Skip to main content
Loading video...

Metropolys Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:12

hey everybody today we're going back to 2008 and taking a look at metropolis which is a board game designed by sebastian paulshon and published by istari games this one accommodates two to four players and takes around 45 minutes to play on average now the key mechanisms of this game are kind of bidding and kind of very majority but we'll delve into that a little bit later the setup is going to look like this we have the main board here which is which consists of these five different regions um with the center region and these four going around this side here separated by these rivers you can see the map is made up of all these different terrain types which matters and also has these tokens semi-randomly scattered throughout the map there's also going to be some additional tokens consisting of these kind of skyscraper tokens here which basically is going to award people points depending on how many of these areas they control by building the highest skyscrapers there you've got these additional cards as well which you can get throughout the game as you take your actions and also a score reference sheet here now i will say there is two modes to play this game you've got the basic family version like this and you've also got the advanced version like this but i would say always play with the advanced version because it's not too much more advanced than the basic version now each player is going to have a set of these skyscrapers that range from value 1 all the way up to value 13 and additionally at the start of the game you're going to get given two cards at random which is going to be a secret objective so the first one is going to correspond to a terrain type so you see you've got all these different terrain types corresponding or

correlating to the ones on the board here and basically what that means is if i get one of my buildings on these regions then for each time i do that i'm going to get an additional two points and also you're going to have a secret objective um which might look like this where you've got ones where you want to be getting your buildings surrounding these little fountains here or ones where you want to build up three buildings in a row connecting uh ones where you want to have your buildings on either side of these bridges and finally the one here where you want to get three of your buildings surrounded by one of these little ponds here okay so gameplay in this game is rather simple where the first player is simply going to select one of these terrain types and put one of their markers on it so let's just say the white player wanted this spot here like this then the next player has one of two options one of which is to pass and not to outbid the six that the white white is placed here the second of which is to outbid the white and when they do that they're going to take one of their markers as obviously higher than the six and then they're going to place that marker on any adjacent region to the one that's already been built on so they could go here they could go here they could go here or they could go here based on the fact that you can cross bridges so let's just say the grey player is happy to outbid and put that eight like this then i go to the next player so it says the reds go and the red would put their number 10 here like this always snaking off from the previous bed and then it'll go to the blue player and let's just say the blue player is not interested in raising the 10 because it's too high for them and then a pass then they'll go back to the white player and let's just say they wanted to place their 11 here like this

and then everybody else passes because they don't want to raise any higher than 11. now what's going to happen is that all the players who've been outbid are going to take their markers back to their supply ready to be used again in the future and the person who won the bid is going to place their token face down for the rest of the game because they're not able to use it again now this is going to count towards area majorities which i'll talk about a bit later but it also restricts the board further because any region that has a building in it can no longer be passed through so as more and more buildings are put onto the board it's going to get tighter and tighter and you're going to have fewer options where to spread out so let's just say in future rounds let's say a grey player claimed this region and a blue player claimed this region you can see that this area here is trapped between these other ones meaning that if a start player went straight in there see with a really low number like a number one they're going to automatically win that region because no other player has the option to spread out from that spot also whenever you win a region with one of these tokens on you're going to take that token for yourself and they're going to do a number of different things so let's talk about what they do so these ones here with this fashionable lady are always going to grant the winning bidder three points which is quite a strong amount of points so that's going to naturally increase the value of that region and you've got these tokens here which are always going to grant you a negative point so you have to weigh up that decision of am i still willing to win that bid and maybe you know contribute towards my secret objectives or not but additionally whenever you take one of these um negative tokens you're also going to take the negative card to give you an additional minus two

points so always the last person to take one of those negative tokens takes this card two so it's quite good to get those done early if you're going to take them so you're not lumbered with this card you've also got these subway tokens that look like this they're all going to be worth one point each but additionally the person with the most of them is going to get this card here to get you an additional three points and let's talk about some of the other things you're aiming towards so one thing i didn't talk about in detail was the air in majorities like this so at the end of the game once somebody has placed all of their um all of their markers down or their buildings down each of these different regions is going to be calculated by the amount or the the amount of tallest buildings in that region so you can see here at the moment this is obviously i'm just an example both the white and the blue player have their big tall buildings here they've got one each therefore it's going to be a tie then it'll go down to the next level um which you can see that only the white player has another building there so therefore the white is going to be the most or the strongest player in that region of course you're going to get victory points based on your secret objectives and depending on how many times you get that fulfilled so you know you can score these a number of times if you manage to pull that off by scoring you know seven four four five or even different options and two points for each region that you've got your buildings in that particular um terrain type so that is essentially how the game is going to play out so i've advanced the game state here just to show what the board is going to look like towards the end of the game and once one player has

placed all of their buildings then it's going to immediately end the game so you need to really keep an eye on the amount of buildings that each other player has because they can catch you off guard and maybe leave you with too many buildings in your supply if they choose to end the game or if they're able to pull off ending the game and something i should have mentioned as well is that the person who wins the bid is always going to leave lead the next round by placing that building first and that can create some quite interesting decisions because sometimes you will want to win regions and even if you're not particularly interested in it just because you want to lead the next time because as i said the board is going to keep getting more restricted and cutting off regions meaning that you can get a lot of mileage out of your very low point tokens just by jumping straight into a region that you know is disconnected from the other ones and sometimes that can create some quite cool chain reactions where if you keep winning then you can keep on kind of getting these combos to close off the board again and again and again and again to make sure that nobody else has the opportunity to even place their buildings onto the board and that is one of the big decisions to be had in this game so it does get tighter and tighter as the game develops also how are you going to pace yourself is a big factor in this game because you do only have i think it's four of the large buildings and if you start using them really quickly to get the you know very particular spots that you want then you're going to leave yourself a bit outgunned going forward because people are always going to be able to upbeat you in the future turns that's what you need to really start to use the actual spatial puzzle of things in order to close things down in order to actually pull off the win with the smaller tokens so it is quite a strange thing where

sometimes people could really run away with placing a hell of a lot of their buildings on the board you think well i'm not winning anything here i might might not get a chance to put anything down but inevitably because the board is quite open at least to start with you will start winning bids and start catching up but it is something you need to be on the pulse with in terms of the pacing of the other players and additionally you will obviously be trying to focusing on your own objectives because you know you're going to get points by getting into the particular regions and also in locations where you know your objective corresponds to but you also want to be keeping an eye out on what the other people want as well and you will inevitably learn what they're going to go for because obviously they're going to start spending their bigger tokens on the certain terrain types and you think well they're obviously going to go for the grass region or something but also you need to be on a pulse with people you know going for certain objectives so maybe they want to get three of their abilities in a row like this and therefore you might start making a conscious effort to outbid them to stop them from pulling off those objectives which is a big part of the winning strategy but as you are trying to fulfill your objective you've also got to be conscious of the fact that these these cards here are going to be passing around by the actual tokens themselves because you know even if you don't want a region i might not be interested in blue regions they might have one of these tokens on which could be worth you know a massive three points so even though some of the objectives of some of the regions aren't going to relate to your objectives you're still going to want to compete over them and stop people getting bargains by collecting these tokens and if you are running away with these um these subway tokens and you want to keep hold of this card you might make more of an effort to keep hold of that token because you know

three points is not insignificant additionally as i mentioned before these negative tokens are important because just passively sometimes the disks are put on the regions that you want you know that's going to happen and you've got to weigh up the fact like am i willing to take those negative points now um and and try and get my objectives fulfilled in order to hope hopefully someone will take one of these card these tokens later and it will take the card off me to prevent me losing that further negative two points so it's got a lot of decision space here um so not on you your objectives but also the tokens and preventing other people getting their objectives and also of course the majorities in each of the regions because a five-point swing is quite strong and if you manage to pull off a couple of those and then you're gonna probably be in a good stead for winning the game so the decision space in this game is absolutely plentiful loads you need to consider with each of your placements but something i want to really want to stress is how different this bidding mechanism is because normally in an auction or bidding style game you're always competing over the same thing that the start player kind of triggers this one you're not it's always to the adjacent region so it's like a betting game but also not because you're again you're cascading out to the adjacent spots and each of these spots is going to have a a different value to each player because kind of objectives are going to be different terrain types are going to be different and the desires for those are going to be different depending on the player so that decision space and how things jump around the map and close things off is just a whole new dimension it's something i haven't seen before and i just like how clean it is you know in

terms of just those two decisions outbid or pass also the time investment for this game is spot on it only takes around 45 minutes to play which is a lot of game in a short time frame now despite praising the elegant mechanisms and the unique mechanisms as well i will say that replayability isn't the best for the game and because there is only a certain amount of objectives you have i think there's five in the game and one of them doesn't really feel quite balanced to me um so it always feels pretty obvious about what people are going to do and it almost feels like a mute point in terms of what objectives people are going for because we're going to turn a turnover you pretty much know um so it would have been nice to see some differentiation in terms of the objectives and seeing a whole bunch of cars which would affect the game in different ways so you really don't know what your opponents are going for because you only need to learn these which only takes a second and you're going to know what they want it's pretty pretty sharpish now it is obviously a more of a reactive game in a a tactical game as well because you're always reacting to the board state it's always going to develop in different ways new opportunities are going to develop so there is that and i wouldn't say it feels samey each time but it just would have been nice to have more variety in terms of and gain and game objectives and maybe different things to go for play interaction is fantastic obviously you're dictating your pace based on the buildings of the other players so you know if you know that you've got your big buildings left and everybody else has got their buildings spent already then you can kind of use that to trump the other players in terms of getting into the majorities and getting all getting the majorities of the regions and additionally the back and

forth of these tokens here is quite interesting because there is like competition to get to those metro tokens in order to get those bonus three points and also trying to get rid of that um horrible negative card there as well so there is some kind of passive interaction and everything you do and just trapping players and just creating opportunities for yourself it's all part of the game and it really isn't a game that could operate well without the input of the other players i think the production of the game is really striking you know i like the way the board looks it's maybe a little bit busy a little bit frantic but i don't mind that it does have a kind of a classical euro feel to it um some of the components themselves are fantastic you know these buildings are greatly these nice solid wooden pieces nicely clearly marked on there so it's nice to see um a real cool table presence developed as the game you know as the game plays on and it looks like you're building this kind of cool kind of skyscape uh the actual graphic design on some of these cards is okay it's not it's not the best um but it's fine nice and clear and the card stock is decent um yeah they're you know not going to get shuffled or anything so they are going to hold up quite well and the tokens as well are nice and clear and are of a decent quality so yeah overall i'm happy with the production um especially with the buildings themselves something i want to touch on briefly is the scalability of the game so with a full four players then the whole board is going to be open with three players one of the regions is going to get closed off and i think with two players two of the regions are going to get close up just to make the board a bit tighter um additionally that is going to create some kind of um opportunities to put the buildings down in the corners because you're not going

to be able to cross these bridges so it does kind of create that more opportunity to get back to back turns and close off regions and get your lower buildings down but it works fine either way you know but personally i've probably only ever played this one at three or four players i don't really have the desire to play it with two okay so final thoughts on metropolis now i will say this game is really well designed though it's so smooth and elegant in the way it operates just outbid or pass and that unique system off you're not always bidding for the same thing you're spreading out from the existing spot that is something i haven't seen before and i always love it when i see mechanisms that i haven't seen before there's a lot of things to consider here in terms of getting points but i would say that something something that does work against the game quite a lot for me is how predictable the different objectives are it would be nice to have again more variety in those um but there are of course other things you need to fight for you know the majorities other tokens themselves so there is a lot of competition there and i like the way that the board gets tighter and tighter as the game develops you know when you start the game it does feel quite open and obvious about what you want to do but it does become a lot more exciting and tense as the game develops now something i do want to touch on is the fact that i have a lot of bidding games and auction games in my collection it's a very convoluted part of my collection and i need to be quite picky on what i choose to acquire because i don't need a million games of the same genre and that is where i think i might be kind of why i'm not singing from the rooftops about this game because although i really appreciate i think it's a lot of fun and way better than the average game i think it's a very well well designed

game but ultimately i think i've got better building games in my collection and i can't really see myself constantly leaning towards this one above all the other ones i have so for that reason really is going to be the only thing to stop it from hitting this table regularly and staying in my collection but that doesn't take away from the design i think it's a very good game um something that should be appreciated more you know you don't really hear anybody talking about this game despite i think uh it's going to get reprinted this year or re-implemented so it'll be exciting to see if this game reaches a whole new audience because i think it deserves it i always appreciate very streamlined clean designs like this one is again things that are unique so while i appreciate it i just can't see it kind of um sticking his head above all the other games i have of this genre and that is kind of my parting thoughts on micropolis really a solid solid design in fact way better than average but ultimately it's not excellent and i'm kind of looking for excellent games now

Progress saved