Gloomhaven 2nd Edition - TCbH First Impressions Review
Transcript
Hey everyone, it's morning and just this weekend I got my chance to play Gloom Haven Second Edition. Kind of over my shoulder somewhere over here. But I wanted to take some time to give you some off-the-cuff first impressions of the game. This isn't really meant to be the end all be all of our Gloom Haven review. I hope to complete something that's much more scripted and produced and kind of what you normally expect from us down the road. But given that this is one of those campaign games that could take a lot of investment to really come to some final thoughts, it seemed appropriate to do another one of these casual campaign first impression reviews. So that's what we're doing here. just kind of the goods, the bads, the what I liked and didn't like in our first fay in Sephar's latest Haven game.
Of note before we get into this, know that I am playing this as someone who has experienced a lot of Gloom Haven and therefore am using the Xhaven app as a Gloom Haven assistant to drive a lot of the uh upkeep things, keeping track of health and experience for characters, status effects, flipping enemy cards, driving the initiative assembly. You don't have to do that. Bloom Haven has always been and presumably always will be something that you can play independent of any app assist, but I strongly encourage anyone who's playing a lot of Gloom Haven who doesn't absolutely hate any digital presence at the table, go ahead and check out that app because oh my god, it saves so much time. So, first off, in case you've been under a rock, what is this thing? Well, Gloom Haven is the absolutely uh genredefining game by Sephilair. That was their debut and has now since gone down as one of the most celebrated games of all time with immense crossover success, digital adaptations, and it has gotten a little bit long in the tooth, especially as Sephair has become more experienced with the release of Frost Haven, Gloom Haven, Jaws of the Lion, Buttons and Bugs, and they wanted to take another crack at Gloom Haven proper. Now, the game itself is a campaign-based character-driven action
tactical dungeon crawlesque type of game where you play through scenarios, you get upgrades, you level up your character, every round, players pick, then reveal the cards, which will define their actions, and then the enemy automated behaviors are revealed. You resolve in sequence based off of initiative order, continue until players lose or the mission is completed. There are tons of instructions on how to play Gloom Haven or this system in general if you want that. That is not this review. So, who were we? Well, I decided to play a character that I really didn't invest myself in that much in the first time playing through Gloom Haven. That's Orchid Spellw Weaver. I thought, you know, they were pretty powerful in the first one, but I only got to observe them as another player watching a friend play that character. and I thought I wanted to harness that power for myself.
Whereas Mike, part of our campaign crew, decided to play the brute, thinking that he would take probably the most rudimentary, straightforward of characters from the original Gloom Haven and put it through the test to see if it was more dynamic and interesting. Of note, right off the bat, we notice the difference of the brute being renamed to the bruiser, giving a less negative connotation to the character, I suppose, defining more of what their actions are or what their style of fighting is as opposed to temperament and the sort of gray morality that it's known for. And again, just really kind of leaning into brute could just be a temperament type of thing, whereas bruiser is more the type of fighting style that they have.
On top of this, we completed just the first scenario, which the reason why we didn't pursue into the next scenario is that we are intending to replay the first scenario, possibly with these same characters, but with our full campaign group. Sorry, Christina, you were out of town and we really wanted to get to this game and we couldn't play Tidal Blades, which is still under the Jasper table over there. Okay, let's get to some of our observations. Right off the bat, the game strikes a tone that's a little bit more nuanced, interesting, dynamic, not only with how the characters are presented, described in the rule book, but also in the story itself. The introductory tale is essentially the same setup, the story that you know, which I was glad to see that they're preserving the story. there's a little bit more tongue and cheek of a nature almost a tone similar to like Super Giant Games with how they've presented Hades. you know, the sort of narration and commentary that's observational and a bit dry in its humor, which underscores that this is a dire setting, and you're trying to scrape by as these mercenaries, but at the same time, you can find black humor in these settings, and that kind of cuts some of the tension. I think it works mostly well here. I was actually really enjoying our time reading through the scenario prompts as well as the conclusion. So,
we get to scenario one and you can tell [clears throat] the visuals are so much more spectacular in this. Just the presentation of everything looks so much nicer and more interesting and more inviting and adventurous. And the scenarios itself are bringing in what you've gotten used to, especially through Frost Haven, uh, with the scenario prompt being in one spiralbound book, but then the developing scenario in another one. So, it's kind of obiscating what's going to happen as you continue on. The first scenario is really straightforward. you're going to need to kill all the enemies and so there's not a huge puzzle element to it, but it definitely had more developing elements and more of an arc. Ultimately, even as very experienced Gloom Haven players at this point, we barely skated by where Mike as his bruiser ended up getting exhausted during the scenario and I had to finish up with the spellw weaver. Now, before I get into the characters, I do want to make a comment on the production. Even though I love these visuals, the aesthetic, the presentation, I did notice that consistently, even though the the artwork, the aesthetic really seemed to come through beautifully, a lot of the production does feel a bit cheaper, even above the
original Gloom Haven and certainly uh more than Frost Haven. And this comes through in a bunch of different ways. From the miniatures, which have incredible [snorts] dynamic poses, but are both smaller and seem to be a bit muddier. They don't have as much recesses within the materials themselves. And in the comparisons that I'm showing you, I get it that I have some that are dry brushed to accentuate the details on them. I don't expect that these new minis will look quite as good with this painting technique because you don't have those recesses. Then this may seem like a small thing, but within the game, the packaging is a little bit different and kind of disappointing with the characters. You don't have the realable pouches anymore that have all your cards in it, which was very vital for our storage and not having to put all of our cards in Ziploc bags. Now the packages are in those oneandone plastic cellophane wrappers like a cigarette pack or something that you have to throw away and then you just have loose cards unless you put them in a plastic baggie or you salvage old Gloom Haven wrappers or whatever. It may seem like a small thing but that's definitely a production consideration. And also this may be crazy. I may just be doing this in my head. I I'm no cardboard scientist, but
the cards do feel a little bit flimsier to me, especially the smaller cards that your equipment is on, but even the character cards just feels like a a thinner, cheaper card stock. I don't know. Someone else can do some observations on that. That that may just be me. Okay, these characters now, the characters like the scenarios, like the writing, it's just more dynamic and cooler. I laid out all the cards for both the uh bruiser/b brute, as they used to be known, and the spellw weaver. And what I found was that these characters seem to have been presented in a way now to try and make them more interesting as well as leaning into what they do best. Take the spellw weaver for example. You don't have a summon anymore because no one really needed that summon. Then there's things like their cornerstone card, the reviving ether, which used to give you only dark element, but now gives you an element of your choice. Again, giving more flexibility to that card and that character knowing that the elements are going to be a cornerstone of how this character builds. And every spellw weaver is always going to keep the reviving ether in their hand. So that doesn't define a specific direction that you have to go into. There's a lot more AoE attacks in addition to their recurring bottom action to do an attack.
They have a one-time use bottom row attack which is fantastic because again as that character you're emphasizing those loss cards that you know you're going to hopefully get back with the reviving ether. And there's just a general greater mobility that's available to the character, which allows you to do more positional stuff and skirt out of the way if you're kiting some enemies and hopefully still being able to smack them around with your elements. The bruiser is similar and I played a lot of the brute in the original Gloom Haven and it seems like here it's really leaning into like a high risk high reward situation where there are certain cards that are reducing the amount of armor that's given. You're still getting some armor, but it's also increasing the amount of health that you receive as bottom row actions or other recoveries that you're going to do. And there's greater emphasis on attacks, which is nice. I mean, the character always had that, but now they're a little bit bigger, slightly stronger attacks. And then there's even some more emphasis on repositioning and movement, which I think makes the character more dynamic and fascinating right off the bat. I love a lot of cool repositioning tricks that you can do, making you a better support character and give you more tools to play with other than just different ways of doing more damage.
Just in the initial loadout of cards available, the level ones and X's, there are now four actions that have repositioning, a combination of two pushes and two pulls, whereas the original brute only had three actions in their initial load out, and all three of those were pushes. That pull is so cool and so vital because you need to bring enemies to you to smack them around. Again, I think it's a smart transition for that character and presents a lot more utility, not just for the player, but for the group. So, final thoughts. I mean, it's a damn good game. It's one of the best dungeon crawls that's ever existed, and this is the presentation by a more experienced, more confident company that I think is just going to be all that much better. I'm going to be honest that the original Gloom Haven, while I enjoyed it, wasn't like top five games of all time for me. But when I got through Jaws of the Lion and then ultimately played so much Frost Haven, I ended up growing in my affection for that game, even going back and playing some of the original Gloom Haven just so I'd have more of a primer going into Gloom Haven second edition. And right out the gate, I am more excited for carrying forward in this new second edition than I have in any of my campaigns of the original Gloom Haven, which I think I ended up playing through
three different attempts of varying length and probably got like 40 to 50 games under my belt of the original Gloom Haven. So, I I got my time in. But this already just has me optimistic, interested. I love that they preserved what the core game was originally about, but also brought some of the best elements from the other games that they made since into this. And I'm cautiously optimistic that even though I really do love a lot of the base building aspects of Frost Haven, a lot of the crafting, a lot of the uh dynamic world events with the winter and summer dates, it does seem like Gloom Haven second edition is preserving the more direct focus on the adventuring side. Probably my biggest question that I have going forward is how much of the scenarios are going to be reworked to be similar to Frost Haven. In Frost Haven, especially towards the end of the game, I'll admit that I was getting some fatigue from some of these scenarios that are like, "Okay, so what is the special gimmick of this scenario?" which can be fun, especially if you're playing hundreds of scenarios, but it sometimes it's just fun to be like, "Kill all the enemies.
Explore the land. Kill all the enemies." So, that's it. Those are initial thoughts. It's kind of rambling. It went all over the place. I zonked Arrow out. He's totally like, "Geez, come on. Can you talk any more about Gloom Haven?" And that's uh that's the news. Hope you dug it. Hope you uh got something out of it. If you like these more casual uh first impression reviews, especially on campaign games, then let me know. The feedback is appreciated. If you absolutely hate it, let me know, too. That is helpful as well. Uh as normal, we'll stick with more of our scripted content or more of our more focused content for the vast majority of things on this channel. Uh and if this is your first time checking out any of our stuff, then welcome to the channel and thanks for supporting. Thanks for being a great community, doing all the social things, and above all, thanks for hanging out.