Metropolys Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Metropolys
Metropolys comes up only briefly in the community videos, but the tone is consistent. Matthew, on Watch It Played's "Matthew Answers the Internet" segment, calls it a city building negotiation style game and says they want to find a copy, noting that it is often cheap in other countries. Heavy Cardboard groups it with Masters of Venice as a game that looks rough but is really excellent.
The videos agree that the game is worth seeking out despite its appearance. The same Watch It Played segment also observes that the remake, Skyrise, is well liked and differs mainly in its artwork. That suggests the design keeps its reputation while the original's look is the main thing holding some players back.
Core Mechanics That Define Metropolys
Bidding With Numbered Markers
Each turn a player places a numbered building marker on a board space, and later players can pass or raise by placing a higher numbered marker on an adjacent space. The winning bidder flips their building face down to claim the spot, and losing markers return to their owners. Matthew's shorthand, a city building negotiation, fits this system closely, since every bid is also a claim on the city's layout.
Scoring Through Position and Adjacency
Final scoring rewards where buildings end up rather than how much was spent. Metro spaces pay whoever has the most neighboring buildings at game end, archaeological sites penalize the player who built there most recently, and fashionable locations give flat bonus points. Each player also holds secret agenda cards, such as surrounding water fountains or occupying both sides of a bridge, which add a personal goal to the shared board. The game ends when a player places all of their buildings.
The Metropolys Experience
Negotiation Built on Scarcity and Pursuit
Matthew's enthusiasm for Metropolys is described as a hunt. Matthew places it at the top of a wish list of games to track down, reports that copies are often cheap abroad, and says a UK seller was asking around £100 for one, calling it a nightmare. That framing presents the game as a prize that is worth the effort to find, in keeping with the tense bidding it offers at the table.
Looking Past the Cover
Heavy Cardboard calls the game pretty damn ugly and then immediately says it is really excellent. The host treats the appearance as a separate question from the quality of play. The same reasoning is applied to Masters of Venice in the same discussion, so the first impression of the artwork is presented as something the game quickly overcomes.
What Makes Metropolys Stand Out
The Original Behind Skyrise
Metropolys is the original version of a design that was later redone and renamed Skyrise. Heavy Cardboard identifies it as the source of that remake, and Watch It Played's Matthew notes that people are loving the newer version, with the artwork as the main change. For players who know Skyrise, Metropolys is the version that started the line.
A Design Players Hold Onto
Matthew lists Metropolys among the games most wanted to track down, and compares prices on BoardGameGeek to show how uneven the market is. Copies look reasonable in some places and far more expensive in others. The fact that a longtime collector still names it as a top target suggests the game has staying power beyond its first release.
Potential Drawbacks
Artwork That Divides Players
The most consistent criticism concerns appearance. Both channels bring up how the original looks, and Matthew's point that the remake changes mainly the artwork suggests the visuals are the main barrier to getting the game to the table. A game that many people judge first by its cover may struggle to reach players who would enjoy its bidding.
Uneven Availability
Matthew reports that copies are cheap in some countries but expensive in the UK, where a single seller was asking around £100. Players in markets without easy access may face a similar search before they can try the game for themselves.
If You Enjoy Metropolys
- Skyrise: Heavy Cardboard describes Metropolys as the original of the design that was redone and renamed Skyrise, and Watch It Played's Matthew notes that the remake is well liked and mainly changes the artwork. Players who like the remake will find its source in Metropolys.
- Masters of Venice: Heavy Cardboard places it alongside Metropolys as a game that is pretty damn ugly but really excellent, so the two share a reputation for strong play despite weaker appearances.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Masters of Venice, pretty damn ugly game. Metropolis, pretty damn ugly game, but they're really excellent games. Metropolis is the original of the Roxley one that they redid, they redid it and named it Skyrise. That's it."
— Heavy Cardboard
"the one that's really on there at the moment is a game called Metropolis it's a city building negotiation style game I want it I want to find it and it's always so cheap in other countries"
— Watch It Played
"Metropolis, which has a similar aesthetic, was remade into Skyrise and people are loving this game, want to play it, it looks beautiful, and all has changed really is that the artwork is different."
— Watch It Played