Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Hungry Gamer's Great Western Trail El Paso Mini Review

Transcript 11:27

Ooh, that looks tasty. Welcome folks to the Hung Gamer is back with another mini review and today we are talking about Great Western Trail El Paso. And what this game is is this is a light fast version of Great Western Trail. Now, I'm saying that solely based on two things. One, the name. Two, the information that original Don gave me because he has Great Western Trail. He's played it quite a bit. I actually have never played Great Western Trail and he said that one of the biggest challenges with him getting Great Western Trail to the table is it is a longer game. So, with that said, he was interested in checking this out and Asay was kind enough to send me a copy.

Thank you as day for doing that. And so, we got to check it out and see does it hold up to his thoughts of the original. Is it fast? Was it simple? And for myself, what do I think? So, the way this game works is you have a small map that is a rondelle, and you're always going clockwise, and you can stop wherever you want. You're going to be moving one to three or one to four spaces depending on how you've built your engine. And you always have to stop at the top of the map on El Paso. You always have to stop there and do things. Otherwise, you got to go wherever you want. And every location that you stop on, you will either do the actions of the building, which are written on the building. It might be get more cattle, it might be hire a worker, it might be use the train that's up at the top of the board, etc., etc. Or you're going to just do a basic action off your board, which is these little cogs, and you activate those, and you get more and more as you go through the game. You're also going to be able to build new buildings. And so you're going to be able to buy buildings, which you're going to take some of the workers that you're able to hire, which I mentioned briefly earlier. You spend some workers, and some money, and then you take a building, you put it out onto the board, and now only you can activate that building. Nobody else can. And then you're also able to upgrade that building later on. Now, it's important that you can only build two buildings per player. That's all you have component-wise. And obviously, that's also the point. So, you're moving around, you're doing that, and you're collecting things, and eventually you get to El Paso. When you get to El Paso, you start getting closer to the end of

the game. You take one of the orange cows, and you take one of those, you get some money, and then you do, I think, like cattle breeding or something. So, you're going to look at all the cattle cards you have. They all have numbers at the top. And for every different breed of cattle you have, you get to add their value to your breeding score. And then you see what your score is. There's little certificates you can use that up your score. And there's some abilities you can kind of unlock as you go through the game, little tiles you can draft that might up your score a little bit, but then you're going to add that up and you're going to get to score. Now, if you score very low, you're just going to get some kind of bonus. Might be a coin, might be a tile, might be another worker, whatever. But if you get high enough, you start to score in-game points, and you're going to go around and around until that stack of orange cattle that I mentioned is gone. Once that's gone, the next player that gets to El Paso is going to get two points.

Then everybody else gets one more turn and the game will end. And you're going to score your points based on cattle that you have purchased from the cattle market, workers that you have picked up, and then the scoring that you have done and then some in-game scoring tiles that you may have drafted throughout the game. High score wins. So with that said, what do I like about this game? Well, first off, it does what we hoped it would. It was fast. It was probably an hour between my teaching Don and us finishing. maybe even a little bit less. It's just a really quick, fast game. So, I do really like that small box. Really like that. Also, I'll say in the box, it has a couple really cool components. You get these huge chunky chunky meeples.

They're great. And then all the other components have little tiny cube boxes that just stores everything in, which that's great. I love that. I'll get to the other components later. So, I do like that. I like the basic Rondell system. I like that it's always set up differently as you're going through. I like that you're buying buildings and you're upgrading your buildings. And then usually, I wouldn't say this, but I kind of liked that only I could use my building. That is so different than usually what you get in this style game. Usually, if someone uses your building, you get some kind of bonus, but no, they can't use it. So, I I really like how that works. I also enjoy the kind of hand management that you're doing. And the first time that you play, you don't realize just how fast the game is, and it feels like, ah, I didn't do anything with all my cards. But you have this lovely challenge of figuring out, well, what are you going to get? Because sometimes you can get a whole bunch of money. There was one time in the game we played last night where I had like 22 bucks. That goes so fast. So you think you can do everything, but you can't do everything because getting the fancy cattle, it's expensive and you have to have four workers, four cowboys that is to be able to do it. Well, to get those cowboys, you had to spend a whole bunch of money to get those cowboys. So all around it's just challenging to do to do the big things. It's real easy to get one or two cowboys and get a lower level cow. It's real easy to hire one worker.

It's super easy to do the low-level train actions. All that's really easy, but the higher stuff is really challenging, and that's cool. I really like how that works because that sets you up for a high-risk, highreward style of play because you're flipping out your hand. And the another cool thing that it does is the backs of the workers and the cows are the same. So, when you use a worker, and it also has these cool little one-use things you can use on your workers to kind of move yourself a little further or get some money, whatever. But when you use your workers, it goes into the same discard pile that all your cows go into after you've done your cattle breeding or whatever it is. And then when you draw your hand, anytime a worker comes out, it just goes into your supply to use again. I really like that because on one hand, it seems like, well, why? But on the other hand, it's great because what it does is when you have this ability, there's exchange tokens where you can use this and draw a new card and throw one away. Suddenly, like you can start pulling out a whole bunch of cards and then you have three, four new workers and then you still get a new cow that you want. It really is clever. It really does work well. So, with that said, what are my quibbles with the game? I'm going to start out components. I mentioned it's got these cool boxes, these really chunky meeples, and then crappy little tokens. Now, to be fair, they are standard cardboard tokens, not thick cardboard, just standard cardboard tokens.

But when you have fancy boxes to hold your components and then you give me cardboard circle chits and cardboard cubes like I don't Yeah. cardboard cubes like they literally look like they're little cubes that they've made but they're flat cardboard. I don't get it. Don't get it. It's just weird because it just seems like it could so easily be awesome components all the way around. I don't know. I'm sure there's a production reason for it, but whatever. It didn't it did not affect my enjoyment of the game, but it did stand out to me because some of the components are so cool and some of them are so acceptable, I guess, is the way to put it. Anyhow, next thing I'll say is I already kind of alluded to it. Because the game is so fast, sometimes you do feel like, ah man, I couldn't do the things I wanted to do. I I I started building up this hand, but I never actually got what I needed in my hand.

And that kind of happens because sometimes to get that really good hand of stuff that you need, you need to actually slow down and go one space and not do the action that's on the building, but you need to do your core action on your board. I forget what it's called, the little cog action that lets you kind of trade cards so you can kind of fill out your hand into the best way to get to those really big points. But that is less exciting than doing the other because it's more exciting to run to the building, do the building action because the buildings are letting you do two, three, four different things. Well, maybe not four, but multiple different things every time. And so you want to do the building actions and so you want to move further. But by doing that, you're speeding up your way around the board, which means you're speeding up your way all the way around to El Paso, which means those cards in your hand, most of them are going to go away anyway. So, it's an interesting balance there, which on the one hand, you might be thinking, "Well, that's good. That sounds good."

But because at least people like me, you want to do the exciting actions, it's just going to speed the game up and it's going to end quicker and so you might not get to do those fancy things. So, I'm again, that's why I call these things quibbles, y'all, because it's on the one hand, that's a great balance. On the other hand, that might bother you because you're like, "Ah, I got all this stuff. I don't know what to do." Next thing I'll say is there is a high level of randomness to the game. And again, for someone like me who likes chaos, that's great. But it's a Euro game and there are those moments when you just don't get the cards that you need. I know the last time that I played, there were several times where I was like, I just need my other builder. And I took several actions of doing the exchange. I got several exchange tokens.

I was buying them every chance I could. and I just didn't get what I need. And that meant when it got time for me to do a build, I couldn't do the cool action that I had built up the whole game to be able to do. And so, it was a little bit of a bummer in that moment. And so, if you're somebody that does not like randomness in your Euro games, then this one's probably not one for you. Even though on the surface it does not seem like there's a lot of randomness in there, that hand can be unforgiving, just like dice can be unforgiving. And the last thing I'm going to say is there's not a whole bunch of meat to this game. The rondelle is cool. The building of the buildings is cool. I enjoy it, but keep in mind this is a light game. And from everything that I've heard about Great Western Trail, and perhaps I'll play it one of these days. Is there's a lot going on.

There's a lot of meat. There's a lot of This is not it. This is a streamlined fast game, which is, I think, what it is intended to be. and it does that and it is fun. But just make sure you're not expecting the full Great Western Trail experience in this tiny box. Before I sign off, I want to say thank you to Matt Pquette and Co up at Be Creative. I don't know what he calls his studios, Matt Pquette Studios, Creative Studios. I don't but they sent me this amazing shirt which I love. So, I'll put a link down in the description. They have a whole bunch of them, but Canadian creativity on the screen. Anyhow, as always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.

Progress saved