So,

also one that is very unique to this one, I think, which is I feel like it's a little bit of Skyteam because you kind of have to somehow tell your Well, your friend to win certain amount of tricks without telling them. Kind of like, do you play the cards to edging into higher card to say, "Hey, you need to lose." or "Hey, you need to win." if you keep playing lower cards. That's quite unique.

So, that's kind of the difference.

Yeah.

Uh what's your favorite?

Well, story-wise, I think the first one has got more story, richer narrative. This one, yes, it's traveling, but there's not a lot of stories here. The second one, I mean, you know, like if you are Eurogamers, if you are Eurogamers, that you don't really care probably about the story or whatnot.

They do They have dropped the narrative for the most part, yeah.

Yes.

Yes.

So, for me, yes, it maybe matters to some degree and maybe not. This one is Okay. I think probably my least favorite is The Crew number two. The reason being is that some of the tasks are not compatible. So, you need to Oh, okay, this is not compatible and you have to look at it and okay, you need to draw again. So, it feels a little bit like I just want to play. Okay, what's next? What's next? And this one you need to analyze first and then Oh, they're not compatible. You need to draw another one. I feel like that for the second one. Crew number one obviously we played the most because it went out It came out first. I feel it is a good one to start with because it has a really nice progression. It's just taking you through first mission, second mission, it's getting harder and harder. And at the time, I did not know how to play trick-taking games properly. So, that The Crew is my first real play of trick-taking games. And it's easier because it's cooperative, right? Like you're really good, so you can also help me guide through how to play trick-taking games.

Yeah, the importance of seeing card counting and responding to responding to that.

Yes, so I think The Crew has got a special spot for me. This one I enjoyed like um we haven't actually finished this one, but I already see that this is probably Okay, number one for me is The Crew number one. Number two is The Crew number three. Number three is The Crew number two. How about you?

For me, I Look, the first two crews are very much the same game and I like the extra variety that the second crew introduces. So, it's slightly above the first crew for me, but really they're the same much the same game. It's hard to hard to really make a distinction.

Yes.

This one takes it in quite a different direction and not a direction I like.

Okay.

Um I find I found it very unusual playing some of these tasks where the objective was based on what cards were played and not who won each trick. And there there was uh there's one where you had to make sure that within each trick the highest card played was at least four above the lowest card played.

I actually like that. I I like that Well, you don't really like that. I do like that cuz it's different.

Like it was it was playable, but didn't matter at all who won the tricks and I found that counter to my experience.

Okay.

Counter to what I expect and like out of The Crew. And then when you come down to the map, when you start introducing you know, the the other thing I really enjoyed about the the original crew in particular, it was that first modern trick taking game that gave a modern spin on what I really like about partnership auction trick taking games. It didn't have you know, lots of random abilities and and things that that mixed play up. Whereas this now starts to introduce it when you've got effects that make everyone change hands partway through the round, it just for me that takes it away from what I loved about The Crew. So,

Okay.

yeah, this one this one doesn't do it for me.

All right.

It will it will introduce, you know, those things I just kind of mentioned. A lot of people who grew up on hearts and went into the kinds of trick-taking games, modern trick-taking games that came off hearts, will enjoy that. But, I'm a bit more um because I'm a bit more contract style, um I don't enjoy that.

Mhm.

It's something I I always I'm sure I've said this once or twice before. I remember to me it was so clear when I first played The Crew that it's like, "Oh, this is the first modern trick-taker that really feels like the ones I grew up with." And I for a while I just assumed that that was that was

A view.

the view. That was the view. And then I remember reading someone put the exact

view.

I remember someone putting the exact opposite opinion on a forum at one point. They were like, "This is this is not the sort of trick-taking I'm used to. This is This doesn't feel like a trick-taking game. Cooperative, what is that?" And it was that realization that, "Oh yeah, if you're playing games like Microsoft Hearts that then go into your modern trick-takers where certain cards have different powers and give you different numbers of points and you have to try to work that out." That's an entirely different class of trick-taking game and it is having to to think cooperatively and think how a partnership game would work is alien if you're used to that kind of of game. So, if that's where you've come from, if that's the kind of trick-taker you like, I would expect The Crew 3 to appeal to you more than The crew one and two.

But if you've come from a partnership auction background and and it was that that really drew you to the crew, then this is probably not for you.

So, does that mean I have to find someone else to complete the rest of the mission, Terry?

Oh, we'll still play.

I mean, this is like if you have the ranking, but you still enjoy it, right?

It's still good. It's It's still Yeah, you still do have to think cooperatively.

Yes.

It's just got more more tasks.

Well, I hope that I don't know. I haven't checked Board Game Arena. I hope they will have the crew three on Board Game Arena as well. Because we played lots and lots and lots of crew on Board Game Arena. And for some reason, I'm the captain like 80% of the time. It's like, "No, I wanted you to be the captain because you're really good. You'll just like control the third player." Because we just play two players. I want you to control the third player, the ninja and our shadow.

Uh ghost.

Oh, sorry. Ghost shadow. Ghost. Yeah. Shadow ghost.

That does kind of allude to one other point though, which is the correct way to play this game is you try the task once and then when you fail, uh you discard it, you return it to the box, but you still advance the clock.

Yes. Otherwise, you know, let's say for the crew one, like you didn't complete mission six, you just play it again and again.

Yeah, and particularly with the second crew, I always enjoyed getting those combinations and just trying to find a way to make that work and play it over and over.

I remember on Board Game Arena, I kept uh pressing the buttons like say with the uh try again with the same task and then I accidentally click uh new task. Like, "No, I want to try again." No, it's too late then. Then like you just like get dealt another cards, another tasks. Yeah.

Yeah, I always found it very satisfying trying to find a way to meet those objectives, but here because of the way the decks work and the way you're supposed to uh react to the difficult task on top and and try to make that match with your path, that option [clears throat] kind of comes out.

Yeah.

And particularly with these individual kinds of objectives, again, I would love to just keep trying until I succeed. Maybe it's the '80s and '90s video gamer in me in the pre in the pre my game saves every 2 seconds era, you know.

Uh yeah, that's horrible. Playing King's Quest, oh my gosh. Like almost finished and then died. Like went into a valley.

only. Next.

Very sad. Well, what do you think? Have you been playing The Crew 1, 2, or this is the third one? I recently posted on Instagram um The Crew 3. I was like, "Oh, I didn't know there's The Crew 3." Yes, there is. I picked it up from Gen Con 2026 just passed. I was I almost say Essen, but hang on, Essen is not there yet.

Essen is to come.

Which I will come. So, which one, if you have played all of them, which one is your favorite? Or maybe the first two, which one is your favorite or both equally? Or maybe you don't play trick-taking games and you like to start your journey of these weird cooperative trick-taking game, as Taran said, well, go for it. We will Once again, we'll link the description of the link to the video in the description below for the how to play of The Crew 1, which you also taught how to play trick-takings. And thank you so much for watching. Hopefully you enjoyed it and have a great day. Bye.

Progress saved