Cost of Plastic - Heroes of Land, Air and Sea Review
Transcript
just like underwear boardgames come in different shapes and sizes you have tiny very small small this is starting to look like a board game this is a board game whoa slow down there cowboy and gloom Haven today we have a board game that introduces an entirely new size to board game one half of Africa sound very good heroes of land Aaron sees a full-length board game that promises you and up to three of your friends free hours of fun and if you buy the accompanying expansion order and cares you can have up to two extra friends playing it and just in case you haven't got enough friends this box is so big it comes with an actual extra friend inside go online open it I don't need to cuz I already know what's inside this box is the game that gives you thick slabs and a full sized family bucket full of plastic miniatures tool cardboard structures representing your fantasy races like walls elves orcs and Italians tell me more about the things in this game right now oh well Africa you get to do such board game staples as recruiting at an army made up of surface hero's build towers build boats and ships increase your capital level by layering these towers like layering a okay okay let's not
forget the fried chicken please tell me you didn't actually put fried chicken with those board game component did you yes right I watched them right now I want to tell you about publishing gambling games who have made a name for themselves cramming big experiences into tiny little boxes fitting in as much game into as compact a space as possible and then to go from this into that it's just like a explosion of pent-up components it's like a board game teenager finally hitting puberty and going I'm a big boy now here's of land Aaron C follows the Forex genre of games for extending for explore expand explode and exsanguinate to even know what exsanguinate means yeah it's a philosophical thing right as you build bigger army surround yourself with airships and I'm cool abilities with your buildings and heroes you will inevitably push towards one of the four endgame conditions as soon as someone either builds all the towers recruits all the figures explodes all the surprise exploration tokens or actually eliminates a player from the game fun time is over and it's time to pack up your toys because you don't count up your points see how I ask the most because get this what a toys bag yes what there is an elephant in this room and it's getting a little bit uncomfortable and not just because of this freemium mobile phone game or aesthetic this logo reminds me of
something something and I don't know is something about the scope of the game and how at first you recruit peon sorry I mean serfs and then you recruit as many as possible and then send them into resource collecting locations and then they bring in resources and then once you finally have enough and your economy is going you start recruiting warriors and then get buildings and those buildings will produce either different warriors or give you upgrades for those warriors and then you'll send them how to find someone else it's just it just reminds me of something and I don't want to say what it is because we all know what I'm talking about but from what I hear publisher gambling games is so scared of comparisons that they're actually afraid that the company who produces the thing that I'm not talking about do I even sue them or something which I don't think it's the case because this is clearly distinct enough as its own things so I just thought I'd bring it up for those of you who might you know feel that that is relevant and an interesting catch paradoxically here is with land air and sea never tries to compromise on staff or size but it tries to compartmentalize a big Forex game into a very compartmental two to three hours it's big but it never feels overbearing there is a lot of stuff but it all fits elegantly into a very sleep rules framework publishers went hey let's take everything we've learned from making a tiny game and apply it to as many components as Kickstarter money will let us have I really like this system of upgrading your things let's say you are playing the orcs and you want to do more killing right ok so here's the thing I
like all I have just the solution for you it is what we in the business call a blood tank now if you could just step inside then will that's it's not even the ten I know we had some budgetary constraint issues so these now is shed look the committee decided so just come on should be about two minutes one of the things I can do in this game is build a building let's say I decide to build a blood 10 because we already established that it's cool and also it gives me a cool new ability which is before any combat I can spend to mana and turn one of my serfs into a warrior if I want to do that all I do is assign a serf for permanent indenture in that building spend free mana and I have it built and that ability unlock but what's even cooler is that I can always build a second level of my capital and if I do that not only there's an unlock a second ability for the blood type which basically makes my army stronger if I'm fighting against serfs but also unlocks that ability or different abilities in any building that I have already built or will build in the future and not only that in unlock second abilities for each hero that I recruit it allows me to build a second tower whereas before I only had one and it allows me to scribe a second spell second everything one rule for everything in this game I think my blood warrior is ready alright
action selection is also streamlined each round I'll get exactly two actions with my action shields and when my turn comes along I can put that shield down either on a Capitol action or a command action Capitol actions let you do things like recruit soldiers build buildings scribe spells or just kick back with my taxes but each time I select a Capitol action I invite each other player to put down their serfs on that same action spot and do that action for free giving them an opportunity to exploit whatever it is that I'm doing but if I instead do a command action which generally relate to moving and getting yourself into a fight no one can follow that action but I can do an extra one of them just by putting a serf down myself of course I want to do capital actions at the most opportune moment which is generally late in the turn when everyone's already spend their serves and can't actually follow me but what if I need those soldiers now what if I need a building that unlocks one of my crucial abilities what if I just really need to kick back with those taxes and you get to fight and yet again it's a cool simple system when you're in a fight you count everyone's strengths and then whoever has the highest strength wins right no no wait just a bit okay you can't everyone strength then the defender gets to play a combat spell if they want to then the attacker gets to play a combat spell if I want to and then the highest strength wins right no then each player
plays secretly one of seven different combat cards and then reveals them simultaneously anticipating what combat card your opponent played is key because some cards cancel out other specific cards let's say your opponent played conscripts hoovering up friendly units from nearby areas into the fight well they won't get to do that if you played first strike and killed them literally before they could do that and then the highest strength wins right then everyone has to pay resources for the cards they played and if they don't have enough they have to sacrifice fighting units but they still get to participate in the fight and then the highest strength wins right yes okay Africa has a point this is far from elegant but it's kind of my favorite thing about this game rock-paper-scissors wizard Goblin or Spock is not since but by simply observing the resources that they have you can eliminate maybe four cards and then maybe another one because it just doesn't do anything relevant to this situation and then you're left with a 50/50 choice and your opponent knows this some fights in this game a very one side where it just doesn't matter what you play or they play or maybe they'll have all the resources and you just won't but sometimes you will be in an edge of the blade fight that makes Blade Runner seem like a slow and ponderous fill wait there's gotta be some sort of a cost for all the streamlining like a crossroads deal with the devil because it is just too sleek what happens when you build a tower well like a famous
boxer called assassin creed you get an eagle eye view of all the lands around you and you reveal all exploration tokens on them but because it is your outpost in current nights you get to teleport units from your capital on to that territory what happens when you want to put units into a boat or a sky ship and how many rows wise can you put in the answer is two because physically you can only fit two in I mean isn't that just amazing well okay honestly yeah obviously honestly this is the worst trip or I have been on this year and I feel so broken I want to go home really this is the worst board game trip you've been on umm I mean no okay obviously that's in this decoration right why did you say it then well because I needed a good segue and we have the Beach Boys up there and this boats in this have you have you got another segue we can use because we can't use this one anymore surprise this game to borrow a phrase from Alfred Quinn's is a little bit bobbins nothing we said was alive but everything else isn't very good which when you put the two together makes it alright Oh dare I even say it possible heroes of land air
and sea has as many little problems as it has little bits so let's dump this KSC size family bucket onto the table before we get to the gravy the spells range from this almost as nothing to completely preposterous erasing entire armies off of the board your abilities are an information dump that take forever to pass and you constantly forget them roars exceptions create multitudes of clarity issues making you spend time looking up things in it FAQ that wait a minute at the time of filming doesn't yet exist and this box half a centimeter too big to fit on the standard pallet shelf half a centimeter please find me the person who is responsible for this decision because I have words to share but these are just the bitty issues and whilst they do sometimes make you feel like you've got bit in your bits let's talk a little bit about the bits that don't feel so bitty on the surface getting that whole Warcraft experience on the table sounds exactly like the sort of thing that you might want and I get back that's the reason why we bought this game it's nostalgia I too want to go back to that time when nirvana was a bad then Keanu Reeves and spear mean the matrix was cool here's the thing when you're unraveling this efficiency puzzle and spent a good half of the game building up your economy and getting your engine going it is incredibly charming for it then to erupt into an all-out brawl at least in this game because it turns out that just like in comedy the most important thing
in boarding in good forex games when someone attacks you it makes sense because you've built up you recruited some cool new units and then you send them off to a fight but you didn't just do that there was a narrative reason for it you were invested in attacking the certain enemy for whatever past grievances or maybe just a really good tactical decision whereas in heroes land air and sea when someone attacks you it just feels annoying because there is nothing distinguishing about this map and actually despite looking like a flood board it is more like a donut everything is just about equidistant meaning that if you'd like someone because they maybe had a weak spot you actually didn't because in all likelihood everyone else also had a weak spot that is equally reachable just as that one and then when the fight is over everyone's just gonna lick their wounds and start rebuilding except they won't because again they've been weakened and other people are gonna start attacking them and the cycle repeats over and over again it is possible that this feeling of listless punch-up stamps from listless scouring everything you do in this game scores you points and I mean everything recruit a Duke that's points build a building that's points win a fight that's also points and scribe a spell sure why not go ahead points and in theory this is great because no action in the game gets unrewarded but in practice and I'm sorry to say this it just feels a little bit pointless there are no clear objectives it's just do things cuz it's all good
and points but a lack of a clear objective creates a lack of narrative in games like toilet Imperium sure you're also trying to score points but each and every single one of them was a heart for battle that told a story you either brokered a deal or negotiated an alliance or betrayed your friends and talking of Twilight Imperium this box right here retails at 80 pounds and comes with just four factions meaning that you playing it with free other friends you are always going to be playing with the same factions that's the problem and the solution of course is to introduce a box of the exact same size but for 60 pounds adds another four factions and if money was not an issue sure you might be thinking to yourself great this is exactly what this game means this is probably the most disappointed I've ever been opening such a big box sure it's full of plastic minutes and even more couple towels but I got to the four-page rulebook this isn't rolls this isn't rolls this isn't rules and neither is this this is just a big picture and it's tiny here tells you how to add another port to play with five to six which we wouldn't recommend and that says that the undead get some tokens that's it the really disparity moment was when I realized that if it wasn't for all these minis for buildings then this box but probably have space to fit in everything that's in this box and the cost of them together would probably be less than this box and the cost of the excess
isn't just financial its space and the lack of space is what does this game in everything that the Kickstarter enabled is to its detriment and for a combined cost of a hundred and forty pounds I'd honestly rather buy Twyla Imperium which comes with 17 playable races but what if you don't have time in your life to play Twilight Imperium it takes at least twice as long and that's a valid point even though I would rather play one game of this than two games of this believe it or not even though we didn't end up loving it we would recommend sides over here offal and Aaron see as a similar Skype a similar length and it gives you a real sense of achievement when you've built up and you go out looking for trouble and if you bought this and both the expansions you would still end up saving yourself around 40 quid compared to this and that's it scope that is the real issue with this game because we kind of wanted to like it and actually a lot of people really do like this game and that's because I think they take one look at than sheep and go that's an ability that's an ability wait a minute I can combine them together and that's a combo there's so many combos in which one will I pick that's exciting I get it and I think it's almost exciting in this game except that it doesn't really fit into the turn frame of the game there are so many possibilities and yet none of them feel like they are fully explored any time you play it and that's why hero's of line Aaron see is a little
bit like the London Eye it's big flashy it's really expensive to get a ride on a lot of people enjoy it and I'm just left wondering why did I spend my money on this whether you agree with us or not we hope you find value in the fact we exist and will sometimes take very popular games to task because I'll tell you I it destroys relationships with publishers and it also destroys relationships with viewers because people get really precious about games and that's understandable this entire hobby is built on a passion for games and you know what we're also passionate and if you want to see some more positive stuff from us here's the thing we did it's our top 10 games we will talk a lot of good things about a lot of good games and while you're here why not hit the subscribe button come on you stuck all this way through you're enjoying this click the button