First Monday in October Impressions & Light Review | Board Historical Game | Fort Circle Games
Transcript
hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome today we're going to give some Impressions on gameplay of first Monday in October the upcoming one to four player strategy game designed by taler Rosen and published by Fort Circle games where you play out the 200-year history of the US Supreme Court now this game is currently in its later stages of Kickstarter I'll put a link down below to that and I've also got a gameplay video and an overview video up on the channel I'll put links to those down below if you want to see the game in action and see the components more closely now in this game you're trying try to win Renown by having clerks on The Winning Side of landmark cases by influencing the composition of the Supreme Court and by shifting and adjusting the philosophy of the Supreme Court to one that's more amenable to your overall and overarching philosophical goals the end of the game the person with the most renowned points wins the game before we get too deep into this video I do want to thank the US Supreme Court for them allowing us to use This Magnificent space it's a privilege and an honor to be here to do this review and Impressions video from this bace I want to offer up some Impressions I'm going to call this an impressions in a Light review video because I had a chance to spend about 10 hours with the game I think I'd have to spend a number of more game plays to give a full review but I definitely have some strong Impressions based on what I've been able to play so far let's start out with the theme US Supreme Court if you asked me before I played this game would I rather play a game about the US Supreme Court or would I rather go to the dentist I'm picking the dentist honestly I am but then I got a chance to watch some Gameplay at SD histon in San Diego I watched about 15 20 minutes and I realized this has got
some really really sharp gameplay now after SD hison was over um I had the opportunity to work with Fort Circle games on the kickstarter video for this game so this is by way of a disclaimer however this content and these words are my own and they have nothing to do with that work so with that being said let's finally dig into it do I like the game what are my overall impressions of the game first off this game gets a huge thumbs up for me it overcame my reluctance about the theme and I would ask you the same thing that you you may be surprised even if you look you hear about US Supreme Court history and you thinkoh that really doesn't interest me I'm not interested in the topic I think you might want to give this one a chance and I'll talk about why for a couple of reasons first up um reason number one is the outstanding gameplay I'll dig into this a little bit more shortly but reason number two is that what I found as I was playing the game was that even though I'm not incredibly interested in us legal history what this game gives you is not so much a lens on legal history but a lens on US history so as you're going through these landmark cases what you realize is that US Supreme Court case history is very much a prism on the what's happening in the US Society of a whole so you've got these fascinating cases that come up because again it's 200 years worth of US history that this game encompasses and so you'll get a case on things like the one that really blows my mind is child labor like the US Supreme Court is
making a Jud a judgment as to whether child labor is legal or not and you think oh my God where was our country at this point in time to have this be the focal point point of a Supreme Court case so as I was playing the game I I think again not so much as that that lens on legal history it was this opening up of just some really interesting aspects of us culture and US history in general that really sucked me into the theme theme of the game so stepping beyond the historical theme what also captured me about this game is the richness of the gameplay um we played again a four-player game it took us about three hours to play through and as soon as I was done with it I realized that the game checked off a lot of boxes that I like to see in terms of a good solid strategy game first up as soon as you're done you're thinking like okay how what what are some strategies to win this game and you can see multiple Pathways towards Victory so in this game you're trying to influence case law and get your clerks on The Winning Side of landmark cases but there's a number of ways you can do that you can get involved in the case law late in which case it's going to cost you a lot of your influence and a lot of your energy and effort or you can get involved early but that's going to give other players more time to swing the case law you can try to be on the losing side at first and then swing over to the prevailing side so that you win in the end by Shifting the philosophy of the court or adjusting the views of the Supreme Court
and the composition of the Court you can concentrate on dissents and opinions in cases after they're judged you can try to shift the philosophical goals and you also have these philosophical cards that you have in your hand eventually narrowing down to one at the end of the game and you can get a lot of points that way too so you can be trying to shift the court composition to match your goals at the end of the game and you realize you have a lot of different levers and buttons and ways and things you can push and play to try to get that toss into that the fact that how your other players are playing how your opponents are playing can make a huge difference in how you might want to approach the game so as you're playing the game you're watching what your opponent strategies are like and you can see if you've got a couple of opponents that are really trying to push a philosophy in One Direction you might realize okay hey I'm outnumbered I've got to find another place to play my strengths are kind of another strategy to work around so you you really have to morph your strategy dependent upon the strategies of the other players in the game and on top of everything as in all good games you never have enough capacity uh strength time energy to do everything you want to do so you have to be extremely judicious pardon the pun in terms of how you use your limited actions per turn now we played a learning game too in about three hours I think when you get gameplay down it's probably going to be more of a two-hour experience for four players so all of this happens fast so the game has very
good momentum and Pace never gets bogged down and I probably put the complexity at like a three out of 10 so overall as you kind of look at this game it's an accessible game and you don't need to know case law or US legal history at all in able in order to be able to play this game I mean roughly know like okay Winning Side and losing side on a case and Clerk and things like that and how the Supreme Court has nine members I mean just basic stuff that everybody knows so can play this purely as a strategy game without needing to know any of the legal history behind it so everybody really starts out on a Level Playing Field in that regard so from those perspectives in terms of the accessibility of gameplay the pace the momentum of gameplay all of the different strategies that you can use and the fact that it's got to morph around the play styles of your opponents you get to the end of the game and you realize I immediately want to play this a game this has got really really all the components that you're looking for in an outstanding strategy game so I've gone on a lot about gameplay I want to talk now about replayability because that's a very important element I think in a game like this especially this game has one game right there's not a number of scenarios you're not starting at different points in US legal history you're just playing this one game and so are you going to play it four or five times and you're like no I'm really interested in this anymore I think uh the the biggest argument in favor of this game having a lot of replayability is just what I was talking about with the quality of gameplay that's number one however there's a number of other factors to mention that I think really make this game very rep playable first up is you're going to have a case pallet of uh landmark cases in each game and
that's going to be different and the order those cases come up is going to be different in each game likewise the Supreme Court Justices that show up in each game are going to be subtly different there's a certain number of uh cases that are going to be omitted from every game and a certain number of justices that are going to be aditt omitted from every game and even if they're in the game they might not actually make it to the docket and make it all the way to judgment if they're a case or they might not eventually rise up to the Supreme Court if there a Justice that doesn't eventually make it to the Supreme Court so as you're playing the game uh each one of these games in terms of that composition of case law and composition composition of the justices that are potential candidates for the Supreme Court is going to give each game I think a different flavor and a different feel to it so you there's that element too in addition to the richness of gameplay that I think makes this game very very replayable a game that this reminds me of a lot in least of how experience is the game Obsession which is one of my favorite games uh similarities here uh obsession is a game where you rebuild a British estate so you're hiring you're bringing in Prestige guest guests and trying to rebuild different buildings as part of your estate it's a topic I'm not incredibly interested in in and of itself although Pride and Prejudice is one of my favorite books um but still the whole theme of like building a rebuilding a British estate's like yeah okay but the gaml is so rich that it's one of my favorite games and so that thematic uh neutral nature for me and the solid gameplay is there's very similar aspects there too and then that richness of strategy and subtlety of
play that's a part of obsession that keeps me coming back to it is also here I think in first Monday in October I've covered the main points that I want to talk about I want to talk about three more things the sensitive topic of the game about the US Supreme Court uh secondly I want to talk a little bit about soliter play and then lastly are there any negatives or any um you know criticisms that I might have the game after what I've seen so far first up I think you don't have to worry if you've got friends who are Democrats Republicans and you're right okay if we put them together they're going to end up like having fist fights as they play this game the game does a very good job of kind of softening and neutralizing the political polarities that might be around the Supreme Court in today's current political climate a couple of ways it does this is uh first up uh the case law ends before the year 2000 so a lot of the more sensitive issues that happened have happened in the last 25 years or so aren't really in the game second up it really doesn't even go red blue it's not Democratic or republican it uses a federalist or kind of anti-federalist position silver and gold are the colors so it really softens I think a lot of those potential uh rough edges on a game that would lead people from different political views to end up at loggerheads in the middle of a game a word about solitire play I there is a solo mode in the game unfortunately I had to send the Prototype back before I really got a chance to explore that I did play solo three-handed uh to kind of get a sense to learn the game the first time and then to check out some a gameplay video and to kind of get a little bit more more sense on some of the strategies after ID played the four-player game live multiplayer uh so I did like it that way I really wish I
had a chance to play the soliter game I didn't get that uh based on the quality of the multiplayer experience I think the soliter experience I I'm cautiously optimistic it will be solid but I really can't offer up too many thoughts on that lastly any uh criticisms or wishes or opportunities for improvement that I saw in the game uh there there is one I I I found so I'm coming at the game as some some who isn't really doesn't have a legal background isn't really steeped in US legal history and while you can play the game fine as a strategy game without that one of the interest aspect interesting aspects of that again is the history of this case law and what I found is in many cases is that the Federalist Anti-Federalist the the silver and gold nature of the case law the sides and some of the history uh it was a little bit hard for me I I needed someone to explain it more like I was a 5-year-old if that's where I put it like okay okay what does it mean for a federalist judgment in this particular Landmark case and I was like well I don't really understand like what who won kind of thing now I couple caveat a couple thoughts on this one is that the Prototype I had doesn't have all of the historical elements that are going to be included I think in the final version of the game Fort Circle games if you played some of their other games um I call them sometimes a museum and a box because they put in so many historical artifacts and they do such a great job of providing supplemental materials that bring that history to to life that I I suspect the final version of the game I won't feel that way when I finally get it and get a chance to play it that way
having said that I do think there is an opportunity in the game to really spell it out like you're a 5-year-old for people maybe like me or other people that have um a limited exposure to US legal history and might really need things spelled out cleanly and crisply in order to be able to appreciate the US history and the history that the game is focusing on those are the big things I wanted to talk about just a kind of couple of final thoughts that I know I've admitted in this the design of the game is spectacular I really like the the color palette and the artistic Vision behind the game the way the game and the user interface is organized is really comfortable and easy to use um I would also say this game very much to me feels like uh it's a game that has been very tightly wound and I mean that in a good way right that uh this and this my understanding is this game has more than a 10-year design history and it feels like that so I don't think there's going to be a killer strategy that you're going to find after you play the game like three or four times or uh the best way to win I feel like there is so much subtlety nuance and elegance to the game play that this is going to be a game you can come back to and keep coming back to it's it's that good I think this gameplay is is just outstanding that's been my experience with first Monday in October l L are down below if you want to check the game out thanks for watching Everybody if you've enjoyed this video and want to see gameplay of the game in action I'll put a link over here to that video