Skip to main content
Loading video...

South Tigris Moonsaga - Expansion Review - Beyond The Base Game

Transcript 20:47

Hi everyone, I'm Blue Hector and this is the Broken Mele, a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games, but usually more the latter part, let's be honest. We're going to wrap up now this whole South Tigris trilogy that I've been doing. Well, I suppose it's not so much a trilogy, it's now a quadrilogy of videos. I have done a review of every single expansion that has come out for the South Tigers trilogy. And these weren't even review copies. I bought these with my own cash. I funded the Kickstarter because I love these South Tigers games and I wanted expansions for them. And so we have already had me look at the Scholars, the Wayfarers, and the Inventors expansions. And you know, all of them have been solid. They've all had seals from me. You know, we've had a a seal of endorsement for Tides of Trade for Wayfarers, which I thought was good, but not essential and probably not like the most groundbreaking of expansions, but then we've had seals of excellence for Body of Books, which is probably, I would say, the best expansion of the free in terms of its impact, how much it improves the game before it, that kind of thing. It it it it, like I say, had the most impact. And Inventor South Tiger is also a seal of excellence because it's a very simple expansion to include. It's pretty much an auto include and it does allow you to do more. It gives more variety with the player powers. There's not much in the buck. So, you could argue maybe it's not the best in terms of value, but it's still a really solid pick. Now, we've got one that's a little bit different.

The Moon Saga. This is one that, you know, they've done various types of sagas for the other trilogies of these games. They did one for North, I believe, and they certainly did one for West Kingdom. I never went anywhere near them though because they require you to play all three games in succession, whether it's solo or multiplayer. The thing is with all of the other trilogies, there's always been one game I didn't really feel like playing. I didn't want to play Explorers after I tried that. And I don't like Paladins either. So, you know, this kind of I don't want to play something that says, "Right, you can play all of these games in succession. You will like this one, you will hate this one, and you will like this one." It's like, "Hey, wait a minute. What? Okay, hate is a strong word. I dislike, you know, they don't they don't gel for me as well. But, you know, if you're going to play all three of them in succession, you kind of need to enjoy all three of them, right? Well, this one was a shoe in to actually try this out because I enjoy all three of these games. So, naturally, something that was going to get me to do it was worth it. Now, there are two ways to play this, solo and multiplayer. I have not played multiplayer because that requires me to find a group of people who know these games inside out and want to play it in succession three times in a row. At a convention, maybe Gridcon this year that will be possible, but generally at a game club, no, that's not going to happen. So, I have not played this multiplayer, but effectively all you do in multiplayer is you have essentially gold cards that you collect which in between games and the idea is is that as you go through each game, you'll be able to satisfy these gold cards. You and by collecting them, you get some like little bonus that applies to you. But in subsequent games, other

players will start with more silver to begin the game with based on how many of these abilities you've got. And then by the end of the free games, it's a case of right, well, who has the most of these gold cards and they're the winner. So, it's interesting. It sounds cool, but I don't know. I think I'd just rather just play the games really. But that's the multiplayer, and I have not tried it. So, we're not going to talk about that. We are instead going to talk about the solo mode. So, this solo mode is essentially one where you get to play all six, sorry, all three games, but you play a total of six times. You play each one twice. So, you go through two games of Wayfar, two games of scholars, two games of Inventors. But there's a bit of a twist. Firstly, the first time you play each of the games, you play in his base game only. So, you don't play the expanded version. The second game, you play the expanded version. The other part is that you essentially have this story book full of narratives, which to be fair, they do go into a fair amount of um length in terms of these narratives. These are not just one paragraph long. But the idea is is that you'll start off at the beginning and then you'll play the first game and you'll usually be given like a 50/50 choice, maybe a choice out of three to say, what do you fancy doing at this point in the story and depending on which one you pick will determine a slight setup twist to the next game and then so forth. You know, you'll play that game with the setup twist and depending on your result or choices from that, you will read a different intro for the next game and then that will have a setup twist. And that's basically all it is. And once you get to the end of six games, you essentially end up with a score pad full of the scores that you had, the scores the AI had, whether

you satisfied some specific goals for each scenario, like you need to have 12 retired translators and scholars, that kind of thing. And you know, and your outro and intro numbers. And the idea is once you get to the end of the six games, you total up all the score you had. You total up all the score the AI had. You deduct a penalty for how many of the goals you did not achieve. And then that score is what you rank on the scale to say how well you did. So in terms of and the other thing that this box has we'll go into later, are some promo tiles, but for now I'm just going to talk about that solo moon saga tile. After playing them, you know, it's fun to play these games over again. You know, I enjoy all three of them and I enjoy the solo modes in all of them. So that in itself is fun, but in terms of adding this little moon saga thing to the mix, I'm not so sure. I don't think it's worth it. it. I mean, for starters, yes, you get a reasonable amount of narrative in here, but it's not like it's a compelling story or anything.

It's just it's like telling some it's like the Disney Plus shows, like the Tales of the Jedi, the Tales of the Empire. It's like this is basically tales of the Middle East or something where basically you've got some short five minute story about your life as an inventor or something and you know, depending on your choice, you do you want to study in biology or mathematics? Well, whatever. It doesn't really matter. It's just which tiny little setup tweak do I get for the next game? And these setup tweaks aren't even that interesting. They basically say, right, you need to play on this difficulty, this board. You might have a specific setup card that it tells you to use and maybe one little tweak that it says like you start with a certain card already or you start with this device already in play. You know, like they're really small tweaks like that. But otherwise, it's just the same as playing a normal solo game. And on top of that, yes, I'm playing these games two games each, but if you really enjoy the expansions and you want to include those in the game at all times, why would you want to play a lesser version of the game first before you play the better version afterwards?

Now, as a teaching tool, it's not bad because for someone like me who had to get back into the solo mode and figure out how it works, it does at least enable you to kind of go, "All right, I say this is how the solo mode works with the normal game right now. Let's play the expanded version now that I'm more familiar with the solo mode." But in all three cases, the solo mode doesn't get a huge amount of tweaks for the expanded elements. So, it's not like you really need a whole game to learn it just so that you can do the expansion element. You could just do it from scratch to begin with and it would work just fine. So, is there anything that this really offers? Not particularly. It's just a a barebone story part, some slight setup tweaks which you could pretty much invent yourself. It's not even that, you know, not even that cool. And that's it. That's all it is. For €25 or whatever it was selling for on a Kickstarter, if I was just getting it for the solo play and not even including the multiplayer aspect, that would just seem like a waste of money. And even then, the multiplayer aspect doesn't exactly sound amazing. I mean, you get a couple of little gold cards to play over and that's it. That's basically the only change to playing these all the way through. And again, it's easier to play this solo by yourself than to find a group of people that want to play all three games in succession. So, it's already going to be a niche title as it is. So, you know, on that basis, I just don't think it's worth it. Not to mention the scoring at the end is downright diabolically difficult because I told you what it was. It was your score less the opponents, less aer penalty. And there's your score, right?

So, I played through and I got two points at the end of this. Two points. Two points at the end of this moonside. All right. Do you want to know where I rank by getting two points? Student. because 0 to 24 is a student and then 25 to 50, 50 to 75, 75 to 99, 100 plus, right? 100 plus victory points. And that was because I didn't do the goals in three out of six games. I didn't realize they were so critical to your score that you needed to do them. And trust me, if you fail more than like three or more of these things, the penalty you get is ridiculous. I lost 24 points because of not doing three of the goals. And the goals aren't always easily achievable. I mean, it's basically saying, do these goals or you're going to suck at the campaign, but the goals require you to play in a very pigeonholed way. And sometimes the game won't play out in a way that enables you to do that very well, you know? So, it's all right say, oh, I need to get a bunch of these cards. But if the if the game's saying, well, you know what, strategy-wise and board statewise, you ought to go for this instead. Well, how do I argue with it? That's just a bit annoying. But on top of that, you're supposed to in theory to get as high as 100 points here or even 50 means that let's assume you do every single goal and that's not a problem. Okay, let's say you complete all of them and no penalty at all. You still have to beat the AI by about 50 plus points. For master difficulty, 100 plus. This game, sorry, this saga is wanting you to beat the AI by about 50

to 100 points overall. Have you played the solo modes in these games? They are a little on the cheaty swingy side. Their scores can fluctuate quite wildly. This is not a game where you can easily beat the AI. The AI is not like, you know, unless you play on the easiest difficulty, the AI is not a cakewalk. You know, it will put up a challenge. And given that the moon circle wants you to play on the second hardest or hardest difficulty at times kind of makes the like whole scoring system at the end frankly impossible because you want me to get master level to beat the AI as well as completing all six goals. You want me to beat the AI by more than 100 points. Good luck with that. I mean I won every single game here, right? So the the opponent did not beat me in a single game, right? So 6353 10 points.

4948 barely scraped it. 64 62 84 76 61 65 71 62. So you know, so I won. Oh, no. Sorry. I got beaten in one game. All right, so I lost one game and won the others.

Oh, wait. You're serious? Let me laugh even harder.

But that scoring is ridiculous, isn't it? I mean, I got two points in this whole campaign, right? I didn't achieve three of the goals. I lost only one game. I lost one out of the six games and I only lost by four points. So, it was a close loss, right? So, I won all the other games. A couple of them were tight wins. Some of them were like 10 point wins, that sort of thing. But because I only beat the AI by about 30 something points and then got the 24 point penalty, you know, I or whatever it was, I lose like a I lose the campaign with a very low score. How does that work? I mean, how do you think you're going to beat the AI by over 100 points? Good freaking luck with that. Especially when you're playing stuff like Scholars on the second hardest, possibly even the hardest level difficulty. It wants you to beat it by that much. It's just not possible. So, honestly, get rid of the scoring at the end and just enjoy the fact that you've played six games of some good of some good fun games. But then at that point, when you've only got a book full of little tweaks and stories that mean nothing, that just There there no point.

There is literally no point to the solo play of this Moon Saga expansion. I would have had more fun and probably got it done in less time if I'd simply just played one game of each with the expansion included and not bothered with the whole base set version of it.

Well, that was pointless.

There is no use to it whatsoever. So, you know, in that respect, waste of time, frankly. So, with that being said, is there actually any redeeming features to this box? Yes, there is. Although, it's still not exactly worth the 25 euro. Each game gets a selection of promos while you play it. So, I'm not going to get the promos out. I've just got the sheets here cuz they're all kind of integrated into these games now. But essentially, each game gets a selection of promos like they normally do on Kickstarter and are all contained within the Moon Saga box. Some promos are definitely better than others, though. So, for starters, we got the wayfarers ones. The Wayfarers includes eight new journal tiles. So, basically, you've got a little rule sheet here, and those journal tiles that you put on the journal track that are little bonuses that everybody can get. Well, now you got eight more. So, you've got stuff like gain a worker upgrade tile, gain a land upgrade tile for free, a water upgrade tile for free, gain a space upgrade tile, put influence in various gills, capture a worker from another player, move up to two influence, you know, and they're pretty straightforward like rule sets. I mean, you can tell what it is by the picture. So, you don't even need the rule sheet, but it now adds more variety cuz normally you used every single one of those tiles in the base game. Now, you've got twice the amount. So, now it's going to chop and change how that journal track gives you bonuses. This is a great little promo. I mean, I I like promos when they just add to the variety. What I don't like is when a promo basically makes the game unbalanced, and promo cards usually have a problem of being designed with to be too powerful, and so I don't want to include them. But these, this just adds

variety. So, the Wayf Farer promos, great. Like them. Not as much as I like the Scholars one, though. Whoa. Yes, the Scholars ones are a must include. These basically give you 12 more map tiles. Six of which are identical to the ones that are already on that uh travel track and six new ones. But the idea is, you know, those little bonuses on the travel track that people are usually hesitant to grab because they think it's not worth the action to do it. Well, now you can chop and change what those bonuses are. You basically cover them with the map tiles, and now the bonuses are not only in different locations, but they're different stuff. So, for example, we take this one here. So, now you can have dispatch a translator, increase a primary research track, gain a golden silver, gain a page card, you know, for the expansion, gain a black dye to your hand, and destroy a white dye, gain a worker of any color plus an XP, you know. So, you've got the original effects, which are still useful. It's just people seem to underestimate how useful it can be to just basically go, "Oh, well, white die free, move to there, get exactly what I need to do a translate in a minute." But now with these additions, the travel action just got a lot more interesting. And with these included, certainly I was a lot more interested to go around the travel track and just get the bonuses rather than even delivering a scroll. This is such a simple inclusion. It's clearly fixing one thing that I did have a problem with in the base game where I thought that aspect of the travel action was a little bit lackluster. This fixes it hands down. This as a promo, if you can get hold of it, is a must include.

And then finally, you've got the inventor's one, which is a little bit more lackluster by comparison. It's more variety, but it's not enough variety. You basically get three more workshop tiles. Only three. I would like a few more, which basically require two dice of different colors to use. You get two more of those tent tiles, the ones that when you finish the when you finish the round and you choose where to put your tent for the bonus and turn order, you get two more of those. Adds a little bit to the variety, but nothing much. I mean, the workshops are pretty standard affair. These new two tiles, you get a color, any color dye to your exhausted pile. Pretty good. Or you can add a testing die of any color to a chosen device board as low as legally possible. And you gain influence as normal, but do not move your ship. So, it's a way to get influence, but also add dice to various devices to, you know, improve their testing. These two are nice. It just adds to the variety, but it's still only two. And then you get one more tile, which is those research tiles for each of the three stacks. One? Really?

One per stack? You couldn't give us two per stack. Three per stack.

Really spectacular. Spared no expense.

That just feels like you wouldn't even notice having an extra one per stack. It just seems a little bit annoying. Now, I talked about the inserts with Wfarers and Scholars and and obviously there wasn't one for Wayf Farer. All of these fit in the insert fine. Okay, these inserts have clearly been designed with the promos in mind and wayfairers. There's enough room as well. So, trust me, these will all fit in these boxes with the inserts just fine. and the Finniverse ones, which I need to make certain and I put the link up in this video as well, I think. But yeah, so the promos are actually quite cool. Would I pay €25 though for a few promos? No. This is the kind of problem that you've got. I think this is going to be one of those things where if you can get the promo separately or maybe on a future Kickstarter they're allowed as an add-on, then by all means grab these promos, particularly the first two. I think the Wayf Farfarers and the Scholars ones are definitely worth including in Inventors if you really want it. But if you can get these separately, great. But in terms of the Moon Saga, I mean, I can't speak for the multiplayer aspect, but the solo one is a waste of time. It just really isn't.

So, reviewing this one is kind of weird. For €25, I wanted a bit more interesting stuff in here. The story book is like whatever. Who cares? You know, the setup tweaks aren't that good. The scoring is downright unfair. And, you know, there's just problems with it. So, all all in all, I think I would only be willing to give this Moon Saga box a four out of 10, a below average rating. And some of that is propped up by the promos. I think the promos are what elevate this box to a four out of 10, but I wouldn't really want to give it any higher. Now, maybe with the multiplayer aspect have a, you know, if I was able to play that, maybe that would increase it. But you're basically just being told that you'll get a few little gold cards with tiny little bonus tweaks and you play through free games and see how many gold cards you've got. Yeah, that could be an interesting little tweak on the multiplayer experience, but is that really going to elevate this to a level where you're going to want to spend all your money on it? And even then, have you got the setup of players to play through three of these games in succession and do that outside of a convention? Probably not. So maybe with if the multiplayer aspect was half decent, I could say this could go up to a five out of 10 being average. But the promos are the only thing out of this box so far that I like the solo mode. Oh yeah, I mean it was fun to play the game solo, but I would have had just as good, if not a better time if I'd simply just played each game once, not six times, just three times, and not bothered with a tiny inconsequential setup tweaks and certainly not being deflated by the

ridiculous scoring system at the end of this, which is literally just a beat your own score that is outright unfair. So, this is not worth it, you know, and I didn't, you know, I wasn't expecting this one to blow my mind, per se. You know, a very few people talk about these Moon Saga boxes, so clearly I'm not in the minority when I say that this is like not something that a lot of people get, but you know, in terms of all of these, yes. Okay, we've got three really good, two fantastic, one really good expansion out of all the South Tiger stuff. This is just a bolt-on bit at the end for diehard fanatics of the game. And I mean, you have got to be a diehard fanatic. But even then, I think you would just be better off playing the games normally and not bothering with this. So, if you want the promos, great.

If you can get them separately, even better. But as a package, just not worth it.

He's already dead.

So, that's it for me on this episode of The Broken Mele. Don't forget to thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on board game when it goes live on the official expansion page. Hope you've enjoyed this little series of the Tigers Trilogies. I love these games. I like Garfield games stuff. Not every single game they do wins me over. And certainly I much prefer these trilogy games than I do those spin-off historical ones. Although I do have the Anarchy and Scar Bray on order from Garfield Games. You know, I just went on the website and purchased it. You know, you know, thank you Patreons for helping to keep this channel going. You know, to buy those two boxes. So, when I get them, I intend to buy them. And if I've got time, I will certainly like to do some reviews on those ones. But, uh, you'll have to wait a little bit for those. I suspect by the time I get them and play them, probably some point in late September, I'll be able to get reviews out for those and, you know, I'll let you know my thoughts. So, there you go. That is my run of South Tigris games. Take care and remember, regardless of whether you intend to stare at the moon all day or not, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.

Progress saved