Carnegie: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Carnegie uh which is a game that has the driest theme I think I have played um in a long time at least yeah like it's uh this is the game that I backed and I don't know why right like because nothing about this like genre or theme would ever draw me to um to actually just be like oh yeah let's just get in on that but it's from the same designer as uh black angel which I like black angel quite a bit I'm probably only one of the few that are kind of like spearheading that game because I I think it's solid but uh that's the only game of his that I've actually played although I am familiar with his other ones uh overall what do you think of Carnegie I liked it yeah um it is for a Euro game you're pretty invested to everybody else's turn right honestly and thinking through okay looking at Seth's War what's he going to do he has tons of cash and I don't so his best move is to go and do a charity or donations yeah um and there were a couple times where like I looked every boards like oh I can do construction and I don't think you can follow right and you did a donation and
I could not follow right right I will say what's kind of interesting about this game is um there's a couple things because the whole the whole shtick or the whole theme of the game is Andrew Carnegie was a philanthropist like I don't know if he was a billionaire but like one of the richest persons I mean he's been but he did a bunch of charity work I mean there's so much stuff named after him because he had all this money from being in the steel industry yeah that and he donated it all right and it is kind of weird that they have these donations but they cap it yes and I'm not sure how I feel about that because to me thematically it should be a viable strategy to go after all those and be like oh I want to um like I just want to go heavy in donations and it's where they are capped at 12. and the only reason I can think of why they did that is mechanics are alone because it would imbalance some of them right because like the train Max you can do is 12. it's 12 points exactly the cities right you can do is 12. right um so I think that's why they did that because otherwise like having a bunch of Cubes like you can just get a bunch of cubes and then that would you could make that 30 points oh yeah whereas someone doing one of those is only going to get 12 right so I see why they did it um just for the strategy I did for the run through that's kind of what I went heavy on uh and I mean but I will say even though
this feels broken like making it to where you're paying 25 for eight points or 25 for 12 points I'm paying 15. to get the same amount of points uh it's not like the the Departments all of them are good yes and the interesting thing about this game is even though I got like blown out and I like once because once you started also getting 12 points which I think might be actually a flaw of a two-player game yeah I agree um just because in a two-player game both players are pretty much gonna get the donations that they want having a third player jump in to take some of those uh means that my strategy I think in the three player game if if I did the exact same thing I think it would have actually been better yes because you do it equally well wouldn't have gotten as much more I don't know if it was a one but it it might have you might have lost 26 no 20 24 maybe 36 points if someone also was going for the East right so it was also going for those so and some of it was like so you went more broad spectrum and I went very targeted like if I saw like if I chose a donation that I was going to go for I tried to Max it out right and I didn't move to another one until I had the previous one maxed out and then basically at the end like when I did the East it was more I didn't think I was going to the 12 points from the East it just happened that I did construction I had the resources to do it yeah but my kind of goal plan was like well it's extra points at this point I have money there's nothing that
money is valuable for it's the second to the last round let's do it yeah and I think in a two-player game you can also be kind of more of a dick because I saw that you could have gotten eight to twelve points and I could have just taken that right and be like well I'm not getting anything right um I actually thought you saw the train and that was the one you were going to go for because no you were close enough to a couple trains to get some points from it yeah I was I didn't I was trying to see how well you can do without going studying yeah um and you can do really well I don't think there's any one Surefire strategy no uh but I think that some Avenues are a lot more powerful in a two-player game uh studying does go a long way because there's not as much points of contention there's not as many people also going for donations going up on the tracks right taking locations in in cities that you might want to go to right um so interestingly enough I think a two-player game is a lot more free yeah because I mean realistically like building was because I was actually kind of afraid it's like oh you know if we all start like in the east then you're all competing for routes but here because I started basically in the East I started Midwest then East really because I was trying to connect Chicago Atlanta or was it New Orleans and New York together because that was going to be my train I wasn't even going to try to get to San Francisco yeah I just wanted that chain where's the fourth one no so this is worth two oh that's it you're right okay so if you can connect it to you know any of the
two other major cities yeah it's quite a bit points again it's a lot of points yeah it's 36 points and it's like I could have competed for that I was trying to focus on the donations and get those out um to be like to make kind of like a chain and it just didn't and actually what what did hurt me was because I the way that the turn order worked is I'm I wanted to have more people standing up yeah by the end of it because I could have if I had gotten 12 points for that it would have been another 12 points when you sent two of your workers out here and the last turn I was like I think you got money wise more points out of it but I was like you know you're getting double points by having those guys well because I didn't I can't see the slash through that times five got it so I was like oh you just have five you know it's five or two points for every five dollars I still think that you got more points out of it than you would have half of the two extra workers standing up I did and I mean and the thing is is like what I could have done is because I had ways I even mapped it I was like oh I should get 60.
um 60 and I could have gotten well I would have just needed I needed 45. total to get them to get the max amount of points from that right um so but in my head I saw that because for my for my angle it just shows a five that that was like the thinnest paintbrush stroke of a line right uh that I was thinking oh okay I just need 30 and then I can use it up for both of those yeah um so that was that was quite a lot of points I left on the board I mean because if I had maxed out on that it would have been another 12 points right on top of well so you maxed out this for 12 points and then I think you had I got I had 15 left yeah so you went on six more points so another 18 points if I had maxed out this because if I had 12 here that would have been another six and then another six there so 18 points still wouldn't put me at uh 110 right which is not nothing no so I will say because I think you even said it in the game like it felt fast it's like it's 20 rounds yeah like I was thinking like when I was watching the playthrough it was like man 20 rounds that's going to take forever I know and I was like I guess like I was looking at boys like we're halfway done yeah I haven't done anything yet yeah yeah yeah well it was like it was so weird just because of the way this is probably one of the greatest ways of making Variety in a game because I mean just by taking one of these and
flipping it it already changes the game yes and the way that the order of donations was like I mean I was sitting there and I was like I don't like where these are at yes because I went through waves like it's it's like we almost swapped at the beginning beginning half you had a lot of money yeah and I had none then the other half I had a lot of money and you had none right and it's like okay now I'm gonna pick it up and it's also another weird semblance of this game where you're not really getting any points throughout the game no not unless you go very specific like so if you go Bridges early you can start getting some points but one of the things I did figure out like I I did not pick up departments that drop people off very readily oh yeah I started realizing I that's actually kind of a bad idea like I really actually do want to send people out yeah because you're missing out on just these nice General income I mean hell think about it like and we'll I'll talk about this in a sec but like a a pretty good strategy is because you don't need if you pull all these out you don't need um to build all these to get these points so and these are cumulative yeah so it's like how much how many points is that that's this is 12 is it all 12. I think it's all twelve nine twelve four five six seven eight nine no okay so these top two are 12 points that's nine this is six okay so 24 30 39 points right if you just I mean you can go
heavy you can get the seven pointer plus that and then if you can really just get move that over and stack the load right which is why I did one time like I just had like 18. yeah yeah and I was like you know because I saw this like oh man that'll get me all these I mean I think I got the ten dollar from there which then helped me because the next round was able to actually buy a donation yeah because of that ten dollar yep and so it was all The Sweet Spot areas that yeah you can just get away with a lot of stuff I mean and it's very interesting because the one I think the production value of this game is outstanding like it's so it's not like I mean it's not like goo gong or what's another high quality like I mean um any vital start of the game really it's kind of it's on par with a vital game yeah um because whenever I was first watching the video I was like oh my God he's gonna be stupid and they and they're just slide under some cardboard or some some paper tray uh no not at all like they they actually slot into a little sleeve section yep the fact that these are like gears that um uh like show you what level so you don't have to like keep pulling them out there's also a b side that it looks like okay so that's points but well no because if this one you get um oh points based off this one's specifically donations uh oh they all are so interesting but it does it has less points but you get more resources yeah for income but yeah like if you're not
pulling those out or if you're not putting workers on missions in various spots and people are like it makes it to where you're like man I don't want to do that action because then they're going to pull people back and well there's a time where like I knew I needed to do research so I could get this Midwest training because I had three guys here and but it was like but the only way for me to get that research is to go and do a movement action but that's going to pull all my Midwestern people exactly no this is not right right or you take up a spot like if it's very limited and it's like okay I know he has people there but he's on he's all the way at the beginning right you know what I'm gonna do that action just to force him to be like I guess I'll leave him there but you leave them there in a Midwest spot may not be coming up anytime soon now I do like the one fact that you can pull only one which still allows you to pull all this production and so like there's one time I think like in the midwest it was that situation it was like I need this income so I'm gonna pull that one guy knowing it's not really what I want to do but this will save me and I'll get the other two guys later yeah yeah they uh because in most games like this with Euros it's kind of like okay I've seen it like this is kind of a and if this is definitely an efficiency game but it's not like kanban where it's like okay we were so efficient that we played the game right this one has so much variety with the action selection and there's more of
those there's yeah number there's eight total and they're all double-sided you just shuffle them up and then just put four in right and then the Departments um are also randomly shuffled so like we could have played a game where this plus seven of study points is never going to be there yeah yep uh and I really like that yeah because I some games where it's like okay you have to have these in the game but then you randomize these it's like okay because then there becomes a meta of what your first couple moves should be every single time because because you know this is a known fact you'll just start building a strategy around those known facts right but here it's gonna be so Random for your start that every game is going to be how flexible are you going to be able to be to do X Y and Z yeah do you have any uh negatives on the game uh so there is as a Euro game there is take that in it like there can I mean there's definitely times where we kind of lightly at least took uh take that um because you can see what people are probably going to go for for donations if you're first you can go take it from them yeah um and it doesn't necessarily hurt you because you can probably still accomplish yeah like there was nothing if I at the time I could have taken the East right then I probably could have jumped in and started please you've probably gone six points yeah um right and so that's the eighteen Point swing that's not terrible yeah and so
from that standpoint that to me is a negative in a euro game but at the same time realistically I felt like I was pretty much almost exclusively focused on my board like the only reason I would look at your board to see how it was going to hurt you is there's two actions I could take which one is probably the best and I don't consider that take that no the whenever what I personally consider take that is I'm I'm only robbing you of something right like me taking East like the East times two gains me nothing right but some people warp that in like a well my gain is your loss right and I hate those people because I sat here and I was like yeah I could and I was like that'd be nasty but I I don't play that way right like so what this game does extremely well yeah people could do that just don't play with them um but I think looking at someone's board and being like because this game is you want to be efficient right it wouldn't make any sense for you to take an action that you also get nothing for just to deprive someone else of doing something so it's like you're looking it's like hmm I'm gonna do a human resources again because I can benefit from that because I get I have the one that gets me points or I have I need to move more people and he just moved his so he's not going to move him again so I'm just gonna do it again like I like that yes I think that that is an excellent way to have competition in a year again because so many Euro games are just salt cooperate not Cooperative competitive solitaire games right this is my board this is everything I'm doing I don't care what
anyone else is doing I just want that to be my turn um and there's a time and place for those kinds of games right but it is kind of refreshing to actually have a hit mid to heavy weight Euro game where you're actually looking at what your other players can do I wanna do I want to do that action even though that's going to let them do income yes because I have I'm gonna do because my actions are gonna be extremely beneficial so it doesn't matter if I give them the income right so it didn't really affect me but I could see other players this game could cause a fair amount of analysis paralysis um because you are trying to be efficient and there's going to be times where you're just not going to be as efficient as you want it to be yeah and so making that choice of what's the least inefficient move possible and I can see some people just struggling with that yeah because it whenever you hear 20 rounds and you hear a Euro you're like that's a six hour game right like that sounds awful uh but surprisingly they found a way for it to be tense but also light like we're not sitting here like okay if he takes that one thing for me my entire game is ruined you know you're still free yeah like we I think I mentioned it before we had played hey money's tight but like you can get around it you can get around it like there are ways for you to get a bunch of money yep like you might not have you might not take the action you want right then and there or you
might have to do a few setup actions like I did yep I was like I don't have any money I need to do this action now I have thirty dollars right and then that frees me up for quite a while right uh but I think that that's a good element of a Euro game if you're always swimming in resources and you're always getting to do all the actions you want I find that kind of boring it's like just art just be like I got 110 points yeah well we didn't play yeah but then we get we get whatever we want so might as well just say we played and just give out a number uh yeah you know it's super solid the other thing super good is I was listening to Paul Grogan and he made it he made a um he made a good point that I was like well you know what let's see what he's talking about on the back of the rule book it has an icon reference that actually shows the icons and explains what they are we never had to look at that yeah like never once have we had to look at that and be like what does that icon mean yeah we might have had to be like okay let's just clarify what the department does right but surprisingly in a game that is like language independent and with the icons it they just make so much sense they made sense uh again here's the thing the production value I I could not be more happy with this game came because I whenever I was setting it up for us to for us to play I was like I was like okay I'm getting ready to punch out all these [ __ ] things and nope these came organized in the tray your each player can't like
came organized in the tray even with the setup stuff like yourself in there they're already organized all the cards are where they're they're meant to be it's um like and it's game trays right and so many companies are now using game trades but they don't organize it for you right I'm blown away like it's such a small thing but it's like as we play more and more games I take into consideration set up a lot more like if a game doesn't have an insert I'm almost not inclined to play it because oh my God I don't want to just dump out all these [ __ ] from bags I don't want to do all this but the fact is that so many games use game trays and then they either give you the shittiest little toilet paper [ __ ] thing where it does it's like okay I don't even know how to organize this right and the company doesn't do a video and this game was like oh open it up and yeah it's all organized for you right it's outstanding I don't even know who this company is it well what's interesting is it used to be Pegasus spiel but that oh really yeah but that organizer isn't um
Quinn games yeah they did as publisher they did key flower trajan Aqua Sphere um and I mean Board Game Geek always has kind of weird things where it's like if you ever look up Simon Publishers you're like they didn't how are they involved in that game it's this this guy kind of like just odd yeah uh this game also does have an expansion it has a modular expansion um one of them adds like these uh like I guess auctions so it uses a notepad on fitting sheets so in addition to customizing their starting resources each player may also bid to start the game as first player the players then revealed or completed bidding sheets simultaneously the high Builder will become the first player in play will proceed clockwise um oh and that determines your starting money so it depends I guess it depends on you start out with 50 bucks and you could bid for put for and how many cubes so you could pay 18 coins to start out with six cubes and if you want to start out with how many workers in your lobby that costs money it depends on how many victory points you want to start with like you can gain 12 points to start out negative six so it's just a additional Choice a variety set of variety that's that's odd
but but I mean kind of cool because I've never seen that you have super flexibility for how you want to play yeah that's oh and how many setup moves you get you can sell the moves for 20 bucks right so as long like I mean you could start with 50 bucks and almost nothing on your board which is like well guys uh my entire first half is setting up I got but I got 50 bucks just wait that first donation spot I'm gonna get the times to five bucks location yeah yeah I'm gonna have no cubes I'm gonna have no workers no it looks like uh it looks like to start with cubes you do have to pay but you will have at least three workers and zero victory points okay like that's those are at least free okay um that'd be so funny but I think that's neat I think that's me I am we haven't played with any of the expansions but uh it is here they have new departments um so I don't know if these are shuffled in with the others um I would hope so but like there's one renovation when using this department the player must choose a single region of the map for each project you get either two dollars or a victory point I would imagine just by quick glancing there's at least some in here that I'll that give you more points I'm lying um there's two there's two here that give you points throughout the game but again even if it
just adds more departments I would probably just throw that in and Shuffle in new donations as well cool that's so pretty much in an optional rules whether these the first player has the option to wait that player simply has to announce that they are waiting rather than playing first the other players must then play First and the first player will go last huh okay probably wouldn't do that just because there's no downside the reason why going first because in this game going first is good and bad because it's like a lot of people see what you're doing and quartz correct but also you get first dibs right um no it's actually what's great because there's very few games where you or I like I wouldn't really call this a blowout but it's a pretty significant because like getting 12 points is a lot so it's 127 to 92. it's what is that 29 29 Points um you know more than 29.
um because you go up eight right so 35 yeah 35. um yeah I mean and that's just if I had capitalized more on various locations right um but there's very few games where you or I blow each other out yeah um and were either one of us like I can't think of a game where I've beaten you that you've been like well I guess if I counts both expansions is like how many points did you get I don't know like 300 yeah [ __ ] this game yeah but anyway because you and I are pretty close like right uh we don't keep tally on like what the ratio is but I would say we're pretty much even in terms of competition right uh but where one of us loses where it's like yeah I want to play this again and I like this game enough to be like yeah let's give it another shot oh yeah uh let's see I can't really think of any other negatives um in fact I mean the only negative I really had was just kind of the weird cap on donations which I get why they did so it's not that big of a deal um and to compensate you could theoretically just because there are a total of eight donation spots because you'll get four there and then the four at the end and theoretically where was it I think I did grab it oh yeah remove a worker so during a r d
you could send them work on a mission and donate again yeah so the cop would say yeah I mean you're right I probably should have grabbed that one there was a reason I was great I was funny enough I think I did look at that I think I think I whenever I started with my thing like making them cheaper I think I did look at that and I was like oh I need to get that yeah and then I didn't oh because I had no money and I was like there's no point me grabbing it because um but yeah yeah I don't think I would it's not bad at two I think I think two is still pretty solid yeah but I think three would be I'm gonna go with three three seems to be a sweet spot um because also in the three player game the I think the person going last gets this token yep which means hey I'm not gonna do that actually I'm gonna do my own action or it's three points at the end right four player game everyone gets this um but I like the fact in a three-player game there's still going to be some seating of of a random setup right uh but I think a third person jumping into it was just smooth some things yeah or it would hinder it would it would hinder all players yeah like they're gonna take donations because they're gonna go for certain strategies they're going to take departments they're gonna take spots right um that that isn't that it's just not taken like there's not enough of the uh dummy player getting set up that's gonna really because it's still a dummy player
they just get stood up there just shrinks the board down but it's not the same as having one other person also vying for the East taking that spot also vying for trains taking that spot right um what I do find interesting so it's the same number of travel spots that go from New Orleans to Chicago through New York as it was to go from San Francisco to Chicago it's both six uh building spaces uh uh sorry to get from New Orleans to Chicago to New York yeah is six yeah one two three four five I guess it is faster one two three four five you got five okay if yeah if if you went that way yeah um I did hear some people say that like there are some cities that are very crucial to try and get the 36 right uh in Denver is is a really solid one because that is the shortest route right from Chicago in there uh but again we were also talking about spots of donations they also take spots of of paths right if we have a third player right um so I would say like not bad at two but I think it would improve it it would improve it three and with um I think there's not a lot of Euros that are great at two honestly yeah usually three is a soft spot four is like we I don't need a fourth person here to mess with stuff
um you got anything else nope all right good on a scale of one to ten what would you give Carnegie I'm struggling with that one 9.5 9.5 God damn yeah God damn um I'm out of nine I met I 9.5 if I like the theme more uh but I I do really like this I think because most games like this are like the nines and tens are usually reserved for Vital games and it's like oh here we go like here's another one that's not as heavy but still very efficient with the variety of setup like the cool engines and the actual interchanging of players like um and then just the cool like it's just a smaller expansion but like modular expansions are great right and it's like oh hey you know what we've been playing this game quite a bit like let's uh let's do variable setup right here's your auction uh yeah I was debating on 10 like I think I won't play at least one more time before it added to my collection but this is definitely one that I would consider just straight up adding to my collection yeah yeah I figured that out of everyone in in the group that I play with that this one would have resonated with you the most yeah um and yeah it's just so clean and like I watched a three player run through and it took them an hour and a half right like so it was basically 30 minutes per
player which is what it was for us right two player game was about an hour uh which is pretty solid that's so good that's a sweet spot for player count time yeah um especially for medium to heavy Euro game um and so it says 120 Minutes it's two hours okay is what it's doing and you know for four players four player games about two hours yeah my good reaction yeah and there's so many times where if you're doing an action like there were times where like the the human resources one it was like I'm moving my stuff I don't it doesn't matter what you where you move on I can't stop you from moving your own people right uh I will say the only thematic thing about the game besides the fact of whatever it's Carnegie is that I see kind of where they're coming with the victory points is that to me in my head you don't get a lot of victory points throughout the game because he wasn't as well known until the end where he was donating all of his money right to where it's like that's why at the end you get a bunch of victory points because it's I guess maybe thematically they were thinking oh at the end of his life he donated all of his money that's how he became renowned but he was still some guy throughout his life uh donate just maybe doing some stuff but not a lot so that's why you can do this and get two points you can do this and get two points right I am very curious as to how like if anyone knows or if you've played this game I want to know what your max score was
in the middle of a game like if someone was trying to go for victory points uh my gut reaction I mean it can't be 20 points I was thinking 30 if but you're like that's your Strat I mean you have to go heavy on Bridges to begin with yeah and you have to be pulling people back so often that would be that would be four points um and how many times do you think you pulled like quite a third maybe yeah like part of the action quite a bit so I mean if you let's say you did do that third of the actions so there's 20 actions um so um if you really think about so but to do this this takes four eight yeah no 14.
there's 14 to get to the two Oh no you're right yeah yeah so 14 Research to get that out which means if you don't have the seven you have to fill this up twice but if you do have the seven then it's just one action right is to is do that now granted you also have to build them out yeah um which is cheap I mean you get six cubes and just pop them out real quick yeah but here's the thing if you do that you get you have six cubes so you you get the seven you start with it you build it um then you fill this so seven let's we said 14 right yep um so you do still have to fill this out which you could just set up at the very beginning of a setup you can just move people over so that's taking four of your movements you only have two more movement you could get one more guy up here for a cube um oh yeah if you want to grab the cube I think it would still probably take you two turns to set up yeah um I think so but you get those out then you have the cubes then the very next action um we're not the very next but hopefully let's just say optimal very next action is you have you already have these pulled out and then you construct the seven right you get that built um and then you already have someone on there so you pay uh to get them up right so then you uh yeah so then you have that then you have your uh 16 run pull those out then you construct and some of your construction and the
Seven is probably placing basically everywhere I use one that's what I'm saying everything you pull three people out then you go you just look at the next oh the next three are going to be uh right you know two East and the South um and then you have those out so now from every income point you are getting four points yeah maybe so if you if you did that I think I think 20 to 30 just off this alone you would get 20 to 30 points which to be fair how much did I say we were different 35 that's that that closes the Gap right Five Points um I think it's possible I think this is actually a really cool uh element of a game where the points you actually gain throughout could be the Super are super beneficial versus others especially then if you get this one so Three Bridges right yeah there's another 12 points right there um yeah you get that one you uh because also if you're going that Strat with study points then you can also quickly ramp up on at least one track so then you're pulling and getting two points each time right you pull from there um I think that's a potentially winning strategy because there are other ways to get victory points throughout the game this one for every two people you have standing uh this one right here was um for three uh three times you can spend a
cube to get three money in a point right so that would be three points and nine bucks right it's a it's very interesting so I think I think thematically that's probably the most thematic spot is if your Carnegie then you're you're kind of supposed to be like okay how how much impact am I having in the middle of my life towards the end right and still not bubbling up to 9.5 but that's just kind of like that's that's one thing of of this game that I'm like I'm trying to give it some theme it's really not uh the most but I think to me that's the closest yeah I can get to putting some elements of theme on here uh but yeah uh so nine and a 9.5 from us that's our thoughts on Carnegie let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever type of day there's for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you