Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:43

this video is sponsored by launch tabletop a fullscale board game manufacturer with a print on demand prototyping service launch lab hang on until the end of the video for more information and a discount code and it's time for another 10 in my top 100 lessons that I've learned about board game design and the industry over 10 years or so of making games we're today looking at number 70 through to 61 and and as before I'm going to show you now the topics that we're going to be discussing today uh through the magic of editing I haven't actually seen these yet because what I have is a deck of cards which all have different um lessons or truths about the board game industry that I've uh that I've written previously so card number one table presence can be a strong hook you'll find it with specific Publishers when you speak to specific Publishers they will say they they they definitely want something which is going to sit at the center of the table it's going to catch the eye that's kind of their strategy their marketing strategy it used to be uh in Years Gone by when toys and games were always sold through catalogs right back in the 1980s or whenever it was before the internet in the 1990s maybe um in those days it was always about how well a game photograph right so if a game was going to look good in a photograph look good from a distance uh then it was going to really

stand out and and sell well um from from catalog advertising or billboard advertising you know but it but it may also be how it looks in a in an advertisement if it's on the television if we're talking about the mass Market within the hobby market it's how good it looks on a convention table or how well it stands out when people look at it online on its Board Game Geek page um so a key um physical component uh is can be a real draw even if that physical component is not necessarily absolutely essential to play in the game so I'm looking at everell here for example with its massive cardboard tree that has no real gameplay function but just really catches your attention or the The Dice Tower in wingspan that looks like a bird box don't need it you could just roll the dice but it's nice to have those things can be very very effective if you can make them affordable right so that they're not completely bumping up the cost um and and if they're functional all the better I mean look at the the marble dispensers in potion explosion um another example of one which is is not entirely necessary would be the uh the dice dispenser in camel up that shaped like a pyramid those things can really work well for your game if you get it right so consider those when you're designing work on many games I think

people get too caught up in a single game and it creates a whole bunch of problems they become very very attached to it they don't want changes to be made to it it makes rejection much harder to take and if you get stuck it can be really really disheartening because you just keep on trying to push through you're not getting anywhere if you work on multiple games a lot of those problems go away you know if you get stuck you can't really work out a solution fine we'll put it to one side will work on something else and then you the solution will inevitably pop up a solution's just popped into my mind a couple of weeks ago for a game that I've been designing since 2014 and it's been on the Shelf probably since about 2016 right for the last 7 years or so i' there's been a problem in that design that I haven't been able to fix and over the last couple of years I've not really thought about it one day recently just popped into my head when I was playing another game I thought hang on a minute this might be the solution for my game so working on multiple games really helps it really helps when one of your games flops okay when it sinks or when it gets a bad review or something like that if you got other stuff that's going on it doesn't hurt so bad right because you got other things going on you're not ring on just one thing you also learn a lot by working on different types of games um so I would say all around it's a good strategy don't just focus all your attention on one thing work on multiple things and you'll have a much more rounded healthy experience and relationship to your

projects Kill Your Darlings chase the fun so that's a classic phrase that's used in a lot of creative Pursuits isn't it Kill Your Darlings and what it means is sometimes you can become too attached to a specific thing and you can't see that it's not helping your game it could be a mechanism it could be a thematic thing um that really needs to change and everybody else can see it but you can't because you love it it's too important to you to let it go even when it's really working against your your product sometimes it can be really helpful to have a collaborator it's where Cod designers can work really effectively when somebody who you trust and respect can look you in the eye and say I know this matters a lot to you I know it's an important aspect of the game to you but it's not working it's not getting getting us anywhere you're going to have to put it to one side and use it in another game cuz this isn't the one what I mean by the chase your fun bit is this is these are almost two different things really chase the fun is when you're play testing and you can see that the play testers want to do a specific thing and your game is not allowing them to do it and it may be because one of your Darlings is getting in the way hampering that experience putting up a barrier stopping them being able to do the thing that they really want to do well forget about your darling forget about the thing which you know you thought was really important if it's stopping people having fun get rid of that thing doesn't

matter how important it was to you use it in another game let them do the things that they want to do really good question to ask your play testers what would you like to have been able to do in this game but you couldn't and then see if you can facilitate that you can pitch virtually but in person is superior and I maybe it's unfair of me to to make this statement because I don't do much virtual pitching and perhaps it's great and I'm just no good at it I don't know I have done it don't get me wrong I have done virtual pitches and I've I've done it successfully as well but in person is so good meeting people in person looking them in the eye getting to know what they're about them getting to know what you're about having the opportunity to make a bit of small talk to get the T the the game out on the table show them some physical components so they can touch it feel it see it um it's a it's a very different experience to showing them a little video online or trying to angle your webcam so that you can see the game on the table don't do that make a make a pre uh a pre um pre-made video or show them a PowerPoint with some some images okay don't rely on your webcam bending around to show them the table that's not going to work at all um virtual pitches even after when did we all start using zoom and I mean I know there were things before the pandemic but you know 2020 was the year where we really started to

get stuck in with zoom and Microsoft teams and all these sorts of things but they haven't really Advanced have they I'm always shocked by how little they've changed in that sort of three or four year period all the things that I wished I could do with zoom and teams back in early 2020 I still wish I could de with them now so yes Publishers will meet with you virtually and it's much much cheaper and you don't have to wait for conventions my preference is still hang on for those conventions you see them as a big deadline that you're working towards and get in there and do the use all your energy on that few days and that for me is a much much better experience mainly because of the relationships I just enjoy the communication and building those relationships you can't do that virtually and it's too it's too easy for them to say no okay in person they've given you half an hour they're going to spend half an hour with you probably and if if if you you run out of things to show them with your game they're not interested well in you get talking about their their strategies for the future what their plans are even just what they've enjoyed at the convention and you start to build relationships build a network code designs have your income but they double your fun coddesigns are a mixed blessing because the people who get on really well with Cod designs and do it a lot will tell you it's fantastic and of course they will because they're doing it all the time and it's the way that they know how to do things and they've got fantastic co-designers it can be difficult it

could be a bit of a struggle you could have completely different ideas about the way you want to take the game you could have somebody who's not pulling their weight and somebody else who's doing everything or you could have somebody who just takes over and doesn't let you do anything you could have a totally different um viewpoint on things and that might not emerge until you're halfway through the process and you get half the money and actually the money is very small anyway you don't earn an awful lot from game design unless you're very very successful so by taking on a code designer you are potentially speeding things up but also potentially going to sink your game because once you've agreed to kind of develop it with this other person once it doesn't work that relationship's not working well Who develops it now what happens to that game it goes on the Shelf cuz nobody really owns it you know is it's split between the two of you but if you get it right then it's really really fun okay I've co-designed a lot with a a local designer in Wales called Rob Fischer and it's really really good to just have that sounding board we've worked together a lot we understand each other we've got a similar mindset for these things and any ideas that we have we can just bounce them off each other um and you're just sharing the whole experience in a way that you know other friends and family can't because they're not in it they're not invested in it in the same way they may not be that interested in games really Beyond a very superficial interest so somebody who's really devoted to it and connected to it it's

really really fun to share that experience um I love it when I'm at Essen and and I have you know promising uh meetings with Publishers and then I'm able to pick up the phone and speak to Rob specifically and say you know what's um this is what's happened today day this is what I've seen what do you think about this what do you think we should do next if I was doing it on my own which I often am I don't have anybody to talk to about that stuff game design is addictive keep it in check right I think that's important as with any hobby particularly more addictive Hobbies this one's really addictive gaming in general not just game design but gaming design oh my word you can go down a rabbit hole you can spend all your time you can spend loads of money you could you could devote your life okay this is like a a full-time gig that you do on the side of your full-time job it could take over all your evenings all your weekends um and and you know you may have a family that you need to spend time with and even if you don't well maybe you want to be working on on you know other networks not sitting in your in your dining room cutting up cardboard you know stop watching this video go and find yourself a network of people build a social life outside of game design game design is

really addictive and yeah you've got to have a life You' got to have other Hobbies outside of it I've struggled with this over the years game design has increasingly taken over all my spare time all my hobby time becomes about games and games design um I've mentioned frequently in these videos I used to be an actor for many years as an amateur actor for several years as a professional actor that's all Fallen away I don't pursue that whatsoever I do nothing in that regard I never go to the theater these days um I watch very little television even I don't read that much it's game design all the time game design and that's hard on everybody around me really and YouTube YouTube takes a lot of my time as well as you can imagine game design is addictive keep it in check okay don't spend all your time on it do other stuff and it'll inform Your Design as well where do you get your inspiration from if all you're thinking about is games go out there live life you'll get interesting new

ideas you don't earn enough to play test 100 times I think I've already made this point in a previous video some of these cards inevitably I guess they they overlap a little bit so I won't stress this point too much but I do have a a a a strong feeling that it is unreasonable to expect designers who are designing you know unsolicited designs they're going to they're going to pitch them to Publishers they may or may not get picked up why would you play test your game hundreds and hundreds of times hundreds or thousands of hour hours of unpaid time going into that when it may or may not get picked up that's a huge risk and also your play testers aren't getting paid for it so a lot of people's time is getting wasted there potentially really feel that a lot of if you're going for that super duper balanced game really that falls to the publisher to do that sort of work after there's a contract in place after things have been signed and everybody knows what the deal is and the publisher hopefully has more resources to do that and can uh you know recompense their their play testers or at the very least find play testers who are are willing and are not being exploited in any way um to do it there's a lot of people in the board game industry who are not being paid you know adequately for for Creative work inevitably because the margins in everything are so small yeah with

margins so tight I don't think you can you you can play test 100 times you're not going to be making enough games if you're do spending all your time on that single game then you're not going to be making enough to to earn anything like a living you're going to be working for basically nothing essentially at that point I've made a whole video about this the the the big myth about play testing so maybe go back and watch that one and and and maybe I can talk about it a little more more clearly if they're rude they go on my list so I'm talking about Publishers here so I've mentioned in a previous video that Publishers are very warm and very friendly and of course that is the case for the vast major majority of Publishers the vast majority of Publishers are lovely every now and then though maybe once in a convention so I'm talking one in 20 one in 30 Publishers where do you know what they're not very warm they're not very friendly they may even say something that irritates me I was going to use a stronger phrase they might might offend my sensibilities okay they might be critical of a certain genre of game or that you know I show them a game and they they dismiss it and they're not really making any sense they're basically showing a a lack of knowledge of the industry or they're not thinking about what they're saying or they haven't really they're not respecting the time that I've put into it or the fact or or they're critical of something where I think well obviously I've thought of that obviously I've thought of that and I've worked on that you know it sometimes it can be quite belittling um but this is rare they're few and far between but you can

guarantee if I've met one of those people I'm not going back to that public if somebody is rude and dismissive of me there are loads of Publishers I can speak to I don't need to speak to that one I will smile and say thank you very much and move on okay so it's not like I'm shouting them down or arguing with them I never debate with them it's not worth it but they go on my list don't bother contacting that person again I could do without the stress enthusiasm from a publisher is the tiebreaker oh that's nice that's the the the Counterpoint to this I love it when when a a publisher is enthusiastic about a prototype that I've shown them I absolutely love it it can shift a publisher from being sort of okay I'll show it to them but there's lots of other Publishers I'd rather have it they can suddenly go up the up the ladder and they're at the top now well this is the one I want to work with and it's because they were so enthusiastic they got the game they understood it if they're that enthusiastic they're going to be able to sell it right because they've got it they understand that enthusiasm goes a long long way so when I say it's the tiebreaker what I mean by that if I've got two potentially two parties interested in a game sometimes that happens fairly frequently that'll happen that there might be a couple of Publishers who are showing an interest who are talking about maybe contracts

and I'm thinking which one am I going to go with always the most enthusiastic one even if the other one maybe has a slightly bigger profile or or bigger distribution or something like that if they're less enthusiastic well it counts for a lot I might lean the other way okay so enthusiasm from a publisher is the tiebreaker a bad review feels awful a good review feels okay I made a whole video about this didn't I about my game thrown and how it didn't get great reviews didn't even get that many reviews but it got a particularly bad one and uh and how much that hurts really when it happens it really does feel awful I hate b reviews don't hate the reviewer it's not their fault okay they didn't enjoy the game that's fair enough lots of games I don't enjoy but it does feel bad when you get a negative review uh it feels really bad the the sad thing about it is that a good review doesn't feel that great either good review feels okay right I'm happy I'm relieved basically that's what it is when I when I watch a good review I'm relieved that's what I feel like I'm like okay that was all right I don't watch it and go oh yes amazing this is what I'm in it for and I I think that's probably because the reviewers aren't really my target that's not really who I'm making the game for I'm much more interested in I love it when you know friends or friends of friends or sometimes it will be like my parents'

friends or it'll be the kids of one of my friends that play my games and they come back and they say they had this great time while they send me photos and they're smiling and they're laughing um I love that stuff I love that Personal Touch I really like an Amazon comment right somebody who's not in the gaming hobby necessarily a comment on Amazon is often it's from somebody who's just picked up the game they don't really know much about games and they say they really enjoyed it I love that that's really really satisfying but actual genuine connection with with real people playing the game that's where the real satisfaction is so there's another 10 in my top 100 which takes us to 60 doesn't it so we'll be carrying on with another 10 in the next video I hope I'll see you there all the best did you know that double-sided game boards can be customized to your preferred size with launch labs this is not the case with most print on demand Services if you want a wide variety of options for your board go to launtop tocom and use the code admin Wales for a 20% discount on your order

Progress saved