Railroad Tiles Board Game Review
Transcript
Design the best network of railways and highways in railroad tiles. Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Dope.
And I'm Kevin Dp. Today we're looking at Railroad Tiles. It's a tile drafting and laying game that takes about 30 minutes to play and it's for one to four players. With the collector's edition or an expansion, it can go up to five players.
It's a standalone sequel to Railroad Inc. It's by the same designers and publisher, Horrible Guild. The publisher sent us this copy to review.
Now, in this video, we're going to give a quick overview of the game and then discuss our opinions. In railroad tiles, each player is creating their own network of roads and railways from the tiles they select.
The game is played over eight rounds. In each round, players will take turns selecting one column of tiles. Turn order for the next round will be based on the column selected from left to right.
When placing tiles in your network, the sides have to match. Railroad to railroad, highway to highway, and empty to empty. After everyone has selected their tiles and placed them in their network, players can add tokens based on the symbols in the active area. For each symbol, you can add one matching token, a car, train, or traveler, to an open pin point in your grid of tiles.
You score points for the placed tokens and reset the board for the next round. You leave the leftover column of tiles and add a star to it. You can spend stars to place a different type of token than the ones showing in the active area.
After eight rounds, you score endame points. Each group of three or more blue town tiles is worth five points. Your largest rectangle of tiles is worth one point per tile, and you lose points for each open railroad or highway.
If you play with the optional objective tiles, you'll score each of those as well. Fulfilled objectives are worth five points each.
So, no surprise, the player with the most points wins.
Now, that was a quick overview. We're going to separate the rest of the video into our five C's. Our thoughts about the components, our critiques, our commendations, comparisons of the expansions, and finally, our conclusions. Let's start with the components. So, there's wooden components for the player tokens, the stars, and sort of those three things, the trains, the cars, and the people.
Most of the other components are going to be cardboard, the tiles, the point tokens, the little clock tokens that do your uh timing of the rounds, and also tell you which of those,
they're not really meeples tokens to wooden tokens to put out. And then if you have the collector's edition, it has all the expansions in there and you have different bags for well you put stuff in the different bags. It doesn't come pre-sorted,
right?
But you have the different bags which is nice. They're different colors which you can put the different expansions stuff in those. So, the main difference between the retail version and the collector's version, besides the expansions, obviously, is that the collector's version does have some screen printing on the trains, the cars, and the travelers. So, they're a little uh
upgraded.
Upgraded, I guess, would be the term.
All right, let's move to our critiques. My first critique is the point tokens, the denominations they're in. You have 1, three, 10, and 20. Y.
Now, during the game, you're usually scoring 1, three, maybe five here and there. But at endame scoring, a lot of the points are in five, like increments. Five points for this.
So, not having a five was kind of odd. Now, I guess people may just do endgame scoring like writing it down, but if you did want to use the scoring, the point tokens because they're in there, I felt like there probably wasn't enough of the higher the 20s. It would be nice to have some 50s and fives would have been really good.
Some fives and 50s and you take care of it all.
Some fives and 50s. Although I guess especially if you're playing with a lot of people, maybe you'll just write down the endgame scoring instead of using the token.
It's nice to have a token especially when you're doing the scoring like like at the end of the game you're you know instead of having to like write everything down like okay give me five for that give me five for that. So
um one of my critiques it has to do with um the game play sort of. So the base game you are one of the big scoring um aspects is creating sort of a square or or a um
rectangle
a yeah rectangle a uh you're counting up a complete rectangle a row and column and then you're basically getting points for all the tiles that are in that completed rectangle. You can have tiles outside of that but you're only scoring for that. And then you're also scoring in the base game for the city tiles. I believe I checked all the expansions. I'm pretty sure all of them include those two things. And I just wish that there was maybe one or two expansions that just basically did away with that. And I think it could just enhance the game play just a little bit more instead of being restricted to that sort of
gridlike pattern and you do something I don't know just different for the expansion. So
okay.
Yeah. So,
I'm okay with maybe the cities because they're cities, but like I would just like I could just think of an expansion that has I mean there's so many. There's like eight or nine different expansions. Why not do one that it's not a rectangle?
Okay. Yeah. I would say kind of jumping off of that a little bit. I find the base game, especially if you're not using the objective tiles, to be a little too simplistic for me. not enough going on. So, I would probably always choose to play with the objective tiles, even if all I have is the base retail.
Um, because I want that slightly extra layer of puzzlininess and kind of thinking through.
They're not too bad. The ejected tile is not they come out during the game based on the
the little tiles that that come out. So, it's it seems like the objective tiles are an easy way to an easy thing to add in,
right? Yeah. So, if you do play it without the objective tiles because they kind of suggest that the first time and you think it's way too simplistic, try those in and see if it gets it to the right level.
All right. Well, let's move to our commendations. So, my first combination actually is a counterbalance to your critique.
Okay. I kind of like that there is this game that's maybe a little simple in what you're getting, but it's easy to understand. It's easy to pick up and easy to play. So, I think that's where my combination is. Even though it may be a little simple and the game play, I kind of like it. Um, it's not, you know, you're going not going into this heavy game, you're like, "Oh, I can pick that up and play it pretty quickly." I know it says like 45 minutes in the box, but you know, two, three players, you can play it even faster than that. And one of the things I do like about this tile laying game is the drafting component of the game. I think that's fun. It's like, oh, okay, there's, you know, three, four different rows that or columns that you're choosing from. It's like, oh, I just hope doesn't choose that one.
They're the one tile I need. It's right there.
Right. The one tile to help complete your things. And I there's a little bit of tension in there. So, it does have that interaction. Even though you are building your own city, there is that interaction with the drafting, which I appreciate.
Okay. Um, I like how the expansions, if you play with them, are integrated into the game. Now, you can only play with one expansion at a time, but it gives you,
but if you're will, you probably can put more in.
If you're will and you're breaking the rules, it would be chaos. Um,
we'll we'll get to our comparisons of expansions. There is one that breaks the rule of not of playing. That's great. only one at a time. But basically, there is the expansion tiles stay in their own bag and the regular tiles have their own bag. So, you're not mixing them, which I think is good. And then there's a pattern that you put out a certain number of core game tiles and a certain number of the expansion tiles. So, you know that each column is going to have at least one expansion tile in it. So, I think that's a good way to mix those things to make sure it's not like if they were all in the same bag, you could get there are no expansion tiles or all of them are expansion tiles on the board this round. So, um the way the scoring works for the different expansions that helps make the game play smoother.
Cool. Um one more uh combination I like the screen printed for the collector's edition. you have a lot of the wooden sort of meeple uh characters or things are screen printed. It just adds a little bit of upgrade to the to the to what you're playing with. Say you know we were you know the little people the trains or you know all the things just like it looks cool
on your in your city. So,
okay. And I think they're cool even even in the regular edition that they are shaped.
They're shaped wouldn't, but the screen printed I just think um bumps it up a little bit.
And and I do believe all of the expansions theirs will be screen printed.
Um so if you get a one or two expansions, those uh
if you don't have the collectors and you just have the base retail and you get a couple expansions, yeah, I think it's going to have the retail or the um screen printed on them. Uh my last commendation kind of is in line I think with what you were saying at the beginning of this section that the game is a nice kind of weight and time length for when you don't have a lot of time and want to fit in a quickish game. You know, we're talking 30 maybe 45 minutes. Um and if you want something more on that lighter weight. So, it's not going to burn your brain. It doesn't have a huge amount of pieces and setup and rules overhead. So, when you want something a little bit more casual and quick, it's good to fit into that slot.
Or if you want to play it a couple times in a row and maybe put in some different expansions or switch out objective tiles, um, because it's so quick, I think you could do that.
Easily done. Well, let's move to our comparisons. So, the first comparison, the collector's edition has it all. You can buy this and you get all the expansions, but if you want to start, if you're like, do I want it all? Right.
You can be like, I just want to buy the retail version and then you can purchase a few of the expansions, the ones that you like. So, what are some of the expansions that are out there? Well, first off, they all of the expansions add some more of the objective tiles that are specific to things in that expansion. So, you'll be getting some more objectives that you can use when you play with that expansion. I would say they all add at least some complexity
to the game with more pieces and rules. The forest one I would say is probably the simplest, easiest to add in. It's basically just adding towers, which is another scoring thing. So, if you don't really want to jump in complexity, the forest might be the one to go with.
If you love cute little animal meeples, then you might want to check out countryside. So, the tiles are going to have barns and pasture area that you're creating, and you're basically trying to get the same type of animal into the same pasture. And it's a little more difficult than it sounds to try to get everything to line up, but you end up with these little farm areas with animal meeples in them.
Cool. Some of them are actually kind of some of the expansions are sort of similar but just with different themes. For example, like the energy, the um canals, the deserts, the lakes, they all um just I there's a lot of things that go in each of them, but some of the similarities are they all add different routes
um that you are creating in the game. So, it might seem a little similar, although each of those brings a little bit of nuance to what you're doing in the game with the energy and the
Yeah. Of those four, I think the desert is probably the most complex because not only is it adding desert trails and camels, but I believe the tiles have different like landmarks on them like py pyramids and things like that and there's a scoring aspect for getting those landmarks connected to other things as well. So, a few more layers in the desert
and the world one has a lot of objectives. Right.
Right. So, the world expansion is the outlier, the one that can be added into other expansions because it is adding 10 new objectives.
So, and you can use them with the base game or a combination
all 10 though,
right? Each game, if you're using objectives, you use three and every player has the same objective,
which is kind of cool. So, it's adding more variety to your objectives, and you can add them in whether or not you're playing with expansions. And then the second thing the world one adds are specific uh meeples and buses and trains, different things where each type has a special power or scoring uh tweak to it. So, for the game, you could play with the the robber, the bus, and the bullet train or or something like that.
And when you put them into your tile grid, they'll do something special. So, it adds
uh a symmetry to the tokens that you're putting out.
Cool. And there's a bunch of different ones, but each game you would choose one for each type, and every player would have that same special one that they can put out.
So, you could choose an expansion based on its theme, or you could choose an expansion based on like how different it plays. And I think the monument expansion is probably the one expansion that is the most different. Is that a word?
I'd agree with that.
Most different. So, what that is adding is some action points to your turn and your base. You're sort of getting three action points to use. You're getting these monuments uh that are on the tiles. Well, they're printed on the tiles that if you have your if you can move your architect to those tiles archist,
sorry, thank you. An architect archaeologist uh to those tiles that have the different shaped monuments, you can actually build that monument. Architect sort of makes better sense.
No, they're discovering the monument. They're archaeologists who are unearthing the monument.
I gota
So anyway, um so you're using action points to move your archaeologist um to those different spots. Now in the game you have the highways and you have the train routes. Um highways take your archaeologist a long time. They have to go from tile to tile along that highway. But the train routes are kind of cool because how they move is from train station to train station. Now, if you can build a train station and then you have a train route that's a little bit longer to another train station, your archaeologist can move with one action point from one station to another station pretty quickly. Last time we played, I didn't build my train stations far enough apart, so my my archaeologist was not moving as fast as Melissa's. Right.
Yeah. So, that was definitely, as Kevin was saying, a different feel to the game because it was adding that new layer of the action points and actually like trying to move around your grid. So, I was thinking a little bit more about where am I placing the tiles with the monument symbols on them. Can I get to them? Kevin accidentally built an inaccessible one.
Couldn't get my archaeologist to the other side. I found out pretty quickly you couldn't do that. So I saved saved it a little bit. So
right because you have to travel along highways and
you can't jump roads.
So yeah, that's the a very brief kind of look at a lot of the expansions. There's more information online about them and the different nuances that they each bring.
Well, let's move on to our conclusions. So we really didn't talk about the game that these are based off of. Road Tiles is based off of Road ink. We mentioned that at the beginning of the video. Railroad Inc. is a RollandRight game. You definitely have that feel of the routes in the Tiles game. The one nice thing about the Rolland Right. Railroad Inc. is that it's a smaller pack game, so you can travel with it. You, you know, it's it's a little bit easier to go, you know, around, harder to bring to game nights, the collector's edition. But I personally like the gameplay of Railroad Tiles maybe a little bit more. I like the tile drafting. I like that you can sort of build your city out. Um yeah, I I think I like the tiles version a little bit better and I think it plays well all the different player counts.
Yeah, I'm not very good at drawing. So, um tiles are probably better for me than the really messy was that a road or was that a road?
Railroad.
Um so, in general, I usually enjoy tile laying games because I I just like that mechanic. I also like games that have a good amount of variability where you can try different strategies or the the puzzle is slightly different each time. And I think Railroad Tiles does that with the objective tiles that you can add in because it's going to be a different assortment each time. And then especially with the expansions,
I do think if I only owned the base game,
I would probably get a little like bored or tired of it after a while because
even though you do have the objective tiles, I think I would want a little bit more. So, I am very glad that we have the collector's edition or at least that we have some of the expansions to put those in and kind of have a different experience each time. It's the same like core gameplay, but like little sprinkles and and toppings that kind of spice it up a little bit. So, I enjoy that the strategies are a little different based on the combination of objective tiles and which expansion that you're playing with.
I want to know what spicy sprinkles taste like. Maybe sweeten this.
You know, it was a bit of a mixed metaphor. Anyway, back to conclusions. Um, I would say that I would be happy to play Railroad Tiles and suggest it when our group is wanting a short game, something that is relatively light and quick. I I think I would definitely suggest road tiles. I enjoy it.
Yeah, me too. Well, thank you so much for watching today's video. Please like, subscribe, and check out more videos coming from Tantrum House soon. Design the best network of railways and highways in railroad tiles. And again,
design the best network. I'm going to have trouble with railways every time.