Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 10:39

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I go over my first impressions of worms span a 2024 release designed by Connie vogelman developed by Elizabeth Hargrave of course art by Clementine cardo published by ston Meer games and this game is for one to five players play in about 90 minutes its weight complexity is a 2.7 out of 5 and and right now it is overall ranked 2513 with an average rating of 7.9 out of 10 on Board Game Geek so what makes this game good and unique first the cards there are 183 Dragon cards to play from boasting a wide variety just like its predecessor adding to endless variability and replayability in addition you have 75 cave cards that also have individual abilities when you play them so essentially you're working with over 200 cards to mix and match effects with for engine building onetime effects and endgame objectives are thrown in as well second is theme this game not only features dragons as the theme of the game but goes into a lot of work to create a Mythos as it were for each of these dragons while in wingspan the bird flavor text and even their abilities on their uh cards are drawn from real life facts about those birds it was as if the dragons and worm span had abilities assigned to them and created and then the lore of each of

these dragons was described and created after the fact it's quite the feat to World build these dragons as it were and include that in a kind of a beastiary separately found within the game box third is familiarity of course since this game is based on wingspan many people both veteran hobby board gamers and the more Casual Gamer will be able to grasp the mechanisms in game Flow if they are familiar with how wingspan plays it's easier to teach the game and the game time may be quickened because of previous experiences with wingspan which may lead to a more enjoyable first play and subsequent plays for game comparisons I've personally compared wingspan to many other games in the past on the channel to include popular games like Arc NOA terraforming Mars Earth Agricola even and Etc so let's set those aside and just talk about these similarities and differences between wingspan and worm span first is the action selection instead of as in wingspan where you start with eight action cubes and round by round dwindle down to five in worm span you start with each in each round with six coins to spend on actions you can buy card abilities gain or lose coins but otherwise it stays pretty consistent throughout the game second is the engine building aspect disregarding the directionality of how the engines are set off in each respective game wingspan offers the chance to fire off the abilities of each Bird card in a row when you take the action pertaining to

that Row in worm span you take a completely separate action to fire off that engine in a row and the cost to utilize that row increases each time you do so in each round spending precious eggs to do so third is the dragon Guild worm span offers a separate board not seen in the base game of wingspan at least where you advance on a circular track called the dragon Guild obtaining rewards as you go along and occasionally you are able to place cubes in a central board to obtain immediate benefits and resources as well as participating in endgame scoring think of this as a replacement to the objective cards from wingspan there are four different guilds that you can play with adding variety to the game fourth is the resources there is no dice tower and Randomness with the dice with the resources in worm span you basically get resources from cards advancing on the top row for player board and occasionally from the dragon Guild and then finally from what little I've seen so far there are some dragon card abilities that seem unique compared to wingspan for example abilities that pertain to orthogonal adjacency of Dragon cards and obviously interactions with the cave cards which are unique to this game otherwise the overall gist of the cards and of round scoring and even the otoma solo play are very similar if not the same as compared to wingspan or peer review there has been a lot of hype and comments made about this game both on Board Game Geek and otherwise so let's see what people have said particularly on board game geek in

the comment section now that the game has had some time to be released and played by the general public for praise folks who highly rate the game first of all like the theme they like the artwork and the very smooth gamep play the additional complexity of the cave cards and the dragon Guild the solo play for some has been easier and better than the one found in wingspan uh they feel like the decision space is improved which I interpret as having the ability to play cards from your hand faster and not having that slow burn and that ramp up as you do in wingspan for people who do not give it such a high rating they have some concerns and criticisms and they are as follows for some they mentioned that they did not like the reskinning of wingspan especially with a theme that is not grounded in real life the theme of worm span is definitely polarizing in the community for with some enjoying it and some who don't some people feel that the strategy is somewhat linear in worm span whereas in wingspan especially in the base game getting eggs was a pretty good strategy and seem to be pretty dominant until you got into some of the expansions while here in worm span feeling out row as quickly as possible to some feels like the dominant strategy here and therefore that the diversity in decision spaces and strategy is lacking some people don't like how long it takes to get things going in your rows as well having to play cave cards on to your board before playing Your Dragon cards

it just seemed a little like an extra effort that is clunky compared to just plain Birds onto your Tableau in wingspan finally while the resource Randomness is quote unquote fixed in worm span some people did not feel like it was Dynamic enough or robust enough to feel fun or thematic as it was in the wingspan in conclusion and my final thoughts for my Impressions on worm span first of all I'm a big fan of wingspan and so it was intriguing for me to play this new reimplementation and I do admit I was a little skeptical coming into it I do enjoy the differences this game offers with the straightforward resource gathering without the randomness of the dice the neat two card interactions with the caves and Dragons was really neat there were times when I needed some eggs to continue exploring or to play dragons and having those cave cards to excavate pulled me through some of those tied spaces so I liked the variety that they offer for gameplay and tactical strategy I'm less of a fan of the Dragon Guild track because it is essentially a track and I would rather have the objective cards to play around in my hand rather than a simple track to advance on although I do like the race to obtain the benefits and the scoring from the track as if you do Advance faster than others you may be able to snatch some of those opportunities in front of others so I think this is a great game because it builds off of a formula that is tried and true and adds some more complexity to make it feel different enough it's

kind of like how I feel about Agricola and caverna the differences between those two base games or even other Rosenberg games that changed the game dramatically through expansions like the Norwegians did For A Feast for Odin and farmers of the Moore did for agrica on that similar note wingspan has many expansions for it already with more to come with the release of oania for example the game boards were fixed to alleviate the egg dominant strategy and after playing it recently with the Oceania and other expansions of course I noticed that it was a lot easier to mitigate the randomness of the dice not only with the wild nectar resource but with the card effects to cycle through the food the question that I'm left with is well I like wingspan a lot so is there room on my shelf for worms span unfortunately the answer for me is no especially since I own the expansions to wingspan all of them in fact and with that all culminating together I feel like it offers the same complexity as worms span does albeit with some differences here and there I would miss the cave and dragon card combos the most but overall I think I just get as much if not more enjoyment from wingspan strategically on one part when you add in all the complexities that the expansions include but because I think I also enjoy the more of a Slow Burn at the beginning of wingspan Having Eight actions to build up your engine slowly and having it becoming increasingly

tighter as you finish the game with less actions and then firing off those big engine combos at the end of course worms span felt the same throughout despite the increasing engine building and you do have those big combo driven engine fire offs in worms span as well and so there are some similarities there but I am more drawn to the theme of birds which I think does help me feel grounded in wingspan it also helps me return to wingspan more often I feel like I have more of a personal connection to it rather than the mythical dragons that are depicted in worm span anytime I'm walking through the park with my children or when I look outside the my window I see birds flying around and doing what they do and when I think of them and see them I kind of feel a tug to pull out wingspan again and just enjoy the coziness of the theme I know for some the theme of wingspan does not make sense when he translated the game play but the artwork and the overall aesthetic of the game really appeals to me so that coupled with the Strategic depth that the expansions have added to the game fixing I think a few things here and there make wingspan my preferred game over worms span however this game worm span is a solid game and I feel like many people are going to enjoy it and will enjoy it for years to come so those are my first impressions on worms span thank you for Consulting with us today and hope you schedule an appointment with us real soon take care

Progress saved