Skip to main content
Loading video...

The OODA Loop and Rules that Ruin Board Games

Transcript 22:25

hi everybody gary chavez here a couple months back edo made this great video called entitled game mechanics or rules that ruin board games and it's a great video if you haven't seen it you should you should watch and i'll put a link to the video in the description and it's great particularly for designers to understand what rules really uh mcgann mechanics really make a game a good game bad me personally i wrote an article recently for meeple mountain uh called the the ooda loop how to use a military concept to make good games even better and i really thought this the concept of the ooda loop could really expand on edo's uh discussion in his in his video in edo's video he he well first of all he he basically asked this question what will game mechanics or rules uh ruin board games and he put it on twitter and other social media facebook and so forth and he got a great response to it and he basically gathered all the responses and grouped them into five categories and as i see it the loop really even ties those five categories together in one common uh common concept and um i think the ood loop also explains why those game mechanics or rules ruin game designs and i'll put a a link to the ootaloop article to my ulta loop article in the description uh for those not familiar with the the ooda loop uda

is actually an acronym and it stands for observe orient decide and act and it just describes a uh the general decision-making process and it's used primarily by the military and that's how i got to know it i spent 20 years in the air force and this stuff was kind of drilled into us and it's the ood loop is used to uh to improve um planning war operations and so forth generally understand the decision making process uh but while it might have originated in the military it's also been applied to many other fields like business even martial arts anywhere where decision decision making process has to be analyzed or understanding that better helps and helps improve the process overall so let me unders let me explain to you how as i see it as i said in the article how the ooda loop applies to gameplay so on a player's turn they're deciding what to do and they're going through these four steps the observe orient decide and act so uh in the observed step uh the player is just gathering data uh suppose the a player is playing chess and uh in the observed step the player is looking at the pieces of the board looking where they are looking what they are what particular pieces they are there's no there's just a gathering of data here

there's no assigning meaning to the data yet and the signing of meaning actually happens in the orient step they're used they're gathering that raw data to assess the state of the game and assessing trends in the game um for example if you know again we're if we're playing chess um the player is assessing or am i is my uh are my pieces vulnerable are my opponent's pieces vulnerable how um how long or how long will it be until i may win the game how long will it be till i might win how i might be how when i might lose the game and so forth uh this is a step where the player's individuality first comes into into the loop the uh two players may look at the same data but depending on their experience they may give a completely different meanings a certainly a new player will give a different meaning to a set of uh set of data than an experienced player or even a a uh aggressive player a bold player may give us the same data a different meaning than a cautious player so this is where player individuality first first comes in and the second part war comes in is in the the side step in the side step the the player is listing all all the possible responses to

the state of the game um preferably how to what responses are are there to create benefit for the player or at least a disadvantage to to other players so in say again the chess example they're listing well i can move my pawn i can move my king here i can move my queen i can move my rook listing all the possible ways that this uh that they that they can do what they want to do they're choosing a response um based on the assessment of the game and again this is where player individuality comes in a you know a two players may have the same list of possible responses but a bold player and a cautious player are going to pick two separate things from that list so the player it's this very in dependent on player individuality then in the axe step uh in the side step there at the end of the side step they decide the player decides on one action to take and that's the actions taken during the axe step and in addition to actually doing what they decide to do in the act step as i see it the axe step is where the player changes the state of the game uh preferably they change the state of the game to their advantage or certainly changes the state of the game to disadvantage uh the other players there are their opponents

um so by changing the state the that now the other players are the cycle starts for them now they have to go through the observe orient decide and act step all over again uh in response to changing the state of the game uh so in a test example again it's moving of it's the moving of a piece uh or taking away a piece um so as i see it the categories that edo was describing really are extensions of or or really aspects of the ode loop and that's how the loop ties all of what edda was talking about together they're part of their he was he was describing uh things um aspects of the ooda loop for example uh one of the one of the game mechanics or rules that he said ruins game one of these categories was losing progress in a way that's out of the player's control uh there's some part of hidden information that that changes the game or some kind of hidden objective that changes alter scoring and this is directly related as as i see it to the observed stuff the gathering of data so as as a designer you know our our and i talked about this in the in the in the article the key design question to address the observed step as a game designer

is is is this how do i provide information to the player in an intuitive manner when they need it so what what edo was describing i think is a a state and a game in which the player needs information because something is about to change their perception of the game something is about to change how the game is how the game is played and that information was hidden from the player when they needed it they could not observe it and so that they basically ruined the observed step the players observed step in their in their loop the game mechanics were such that it it it degraded their ability to observe the game um some information was hidden when they actually need it so your game as i see it our job as game designers is to deliver what information the game the the player needs when they need it to make it to make their decision and if you're not delivering that that's just not going to be a pleasant experience for the for the player and also talked about one of the other uh one of the other uh categories that edo talked about was a genre complexity or visual uh direction mismatch somehow you you looked at the game and you thought it was this kind of

genre or this complex type of complexity and you start playing and you realize it's not that at all and i think that has directly ties to the orient step of the ooda loop so in the article i describe one of the key design questions you should uh look at and when to and strengthen the orient step of the ooda loop for the player is to the design question is how do i minimize the steepness of my game's learning curve and you you and there's several ways that you as a game designer inform the player of what kind of game it is or how to how to play the game i mean more than just rules and game components the art the the box the logo is also an indicator of what type of game you're trying to present to them and and as i said before the player's individuality in the orange step the the player this is where the player's individuality enters the game they're drawing on their past experience to understand how to assess the game in the orient step and through their experience they know that they've you know for the many games for generally speaking a a light game is going to have light um casual you know kind of playful art um associated heavier games are gonna

have are gonna look heavier the arc is gonna be a lot more complex and so you look at the game and you look at the earth and you you says to yourself oh it's going to be this type of game and you that that's one of the things that orients you to to how the game is should be played how um what kind of complexity it is how what how complex it is and when you have that genre mismatch that that really degrades the the players ability to orient themselves to assess the state of the game you know if it if i take a simple game but there's actually very complex things to it you know it's really got light art and like casual art playful art but there's this complex things complex there's a complexity in it that it just you know it it just mismatches in a way where i begin to doubt where i can understand but i have enough experience to understand what to do at that point uh so and also talked about one of the categories that he mentioned was a perceived or actual imbalanced game where it one of the examples he gave it gave was you know games that only have one winning strategy and you don't realize that until you play it a few times or there's some kind of first player advantage and that is this is

this perceived imbalance directly relates to the the side step where so i in the side step um as i explained earlier you're listing all the possible responses you can to assessing the state of the game and you're choosing a response but if there's only one winning strategy and what's the point of having the other choices you know um you want to give the players the freedom to ch to have several options and have any of them work in the way that they want to work to each of them should be to provide a path to victory and if only one does or is a one sure way to do it then you know there's no real point to the side step ed also mentioned um obtuse rules where they were unnecessarily risky like he mentioned in zombicide if i miss a uh if i miss a target i hit the player and in the ood loop article explain one of the key design question um to strengthen the design asp the side the side aspect of the ooda loop is how do i make the game's choices and consequences easy to understand and again these consequences should be intuitive an intuitive level you should understand that um any move that gives me a huge benefit is also going to be risky and any move that gives me you know a little benefit should have little risk associated with it and when you just kind of throw this risk in

um i want to make this move but you throw this risk in and it just it makes it difficult to decide because it's not an intuitive you want to do this then some rule comes in and says well wait you know there's actually more risk to that than than you realize um so it makes it harder for the player to to decide what to do and finally uh edo mentioned um the he mentioned the another category he mentioned actually one of the games he he talked about in the beginning of his video was a game called toasted or roasted and he and he he didn't like the aspect of you needed the card um to continue play it was like you know fire starter card or something like that if you didn't have this uh you couldn't do anything you couldn't do anything else and he was stuck at one point all the three of his opponents had it and they were allowed to continue to play but he didn't have it so in every turn he just kind of you know shrugged and i can't do anything and this is the this is really directly related to the axe step you know you can go through with a mechanic like that you can go through the observe orient the side step you just can't act you can't change the state of the game without this card and so if i can't change the state of the game you know why what am i doing in this game i can't i can do everything i can assess the state of the game i can assess what i want to do but i can't change the state of the game myself to my benefit i

can only watch other people do it for themselves so you know it kind of ruins the run the game for him uh he also mentioned the um upkeep and i think that also has to do with the axe step where you want to do something but you have to do some additional actions also that kind of drags things down or he also mentioned the ruining of progress progress reset and again that's that's related to the act step where you're trying to change the state of the game for your benefit but if there's some mechanic in there that just kind of resets it um and you know if a player does it that's that's a different thing um players are supposed to in a way do that and again you kind of want the option to have that kind of interaction but for the game to do it for it to be designed where something out of the blue happens and your progress is reset that really interferes with the axe step and really interferes with the enjoyment of the game and in the article i mentioned the key design question to prove the act step is what barriers do i need to improve to remove so players can do what they want to do you know and i want to do this i want to i'm an aggressive player and i want to do this but i may i want to act in this way um but as an example of you know progress we said i want to do this but is it going to be reset and it makes it makes the game a lot

more you know uh unnecessarily challenging i guess to say and so the act step is is is kind of degraded for them so that's how i i think uh the eddos and it was named five categories i think they all are all aspects of all different ways to describe the ooda loop or or actually how to ruin the ooda loop uh in my article i i say how to make good games even better but i was i debated whether i should call it how to make a how to ruin a good game and in it say here's the observe orient observe orient side act and just take one of those and really do a bad job with one of them throw them away you'll make a really bad game um and so i think that's what ties them together but also the loop also explains why these things ruin a game why these why these game mechanics or rules ruin the game uh as i mentioned before the ooda loop in the in the orient and the side steps that's where player individuality enters the loop it enters the game and so it's a the ooda loop is a way to connect the player's

individuality to game play it's the it's the basic it's a critical part of the game um where the play individuality and gameplay are linked and the more you can strengthen that the more you can make it so that more personality you know i'm aggressive player either i have should have aggressive choices if i'm a cautious player i should have cautious choices if i'm a sneaky player i should have sneaky choices and i want all these players their personality want to do a certain thing the more you can make it seamless that what they want to do can be done in your game and they can figure out how to do it the the more fun that is going to be for the player and in a sense when my personality is affecting gameplay that gameplay is now the thing that other players have to take into account their personalities have to take into account so in a sense i'm not only connecting player into with the loop not only connects the player to gameplay it connects the player players individuality to other players they're individual in the game and it's the if with a good oodle loop you can have all different types of personalities in the game and they're interacting with each other and they're presenting obstacles to each other and challenging each other in a way

where it's it's a very social thing there's this ecosystem of personalities um interacting with each other and and coming up with this experience and the ooda loop is really a critical part of that you you may have a good loop you make it such that players have the information that they need they can do what they want to do and when they want to do it and you have this person these all these individual individual players individual personalities interacting in that way you know for lack of a better word that's where the fun of a game is and so the ooda loop is where a lot of the fun of the game is you strengthen it and you can have a lot of fun you you degrade it you ruin it for people and it's not going to be fun and that's and that's where the why comes in so these things categories that i was talking about he was talking about ways rules that ruin or degrade the ooda loop in the game and you you degrade the ooda loop and now the players cannot interact with with cannot interact with the game in the way they want to or they can't interact with each other in the way they want to it's it's hindered it's slowed down it's almost like you know if the game is blasting white noise at you or you can't do what you want to do you can't interact with the other players at the level that you want to do it and that really is it really ruins the fun and so i think that's what the loop answers it it it answers it

it's the piece that allows the fun to come in the game um and so i think it's in this is uh i like to talk about this because i think it's a that's an important aspect in game design we kind of all kind of intuitively know what this is but the i think the ooda loop really gives us the framework to talk about it more uh talk so those are my additional thoughts to what uh to edo's discussion on game mechanics that ruin a game mechanics for rules that ruin um board games so i'm constantly working on this uh theory uh to something new i'm i'm doing and so i'm constantly working on it if you agree or disagree or have a different view on it i'd love to hear from you please feel free to um to put something in the comments uh give me feedback in the comments or email me or pm me i would love to hear from you i just want to say thank you for watching the video and look forward to talking to you more thanks a lot

Progress saved