OctoDice Review
Transcript
welcome to tr gets games today I'll be reviewing octo dice this small little yti esque dice game puts you at the bottom of the ocean trying to do some research while scrubbing uh pesky octopods away from your equipment and of course trying to get victory points first I'll show you how the game plays and then I'll jump in in my review at the start of the game give every player one of these sheets that they can peel off from this very large pad that comes in the box then we need to build the lab and you'll notice that this is built out of nine of these tiles they tell you what row they're supposed to be in with these zeros ones and twos but the column is randomized and each tile is also double-sided so there's a good bit of Randomness that goes into building this specific lab setup that you'll use in the game and finally each player puts one token of their color at the top of each of these labs to show that they haven't actually taken any of these labatory advancements just yet but they can during the game game play revolves around these six dice we have three white and three black to start of turn a player will roll all these Dice and then they are going to be forced to lock two of these Dice and then roll four so in this case the player might take this this die here and maybe this die right here and it's also worth noting this is not a blank die there's actually a purple octopod kind of hiding there in the way so that's not a blank side and so once they lock two they have to roll the remaining four uh they can't touch these over here and now that they've rolled these two they need to lock two more and then roll the final two dice so in this case they might decide to keep this and maybe they'll push their luck a little bit I'll tell show you why in a minute roll these final two dice and then their turn is now um over as far as the rolling and now they can try to
score the dice they've grabbed if you look at this player sheet the bottom section kind of shows calendars and what this means is you're going to take two turns for every one of these three calendar chunks and you'll do a scoring at the end of each which I'll show you in a minute and in every single turn you see an A and A B and then a little octopod symbol so this means you could take two actions or up to two actions in a given turn and of course it's the first turn of the game so in order to do an action you have to pair up two dice together so for instance you could take this Crystal right here and this two and we could evaluate this is an action in fact this is probably the best way to do it if we look at this crystal symbol we see it matches this column up here on our player board and this is essentially just finding crystals and when you activate this you must have a black d that is not an octopod and then you just cross out the top spot on the uh on that column and then you score victory points equal to the value on this dice that's why it's really great to do the Crystal and the two because the dice go from zero to two so we would put a two down here in the a section to show that we just scored two victory points for that first action now unfortunately for the second action this player is at a bit of a bind because they have this uh research symbol but if you look at the research column you'll see it starts with yellow and then it goes red and blue Etc with these little light bulbs that get bigger with their victory points now that means you have to start with a yellow and then go to a red but they have a green and an octopod so that means they can't actually use this die at all so they're not even going to get that second action on the turn unfortunately so they just put a little zero there and it's a bit of a bust but the final thing they do is look at their octop pods they have one here and of course this one kind of
hiding one here on the Black die and uh if you look to this chart here you'll see if you have two octopods in a given turn you'll actually score a point and there's a little spot for on the player sheet so we put a little one there and in each of these calendars there are two octopod spots next to a minus two and that means if you don't find two of these octopods in your first two turns or before the first scoring you'll lose two points but fortunately we get to cross off two of these octopods so it's a bit unfortunate the players's only able to do one action but getting the octopods done means they're not going to lose two points and that's going to be the end of their turn but before the next player takes a turn every single player around the table can choose to borrow one set of two dice from this roll and they can write it down into one of these two spots down here you see a one and a two that means you can borrow two different uh roles in the first uh third of the game before the first scoring so if you have three players then you'll have a couple opportunities to just kind of borrow a couple of these dice I imagine many players would copy this Crystal too because that's the best role for it but players could also just copy these two octopods and cross a couple off their player boards so they don't need to worry about getting those on their turn so once everybody is potentially copied then the next player is going to grab all these Dice and roll them let's now discuss the other actions I've already kind of covered the research you have to get a gear with the symbol of your current top spot you get that many victory points the next one is the lab here and you'll see that this just shows a token going down so in order to activate the lab you have to have this symbol here and then you have to have a number equal to the next spot you could jump one of your uh little lab markers so at the beginning of the game you have to use zero because this top
row is zeros if this is the blue player they could use this as an action in order to go down here or they could instead do this one or this one and they're going to get a variety of benefits if they were to take this one then for the rest of the game every time they score for octopods they have two or more in a given role they're going to get a bonus Victory point and then if you go down here on a later round which would take a laboratory uh symbol and a one then from that point on in the game you could use a white dine that you didn't use on a as an octopod so that's actually a really good combo to get both of these things you'll be more likely to score octopods and you'll get more points for doing that the bottom row down here is all Victory Point endgame Victory Point uh tiles so that's how the laboratory works now let's move on to the robot action here you just need a robot and then one of these colored Dice and then you fill in the spot on the player board associated with the color you chose so if you did the yellow robot here you would fill in this leftmost light bulb spot and then you would score one point down in the action you just did if on a future turn you did another yellow robot you would cross off this one and get two points so there's a bit of an investment in doing the same color robot this leads us to the submarine action and when you do that you have a submarine and the yellow in this instance you would go ahead and cross this spot off here but you don't actually get any points immediately if you look down right over here you'll see a zero one and two and this is the number of points you'll score depending on the number of robots you have so if you have a yellow submarine and no robots you get zero points and then one point for one robot and two points if you have both these robots queued up and programmed by the time you do a scoring once the players have taken two turns
you'll do a scoring round and you see this hypothetical one down here you just add up all the points and then you fill that number in down here they didn't lose the minus two points but they had zero points for submarines now let's jump into uh this point let's say we just finished these two turns and we want to score it first of all we see that we only have one crossed off octopod so unfortunately that means we're going to lose two points but if we look up here at the submarines we have two yellow uh robots programm so that's two points here we have one red program uh robot program but no red submarine and a blue submarine but no robots which means all total you just get the two points for the yellow so you write that in here these two counteract each other and then you just add 1 2 3 4 5 six seven and looks like the player was able to score seven points again once all players have completed the six turns and gotten through the three scorings in the game we do some final scoring we notice here we see a little Crystal and that is a little bit of area majority the player who has the most of these uh crossed off is going to get four points the second most is going to get two points and you just fill those points into here and then you add to that any points you get for your laboratory text now these are the LEL two text down here uh this one for instance gives you points for having a full row completed with your laboratory uh text this one right here gives you points for having uh these little light bulbs crossed off for doing a good job of scraping the octopods off and this one actually lets you copy one of these other two so you write that in there and then you add that in with all of the scores you've got throughout the rest of the game and the person who has the biggest number here they're going to be the winner so now let's begin the review for octo Dice and I'm going to start with a couple positive points the first of these relates to the tweaks on the yatsi style mechanism that you have with with the dice now in your standard yatsi style game you roll dice and then you can lock some of them and then roll
some more and then lock some and then roll a third time it's usually the way this works but this game makes a much stricter take on this one style where you roll the six Dice and you must lock two of them and then you roll four dice and you must lock two more and then you roll those final two and you know who knows what those are going to be those are a bit of a crapshoot and it's kind of a neat refreshing take to be honest to be forced into making decisions like if you roll six bad dice for you well if it was yach to you just roll all of them but in this one you have to make the best of a not so great situation try to adapt as best you can now of course that does mean if you roll six bad dice then you are locking to and not a great situation for yourself but I just enjoy the tweaks to the decisions that you're making as you are actually playing the game and also trying to consider what your opponents are trying to do as well amongst the things that you're locking and when you flip it over to think about when you're watching an opponent take a turn and you're trying to uh copy one of their actions it's it's cool seeing them lock those dice being forced into it because you can start to formulate a plan of how you might use their lock dice so yeah it's it's a neat tweak on an old system positive number two relates directly to the out of turn actions that I just alluded to a little bit I feel like in this day and age in order to have a good dice game you've got to be able to do something when it's not your turn the worst thing is just to watch your opponent like do well or fail and have no interactions with it so I enjoy the ability to copy the dice that your your opponent has picked out for themselves and I think it's also an interesting twist in that you only get to copy two actions um two pairs of dice between
each scoring round now if it's a two-player game then that means you're going to be copying every single turn but in the three and four player games you have this decision of when do I copy like is that set good enough or do I push my luck and wait and hope that another one of my opponents roll something that's even better for me and it's just it's nice being able to do something when it's not your turn potentially try to build an engine by using an opponent's um uh lab tech upgrade or something along those lines it's just it's good it keeps you invested uh in what all your opponents are doing and it makes the game Flow really well let's now switch over to my one neutral point which has to do with well the luck of the role of these dice but more specifically how you could definitely get unlucky and not take your double actions in a turn I've seen that happen many times in this game now you're going to take six total actions in the game and at the end of each turn you you use two of your pairs of dice to do two actions and especially based off the mechanic where you're forced to roll two dice at the very end I've often times seen myself in a situation where I get to do one action because the other actions were either blocked by octopod spots or maybe it's a uh research spot where I don't have the correct color or something along those lines now if you have a bunch of octopods then sure you get to score bonus points and that is nice although it doesn't feel as satisfying as Crossing off other spots on your board but I just figured it was worth noting that while the game is structured so that you're going to get two actions every turn I it does not happen as often as I'd like which is you know all the time and sometimes that's due to uh push your luck like you could potentially try to lock your dice in such a way that you for sure have two
good options and then that last roll is you know maybe good maybe bad for you but you're not always uh graced with that kind of luck and you know for a short game it's not that big of a deal um it's almost expected that occasionally you're just going to get kind of hosed by the dice you roll but I figured I would mention that you're not always going to get to use as many actions as you thought you might be able to in the game now let's talk about a couple negative points that are pretty closely correlated actually and the first of these is just the overall length of the game I wish it was a little longer you know as it stands it's a six- turn game with a couple actions uh in each of the three scoring rounds where you can copy an action from your opponent and I wish it was three actions between each of these scoring rounds I wish there was just two to three more turns that you're going to get throughout the game to balance out the fact that you are sometimes not going to evaluate both the actions on your turn which is not the end of the world but when you have a very small you know six turns where you're going to be rolling the dice and making these decisions it feels a little more impactful when you lose out on those actions and I just feel like there's some really cool stuff going on and the game just ends before I want it to um and I suppose that's potentially house rable although it's difficult to you know modify the U the scoring sheets like that and also it is going to skew some of the scoring aspects with the research if you have more turns then every people are going to be more likely to max out all those different colors or max out all those crystals and then whoever got the most crystals is less of an interesting decision so it's not necessarily house rable I just wish I wish the game was longer and this leads me directly into negative number two which relates to the laboratory this has the possibility of
being the coolest best most awesome part of the game you Shuffle up these tiles and build a custom Tech Tree each time you play and um the way you shuffle them up it will be significantly different because they chain into each other as you're doing these techs the problem is that at the end of the game the average person has between zero and maybe three laboratory Tech advancements and that's just ter terrible right I mean it's The Shining coolest part of this game is so often ignored because the game is so short you have so few actions that it usually doesn't make that much sense to invest much in the lab because the game is just going to be over and that technology that's going to give you an extra point every time you score octopods well if you're lucky you might get one or two points off of that depending on where you are in the game and when a winning score is usually in like the 20s high 20s low 30s an extra point or two just it really feels like you're much more incentivized to roll that lab advancement die and try to get a bigger Crystal advancement or try to work on the research cuz there could be tons of points there so I feel like if the game was longer like I talked about in the first negative you'd be more incentivized to go down those laboratory routes and make use of them more and or if you were more incentivized just by the mechanics of the game to do those laboratory advancements maybe just giving you victory points like one Victory point for level one two victory points for level two three victory points for level three something like that there is one Tech that gets you points for doing more Tech or you know laboratory advancements but it's already a second level one so you have to do two bumps before you even have access to it where after that you might get one or two more bumps out it so it just feels
like too little um too late to really utilize this wonderful mechanic it's just I this is the reason I bought the game was this awesome laboratory and being able to use these different custom Tech trees and it's just a real shame that they kind of gets discarded for doing other things that are going to get you more points regarding the replayability for octo di I feel like it's a bit above average but it could have been way above average and that's all to do with the laboratory uh technologies that are randomly uh shuffled out in each game like I just mentioned in the negative points it's a shame because people rarely use them very much but people do use them to a certain extent I've never seen a game end where nobody did any technology so the variety and replayability of the way these different texts fall out is is nice it definitely injects replayability into the game that would not otherwise be there or be expected in a simple dice game and of course with a dice game you're rolling the dice and they're going to dictate the options that you have available to you so it's not like you could always go for a robot and submarine strategy in a given game because you might just not roll the dice to do that even though you might feel like that's a thing that you wanted to do so one play to the next is going to have some somewhat real uh differences and I think the replayability it's above average octav officially supports one to four players and I don't generally do solo gaming so I'm not going to speak to that but the two to four player experience I've played two and three player games and I think that three-player is going to be the sweet spot and the reason for that is because you have this extra decision to be made
when it's not your turn of when do you copy the dice that your opponent has because when you have those multiple different rounds and you can only copy twice between each round you are going to need to decide is this worth it or not now there is a two-player variant in the game box where you roll six Dice and just each person can copy from that in between each person's turn so that you will have a greater variety of die rolls to copy but when we played with that we didn't really like it it felt kind of clunky and as as an add-on we actually really enjoyed playing it as a two-player game because you then are forced pretty much to copy the dice of your opponent you are really engaged so you don't have to decide am I going to or not on every single turn you are doing something every single turn because you do a turn your opponent does a turn you copy you do a turn your opponent does a turn and you copy so I like the way that that uh works together in a two-player game makes a good EXP expence but um three extra decisions those are good and I have not played a four player I think could be fine at four player it's just maybe b a little bit longer uh for the sake of it um and not longer because of more action so I think it probably plays fine with that but yeah sweet spots three in conclusion octad has a bunch of things I like in dice games you have this um roll and lock style mechanism but you're actually forced into it which I think is neat you have um some building aspects to it where you are kind of building an engine with your submarines and potentially with that lab and also you have player interaction with a little bit of a race and also just being able to do stuff on their turns unfortunately I end up just liking this game as opposed to loving it which I really think I would do if the game was a little bit longer and if
going into those laboratory Technologies was more incentivized because that is really where the game um would shine and that it's got this great variability this great options that you could go down but in general it feels like it often makes sense to just forego it entirely and just do other things all that being said I've enjoyed every game of this I've played I look forward to playing it more in the future and I don't know maybe I'll try to photoshop a new um scoreboard or something like that to try and get a couple more uh turns into the game and see how that might tweak things I don't know it it it seems like it might be worth it because there's such a great engine here a great package of uh mechanical thoughts and ideas and it just gets hampered by its overall game length so I recommend the game with a couple caveats and yeah it's just been a good time I'd like to thank everyone who is supporting this channel on patreon including the producer level pledges if you too would like to directly support the channel you can do so at patreon.com jongetsgames if you like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching