River Valley Jewelcraft Review - What's Mine is....Mine
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. and today I'm reviewing River Valley Jewel Craft from All Play. River Valley Jewel Craft is a one to five player game in which players are going to be gathering gems as they build up their tableau in order to buy various jewelry and ultimately score as many points as possible from a variety of sources. This is a prototype. All rules and components have to change and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. Also, it's worth noting that while this review is not sponsored, All Play is a channel sponsor, so please take any bias into account when you're just deciding whether this is a review that you use even uh useful to you. With that said, oh, and also there's a gameplay you can check on the channel at some point, probably going up later. I'll also be hopefully be a solo gameplay. And also, this is part of a two craft a two game crowdfunding campaign. You can also get a game called Some Assembly Required. You can check out a gameplay on that as well. With that said, let's go ahead and dive into this. In the game, you're going to be building up your tableau while gathering gems and spending gems. The general sequence of play is you're going to start the game by rolling the dice.
You're going to go ahead and roll, and then the lead player, let's pretend I'm currently the lead player. I should actually flip this to be on the uh basic side. Let's pretend I am currently the lead player over here. Uh I get to choose which of these dice that I want, and everyone else gets the other die. So, for example, if I want to activate, this would be the row that my miner is in. So, if I want to activate this row, then the other players would get this die and activate that column. The yellow die of course corresponds to the row, and the silver die corresponds to the column. Whichever die you pick, everyone else gets the other. In this case, I am going to choose this one, and that's going to give me one red gem and one white gem. And then the other players are going to get whatever's in their column, in this case a red and a blue. The next step is players are going to go ahead and uh take their activations. What they're going to do is they're going to work basically. It's called the work action. They're going to activate their worker. So, for example, I start on this spot over here, I will go ahead and move down over here, and that's going to let me get a blue gem. So, I'm going to go ahead and dig that spot.
It's a manual digging of that spot. And every player, well, that's actually not entirely true. Depending on the mode, the player count you're playing as, either the inactive players, not the active player, get to go ahead and do that. In a two-player game, both players do it. So, it depends on the player count as far as which of these phases you go through. Uh it is all printed on your player boards, you can follow along with whichever player board is matching your player count. When you're done with that, again depending on the game, if you're playing with a depending on the player count, at a two-player game, you will dig deeper, which means players go ahead and roll their die again and get whatever is there, again corresponding to your particular board. In this case, I would activate row two. I move to row two, I get to activate this one now. Players are going to do that, and then when you're done with that, the active player gets to go ahead and buy jew- buy these various uh jewelry over here. You can spend your gems to buy up to four points worth of jewelry. Any of the fine or artisan uh builds over here cost two points each to spend, and points are not the the gems you're spending. The gems are going to be the cost on the top of the card. Rather, you just have four activation points, uh building points, so to speak. That's regardless of what you have in your personal supply. You can buy four points worth of jewelry, again two for any of these and one for each of those. You can see that over here. You also, of course, have to spend the actual gems from your display over here in order to get those cards, and those are worth points, as you can see on the bottom on some of them. It's worth points for set collection. There are three main types, necklaces, timepieces, and rings. And when you have a set of all three, it's going to be worth four bonus points at the end of the game. And then, of course, there's also abilities on those cards, as you
can see on many of these, not all of them. This is simply 10 points, which is a lot of points, but you get a lot of abilities, being able to trade gems for other gems, activate your workers, all kinds of things like that. When you're done with that, you go ahead and build up your tableau. You're going to go to the market over here, choosing one of these. I'll go ahead and choose this one right now. I will get a green gem, because that's what it shows on the bottom. Sometimes you have to spend gems. And then we go ahead and put this somewhere into our display, which will help us for a variety of reasons. The first is it gives us better places. These empty spots are now giving us gems. In fact, I'll go ahead and place this over here. And now when I roll on when I roll a three, I get to activate this or as well column three over here will give me a whole bunch of gems. Additionally, you are trying to build up bigger sections of like colors. There are three colors over here, the dark red, the uh little I guess uh brown, and then the lighter beige. And when you build up sections of colors, at the end of the game, that's going to be worth points as well. We slide these down, put up a new tile, and that's a turn. Once again, a very quick recap of that. On your turn, you're going to roll the dice. The active player chooses a die, activates their board, everyone else activates their board with the other die. Then, depending on the player count, some players are going to go ahead and activate their person, which will help them get uh extra gems and sometimes clear rubble from their board, getting the gems on the opposing side.
When you're done with that, again depending on the player count, you might roll your dice again, although you won't be redistributing it, whoever has those dice. In a higher player counts, you will not be rolling again. Then from there, the active player gets to buy jewelry and then fill up their tableau. You're going to repeat this process until you get to a running out of tiles on the main board, which will trigger end game, at which point you will have a lot of uh jewelry you've crafted, because even though those early rounds feels like you can't buy a lot, as you build up your tableau, you will have turns where you are overflowing with gems and trying to figure out what to do with them. That is how you play River Valley Jewel Craft. Again, you can check out a full gameplay going up on the channel if you want to see the actual arc of the gameplay out. But with that, let's go ahead and dive into my review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. Oh, also there's solo mode, there's uh uh there's advanced characters over here, so you can play with the custom character builds with different rules. Uh there I assume, I don't know this for sure, but in general, the way All Play has run their crowdfunding campaigns for these box size games, there's usually a bunch of mini expansions that expand upon the gameplay as well, adding more variety, more other things. And there's deluxeification. Uh again, I I think these dice for example, they are cool and fun. If you look at the actual uh page for what the the deluxe dice look like, they look even cooler than this.
But with that, let's go ahead and um and other components, too. With that, let's talk about the uh what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. Starting off with what I like. I feel like I said with that four times, but um I could just ignore it and move on, or I could acknowledge it. I don't know whether I made the right choice. But, what do I like about the game? So, there's a bunch of things. It is fun rolling dice and getting things. If you've played games like Catan, like Valeria, like Machi Koro, like Space Base, this is basically a game where you roll dice and get stuff, and you build up your tableau to get more stuff. It has that element going on. So, if you enjoy that genre, again, Catan, Valeria, Machi Koro, Space Base, I I said Space Base. I think Bad Company as well. I don't know remember as much about that one. Didn't love that one quite as much, but it's well-liked. But that genre of you roll things, everyone gets stuff, and then on your turn you get to spend your stuff, that core mechanic is here. It is fun to roll dice and get things.
It is fun to build up your tableau over here and get more things. It is fun to make that dynamic choice as to what's better for you, what's better for me, because especially in a two-player game, but also at all player counts, there's not just the aspect of what's good for you, there is the aspect of how does that help other players? Sure, this might be better for me, but if they're both if this one's so much better for you, maybe it's better if I swap those, cuz this gets you nothing, even though this gets me a little bit less. So, there really are those decision points as far as how you build up your tableau and what you roll into as you go. You're also making decisions as far as how your miner moves around, what's more important to clear the board, even what things to buy. Because of the fact that many of these cards come with abilities, it's not just about the points in the game, it's about the abilities on the cards and how those play into your strategy. You're going for a bunch of things as far as you get end game scoring. There's end game scoring cards that give you rewards for certain types of jewelry or extra points for sets of jewelry or points for clearing your rubble. All of those things, both regular end game abilities as well as points scoring abilities, will affect your personal dynamic and how you're going to engage with this. The advanced characters are a nice touch as well.
They give you a little bit more asymmetry in the game. The basic characters are pretty straightforward. They're good for a first play, but honestly, by the time you dive into this the second time, I recommend going with the advanced characters. They are not so advanced, and they do introduce a small element of feeling different than other players, as well as how you're going to again have a little bit of a different variety to the experience. So, overall, oh, and then building up your tableau, well, I talked about a little bit, but uh building up your tableau, that's a lot of fun as well. And these arrows, these arrows are my favorite part of the game. In fact, if you watch the gameplay, you'll see these don't come out a lot, but uh in other games I've played, I've had these very active. Chaining arrow abilities, when you activate an arrow, you activate the thing next to it, and you can activate a bunch of chaining arrows, although you can't loop back into yourself. That can be very satisfying to build up a little arrow network as far as how your board develops, and you can layer things on top of other things as long as they're not mis- misbalanced. So, there's a lot of strategy as far as building up a board and leaning into do you want those end game points for a board that's going to reward you for, you know, having those groups, or are you trying to build a more efficient board for in-game gem gem generation as opposed to that end game scoring. So, overall, it looks beautiful, it's fast, it's light, it's uh gives you a fun degree of uh trying to build up your tableau and gather jew- jewel cards, all of that in a relatively short game, like 40 minutes or so, somewhere in that range. As far as things I don't like in the game, there's two main things. Uh one's more of a specific complaint, the other's more of a general genre thing. The specific complaint is there are many times in this game where you get to the max on your gem track, and you can't spend your gems effectively. Cuz again, you don't just need gems, you also have those limit on those four build points. And so, depending on what's on the board and how you can spend your resources, very
often you'll find yourself you're like, "Oh, I'm at 12, and I got four more this turn, and I get nothing for it." And on the one hand, from a balance standpoint, you could argue it's good because someone who already got lucky on the rolls or has too much, they're not able to like get a ton way way ahead of other players. On the other hand, it's also just not a feel-good moment as a player to have a gem maxed out, be unable to spend it efficiently, and then just feel like you're getting stuff and it's wasted. It is less frustrating to not get stuff than it is to get stuff when you can't even benefit from that thing. And so, that's just a not great feel-good moment in the game. Outside of that, the only real complaint I have is going to be this is a little bit on the lighter side, and I do find when games are on the lighter side, something that can really boost that game is the variability of the experience, and this doesn't have a ton of that. It definitely has some. The the cards are going to be the biggest thing for me, the combination of card abilities and how those play into your strategy. They give me the biggest incentive to dive back into it. The asymmetric characters are nice, they're not massively asymmetric. And then the tiles over here, again, you are going to have a different board, but for me variability is not about uh whether something is technically different. It's a It's more about whether it forces me to examine or play the game differently depending on what's happening. And those tiles don't have a significant effect on how I approach the game. The cards I get, those will. You get an early game card that rewards you for sets, that's going to play very different than if you get an early game card that rewards you for a specific type of jewelry. And so I like when games force me into these lanes where I have to pivot and adapt and feel clever. And again, the variability here is a little bit on the lighter side while being a little lighter.
As far as what I can see others not liking, a few small things. First of all, luck of the rolls is definitely a factor. And obviously luck of the rolls is always a factor. But what happens if on your turn you're rolling something that's good for everyone, so everyone will benefit, and on their turn they roll something that's good for them and not as much for you. So they benefit. So luck of the rolls is a factor. I haven't seen it be a particular issue. It is something that obviously can be an issue, but for me it's not impacting my gameplay. It's just worth being aware, you know, not all dice roll equally. And because of that kind of differentiation of of It's not like you roll one thing and everyone gets, which even that of course has luck. But it's that aspect where I can choose what's good for me. And more into that, the hate drafting element. I kind of like the strategic aspect of as to like, okay, I have to be mindful of how it affects others, not just me. But other players might not like that. Why Why are you looking at my board? Why are you not giving me the yellow die when it's clearly so good for me? I want the yellow die. You were about to give it to me, then you saw that I got four gems and you were like, well, I'm going to swap them. Some people don't like that kind of gameplay, and you could play this game with a little bit of that mean streak. As far as final thoughts on River Valley Jewel Craft, overall, this is a solid game.
It's solid. It's light. It's accessible. It's It's again plays in a short timeframe. A great production, great artwork. Overall, this is another fine game in the River Valley River Valley series, which I guess didn't really I mean this this makes it a series now. We now have a series of these River Valley games. In general, this does feel like a nice continuation of being similar to the core jewel concept of the River Valley series while being different enough that it's very much its own beast. For me, the biggest concern is going to be that variability of the experience while being a little bit on the lighter side. And it's tricky here because rating-wise I'm going to come in at a 3.5 out of 5, but I I always feel a little hesitant on these All Play games that are Specifically the this this series over here, which they've had River Valley Glassworks, they had Twinkle Twinkle. Do they have anything else? They may have had others. I don't remember offhand. But I have found with both of those series the base gameplay was light, accessible, and easy to play.
Both of the last two I mentioned are still in my collection. But the tricky part is I have found that during the crowdfunding campaign they often add extra variability and small modules that add to that main critique I have. So I'm always in that weird spot where I'm like, I'm reviewing what I have in front of me, but I do think if this continues like other games, then that specific core complaint will likely be addressed to some extent. So it's a 3.5 out of 5. I do like it. It's just that variability, and I am curious what the crowdfunding campaign will bring. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out River Valley Glassworks if you like this game. I think River Valley Glassworks adds a little bit more player interaction as far as the the mindfulness is when you're drafting gems and how other players might want certain things. But overall, both fall into a very similar weight class. And again, the charm, the visual appeal, and all that. And also, if you like gems and want another game of building a tableau, Splendor is an oldie and a goodie with the caveat that if you're playing it strategically, it's less fun. Which sounds like a weird thing to say, but if you know Splendor, play Splendor for fun, not to win. It's less fun if you're trying to win.
That'll make sense if you know Splendor. Anyways, until next time. I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you found this review helpful. And as always, I hope you have a good one.