Skip to main content
Loading video...

Luna Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:32

Hey everybody, today I'm talking about Luna, which is a 2010 release board game. Um the game takes about an hour to an hour and a half to play and accommodates one to four players. Um it's by designer Stefan Feld, who is one of my favorite designers. He makes very mechanically sound um Euro strategy games. Um and I've always game them generally well, in fact I've reviewed all of them positively because I just love the way he makes very clean, mechanically sound designs, uh which are a lot of fun. Um Luna is while you can still tell it's one of Stefan Feld's game, I think it does feel quite a bit different to a lot of his other designs. Um the game I guess if I had to explain it, it would be kind of like an action points kind of allowance game or kind of an action selection game. There is a good amount of kind of area majority which goes into it and obviously with a lot of Feld's games, the objective is to score the most victory points.

Um so each turn of your game consists of um one of I believe 14 actions. So there's quite a lot of initial overhead to understand all different actions you can take on your turn, but obviously some of them aren't going to be applicable a lot of the time, so you can completely kind of remove them from your thought at certain given times in the game. But the setup is going to be a kind of a huge island in the middle, which is made up of all these different kind of hexes, um all different numbers on them and there's going to be a track around that that almost temple, I think it's called, um with all these different tiles on with matching or corresponding numbers on. Um there's also going to be seven of these uh unique islands surrounding that temple with all kind of unique abilities assigned to them. And and during setup you're going to assign a lot of your different worshipers or eight of your different worshipers to these different islands and um that's going to be what dictates which actions you can take. Um so some of the actions might be to take a favor token of that specific island or to um take two workers and make another worker or bring another worker into your pool or to move your workers around in different ways. Um a lot of the actions are very similar, there's quite a lot of crossover but with very subtle differences.

Um but obviously yeah, you're trying to kind of use actions to um ultimately to you know, get as much mileage as you can out of the workers um in order to move them to the temple to claim um to claim majorities at the end of the round um because um there there's basically in the temple there's loads of these different numbers and when you've placed um one of your kind of worshipers onto a tile and moved them into the temple, you're going to not only claim that that tile, but you're going to knock off everybody around you or any opponent around you with a lower number than that, that's if they're not protected by a book. And then at the end of the round you're going to score for every kind of person you've got in the temple. But in addition to that, you're going to score points based on where the moon priestess is because there is this um kind of this priestess figure that moves around the board in a predetermined manner and whoever's got the most kind of active workers on that spot um by the end of the round is going to score um points um based on who's who's got the most. And there's also what's called like an apostate around as well, which goes around the board, who scores you negative points um you know, if you've if you've got any workers there and you can use workers to kind of move him and stuff like that.

So as I said, there's there's 14 actions to um to use and um I guess if you if you really had to kind of explain where the meat of the game comes from, it's from the favor token um action because you can use two workers and take them off the board and um get a favor token of that unique island type. And those favor tokens that you do a number of things, they can let you protect your um you know, you can protect your worshipers already in the temple because as I said, when you put a new tile that's higher in an adjacent space, you want to kick them off, but if you're protected by a book, you won't be kicked off and in addition you'll score an additional point at the end of the round. Um you can also use these kind of wave tokens which let you move all your um exhausted workers around to different places or or to new islands on the board for the following round, which can be very important because normally you can only move your um active workers.

Um so again, you can get more kind of mileage out of your out of your worshipers. You can use boats to move your island to island, which keeps them active. You can use these kind of dummy worshipers. You can use these um herbs which kind of um take your workers from a deactive kind of um position into a reactive or into an active position, so you can use them again. Um there are these shrine ones which shrines are very important because um there's a master builder on one of the islands and if you cash in one of those shrines um favor tokens, you can build a new shrine where the master builder is, which almost acts like a a dummy worker in a way. Um so you'd only have to use one um one of your worshipers um where you'd normally need two. So it's almost like a a virtual worker. But in addition, those shrines are going to score you points at the end of the game as well, so there is a further incentive to build shrines.

Now when you first play this game um and in fact the first time I played this game, it was very hard for me to kind of understand where the gameplay was coming from. I couldn't understand why I was doing these certain actions. Um obviously I knew you had to try and get these people in the temple, but I couldn't understand the nuances of when and where to use those um tokens. And the more and more I played this game, I started to click and click with me about oh, that's that's why I'd use that and that and there's certain orders you can use those things in. And that's one of the things that kind of separate Luna from a lot of other Feld games because I think a lot of the other Feld games is very kind of transparent on what you want to do, it's pretty obvious. Um you know, you want to score as much points as you can as quickly as possible. Whereas in Luna, it's um as I said, a lot more nuanced, it's a lot more opaque and it's one of those kind of games that keep um unraveling why you are doing what you want to be doing and how to play better and better each time, which I think is really nice. But again, it's a very kind of different approach to um or a different kind of initial reaction I've had to a lot of Feld games, um which is again why I said this game is kind of a bit different to his other designs.

Um but that is one of the one of the things that really fascinated me about it because um when it starts to click, you really do start to see all the different approaches you can take, all the different strategies you can take, when to use things at certain times, you know, when to play the right books. Um because you you are or there's also a lot of um kind of sacrificing your turn short, you know, sacrificing your worshipers short term for long term gain because um you know, you you want to move your workers into more kind of um lucrative areas when you need to use them um and you'll have to do that in the round prior. Um you'll also have to you know, understand when you're going to sacrifice your worshipers into the temple because obviously that's going to score you more points and the earlier you do them, the more more points you get. But it means you're going to have less kind of worshipers in your workforce in order to um actually do what you need to do in the future rounds. So there's a lot of interesting things to go on and as I said um it's it's actually quite a hard game to explain why you're doing what you're doing without playing it yourself. So in terms of explaining the rules and stuff like that, I think I'll kind of kind of keep that to a limit in this review because it's one of the games you really do have to play for yourself.

Um but yeah, once once the game does click with you, all the mechanisms click, um you can really start enjoying this game. The tension does really amp up and um you know, you want to be getting every kind of bit of mileage and every squeeze every drop and every victory point out of your workers as you can because when you start comboing all these different um favor tokens, um it really is there's some really nice synergies. For so example, you might want to um you know, take take two workers off and add another to your pool and then you can use one of your herb tokens and move them back onto the island and then you can use one of your boat tokens to move them to where the island where the priestess is and you know, try and score majority that way and then you might want to use shrines, but you can use shrines with the dummy workers, which can score further combinations. So again, there's there's what you'd expect from a Stefan Feld game, it's very deep um and this game does keep unraveling and unraveling the more you play it, which is great for kind of replayability and um you know, playing it again and again and again.

Um in terms of the decisions, I think it's great, you know, there's every kind of island is completely viable to focus on. Um when I played this the first time, I thought or I couldn't really understand why some of the tokens were as important as others. I thought some seemed a lot more powerful than others, but when I played it the second time, I really focused on the ones that I kind of neglected in the first game and could got a lot of kind of um you know, useful um or a lot of use out of them in that way instead. So there's a lot of different things you can focus on. Um you know, and it's just great. So the in terms of the balance and the decisions, I think it's wonderful. All the different approaches are equally viable. There do you want to really focus on getting all your workers into that building? Uh do you want into the temple, sorry. Do you want to really focus on the moon priestess? Um there's a track you can go up which can break ties and also um offer you rewarded points. Do you want to try and shaft your opponent by putting the apostate where they've got all their workers and score them negative points? Um do you want to focus on building loads and loads of shrines?

So again, there's lots and lots to think about and there's a lot of kind of lining things up and manipulating the board to your um to your needs. And um something that leads on to kind of naturally from that is the interaction of the game. Because generally there's the interaction is restricted to the majorities in terms of you know, controlling the temple and controlling the um you know, controlling the majority where the princess is or where the apostate is. So there's interaction that way, but there's also interaction um in respect of this this candle mechanism. So basically one of the actions you can do is to pass, which um burns a candle down and there's there's four candles and once the candles um kind of got to its last last one, you the person who kind of triggered that mechanism is going to score a victory point. But it also means that you can kind of try and or sometimes you can catch your opponent very much off guard by um you know, by kind of cutting the turn short. So you might want to completely blitz all your actions and move everybody where you want them to the next round. You know your opponent wants to do achieve a lot this turn, um but you can keep burning those candles one by one and just completely um you know, leave your opponent high and dry, not leaving him want wanting to do what well not letting him achieve what he really planned to achieve that turn. So, that tension is really nice and um, something you really do have to experience.

Um, mechanically with the Feld game, you know, this game is fantastically well balanced, well designed, everything just works together like clockwork. Um, again with all the different um, actions you can take, um, it might be a little bit overwhelming as an initial kind of rules overhead and you know, the learning curve is a bit higher or a bit steeper than um, most other Feld games, but the game is not heavier once you've got your head around it. It's just that initial information um, can be a bit overloading at times and it didn't quite click with me as quick as other Feld games do, but once it does click, it is pretty um, you know, it's pretty straightforward. Um, in terms of uptime, this game is fantastic. The game is quick, very punchy and because you're just taking one of those actions and the actions do um, they're very simple, you know, take a favor token, move some workers, you know, um, you know, move the apostate, take one of those tiles, um, and stuff like that. So, again, there's not a there's not a lot of bookkeeping, there's not a lot of um, waiting around, a lot of downtime or anything like that.

So, in terms of keeping everybody interested, it's very much um, it does a great job. Um, replayability wise, as I said, um, nice because there's loads of different approaches you can take. There's different setups of the board you can take or set up because it's modular. Um, all the islands can be are all individual, so you can put them in different orders, um, which affects how they kind of, you know, cuz the priestess is going to move around and the builder is going to move around and the apostate, which can really kind of um, mix things up. Um, and the the way the game looks as well, I actually really like it. It has this kind of, you know, um, mystical, fantastical theme which um, you know, it it looks very nice. It's got Clemens Franz art, it's very nice, clean and cartoony. Um, and with a Feld game, you'd expect the theme to be completely pasted on, abstracted and just not really make a lot of sense, but while that's true and it doesn't make a lot of sense, you know, if you if you think about it, it just works. The fan- fantasy theme just works really well. Um, I love all the way you're kind of collecting all your worshipers and moving them around. It just has this very ethereal, strange feeling to it and it just works. Um, again, the theme, the mechanisms and the look of it just just come together very nicely. Um, you know, while I'd hesitate to call it thematic, it it's not, it just clicks quite well when you wouldn't think it necessarily would. Um, components wise, strictly talking about the deluxe version, it's wonderful. It's a really well-made game by TMG.

Nice, chunky wooden pieces for your not only for your play pieces, but for the queen and or the priestess and the builder and stuff like that as well. The board is extremely thick and high quality and um, the islands are like dual dual player as well. So, yeah, fantastic. The only thing I would say about the TMG version is that the coins or the the metal moon kind of point tokens, they're a bit naff. Um, but you know, no no big deal. So, I expect the the standard version is absolutely fine, but ultimately I think with a with a Feld game, you're looking for more the mechanics and how the game works more than how it looks and stuff like that. So, um, I won't drum on too much about that. Um, set up and tear down time as well, not too much of an issue. It's pretty quick actually. Pick a pick um, a couple of those kind of um, temple tiles based on the player count, um, set up your kind of workers and where you want to put them in and um, so yeah, so that that's pretty much it to be honest. There's not really a lot of setup.

Um, the the cadence of the game is very good. It kind of does amp up as you put more and more workers down, as you as the temple fills up, you've got to work out the kind of domino effect as when you're going to put new workers down and who's going to potentially take the next tile, um, because you're going to be careful about which islands you're on in the first place because in order to claim one of those tiles which are going to go in the temple, you have to be in the right place. So, another thing to think about there. Um, the scalability works really well um, because the the temple tiles are reduced depending on the lower player count. So, if there's only two players, you'll have two temple tiles. If there's three, you'll have three areas and if there's four, you'll have four areas. So, obviously it's going to be bigger areas if there's more players, but um, still nice and tight and you're going to have real cool knock-on effects. Um, and in terms of comparing this to another game, as I said, it's it's not really much I can think about that that it works quite in the same way, which is um, which is quite cool and I kind of always look for unique games and this one certainly is unique. Um, in terms of a couple of the very small negatives, as I said, it's quite difficult to explain for an initial play. I actually found it a bit slower to digest in terms of reading the rulebook and stuff like that. So, something just to be aware of there.

And um, but in terms of the the hidden layer and the so the hidden depth of the game and the layers and stuff like that, it's fantastic. Um, again, getting the mileage out of the workers is great. Different approaches you can take. The quick player turns is fantastic. Um, the two-player game you can play this in under an hour, which is always a great treat because it's a really meaty experience, but still in a succinct amount of time. There's good player tension, good player interaction and just another greatly designed and well well kind of put together Stefan Feld game and considering it's 10 years old as well, it still still feels nice and fresh and is very engaging. So, yeah, overall um, this game is fantastic. Um, as I said, not a game I would introduce as um, you know, a first Stefan Feld game. So, once you've got a couple of his game under your belt, you understand how they kind of work and kind of want something a little bit different than I'd definitely recommend giving giving Luna a go. It really is more of a gamer's game to some of the some of the other designers, but it's still it's still not like it's not heavy game, but it's it's like medium weight, but again, there's just that little bit more going on than some of these other games and a bit more hidden um, kind of depth to it than a lot of his other games as well, which, you know, there's there's more to it than meets the eye is what I think I was trying to trying to say. And the more you play it, the more you'll understand that. So, yeah, this one definitely gets a high recommendation from me. Um, you know, easily um, well, I think I've graded it an 8.2 out of 10, so that's an excellent rating for me.

Definitely check this one out if you haven't tried it and you are, you know, you trust Feld, you trust his designs, um, you know, it's a no-brainer. Give it a go. So, that is Luna by Stefan Feld, um, a fantastic design. Um, so I hope you enjoyed this review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. For Evan else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.

Progress saved