Skip to main content
Loading video...

Akrotiri Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 17:23

Hey everybody, today I'm talking about Akrotiri, which is a two-player board game designed by Jay Cormier and Seng Fong Lim. This one takes around 45 minutes to play. Now, the key mechanisms of this game are tile placement, pick up and delivery, and I suppose you can call it contract fulfillment. So, I've advanced the game a little bit here just to show you how the map develops. Well, you've got this main tile here in the center, which is kind of your hub of the game. And as the game develops, you're placing more and more tiles onto the board and creating these little islands and placing these little cubes as you do so. So, you've got a big stack of tiles to play with. You're going to have some kind of communal resources here, such as these contracts, which we'll talk about shortly. You've got the money, you've got these end-game objective tiles, and you have the markets here. So, this is going to show the current value of all the different resources. So, you've got four different resources here, each relating to one of the different terrain types. So, you can see here we've got the trees, the mountains, the volcanoes, and the and the kind of sea symbol.

And as these get placed onto the board, you're going to be make making those more valuable in order to collect them and deliver them back to the center. Each player is also going to have their personal player board, which looks like this, which is mainly just a breakdown of your potential actions in the game. And you're also going to have six temples placed on all each of these spots. And this is going to be one of the end-game triggers. So, as soon as somebody's placed their sixth temple, you're going to keep playing until there's equal turns, and then the end game will be triggered, where you'll calculate points based on the gold cards that you collect at the beginning of the game and potentially throughout the game. Like this one here says, I'm going to get two points for each of my temples on an island with one of these tree symbols on. But the main way you're going to get victory points is through these contract cards, which look like this. So, how these work is that a particular island, represented by the symbol in the middle, needs to be in a position in relation to the other symbols around it. So, you can see this one needs to have a mountain to the west of it, it needs to have a tree to the north of it, and it needs to have a volcano to the east of it. So, how that works in actuality is let's say I move my boat to this island here.

Um you can see that I have a tree to the north of it. I have a uh a volcano to the east of it here. Doesn't matter if it's north or south as long as it's somewhere to the east. And you've got a uh mountain to the west of it all the way over here. So, I can see I've successfully completed this criteria. Therefore, I can pay this fee, I eat three coins, to put my leftmost temple on my player board onto that particular island. Another island can never be shared with anybody else, and it has to go in a particular quarter of this tile um in just to show where in relation, you know, precisely it is to those other symbols. And as you can see, the more you unlock these temples, the more bonuses you get. So, now um I would start with a Well, I would have started with a basic value of three actions per turn. Now I've unlocked four. So, you do kind of snowball as the game goes on and unlock more and more actions. And potentially, as you place more islands down or temples down, you can get more end game bonus cards, get more actions, more end game bonus cards, even going up to six actions before it is the end game trigger.

So, let's talk about how the game works and how the actions are resolved. So, the first thing you do every single turn is you'll place a new tile onto the board. And when you do that, you can place it kind of flush with any other um tile there. And then you're going to find the resource type. So, you've got the mountain one here. You're going to have a look on the supply and demand board, and you're going to pick up that cube and put it on the matching spot, like so. And then you can pick another cube and put it on any other island. So, let's just say I picked up this one here and put it on um let's say I put it on this island with no thought or reasoning behind this. So, that's a mandatory action. You have to do that every single time, but of course you are trying to think of your objective cards by manipulating these symbols into certain points on the map so that you can fulfill those contract cards.

Now, the other actions you can take are divided as you see fit by using as many action points as you have. So, you can see here I've got four action points and I can divide them up between these other actions. So, the first thing is moving, of course. And to move, as long as your boat is empty, as a single action you can move up to twice. So, let's just say I move my blue boat um all the way to uh let's say this port here. So, you can keep moving until you get to a port. Um and another action I can use to actually teleport from port to port. So, that'll be a single action cuz I've moved twice. One going to this port here and one going to from port to port like so. Now, if you ever had any cargo on your boat, then that movement is actually halved and you have to spend a whole action point just to move once. Additionally, if someone is sat on a certain port and you have to cross their path, then you have to spend an additional movement points. So, that is how movement works. A second action is loading your boat where you can place up to three resources onto your boat as an action.

So, let's just say I took these two red cubes and I put them onto my boat like so. Another action is excavate as we discussed earlier when playing those temples onto the particular island as long as you have that criteria um completed on that card and have the funds to do so. Uh another one is to buy maps as long as you are in the main capital here in Thera. You can go there and you can spend either one coin for one map, three coins for two maps, or seven coins for three maps. And you can take that as you see fit amongst the three different categories. So, you have three different categories of cards here, the easy ones, the medium ones, and the difficult ones. And of course, the difficult ones need a lot harder criteria to fulfill and they they're much more expensive, but they give you a hell of a lot more points if you manage to complete them. So, that's how the buying map works. And finally, you have the oracle action, which which you can basically look through the deck there to find the first tile in the stack of a particular symbol that you want. So, you do have a certain amount or certain degree of mitigation of finding a particular symbol again with the aim of completing these contract cards. Now, there are a few bonus actions you can take.

Um there's free actions here. And number one is to sell resources and another one is to unload resources. So, let's just say you had a boat that you uh you were carrying a resource you didn't want, you can literally do a free action just to drop off a cube. But another one which is a big part of the game, let's just say I was back here at the capital. As a free action, I can choose to sell a number of cubes um back to the market. So, let's say I've got two red cubes here. I'd put them back on the supply and demand board here and take the amount of cubes that I've just replenished. So, you can see here I'd get another five income for doing that. So, kind of picking up the cubes that are rarer or on the board more often um is going to be a lot more profitable than picking up ones that are higher up on this track. And that is essentially how the game plays. You're going to keep taking those actions until you've got all six temples down or the other person has and then points are going to get calculated based on the cards you completed, the end game bonus cards, and you get one point for every 10 coins you have remaining.

Okay, so let's go into some thoughts on Akrotiri. So, mechanically the game is very simple. You just place a tile onto the board um obviously bearing in mind that you want to be aiming towards these objective cards. And the pick up and deliver factor of the game is quite strong. You know, I'm in the camp of really enjoying pick up and deliver games. It seems to be somewhat of a polarizing mechanism in the board game space. You know, you seem to love it or not be so keen. But for me, I am a fan of it. And I think this one does the pick up and deliver thing very well because it's not the sole focus of the game. It really is the economy of the game um because you need money to do everything and the money is based on the pick up and deliver mechanism which all ties back to the supply and demand of the particular cube. So, if you see there's an island here just sitting there with a very valuable cube on like this mountain one here, the mountain the mountain cubes are going to be very expensive, then you're going to be wanting to get in there quite quickly to load up your boat. But, bearing in mind you're going to be spending your actions to do so, and of course actions are going to be your efficiency throughout the game. You'll be making sure you're not wasting any any um actions because essentially it is a race, and if you get caught off guard by somebody placing their sixth temple before you do, then again that can potentially cost you quite dearly. But, yeah, I do love this factor of do I want to race and get to this perfect island because, you know, these islands do get gobbled up quite quickly, and you cannot share islands and they have already have a temple on them. So, you've got to be quite careful that way. Um so, yeah, you need to make sure like can I get to the island and get my temple on it or am I going to go and gobble up these cubes, get them back to base, and cash in on

them in order to get my funds up because you need the funds in order to complete the cards in the first place, and you need the funds in order to draw more cards to give you more flexibility, so you're not such a slave to the cards you're drawing. So, there is a good meshing there of the two mechanisms there, the money and the actual objective cards, which I think works really well. And I also do like the consideration of the of the end game goal cards because these this is quite a strong part of the game. They aren't just a few throwaway points which could swing it. These are very quite pivotal to who's going to win the game if you choose to focus on them accordingly. And these are quite interesting, you know, you've got this the typical ones, you know, have a have a a temple on islands with the mountains on or the volcanoes on, but you have got some quite decent ones as well such as this one here.

This says you're going to get a point for each tile that your largest island with a temple on covers. So, you know, if you have a particularly massive island and you get a temple on it, you can get a lot of points that way. You know, if I if I got a temple on this island, it's going to cover 1 2 3 4 5 different tiles, which is really strong. So, these are all things to consider, and even ones like this, you know, you might get points based on islands where you don't have any symbols on. Or this one, you have three different symbols on, and you get quite a lot of points that way. So, yeah, these are not just a a throwaway thing that could happen at the end of the game if you just just by happenstance. If you focus on them, that can be the difference maker, which I do like. I also really enjoy the way the map actually develops because a lot of these tile placement games, they seem to kind of follow the same pattern and the same blueprint by, you know, connecting to fields or this kind of thing. But this one, you're really focusing on the routes themselves because the routes do actually create some really interesting pathways, and you can actually create these kind of isolated islands where you cannot get through unless you pass through other islands. Like for example, I don't believe I can get to this island unless I cut through this island, which is quite cool. And it can become that movement puzzle.

It can end up costing quite a few actions, but, you know, is that going to be worth it because there are some valuable resources on there. The game also has a nice momentum to it because when you're placing more and more temples down, you are unlocking more and more actions. So, you are becoming significantly more powerful towards the end of the game than you are at the beginning of the game. But that kind of balances out because the map is getting bigger. So, you might need to venture out further to get to new fresh islands that haven't been conquered yet. So, it does do a good job of, you know, keeping the game flowing at a fast pace rather than just plodding along. Cuz Now, despite the rule set being very smooth and easily digestible in terms of the actions you're taking, I do have some problems with the swinginess of luck in this game. Because passively, as the game develops, you are just simply going to be placing more and more logos on the board. And because you are drawing cards randomly from these different stacks here, sometimes the criteria will automatically be fulfilled um just as soon as you draw it. There might be that perfect island there that has all these symbols to the north, all these to the west, all to the south, and all to the east. Um and when that happens, it's a bit disheartening if you are on the reverse side of it. And even if you are on the winning side of it, it feels like you haven't really worked towards that.

You haven't earned those points. It just so happens to be there. Yeah, I suppose you can consider that um you know, that you have to pay to get those cards completed in the first place, which probably means you have to, you know, do some pick up and delivery. But, it does work out like that sometimes. You know, you're just going to get a very lucky card draw and um your opponent might not. So, and when it's such a a tight game in terms of getting your things down, that can swing the game massively. I also didn't find the decision-making in this game particularly taxing or meaningful. For example, whenever a particular style comes out and the resource on that tile is very low on the market here, you're probably going to just go and grab it because money is the key to everything in this game, and it's a bit of a no-brainer decision. So, I didn't find that terribly interesting. Um additionally, getting these cards fulfilled isn't that interesting either because if you're going to draw some water tiles and you've got this card, you're probably going to put it as high up as possible. This the mountains as, you know, eastwards as possible and the trees as southwards as possible. And it will just work out by default that you'll eventually get those fulfilled because all the tiles are laid out in such a manner that islands just form by default. And so, the game kind of plays itself at times, and there isn't really that logistics puzzle, which I tend to like with um kind of uh pick up and deliver style games.

And despite some of my criticisms there, this game does play in a very succinct amount of time. It does only take around 45 minutes to play, which feels right for the game. It doesn't outstay its welcome, and it does move along at quite a rapid pace. The player turns are quite quick. They're simply just buzzing around the map or uh picking up cubes and things. You know, they're not going to be long agonizing decisions. There is some passive player interaction here, and particularly based off the market. You know, if you know that your opponent's going to collect some of these cubes, then you might want to go there quicker to get them more more money because of course, the more this board fills up, the cheaper those resources are going to get when you do sell them. Um additionally, there is some kind of scarceness in a attention to grab the islands to get your cards fulfilled because even though an island might fulfill all your objectives, it doesn't mean that island won't fulfill your opponent's objectives as well. So, you know, that does happen in each game. You know, you really want an island and someone goes and grabs it from you, meaning that your plans are, you know, been thrown away and you have to start again and think of a new island to go to and maybe even place more tiles to get those icons in the right place.

So, there is that passive tension there, but other than that, it's not terribly interactive. Aesthetically and from a production standpoint, I think this game does a fantastic job. Um I love the way the board develops. The The islands look fantastic and and I just love the way that the game looks as it plays. Just really come alive. I love the way the roots develop. It's really good. Um additionally, the actual player pieces themselves, like the boats and the I and the little cubes and things are are wonderful. I love the way that these are just simplified. They're nice and simplistic and the cubes fit in these boats perfectly. There are a lot of games that use this kind of mechanism or this use of components where you put cubes in the boats physically and they're always really fiddly. They always try to overdo it. This one notes takes a nice simple approach and actually does what it sets out to do. Uh the temples and things are really nice.

These are like a ceramic kind of material. Uh the little resource board is just a thin cardboard sheet, but it's fine for the job and these are just all your standard Euro cubes. The money's a little bit smaller and fiddly, but you don't you know, you don't need tons of it and you're always kind of giving and taking that money, so it's no big deal there. And the cardstock quality is absolutely fine. Um iconography's good. I'd say there's a little bit of ambiguity among amongst some of the objective cards and what they do and how they work, but there is a really good kind of a legend on the back of the rules book. So, yeah, from a production standpoint, I've got no issues at all and I think it's a in fact, it's very well done um for such a small little box. Okay, so final thoughts on Akrotiri. Um straight up, I I game is good. It does what it's supposed to do. Um, it's got a good blend of mechanisms here. You know, the pick-up and deliver works well, and particularly when it's synergized with the supply and demand of the different resources, and money being a key and pivotal part of the game. I think the contracts, or the way the contracts work, is a little bit vague, and it just kind of makes itself complete, you know, just passively, um, which makes the decisions feel a little bit lackluster and a little bit a little bit limp.

Um, I would say that I think a lot of this is down to me having played so many games and having quite firm favorites of this genre. You know, I mentioned Oracle of Delphi before. Um, I always think whenever I play a pick-up and deliver game, I think, well, I'd rather be playing Oracle of Delphi. And that this is another example of that. I think that game just is a bit more vibrant, it's a bit more alive. But, I have to kind of give the caveat that this game does take half the amount of time of a game like that. So, that needs to be given some kind of credibility. But, I like the way everything works, and but for some strange reason, um, I don't get an enormous amount of fun from playing it, which is quite strange to say because, again, on paper, this has all the ingredients to a game I'd like, you know, supply and demand, I love, pick-up and deliver, I love, contract fulfillment, I generally enjoy. Uh, the aesthetic and production of the game is fantastic. Um, but, yeah, it's just missing that extra layer of that logistics puzzle, and it's missing that kind of magic ingredient of what creates fun, for me at least. But, I think it's a really good effort. It's a bit of a near miss for me. It's just missing that extra element. But, again, if I played this from years ago, I might be talking a very uh, speaking a very different language than I am now because, um, you know, with more experience of playing games, then more and more games just seem to feel a bit more mediocre.

Whereas, um, this one, I think is above average. I certainly do think it's above average. Quite a bit above average, to be honest. Um, but, because I am comparing it to some favorites which do a lot of the same things, then just by default, it becomes something that isn't quite collection worthy. And that is my kind of thoughts on Aquatimer.

Progress saved