Perennial - TCbH Review
Transcript
When Flatout Games reached out to the channel about covering Perennial, I was intrigued. On The Cardboard Herald, I'm the host that actually likes Cascadia, and this game seemed to be in a similar vein. A nature-themed tiling game, though Perennial promised to be a bit thinkier and more puzzly than previous offerings from Flatout Games in that genre. With this in mind, I was excited to jump right in. Throughout Perennial, you'll be drafting and planting flowers to build your perfect garden. In each round, you take two turns drafting a tool from the garden display. Each tool has a unique tetronimo shape, but always with five squares. You then draft five tiles from the garden display. Which five? Well, depends on your tool. You see, your tool determines two things. Which arrangements of tiles from the display you can snag, and which side of the board you have to start from. Now, you have full authority to flip and or rotate the shape to your preference, but at least one square must be drafted from the side of the board your tool started on. After you gather all your new goodies, you refill the garden, and the next person goes.
Each player will do this twice per round before moving on to the planting phase with two new tools and 10 new tiles in your reserve. During the planting phase, you'll plant those tiles you just grabbed, but again, those pesky tools are here to determine how you can place them down. Starting from your central greenhouse, you'll place down tiles according to the tetronimo on your tools, and you can choose any of the tiles you drafted, no matter which tool you used to draft them. You can always choose to omit a square if you cannot or do not want to fill in. You still have to discard a tile in its stead. On certain spots of the player boards, there are squares with flower preferences. If you can match up the flower preference with the flower tile you place there, you'll get a seed token, which can be used in a handful of ways. These tokens let you do a couple cheeky things. You can either get two random tiles or one specific tile you need, filling up your reserves and giving yourself more options, which is very helpful. You can also spend them to remove boulders to open up spaces on your player board, but maybe most importantly, you can spend them to play three of your tiles onto your board together.
This power is crucial when it comes to filling up weird spaces that are left over from the shapes of the Tetrominoes. And ooh, there are going to be weird spaces left over from the Tetrominoes. One of the crunchy things about this game that I I really enjoy about Perennial is how poorly the shapes fit together. So, you're often taking time to figure out the best way to lay down these tiles to not leave gaps. Then if you do leave gaps, making sure that you can fill them using the seed tokens. There are five different flower colors, which will score at the end of the game for all groups of at least two with greater point returns the larger group is. So, you'll want to place like-colored flowers next to each other. Pretty standard stuff for a tile layer. But there's also three animals: rabbits, chipmunks, and owls.
Rabbits score one point for each of their preferred flower in their row. Chipmunks are the same but with columns, and owls are similar but they score for all of their preferred flowers around them.
Each animal tile from the bag has a designated flower color they score for, but every player is also given one of each that will score any one color of the player's choosing. Animal and flower tiles are all placed in the same way, following the Tetromino patterns. Perennial begins flowing into a natural rhythm after your first or second round playing. Grab your tools, plant your flowers, repeat. All players do their planting simultaneously, so turns go by pretty quickly. This game has more to chew on compared to Cascadia or Calico, two other tiling offerings from Flatout Games.
The multi-use of the tools being both how you draft tiles and also how you later plant them gives you ample things to consider during the drafting phase as you try to plan out your planting. Perennial is heavier in a way that I think will appeal to gamers who were put off by how simple a lot of tiling games are, your garden is going to be a vastly complicated thing after a single round and I've had players who are seasoned gamers struggle to take their turn because of the possibilities. But don't get this mistaken for anything past that. It's still a light to medium weight tile layer. If you don't like tile layers, you won't like this. If you don't like tile layers where decisions don't often have long-term implications, this may be up your alley. Another complaint I've often heard lot like Cascadia or Calico or Harmony's is that it quickly becomes multiplayer solitaire. And let me tell you, this game has that in spades.
You are very infrequently concerned with what your opponents have going on. Maybe to a greater extreme than with the A for Mission games. Your board is its own vast garden to wrangle and since tiles are non-unique, not tied to anything other than what tool you have to use to draft it, another player grabbing a red you desperately needed doesn't matter that much. You'll likely see another rose tile on the board soon enough. Sometimes an opposing player may draft the perfect combo of tool and flowers that you wanted, but realistically this happens maybe once or twice a game, if that. So, if you want a game with, I'll just say, any player interaction, I don't think I can recommend this for you. Perennial is solid. It's It's great. Flatout Games knows this style of game and they they do it well.
Is this different from their previous offerings? Yeah, it has its own vibe and charm and the puzzly aspect of the game is unique in its complexity and obviously with Beth Sobel doing art, it's gorgeous. I just don't know that it's different enough from other tile layers that it's necessary to get Perennial if you already own Cascadia or Calico or Verdant or Knitting Circle or Fit to Print or any of the other tile layers that Flatout Games or other publishers have put out. Perennial's good and if I didn't own some of those games, this would be one that I want. And in fact, it might be my favorite of the bunch. But if you're at your friendly local game shop and you see this on the shelf, I don't know that I can recommend spending your money on it if you have the others. Unless you get a lot of tile layers to the table and you're looking to add another excellent option to your collection.
I'm happy and in fact, I'm stoked to have this in my collection and it's good enough that it's going to push some of these other ones out. But, I got this for free from the publisher, so I didn't have to make the choice between this and a different game. All of this to say, Perennial is good. There are going to be people who are excited to bring this to the table and I'm one of them. It burns your brain far more than a lot of other tile layers and if that's something you want, Perennial is a great option for you. That was my review of Perennial from Flatout Games. Thank you so much for tuning in and being an awesome community. Let me know in the comments down below your favorite flower or your favorite tile laying game. Either one, I'd be happy to take a look at and respond to.
Thank you so much. I've been Eric with the Cardboard Herald.