5 Family Friendly Game Reviews - Carcassonne Labyrinth, Reef & Ruins, Jumlejack & More!!!
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from BoardGameCo, and today I'm giving you thoughts on five more Gen Con games. These five games I came back from Gen Con with. I've played them all. I have thoughts. I have opinions. Let's go ahead and get into it, and let's save, you know, oh, I'm trying to think which one to do last over here. Let's save No, you know what? Let's figure out what to do first. Let's start with Stug Land That, the game from Hala. Stug Land That is an interesting game. Now, I won't be opening the boxes on all of these, but Stug Land That basically has you building out a grid. In fact, I can kind of show you with the back of this map over here. You're using tiles, not the back of the map, but this is a quick way to show you. And then you're going to be rolling these little cubes, and you're rolling them in order to see where they're going to land. So, for example, let's pretend I am the blue player. I'll start by going ahead and rolling some cubes, and depending on how those cubes land, we got two replacements. When you land this way, meaning on its side, exactly like that, you can replace another hut on the board. The only problem is there are no huts on the board currently, so that's not going to do anything for me. They're going to go back to my supply. Next player rolls theirs, and they got Oh, nope, still no huts on the board. So, the next player, they roll theirs, and we got We got a hut on the board. Here we go. This hut over here lands on the board, you place it somewhere onto the board. The various symbols you can get is if it lands kind of on its roof like that, then it's nothing. If it lands on its side, you can move a hut to a new location. And if it lands like this, you can replace a hut that's on the board with your own hut. Why are you doing this? Because location, location, location. On this grid, again, you'll be playing with these that don't bend quite as much. This is just the rulebook. On this grid, you're going to get points for every control of any individual tiles. You're going to get points for being on the city. to get points for
being next to lakes. You're going to lose points for being next to dumps, and you get a point for every single hut you have on the board to begin with. Basically, there's a bunch of ways to get points, and you're just rolling your huts as you try to figure out what goes where. Overall, it's fine. It's fine. Like, I was hoping I was looking forward to this game because I'm a huge fan of Rolling Heights, and I was like, "Ooh, rolling like meeples that has to land a particular way. I love Rolling Heights. This might be that same charm and area control." And it's fun, but like, it mostly feels like whoever rolls better wins, and there's a whole lot of moving things around without really feeling a sense of like actually mattering. You're like, "Oh, I moved to the middle of the lake over there cuz it's awesome. I can move you out of the middle of the lake. I replaced your hut. I replaced your hut." You just roll dice back and forth until eventually someone wins. I didn't get a strong sense of strategy so much as like just roll stuff and see who wins. That said, this is a HABA game and my kids did like it. My kids liked it a lot. It might be a great gateway into games like Rolling Coconuts. The way my daughter put it specifically is rolling things that aren't meant to be rolled and then using that as a game play mechanic is fun. I was like, "Let me introduce you to Rolling Coconuts." I haven't done that yet, but I said that.
So, we'll do that later. Anyways, my own personal opinion of this is a 2.5 out of five, but again, take that as a my opinion as the player was a 2.5 out of five. My kids enjoyed it. I've yet to see whether they'll play it themselves or not. In general, when it comes to kid games, I usually say this one of two things. Either it has to be enjoyable for the adults as well or has to be a game that the kids will play amongst themselves. Do you know why that is? Because there's plenty of games that I enjoy playing with my kids. I don't need to force myself to play games that are mediocre. So, if they play themselves, it's great. I probably would play it. It's not the worst. It's a 2.5 out of five. Then we have, speaking of kids games, let's go to Jumbo Jack. This is a good time to go on Jumbo Jack. Jumbo Jack, you are the pirate. You're basically playing with a voodoo doll. That's right. You're playing with a voodoo doll that's dressed in different ways. And what you're doing in the game is you have to hide your pirate identity. You're going to have a card that defines what your pirate is. Do you have the cape, the sword, the various accessories? What are you dressed up as? And the other players are trying to dress the the the voodoo doll in different ways before pointing, "Jumbo Jack, Jumbo Jack." and pointing at another player trying to guess if they have the right card and whether you've killed them, so to speak. Uh but every time someone points at you, you get more voting power. So, by voting for me, I get more votes the next time I vote at somebody else. You want to be very careful with who you vote for. Give them too much sway over the game and they might point at you and you might be the next target. The game itself is kind of um random. It feels like random. It's like a party game with an element of strategy, sort of, but it's mostly about just trying to figure out who you're going to yell Jumbo Jack and point at.
This game, mechanics-wise, I would give it a 2.5, but the fun factor is there. The fun factor of all the players yelling Jumbo Jack and laughing and being caught or not being caught or getting revenge on somebody else. Like there's a lot of theme to this one. I'm going to give it a three out of five. I I still think it's definitely barely on the game side of things, but the theme of the the theme element I have something in my eye over here. Maybe Jumble Jack got cast on me. But the uh the the the theme of it all does come together in a tremendously fun way. So, it still doesn't really go that high. It's a three out of five for me. I think that the the the whole reason you play this is for the laughs, not for any real sense of strategy. Now then there, let's go ahead and dive into I don't know. Let's do Carcassonne Labyrinth. Let's get the kid games out of the way over here. Carcassonne Labyrinth. Carcassonne Labyrinth is what happens if Carcassonne met Labyrinth. I don't like it. I I I don't like it. It's not It's better than Labyrinth. It is [clears throat] better than Labyrinth, but it's not better than Carcassonne. Uh for me, this is a 2.5 out of five. I'll start with that right away. So, we have a 2.5, a three, a 2.5. Carcassonne Labyrinth basically has you playing a game of Labyrinth to grab the various tiles. So, you're sliding the tiles in and out of the grid as you attempt to figure out, "Okay, great. I want to move over here and take a tile." But the first thing is the tile you slide out of the grid is a tile that you get to put into your own personal board. But additionally, as you position tiles in the grid and able to move towards your destination tile, that thing classic Labyrinth, you have a tile you're trying to get to, you're able to go ahead and get that and add it to your treasures.
Now, you have 10 turns and you have 10 turns in order to get all your eight treasure tiles. You have one or two turns which you can miss, which again, if you played Carcassonne, that's typically what will happen. You won't always be able to get to what you want, but you'll usually be able to get to what you want. And this game definitely has that element. What you're doing is you're sliding a tile and then trying to get to a tile and then being mindful of how it's all going to fit into your personal city. The biggest problem I have with it is the city you're building feels underwhelming. And that's two reasons. First of all, in traditional Carcassonne, you're fighting it out over a grid. And you're trying to key in you're trying to cut into other players' territory. I'll eventually get that feel. That will eventually get that city. I'll even steal that road. That adds an element of tension to the game that this does not have cuz you're building a personal display. But also, like the way the points even work. Like there's not even like there's a nice point track where you get a bunch of points. Rather, when you like do cities, you get like a tile that goes on it and then you stack your tiles and you're like, "I won." It It doesn't work. It doesn't work for me. It removes all the fun of scoring from Carcassonne. It feels more like the Labyrinth puzzle than the Carcassonne puzzle, which if you want to play Labyrinth, this might be a great gateway to Carcassonne. For me personally, I felt like it didn't make me like Labyrinth. In fact, the only game that's done that is Labyrinth Chronicles from Queen Games Realms, and Ravensburger, I guess. That made me like Labyrinth a little more, but this did not. This made me want to play Carcassonne. That's what this one did. A 2.5 out of 5. From there, let's go to Which one do I like more?
I I think I like this one more. So, we'll do this one. This one. Skyward Republic. Skyward Republic over here from Queen Games Publishing is a not really I cut you choose. It's If you've played games like Colt Express, it kind of has that system. Basically, the core idea is you're building out a city of eight buildings. There's other things, there's vehicles and critters, but you're building out a city of eight buildings in two rows. And every building you build has a scoring aspect as to why you're trying to build it. This wants to be next to that. This will give you end game points for that. This will give you an ongoing ability every single turn. You have these buildings that you're placing down and you're just trying to optimize how they all go together. How do you get those buildings? Well, that's the game. That's the game of Skyward Labyrinth. It's all about how you get the buildings because you're going to have piles that go out each round, and then you have your own personal piles, which you're going to be flipping a card. You either take a pile. So, you look at the piles, you're like, that's a good pile. I'll take that pile. Or you say, no, I want more cards in that pile, and so you flip one of the other cards into it and put it into one of the piles, making the piles on the table more tempting for the next player.
They have the same choice. Do they want one of the piles on the table, which now has one of your cards in it, or do they flip one of their own cards, making it tempting for the next player? Basically, at any given time, if you really want a pile, you need to take that pile. And if you don't really care, you can add more cards to the table, which will help everyone get more cards, sort of. You're trying to walk away with not just more cards, but the right cards because you're going to need to play those cards in your city, and you need other cards to pay for those cards. That's kind of what you're doing in this. Overall, it's fine. It's fine. It's fine. It's fine. It's like It's an okay game. I think that the biggest problem I have with it, first of all, I did not think the rule book was that clear. I thought there were a lot of issues. A surprising amount of issues in the clarity of the rules that that that to me like there's a lot of It did not feel clear. It did not feel clear. That's first of all. And that definitely is a ding against the game experience, especially one that I don't think this is a particularly complicated game. I just think there were lots of elements that weren't clear. Even things like the gears and the points, the way the tokens are, feels like weird as to confusing as to are they gears or are they points? Are there The gears worth two points in the game? No, they're not.
They're only worth one point. This would make more sense if you saw the components. It is a weird question. But outside of that, the gameplay itself as far as the buildings you're gathering, I just I I like the drafting system. The drafting system where you're trying to figure out do you want the pile or are you making the pile more compiling to the next person? I love that. I love when games like Colorado do it, when Pat Quirk does it. I love games that give you a tension to do you want the thing or do you make the thing better for others and possibly hope to get the thing when it comes back to you? Those are very fun systems. The gameplay itself, I didn't find a real strong sense of um What's the right word for it? I didn't feel particularly rewarded as I built my city. I didn't feel like the combos or the powers or the point multiplications, I didn't feel like any of that was particularly amazing. It felt fine every time I did it. It's like, "Okay, yeah, that vehicle's good. And now you stole that vehicle. And now I put this building and this gives me two gears."
There was never a moment where I was like, "Oh my gosh, this is it. This is the combotastic city that I'm building." So, it's fine. It's a three out of five. And then we have Reef and Rune. Reef and Rune is from from from What's it called? Oh my gosh, the publisher is Weird Rabbit Games. They did Logic and Lore, which I really love, which is why I was looking forward forward towards Reef and Rune. Reef and Rune is a roll and write game that plays out across three sheets. You have three different sheets over here and you're going to be rolling dice in order to place numbers into the three different sheets. This sheet over here has two different ways to play. I like the other way much better, not the way that's shown over here. This is like a polyomino tile situation going on. I like that sheet much better than the other one. It feels much more interesting. But generally, every single round you're going to roll three dice and then mark things into the different sheets. Because one sheet has all the ways you're marking numbers, the middle sheet is all the ways you multiply the stuff you're marking in the other sheet, and the last sheet is its own little set of mini games as far as how you get the various bonuses that will help you on the other sheets. It's fun. You play across, I think, 18 rounds if I recall correctly. You roll dice. I've played this solo. I've played this multiplayer.
It is a fun, charming game that the only hold up against it is that we live in a world with amazing roll and write games that give a ton of roll and write Yeah, that's roll and write. We live in a world with amazing roll and write games in which is a ton of combotastic goodness and a ton of nuanced different ways to strategize. And I think Reef and Rune is fine in that sense. There's a small a few small complaints. First of all, the nature of the Reef 'n' Roots sheet is that because of the way you have to roll every turn to unlock access to your Reef, you're kind of incentivized to go all in on that sheet every single round as opposed to playing a more nuanced scoring game. And I don't like that because strategically it pushes you in a direction as opposed to giving you freedom to really craft out your sheet. And so you get you're kind of stuck a little bit in that sense. Outside of that, the game is very samey game to game. I played this a few times now. I played it multiple I played it multiplayer. I played solo. I played a few times multiplayer, only one solo.
It's it it I I think that after playing it a few times I and having tried both those two like scoring modes that third sheet which gives you a little mini game. Again, like I told you already, I like the polyomino version much better. But I don't find a strong sense of replayability to the experience. It's a fun game which you roll things, check boxes, you get 18 rounds. There's definitely combotastic things happening, especially late game, but it just doesn't feel different enough game to game. So I still enjoy it. It's just with less variability. I'm going to give it a three out of five as well. And that is your five game review roundup. Once again, we have over here Stuggle 2.5 out of five. Caveat, my kids did enjoy it. We have Jumble Jack, a crazy game that's barely a game, but the party aspect is very very very fun. Carcassonne Labyrinth, this is a three out of five as well. Well, it's a 2.5. Three out of five. Carcassonne Labyrinth is a 2.5 as well. It just made me want to play Carcassonne. And Reef 'n' Roots and Skulls of the Republic both threes out of fives that definitely gave me enjoyable aspects, but neither particularly wowed me for different reasons. In any case, until next time.
I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.